Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's a normal amount of shouting?

135 replies

WhatALlama2 · 02/03/2023 08:39

How much shouting is normal in a relationship?

I've been with DH for nearly 10 years and he can have a bad temper where I seem to take the brunt. This morning for example he sent me a link to a delivery he had coming and I rang him and said I won't be here as I'm out for breakfast and immediately he started shouting and f-ing and blinding at me until I put the phone down. The thing is it doesn't happen very often, maybe 2 times a year for something serious (like he once threw a chair across the room and another time threw a plate which chipped the TV and he had to buy a new one), so in between I forget about it until something happens again and then I think God I shouldn't be having to walk on eggshells surely?

My parents are both very chilled and I've never even heard them have an argument so I sometimes wonder if this clouds my judgement
and that actually a bit of shouting is quite normal.

Besides the occasional temper tantrum we get on fine, have a nice house, lovely DS, nice holidays etc so I know if I was to leave it would be giving up a nice easy life to go to a life of, not struggle, but definitely not the lifestyle I'm used to.

OP posts:
AfraidToRun · 03/03/2023 11:00

My partner and I have never raised our voices and we have certainly never sworn at each other in anger.

My ex was much like your husband, I found myself trying to police the world, oh x got swapped for y in the food delivery ill have to go out and buy x so he doesn't find out in case he explodes. I broke a cup and hid it for a few weeks in case he exploded. It was exhausting. It might well be common but that doesn't mean its acceptable.

NeedToChangeName · 03/03/2023 10:57

No shouting or raised voices in this house

Remember, everything he does is a parenting choice. Do you want your DS to grow up thinking that shouting / throwing chairs is normal?

My acid test is "Would he speak to his boss / sister / Mum like that? Or, would he have spoken to you like that, on your first date?" If not, then why should you tolerate it?

WhatALlama2 · 03/03/2023 10:44

Thank you all for your comments. I tried to have a discussion with him yesterday about it but it didn't go well as he just got annoyed with me for bringing it up, "making it into a bigger deal than it is" and said I was patronising him by saying his behaviour isn't acceptable. This morning he's admitted he feels very stressed, has chest pains and feels like he's going to have a heart attack because he hates it when things aren't in his control (related to work pressures and my illness). I've said if it doesn't ease up he's really going to have to speak to his doctor about maybe getting a little bit of extra help. His family suffer from anxiety, depression, anger and even schizophrenia so I think regardless of the situation with me he needs to take his MH serious for his own good and everyone else around him.

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 03/03/2023 09:52

It’s not normal and effing and blinding at you is certainly not normal.

Siameasy · 03/03/2023 09:50

Dh and I shout at each other now and then but the context you describe sounds different because it’s upsetting and he’s also throwing things etc.
We shout at each other when we’re frustrated in an argument although mostly it’s raised voices or making a point passionately. That’s normal for us and doesn’t feel in any way disconcerting.
His reactions sound scary and explosive however.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/03/2023 09:47

No proper full on shouting is normal I think. We’re only human though, and everyone shouts a little bit occasionally in the sense of “oh just hang on a minute” or something. But nothing like you describe.

My exh was a shouter and would similarly be likely to send a message at the last minute and be angry I couldn’t comply with it. Would then decide what I’d planned to do wasn’t important. It’s really abusive.

19lottie82 · 03/03/2023 09:42

I had a shouty and sulky “d”h, got rid of him and now I have a lovely partner who I have never heard shout once. I very rarely say this but, LTB. You’ll be so much happier, trust me.

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 03/03/2023 09:39

Shouting at someone you love isn't usual. Throwing things isn't either.

I suppose if you both shout at each other it might be an acceptable part of your relationship (though perhaps not great for those around you).

One person shouting at the other... and that person treading on eggshells to avoid it=abuse.

If he blames you for making him him lose his temper- that sounds like abuse too.

If he has a temper problem then he loses his temper with everyone. If he only loses it with you then it is a form of control and a lack of respect.

OnaBegonia · 03/03/2023 08:45

Does he shout and throw things at his colleagues who don't blindly obey/agree with him??
I highly doubt it.

TheFlis12345 · 03/03/2023 07:59

The only person who shouts in our house is the dog. In over 10 years, DH and I have never ever shouted at or sworn at each other. Not once. It’s at best disrespectful and in most cases, abusive.

Franticbutterfly · 03/03/2023 07:51

No, that's not normal OP. My husband and I have the odd argument and we do raise our voices occasionally but it's not usually out of nowhere for a silly reason like a parcel.

Ohyeahwaitaminute · 03/03/2023 07:46

I’m not from a shouty family. My parents often had long discussions but I never heard them shout.
In fact, my DF used to lower his voice and speak very quietly when he was really cross with me or my DBro. It was an excellent strategy!

However, I discovered that I married a very shouty man who would yell at me for not being in for a delivery that he hadn’t told me about. He’d yell at me for many many unfathomable reasons, all down to his work stress that he refused to address. He never threw stuff, but would slam kitchen doors off their hinges.
If I didn’t agree with his POV, he’d just yell louder and louder.
Eggshells, eggshells…

There was then an incident in his office, and his PA called me. I was mortified.

We are now divorced and I told the DCs that I would henceforth be running a happy and relaxed home… with every chance to communicate on an adult level 24/7. They’re delighted.

DangerPigeon · 03/03/2023 07:34

Zero is a good starting point in terms of shouting.

Rarely is probably liveable.

What you're going through isn't okay and I think you know that, especially given you've started a thread about it.

Thepossibility · 03/03/2023 07:19

And I'll add I was raised by 3 awful shouters (Dad, Step mum and Mum) and that has resulted me in being very protective against shouty arseholes for myself and DC.

Thepossibility · 03/03/2023 07:15

Like you describe?
Never ever, over my dead body.
Seriously he would have to be having a mental health episode to get away with that. Even then it would be a one in a lifetime deal.
I wouldn't respect him if he put up with it from me either.
ANY abuse is abuse.

autienotnaughty · 03/03/2023 06:49

I would say dh and I have occasional rows that result in us both feeling annoyed but we either talk it out, compromise or let it go. But whilst sometimes one will raise their voice (the other will usually quickly point it out) that's it. We don't swear at each other or behave aggressively.

This would be a firm no for me it's not healthy for your child to witness and it's not good for you. You say it's a couple of times a year but that doesn't make it ok? Should you be grateful he doesn't doit often?

I would say (at a time when you are both calm) this is unacceptable and he needs to find ways to manage his temper going forward. He probably wouldn't behave that way towards friends or work colleagues so why is it acceptable to treat you that way?

Zcity · 03/03/2023 02:48

DH and I have raised our voices to each other when both under stress/pressure and being frustrated at each other - I wouldn't say shouting though. Just heated.

We've never sworn at each other, that would be a deal breaker for me, as I think as an adult you should be able to communicate without swearing/name calling/being hurtful etc.

If either of us is particularly frustrated, we take a breather and talk when calmer.

Your DH sounds genuinely unhinged!

YukoandHiro · 03/03/2023 02:20

You're absolutely right @WaddleAway - and thinking about that has helped me manage my sometimes short fuse in my marriage too. I can still be a bit cross but it's easier to control now.

YukoandHiro · 03/03/2023 02:16

Raising voice slightly in exasperating occasionally - normal
Swearing, yelling, throwing things - abuse

EmmaDilemma5 · 03/03/2023 02:14

droneyg · 02/03/2023 16:50

We bicker and get stroppy at times but never shout or intimidate each other.

I would interpret stroppy as argumentative & bad-tempered in the way that teenagers are stroppy. So you are stroppy without raising your voice?

Sorry for not being clearer.

I meant stroppy as in, sulky. So I may mumble "you're so annoying" under my breath as I put something away. Or "next time just check with me" before I walk off.

Not great but no one's perfect. In my experience I see most people get stroppy with their partner from time to time.when things get too much, too tired etc.

The difference in my eyes, is when I'm stroppy, in expressing (immaturely perhaps) that I'm not happy. Shouting is more about intimidation and overpowering someone else imo.

Bayleaf25 · 02/03/2023 22:29

None. We sometimes get snippy with each other (rarely) but never any shouting or slamming phone down. Certainly no physical aggression.

MrsSkylerWhite · 02/03/2023 22:28

My husband doesn’t shout at me. We’ve been married 33 years, together, 35.

Silversalt · 02/03/2023 22:27

Blinkingheckythump · 02/03/2023 21:44

Well I'll be honest and say that this thread has really made me re-evaluate my view on shouting and whether or not it's normal, and has made me take a hard look at myself and my behaviour. So for that I thank you all for saying it isn't normal. Time for some changes in my life

Good for you and very rare on here for someone to think carefully and reconsider.
I posted upthread that DH and I have never shouted. My adult DC don't either. One of them met a girl who shouted and it turned out her parents did. She thought that was the way adults resolved disagreement.
When we first lived together, 40 years ago we said if there was an issue we would never try to resolve it there and then but would discuss later when both had time to reflect. Seems to work for us.
We disagree, often, but we don't get angry.

VickerishAllsort · 02/03/2023 22:26

I echo those who say none.
Been with DH for nearly 40 years and neither of us has ever shouted at the other.

Marblessolveeverything · 02/03/2023 22:24

None. Arguments can be conducted without shouting. Violence is never ever acceptable and I would include fear of potential violence.

Please seek some support as you are unfortunately in an abusive relationship.

Swipe left for the next trending thread