Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is just mums being competitive rather than a real issue?

130 replies

Username24680 · 02/03/2023 05:46

We (2 year old and I) attended a new playgroup this week. I usually work that day so haven’t been to that one before. In a neighbouring town so lots of mums and kids that we hadn’t met before.

Got chatting to a group of mums with toddlers roughly the same age. Maybe about 30 mins into the group they started questioning DSs speech. He’s definitely “advanced” (if that’s even a thing!) at speech compared to most others his age that we know. He is able to hold a fairly good conversation, speaks in sentences and his words are really quite clear (most other adults that we’ve come into contact with can have a conversation with him - it’s not just a case of “mum understands what he means”).

I’ve never really thought anything of it - kids all do things at their own pace 🤷🏻‍♀️ Talking just seems to be his ‘thing’ 🤷🏻‍♀️

The other mums were questioning if he’s being assessed for autism 🙄🙄 apparently they’d been told (no idea who by!) that “advanced” speech is usually a sign of “something being not quite right” (their words, not mine!).

Is this a thing?! It would never cross my mind to question someone else (especially someone I’d just met!) over their child’s abilities to be honest so I’m torn between it being a genuine concern or it being cliquey mums being a bit bitchy as their children weren’t talking as much!

OP posts:
LancreWowhawk · 02/03/2023 08:39

My DD had very advanced speech as a 2 year old. She isn't autistic. Speech was just 'her thing' - there was plenty of other stuff for that she was bang on time for, and as expected some where she was a little behind the curve. She's now 7, and speech is very much still 'her thing'😂

PlumsInTheIcebox · 02/03/2023 08:37

Leftoverssandwich · 02/03/2023 06:32

One manifestation of autistic communication can be overly formal use of words, and/or pedantry, and this can sound very precocious. One of my children speaks like this. They like to use unusual words they’ve read if they think it has the exact meaning they want, but often mispronounce them as they’ve never heard them said before. But speech delay is far more common. Another of mine barely spoke at that age.

It’s really not something for random parents at a playgroup to be coming out with. They sound jealous more than anything else!

I am familiar with this from a professional context. There is an American child who periodically pops up in the 'suggested' section of my social media who seems to have become internet famous for her precocious speech, which her parents film and share. It is blindingly obvious that there is something going on with the child and it adds a whole extra layer to the ethical problem of consent with very small children and social media.

WRT the OP, however, those people sound awful. I'd try another toddler group!

Beseen22 · 02/03/2023 08:36

My DS was fluent in conversation at 18m. He's 7 now and not autistic but currently bring investigated for ADHD. He spoke at 9 months and has never stopped to take a breath since.

DS3 was much slower to speak and the HV gently let me know that this was normal speech development.

Treaclemine · 02/03/2023 08:36

I think I would look vaguely round and mutter something about poorly developed social skills before leaving for ever.

ChickenBurgers · 02/03/2023 08:33

My 7yo was advanced with his speech, his speech was so clear at 2. Especially in comparison to my 2.5yo, who barely said anything at 2 and says loads at 2.5 now, but still says lots of gibberish. No autism as far as I know, but he has been referred for an ADHD assessment.

however I don’t think this correlates with his speech. He is just naturally pretty bright, even now he’s exceeds expectations in many school subjects. Just happens to potentially have ADHD. Sounds like jealousy to me!

BestZebbie · 02/03/2023 08:18

Delayed speech is much more common for autism overall, but of children who are hyperlexic, many are autistic. Hyperlexia is more having an unusually wide everyday vocabulary (“swallowed a dictionary”) and teaching themselves to read before starting school, rather than just talking sooner, though.

Dibblydoodahdah · 02/03/2023 08:12

My DS1 was very advanced with his speech. I didn’t really notice as first because he was my first and I had nothing to compare him against. But a few people started to comment (no negative comments like you had though) and then his reports from nursery showed how advanced he was with many areas of his development. He’s not autistic. He’s very very bright. He’s now in a top ten grammar school and is doing really well there.

Aussiegirl123456 · 02/03/2023 08:09

Perhaps they're thinking of hyperlexia, when a young child learns to read very early? As there is a correlation between hyperlexia and autism.

Ignore them. All four of our children were very early reaching their milestones, some children just are. Our youngest even more so as her siblings are a lot older so she copied them. She was fully potty trained by 19 months and could speak so well, write her name, knew the alphabet and numbers etc. The amount of people who asked me if she has been tested was astounding. It is a mixture of nature and nurture. Keep doing what you are doing, it sounds as though your little one is thriving.

Spraylatter · 02/03/2023 08:09

If I had met you, I would have commented in a positive way. I would be rooting for them and you and it shows you talk to them / interact.

It’s very rude to say theirs is something wrong to a friend let alone a complete stranger!

Emmamoo89 · 02/03/2023 08:08

Jealous cunts

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 08:05

I would say that one of them either has a child being assessed for asd or thinks their child should be. My child does have asd and the most vocal about his possible dx was someone who’s own child was having issues they hadn’t voiced.

Cornelious2011 · 02/03/2023 08:05

Precocious speech is seen in autism. It usually presents as advanced vocabulary, formal language and good verbal memory skills. However it is far more likely that your dc just has advanced speech.

CMVB · 02/03/2023 08:04

My 2 year old has very advanced speech and she’s definitely not autistic. My 5 year old is non verbal and diagnosed autistic among other things. I really wouldn’t worry! Sounds like jealousy to me

crimsonpeak · 02/03/2023 08:03

Sounds like jealousy to me OP. Why do perfect strangers think it’s ok to be this way?! It’s so damn rude! I would be avoiding that playgroup.

ItsJustLittleOldMe · 02/03/2023 07:59

And this is why I’m not a fan of mummy groups!
I once had a mum ‘shame’ me because my baby hadn’t got their first tooth yet and her baby (who is a day older) had two already. I was like that’s not an achievement 🤷🏽‍♀️ It’s literally nothing you have done to make that happen. What a muppet

Caviarandgelatine · 02/03/2023 07:59

They're jealous!

DD is autistic and was speech delayed which is far more common. Hyperlexia (early reading) can be a sign but not in isolation.

Appleblum · 02/03/2023 07:59

That's so weird!

DH's friend has a son the same age who speaks so eloquently with a wide vocabulary. During gatherings everyone is just full of praise for him and asking the parents for tips... really can't imagine why anyone would think the other way!

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 02/03/2023 07:54

My son was a precocious talker (with his first word being ‘bollocks’ at 9 month mimicking a bloke that has tripped over when he was out with his Dad in his baby carrier one day). By 2 he could hold a great conversation; I met my now DH when DS was 2, it absolutely freaked him out!

He’s 30 now, hasn’t shut up yet! No autism traits at all.

DH was diagnosed with Asperger’s in his 20’s, the only words he spoke until he really started talking at 3 were ‘I broke me leg’ (he’s never broken his leg lol).

With my ex teacher hat on, precocious speech could be a sign of an autistic spectrum disorder, but it would be just one of many signs there was a developmental disorder which would need further exploration.

Unfortunately some Mums are just competitive about their children (even toddlers). With my son being a child actor, auditions drew competitive mothers like moths to a flame (imagine that sketch in Little Britain with the child & mother at auditions & it was pretty spot on), you’d walk into a casting call, see the same bragging mothers & your heart would sink if you saw them.

Luckily there was a regular group of us who were not living vicariously through our kids, and guess what? Our kids were the ones who’d get the jobs; I think production companies are astute at castings at assessing you as a mother as much as the abilities of your kid, because the competitive mothers are a sodding nightmare on set!

I mean, be proud of your kid’s achievements, no matter how small, and support & be the voice of your child, but crumbs, competitive parenting is just so tedious & can make you doubt yourself if your child - especially as a toddler - isn’t reading the Iliad, speaking 30 languages or solving nuclear fusion by the the age of 2.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 02/03/2023 07:53

Ignore OP.
I went to a playgroup with DD many years ago that was full of that type of super competitive mum who wanted to ruin others who's child was doing better than they perceived theirs to be doing. It's divide and conquer.

And my DS has Asperger's and no, of anything, he had delayed speech. DD who is neuro typical was the same as your child.

Also, I've seen suggestions that children born during Covid have been far quicker to meet milestones.

AngelinaFibres · 02/03/2023 07:53

Travelationjubilation · 02/03/2023 07:29

I can’t remember a time my niece didn’t speak. She was certainly talking perfectly and clearly before she was 2 and was speaking a lot by her first birthday. She’s 18 now and neither autistic or a genius

I was.my parents first child. I dare say my development got a lot of attention as my father was training to be a child psychologist. I talked very early, but , because I could ask for whatever I wanted and have it brought to me, I didn't walk until much later than other babies. My brother was born 13 months after me and moved himself about like a ' fish walking on land' type creature from 6 months old. He didn't speak for a long time. We are in our late 50s now. Neither of us is autistic.

georgarina · 02/03/2023 07:52

Speech delay/regression is more common. They may have been thinking of hyperlexia which is another symptom. My sister had these two combined.

How rude of them though! 'Not quite right' 🙄

DragonsFurry · 02/03/2023 07:50

Yep speech delay is way more likely, even for high functioning ASD. Pedantic speech possibly Aspergers maybe?

People really need to stop comparing and labelling their kids like this.

WonderingWanda · 02/03/2023 07:49

I cannot believe they said this to you. Even if I really thought someone's child showed signs of autism.....which at 2 yrs old and after meeting their child for 30mins is highly unlikely, there is no way I would suggest it to someone I've only just met. These women are clearly jealous.

I would say advanced speech is more likely a sign of high intelligence and lits of parental interaction. My ds was a great talker from an early age. He was very lazy about crawling and walking and didn't bother with either till 13months so I think he just sat and took in all the words.

Londonnight · 02/03/2023 07:48

My elder son [ now in his 40's ] was very well advanced for speech. No autistic traits then or now.
My eldest grand child was also well ahead of peers for speech, again, no autistic traits [ now 16 ]

I feel it is very odd to make comments on something like this when you have only just met and they don't actually know you or your child.

Kissedbyfire1 · 02/03/2023 07:45

My DDil’s friend has a DC who talks like and adult and has done since he was a year old. No sign of any neurodiversity, he’s just an early talker with a chatterbox older sister who talks to him all the time. All these milestones are on a range of timescales otherwise all children would stand up and walk on their first birthday.