Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's a normal amount of shouting?

135 replies

WhatALlama2 · 02/03/2023 08:39

How much shouting is normal in a relationship?

I've been with DH for nearly 10 years and he can have a bad temper where I seem to take the brunt. This morning for example he sent me a link to a delivery he had coming and I rang him and said I won't be here as I'm out for breakfast and immediately he started shouting and f-ing and blinding at me until I put the phone down. The thing is it doesn't happen very often, maybe 2 times a year for something serious (like he once threw a chair across the room and another time threw a plate which chipped the TV and he had to buy a new one), so in between I forget about it until something happens again and then I think God I shouldn't be having to walk on eggshells surely?

My parents are both very chilled and I've never even heard them have an argument so I sometimes wonder if this clouds my judgement
and that actually a bit of shouting is quite normal.

Besides the occasional temper tantrum we get on fine, have a nice house, lovely DS, nice holidays etc so I know if I was to leave it would be giving up a nice easy life to go to a life of, not struggle, but definitely not the lifestyle I'm used to.

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 02/03/2023 22:21

How much shouting is normal in a relationship?

None.

and immediately he started shouting and f-ing and blinding at me

This is not OK.

I don't agree with pp that none is normal, that's disneyesq imo

I disagree. I don't shout at people and neither does DH or DD. We aren't a shouty family. DH and I sometimes disagree, but we never shout or swear at each other. The relationship would feel very wrong if we did.

DoraSpenlow · 02/03/2023 22:13

DH and I will have been married for 50 years, this year. Together for 55 years. In all that time we have, of course, had disagreements. But have never shouted at each other let alone thrown stuff.

Blinkingheckythump · 02/03/2023 21:44

Well I'll be honest and say that this thread has really made me re-evaluate my view on shouting and whether or not it's normal, and has made me take a hard look at myself and my behaviour. So for that I thank you all for saying it isn't normal. Time for some changes in my life

WaddleAway · 02/03/2023 18:00

*in order to ‘not’ raise their voices, I meant

WaddleAway · 02/03/2023 18:00

That sort of proves my point. Teachers shout at students. Bosses shout at their employees. It rarely happens the other way round. People manage to control themselves in order to raise their voices at people in authority, because they know they’d get into trouble, but they can’t control themselves to not shout at a partner. Which shows it’s not just frustration or spur of the moment (because if it was, they’d do it to their boss too), it’s a choice.

droneyg · 02/03/2023 17:46

I never said what the OP was was normal. I was a straight A student in a catholic school but teachers certainly shouted at us/me to stop talking or get on with something. I can't think of anywhere I've worked where I've not heard a raised voice at some point by a boss directed at someone. When I was in labour, 2 midwives were having a full on row with each other, that I would say was unusual.

OriGanOver · 02/03/2023 17:43

Arguing a few times a year can be normal OP and people have different styles of arguing. All relationships rupture, it's how they are repaired that makes or breaks the relationship.

Throwing chairs and plates is not normal. Any grown man having a temper tantrum like that would give me the ick. I'd never respect him again.

MyOwnVolt · 02/03/2023 17:41

I’ve been with my husband for 20 years almost and we have never shouted at each other! I can count on one hand the amount of times we’ve snapped at each other tbh.

LittleBearPad · 02/03/2023 17:39

dontstereotype · 02/03/2023 17:10

Really angrily shouting or raising your voice as you've got frustrated is quite a different thing.

However, it would imagine it's very unusual that a couple don't have an argument where voices are raised.

Well quite

WaddleAway · 02/03/2023 17:35

Certainly not a boss. Honestly I’d be gobsmacked if a professional adult shouted at me. My husband has never shouted at me either.
Teachers… maybe. I can’t remember. I wasn’t the type to get into trouble.
My point was more that some people seem to be able to control their voices when at work etc because it would be unprofessional, but when talking to their partners or children they’re apparently less able to control it. I doubt the OP’s partner for example would talk to his boss in the same way that he talked to the OP.

droneyg · 02/03/2023 17:32

Has a teacher or boss never raised their voice at you?

WaddleAway · 02/03/2023 17:32

In Spanish. Well, half Spanish but grew up there. Have lived in England since my early 20’s.

droneyg · 02/03/2023 17:31

i've had teachers & bosses raise their voices at me but wouldn't shout back because of their position, although if they screamed in my face or were aggressive I wouldn't tolerate that. And I would rather a shouty telling off as opposed to a detention. However if a colleague rose their voice to me I certainly would raise my voice back.

(Im not English either by the way).

where are you from?

WaddleAway · 02/03/2023 17:22

droneyg · 02/03/2023 17:19

there isn't a point, it's just because it's coming from frustration. If you said it in a normal
voice I wouldn't say the frustration is as obvious. And as I said it's one moment, a split second. I really don't see the point of arranging a discussion about it later on.

It's not about adding anything. Like I said maybe it's a cultural thing, people will shout at you in a market abroad etc. I wouldn't find shouting in itself intimidating, that would be based on tone & body language.

Just out of interest then, do you shout at people in frustration at work? Your boss, for example? Did you shout at your teachers when you were at school?
(Im not English either by the way).

droneyg · 02/03/2023 17:22

@WaddleAway now it's my turn to be confused!! So every time your partner upsets you or vice versa you have a discussion about it?

droneyg · 02/03/2023 17:19

there isn't a point, it's just because it's coming from frustration. If you said it in a normal
voice I wouldn't say the frustration is as obvious. And as I said it's one moment, a split second. I really don't see the point of arranging a discussion about it later on.

It's not about adding anything. Like I said maybe it's a cultural thing, people will shout at you in a market abroad etc. I wouldn't find shouting in itself intimidating, that would be based on tone & body language.

WaddleAway · 02/03/2023 17:12

droneyg · 02/03/2023 17:03

Unless the person you’re talking to has a hearing issue, why do you think you’re more likely to get your point across by saying it loudly?

where did I say that?

We talk about the issue without raising our voices

sometimes it's just not that deep & there isn't really anything to discuss but the scenario involves a raised voice to say "for gods sake" or "name, you didn't do that thing". I forget things too, with juggling kids, work, friends & family. We don't need a talk to dissect it.

Eh? I'm so sick of seeing the "eh" faux confusion reply to posts. You can get your point across without it surely?

Ok, but what’s the point? What’s the point in raising your voice? I genuinely don’t understand it (not faux confusion 😉).
You can say ‘for god’s sake’ or ‘name, don’t do that thing’ in a normal tone of voice, surely? What does shouting it add?

Mischance · 02/03/2023 17:11

No shouting is acceptable - and certainly chucking things about is totally out of order.

dontstereotype · 02/03/2023 17:10

Really angrily shouting or raising your voice as you've got frustrated is quite a different thing.

However, it would imagine it's very unusual that a couple don't have an argument where voices are raised.

ReliantRobyn · 02/03/2023 17:08

Did you check with your husband that no deliveries were due before leaving the house? If not his anger can surely be anticipated.

JK. He's a turnip and you should probably leave him.

droneyg · 02/03/2023 17:08

Tbf im not English & shouting has less angst attached to it in the countries my parents are from. I've been to family gatherings at friends houses here & there is often no shouting but you can't miss the passive aggression & often the undercurrent of simmering resentment that can't be expressed for whatever reason!

StJulian2023 · 02/03/2023 17:06

And not remotely passive aggressive! There was no need.

StJulian2023 · 02/03/2023 17:06

My late DH never ever shouted at me or raised his voice, ever.

droneyg · 02/03/2023 17:03

Unless the person you’re talking to has a hearing issue, why do you think you’re more likely to get your point across by saying it loudly?

where did I say that?

We talk about the issue without raising our voices

sometimes it's just not that deep & there isn't really anything to discuss but the scenario involves a raised voice to say "for gods sake" or "name, you didn't do that thing". I forget things too, with juggling kids, work, friends & family. We don't need a talk to dissect it.

Eh? I'm so sick of seeing the "eh" faux confusion reply to posts. You can get your point across without it surely?

LadyOfTheCanyon · 02/03/2023 17:03

My last partner was very very passive aggressive. He didn't shout but he withdrew and would refuse to talk to me. He was an arsehole.

When I met DH 15 years ago we agreed to always talk things through when one or the other of us was upset or angry. It's worked well and I can guarantee that while we have disagreed, raised voices and been angry a few times, we have never ever shouted or thrown things.

We very rarely disagree about much to be honest. It was one of the main reasons I married him!

Swipe left for the next trending thread