Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think ‘the system is broken’ but…

211 replies

Blinddatez · 01/03/2023 23:49

We are also breaking the system.

From reading posts on here, it seems a lot of people don’t realise just how little we actually contribute to ‘the system’, how much things cost to implement, and therefore what level of service we can realistically expect from healthcare, education and so on.

40% of people are net recipients (they receive more from the state than they put in), but that doesn’t include pensioners. Yet the expectations on here of what should be provided by the state seem to be sky high - generous benefits, good quality but cheap housing for everyone, a 5* NHS, immediate and thorough mental health support, good pensions even for people who have never worked for dubious reasons.

AIBU to think, while the money could be better spent than it is right now, the expectation of what should be provided by the state on here is a bit head-in-the-clouds?

OP posts:
PortiasBiscuit · 02/03/2023 06:32

I love this country, I am broadly proud of this country. I would not want to live anywhere else.
If I get into trouble, the safety net is still there, it may be a bit tatty but it is there.
However a lot of us could pay more tax than we do.

RosaGallica · 02/03/2023 06:28

We keep being told that we have to work harder and harder for less and less nowadays op. It’s a load of politically motivated tosh, or mismanagement of statistics, to claim that 40% of us don’t contribute enough to the system: either that or the system has now become a behemoth swallowing people with no thought or care for their needs that has always been feared. Remember systems are built by people and need to serve people, not the other way around. The baby boomers have already sucked quite enough of the lives of people my age up.

For context it’s generally said that hunter gatherers have to work about 15 hours or so in a week to earn a living. Hand to mouth farmers about 20 -25: for the boomers, it was one person working 35 hours and maybe a few part time hours for a second menber of a couple: for the early gen xers it was 37 hours and a part time job for the other member of a couple. Now it’s two full time professional jobs working 40 - 60 hours a week that’s needed and still we get this rubbish about how most people don’t contribute enough.Who is taking all the extra work and resources we are producing?

You are right, the system is broken because none of us are paid what our work is worth. It used to be that if you worked you got paid: now we are told to work voluntarily to get experience for a paid job, “entry level” low pay roles pay rather less than the total cost of living, and we all have to work harder than ever in hope of getting a wage that might match basic living costs.

Gp back to Tory central and tell them that no one likes being turned into slaves to feed an imperial system.

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 02:14

Hold onto your seats folks
This. The decline has definitely accelerated markedly over the last few years since Covid, Ukraine, etc. Sometimes I feel we're on a precipice, about to go over the edge.

Oh, it's depressing isn't it!

I'm sure emigration has its attractions, but I'll never leave. I'll be here to the bitter end! 😭

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 02:00

You are right. The problem is short term thinking by a generation of politicians of a low calibre.

Liz Truss, for what its worth, was the wrong person with the right ideas. She was right that the economy needs supply side reform and lower taxes. Unconstrain business, encourage investment by private sector and give ordinary taxpayers higher spending power. What she got wrong was the messaging and made a fundamental error - not cutting spending. You can’t cut taxes but then say you will continue the gargantuan spending that this government does and add another £60bn on top to pay people’s energy bills. Her tax cuts were not costed. She needed to clearly say where the spending cuts were going to be. This would then be the start of trying to repair the rot that is deeply embedded within our economy.

And the Bank of England has been run by incompetents for a long time now. They have one job - literally one job. To keep inflation below 2%. See how that’s turned out.

Alas, we now have the guy leading us who threw printed billions like confetti for two years, borrowed record amounts, is low cranking up corporation tax to see off the last of the corporations from this country. The lunatics really are in charge of the asylum.

Hold onto your seats folks. The latest prediction is that UK economy will be smaller than Poland by 2030 and our living standards worse than Romania in the coming years. Anyone with an ounce of sense and good employment prospects abroad should be heading for the shores.

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 01:46

Thank you @VoteTurnipGetTurnip and @sst1234 for explaining low productivity.

Depressing that the workforce is so poorly skilled given how hard HE has been pushed in the last 25 years. It seems that many of our universities are little more than diploma mills.

The nature of our democracy is part of the problem, I think. The media is full of Westminster gossip and discussion of trivial, ephemeral events while the public remains in ignorance of the big issues. Our politicians are focussed on the next election cycle and how they can bribe an infantilised electorate with pledges of yet more spending. No one seems to be looking to the long-term national interest.

I'm no Liz Truss fan, but she was at least trying to confront some of these deep-rooted economic problems. Her proposals didn't sound that wacky to me, and I'm pretty leftish. Why do you think the Bank of England, etc and the markets reacted so badly?

VoteTurnipGetTurnip · 02/03/2023 01:29

Oh lordy, I do agree with some of that but firms and banks are moving out of London because of brexit not because of the 16 hours tax credit limit. Which in any case wouldn't be an issue if employers just paid their employees a proper wage.

You yourself acknowledge that this isn't about people not wanting to work.

It's much deeper than that. Our economy is being fundamentally mismanaged.

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 01:19

Here is an example of something that people should be very worried about. But most people wouldn’t even know about it. Corporation tax is about to increase from 19% to 25%. ‘Let the fat cats pay through the nose’, I hear you say. Well, here’s some news, the loathed big corporations just take their business elsewhere. Like Astra Zeneca which is choosing to build its mega plant in ROI now, because of its low corporation rates. I mean it’s not like this country needs high skilled jobs in life sciences, anyway.

Heathrow, once the business airport in the world and then Europe until very recently, is basically a European backwater now. The transatlantic route was very lucrative. But decades of mismanagement since the late 90s, pearl clutching by environmentalist and incompetence by governments has caused major damage. Yes, let’s all be poorer and March to net 0 while China adds more coal production soon being accounting for 1/3 of global emissions.

Low productivity is not solved by people working more hours. It is solved by automation and private sector investment and by having better infrastructure like roads, airports. Which company would want to do business in a country where corporation tax is so high, infrastructure is poor and the workforce he’ll bent on working no more than 16 hours a week in case their benefits get cut?

You want higher pay, better public services. Who is going to pay for it? You think MPs claiming a few thousand less than in expenses is going to fix the problem? Or CEOs (in the private sector, I might add) taking smaller bonuses will fix the deep economic issues? Anyone who is so economically illiterate so as to believe this, should not have the vote. They are dangerous.

VoteTurnipGetTurnip · 02/03/2023 01:16

Yeah I mean with all respect I don't think that kind of fringe behaviour is really an issue. Most people are economically active for the majority of their working age lives, even if some may dip in and out of being so. But even with that, and even with no financial support for people under 21 and no pension for people under 68, we're not making enough money, not paying enough money, to have a viable economy.

TooBigForMyBoots · 02/03/2023 01:14

No we don't @Deathbyfluffy.Hmm Since 2017, the state will only pay benefits for up to two children.

Deathbyfluffy · 02/03/2023 01:11

We do seem to have a culture of doleys who want it all for nothing - I know so many people I went to school with who had lots of kids and just doss on benefits instead of working.

The idea of only having a number of kids you can afford (even if that’s zero) is invariable absolutely baffling to them.

VoteTurnipGetTurnip · 02/03/2023 01:10

I don't understand why our productivity is so low though, as people in the UK work long hours in comparison with other countries?

Productivity isn't really to do with how hard you work. It's more about what gains you realise in return for your activity.

If you have a country full of low waged workers with poor tech, poor infrastructure investment and who are poorly educated then your productivity will be low. Individual people can work as hard as they like, but if the overall economic conditions are bad then the country will have poor productivity.

VoteTurnipGetTurnip · 02/03/2023 01:04

Yes. Productivity increases when there is significant investment in tech, infrastructure and education.

None of that happens in a low wage economy topped by asset hoarding.

Honestly, we are fucked. There are so many countries on the rise that have got this better than we do and now we've left the trading union that was our buffer.

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 01:02

I'm no economist, but my understanding is that we've had a trade deficit since the 70s and are running a gargantuan national debt due to years of reckless public spending.

I don't understand why our productivity is so low though, as people in the UK work long hours in comparison with other countries?

SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 02/03/2023 00:58

It’s this kind of nonsense that keeps people stupid. Oversimplifying the problem to a lazy primary school soundbite.

The problem is low productivity in our economy which affects every single working age person in the country. Low wages, low skills, high tax, no incentive for industry to invest in automation, build new infrastructure. An incompetent and corrupt government. A population that is economically illiterate and thinks you can print money or borrow your way out of a problem. Try building a factory, road, runway, and type of infrastructure anywhere and they come out with placards.

To be honest, the competence the of the government reflects the general intellect of the population. It really is no wonder, the country in a mess it’s in.

Exactly. I've tried pointing out on here before that living standards cannot rise until productivity increases, and people don't seem to get it. Many don't seem to even understand what it is.

VoteTurnipGetTurnip · 02/03/2023 00:55

I'm not sure where you're getting your info from. Did you do a poll?

Also not sure that you're quite au fait with how this grab panned out. It didn't pay for ordinary people's Netflix, that's certain. Christie's opened up a branch in Dubai though.

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 00:51

VoteTurnipGetTurnip · 02/03/2023 00:45

I don't think any regular person believes that printing money is the answer LOL. I think we all know that we've been completely fucked over by that particular policy. All it's meant is that what scant bloody wages we do have are worth even less. And unlike the asset owning class we can't hoover up yet more assets to compensate for that.

Yet most people were happy that £450bn was printed between 2020-2022. Those that did not get freebies openly complained on this forum and wanted to stay to home watch Netflix.

Any sane person could see the inflation juggernaut coming down the track, yet most people were happy with this utter ridiculousness.

The public has whole heartedly stood behind what the government has done to them.

VoteTurnipGetTurnip · 02/03/2023 00:45

I don't think any regular person believes that printing money is the answer LOL. I think we all know that we've been completely fucked over by that particular policy. All it's meant is that what scant bloody wages we do have are worth even less. And unlike the asset owning class we can't hoover up yet more assets to compensate for that.

Adrelaxzz · 02/03/2023 00:44

And yet miraculously when we didn't have years of Tory bastards in power and we were part of the EU we had much better standard of living. And still paid the same taxes and had some freeloaders not doing their share.

Valentinesquestion · 02/03/2023 00:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 00:41

Dibbydoos · 02/03/2023 00:32

Simply put, 1% own 99% of the wealth. That 1% know how to avoid taxes and making contributions. They think if they contribute 1%, they're contributing more than someone contributing 25, 30, 40, 50% and in pure £ terms, they are but in reality that is where society is imbalanced. Make sure the 1% contribute their 50% share and we can all have the healthcare, facilities and education we feel we should have.

It’s this kind of nonsense that keeps people stupid. Oversimplifying the problem to a lazy primary school soundbite.

The problem is low productivity in our economy which affects every single working age person in the country. Low wages, low skills, high tax, no incentive for industry to invest in automation, build new infrastructure. An incompetent and corrupt government. A population that is economically illiterate and thinks you can print money or borrow your way out of a problem. Try building a factory, road, runway, and type of infrastructure anywhere and they come out with placards.

To be honest, the competence the of the government reflects the general intellect of the population. It really is no wonder, the country in a mess it’s in.

VoteTurnipGetTurnip · 02/03/2023 00:34

@Dibbydoos yes and pay workers enough that they can contribute.

No one is going to be contributing much on £10 an hour when a house costs £280000 and a bag of fucking potatoes doesn't cost much less.

Dibbydoos · 02/03/2023 00:32

Simply put, 1% own 99% of the wealth. That 1% know how to avoid taxes and making contributions. They think if they contribute 1%, they're contributing more than someone contributing 25, 30, 40, 50% and in pure £ terms, they are but in reality that is where society is imbalanced. Make sure the 1% contribute their 50% share and we can all have the healthcare, facilities and education we feel we should have.

Whenharrymetsmelly · 02/03/2023 00:30

It's insane to think that 40% of people take more than they give, seems very unfair to me

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 00:30

More than 50% are net recipients. It took 25 years of economic mismanagement and stupification of the population to get here. Everyone wants a handout and are happy with freebies without ever wondering who is going to pay for it. And as the pie gets smaller, their handouts will get smaller. Gun, foot, direct shot.

No one asked 25 years ago how the eve growing welfare state would be paid for when low pay started to be subsidized with tax credits meaning the 16 hour culture set in. No one asked who would pay for lockdown freebies like furlough. No one wondered who would pay for subsidized energy bills. Or what impact sky rocketing taxes would have on the economy.

The chickens are coming home to roost now. The goose that laid the golden egg is starting to lay fewer eggs now. As the number of net contributors has reduced to less than 50%, the handouts and freebies are going to be harder to come by.

VoteTurnipGetTurnip · 02/03/2023 00:23

Nah, I don't have a source, just going on numbers of benefit claimants. Interesting to see that report. I guess it makes sense in that most in work benefits only get paid to people with kids under 18, which doesn't cover an entire working life.

But still. A country with wages so low that workers are claiming benefits is a country in trouble.

And we have no tomatoes!