Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill your pet if ordered to by the gov't?

638 replies

JackiePlace · 02/03/2023 12:31

I read in the news this morning that at the beginning of the Covid crisis the gov't considered ordering the culling of all domestic cats in order to prevent the spread of Covid. This idea was later abandoned after it was proven that cats couldn't transmit Covid to humans.
AIBU to think that this would have caused a mass uprising? We are a nation of animal lovers, after all. Or would people have accepted it as they did some of the other draconian regulations (not visiting dying relatives, etc).

www.lbc.co.uk/news/govt-cat-cull-covid-pandemic/

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JazbayGrapes · 05/03/2023 20:21

I see this news story as classical shit stirring. A splash of negative emotions, and it may be a far away from truth as possible.

But if push came to shove... people would execute their own children, let alone pets. And so many people are very callous towards animals already.

JazbayGrapes · 05/03/2023 20:16

The ignorance of some on the thread is quite alarming. "Just a cold." Of course it isn't. One would have to be very stupid to think that, given the evidence. For some it is mild and others it kills.

Colds kill big time.

JanusTheFirst · 05/03/2023 19:19

The ignorance of some on the thread is quite alarming. "Just a cold." Of course it isn't. One would have to be very stupid to think that, given the evidence. For some it is mild and others it kills.

Pretending otherwise because it suits you is ridiculous.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/03/2023 17:23

They were either all in cahoots with each other OR there was some sort of psychological thing going on.. a mass hysteria if you like... thats actually extremely scary, if you think about it

Though no psychologist my money's on the second option; we only have to look at that Milgrams experiment someone linked, which I'd never heard of but frankly find terrifying

Alexandra2001 · 05/03/2023 16:26

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/03/2023 12:52

Even the sceptics were in full praise of people like Whitty

True enough, but then plenty also bore in mind where Whitty's funding was coming from
That's not to say he was deliberately acting in bad faith, but it's perhaps naive to ignore the effect such things can have

For me, at the time, it wasn't his funding, it was that he was a political appointee... so of course he was never going to criticise Govt policy.

BUT there is a problem with all of this... ALL countries locked down, some very severely, even those that didn't, ended up locking down more... so they were either all in cahoots with each other OR there was some sort of psychological thing going on.. a mass hysteria if you like... thats actually extremely scary, if you think about it.

Meaning we'd have all killed our first born if the Govt had told us too, once it had begun.

AnneElliott · 05/03/2023 15:26

No not a chance. I didn't know about the WW2 advice here but on a visit to Jersey their museum of occupation had a whole section about how islanders hot their animals down before the evacuation. It still haunts me now thinking about that.

I had 4 cats during covid (now sadly 3 as 1 passed to cancer) but no way would I have ended their lives. I would have kept them inside if that was the advice but would never have allowed them to be put down. They come just after my son in order of importance - they are like additional children.

Astrak · 05/03/2023 15:07

H*l would freeze over first.
Cat and I live off grid. We'd slip and go first.

Cherrysherbet · 05/03/2023 14:57

They’d have to find me first. I’d be hiding somewhere safe with my fur babies.

TheOriginalEmu · 05/03/2023 14:55

Everanewbie · 04/03/2023 22:08

I’ve had it twice. Mild cold both times. Everyone I know has had it, including my 90 year old grandma who is in a nursing home. Cold.

Lots of evidence coming out that even if it was a mild cold for you (which for many many people it wasn’t, I know a previously healthy pregnant woman who has been left I a vegetative state by it, thankfully her premature baby survived) you are at increased risk of heart attack and stroke after covid, particularly if you have it multiple times. So no. Not just a cold.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/03/2023 12:55

Remember Neil Ferguson and his dodgy modelling?

Only too well Hmm and he's another doing rather well on government (ie: our) money, whose narrative suited them just fine at the time

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/03/2023 12:52

Even the sceptics were in full praise of people like Whitty

True enough, but then plenty also bore in mind where Whitty's funding was coming from
That's not to say he was deliberately acting in bad faith, but it's perhaps naive to ignore the effect such things can have

MooseBreath · 05/03/2023 11:10

We didn't have a pet at the time, but I wouldn't have supported a cull at all. Surely they could just be kept indoors? I followed the rules for the most part, but used common sense as well.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 05/03/2023 10:46

If the hospital said it I'd believe it but if the government or any of their dodgy scientists said water was wet if have it check. Remember Neil Ferguson and his dodgy modelling? Independent Sage wanting near permanent lockdown? The government and their advisors made it very difficult for anyone to believe a word they say.

Anyway, regardless of who said it or what the illness was I would still choose to keep my cat indoors rather than kill him though.

Cornettoninja · 05/03/2023 09:59

And would anyone really believe any government if they said a particular animal carried Ebola for example?

dunno, if my local hospital had people presenting with patients bleeding out of every orifice then I think I’d be inclined to listen to the scientific conclusions advising government given it’s not an area I have any expertise to make an informed decision.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 05/03/2023 09:48

Patapouf · 05/03/2023 09:36

Covid, no. Something like Ebola or the plague, yes.

Surely you'd just keep them indoors rather than kill them? And would anyone really believe any government if they said a particular animal carried Ebola for example?

HRTQueen · 05/03/2023 09:46

My reaction now is absolutely no way of course not

but at the height of fears around covid the government back this order with science I suspect the majority of us would

push comes to shove my son is more important than my totally adored, loved spoilt fluffy baby

Patapouf · 05/03/2023 09:36

Covid, no. Something like Ebola or the plague, yes.

Timeforchangeithink · 05/03/2023 09:15

No and anyone who says yes needs to get some backbone..This is from a dog person too - I can't stand cats and would quite happily see them become extinct by stopping breeding!

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 05/03/2023 09:11

Sorry it's 22nd March, that's the Sunday before lockdown was announced on Monday 23rd.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 05/03/2023 09:10

GPTec1 · 05/03/2023 08:32

Well, its news to me!!!! & i don't recall many people saying Govt messaging was just "scare stories" we still had around 5 to 600 deaths per day (or so we were told)
At the time, xmas 2020, with vaccines just around the corner, seems a very strange message to want to push?

Remember this an elected Govt minister, not a newspaper or Richard Tice.

& even the sceptics were in full praise of people like Whitty, i know you were Marsha.

These people should be facing criminal charges if they locked down the country for no good reason.

The release of these Whatsapp messages brings into question everything the Govt did and more importantly said.

Have a read of this.

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/882722/25-options-for-increasing-adherence-to-social-distancing-measures-22032020.pdf

20th March 2020, ie the Friday before lockdown was announced. Bottom of page 1 says 'a substantial number of people do not still feel sufficiently threatened: it could be that they are reassured by the low death rate in their demographic group... the perceived level of personal threat needs to be increased among those who are complacent.'

People accurately appraising themselves as low risk was seen as a problem that needed to be solved.

MarshaBradyo · 05/03/2023 08:41

Whitty was good but I thought he got it wrong with the omicron what we know is all bad statement.

That cost a lot economically and there was a lot of fear stoked unnecessarily.

He was usually very good with words though.

Spi B and SAGE used behavioural experts who used fear based messages. They were good at it. Even though I could see why it worked it got to me at times - at the beginning for instance.

But once I could see how it was a behaviour change campaign like any other. A really good one at that I could disengage more.

Covid didn’t worry me as much as the reaction to it.

The fear based tactic had downsides too as did the overall approach. They just weren’t highlighted at all. You can’t tell everyone the economic cost and actual damage of lockdown each day and expect compliance. There’s only one way and that is to massively increase risk and ignore the rest.

Buzzinwithbez · 05/03/2023 08:36

MarshaBradyo · 05/03/2023 08:07

Latest WhatsApp release on the intent to frighten people which can’t be news to anyone but I wish more had thought about that at the time

I had to laugh when they had to come up with more memorable names to get people to get people to keep focusing.
Omicron, then later Kraken.....

Buzzinwithbez · 05/03/2023 08:34

XenoBitch · 05/03/2023 02:03

Not just accepted it.. but probably dobbed in any pet owning neighbours too.

"I did the right thing. They should have to as well...."

GPTec1 · 05/03/2023 08:32

MarshaBradyo · 05/03/2023 08:07

Latest WhatsApp release on the intent to frighten people which can’t be news to anyone but I wish more had thought about that at the time

Well, its news to me!!!! & i don't recall many people saying Govt messaging was just "scare stories" we still had around 5 to 600 deaths per day (or so we were told)
At the time, xmas 2020, with vaccines just around the corner, seems a very strange message to want to push?

Remember this an elected Govt minister, not a newspaper or Richard Tice.

& even the sceptics were in full praise of people like Whitty, i know you were Marsha.

These people should be facing criminal charges if they locked down the country for no good reason.

The release of these Whatsapp messages brings into question everything the Govt did and more importantly said.

MarshaBradyo · 05/03/2023 08:07

Latest WhatsApp release on the intent to frighten people which can’t be news to anyone but I wish more had thought about that at the time

Swipe left for the next trending thread