Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think ‘the system is broken’ but…

211 replies

Blinddatez · 01/03/2023 23:49

We are also breaking the system.

From reading posts on here, it seems a lot of people don’t realise just how little we actually contribute to ‘the system’, how much things cost to implement, and therefore what level of service we can realistically expect from healthcare, education and so on.

40% of people are net recipients (they receive more from the state than they put in), but that doesn’t include pensioners. Yet the expectations on here of what should be provided by the state seem to be sky high - generous benefits, good quality but cheap housing for everyone, a 5* NHS, immediate and thorough mental health support, good pensions even for people who have never worked for dubious reasons.

AIBU to think, while the money could be better spent than it is right now, the expectation of what should be provided by the state on here is a bit head-in-the-clouds?

OP posts:
Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 07:47

hattie43 · 02/03/2023 07:37

@Believeitornot

Any amount given could be spent elsewhere and it's not just physical money that drains the system also consider the costs of the various bodies dealing with these ferals , police , social workers , probation, councils etc .
The costs of these people far outweigh anything they contribute .
They cause nothing but misery and live outside the norms of a functioning society .

You’re assuming that people on life long benefits (of which there aren’t that many) are all criminals.

You’re assuming that criminals don’t include the rich and powerful.

Nasty attitude.

hattie43 · 02/03/2023 07:46

@LetThemEatTurnips

Yawn

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 07:45

Grumpybutfunny · 02/03/2023 07:44

YNBU I often wonder what party represents those that fund the system. To me I'm happy to pay for education, health and security beyond that I'm not happy to contribute more (net contributor). The welfare state need scaling back to only provide help to the very disabled who absolutely cannot work and those where all adults in the household are working at least 37 hour per week.

I would also end council housing and leave it in the hands of private landlords, why are we funding someone else having a house they can't afford at market rates (social rent).

What makes you think our welfare system is generous now?

Have you ever seen private housing?
Have you ever been in a position where you can’t contribute?

I find statements like this so depressing as a child who grew up in foster care and needed social housing plus state help.

Grumpybutfunny · 02/03/2023 07:44

YNBU I often wonder what party represents those that fund the system. To me I'm happy to pay for education, health and security beyond that I'm not happy to contribute more (net contributor). The welfare state need scaling back to only provide help to the very disabled who absolutely cannot work and those where all adults in the household are working at least 37 hour per week.

I would also end council housing and leave it in the hands of private landlords, why are we funding someone else having a house they can't afford at market rates (social rent).

QuietlyConfident · 02/03/2023 07:42

This is a decent introductory article on the productivity problem and why Truss's budget was not the answer. It's short on headline answers of its own though.
www.niesr.ac.uk/blog/why-uk-productivity-low-and-how-can-it-improve

pd339 · 02/03/2023 07:42

My MIL worked about 5 years in her life and yet is always moaning about the state of public services. It's the fault of immigrants apparently ......

LetThemEatTurnips · 02/03/2023 07:39

hattie43 · 02/03/2023 07:37

@Believeitornot

Any amount given could be spent elsewhere and it's not just physical money that drains the system also consider the costs of the various bodies dealing with these ferals , police , social workers , probation, councils etc .
The costs of these people far outweigh anything they contribute .
They cause nothing but misery and live outside the norms of a functioning society .

The costs of these people far outweigh anything they contribute
They cause nothing but misery and live outside the norms of a functioning society This is a good description of Tory MPs!

Hope551 · 02/03/2023 07:39

Well in my view as a world, we should be focusing on evolving and working together to solve worldwide matters. Protecting our planet. So gatekeeping healthcare, services on the basis on who has what money to me is playing god. I have the ability to save you but unless you pay x amount, you die and it goes to a privileged listed minority. Surely if as a world we are capable and have resources to house, heal and provide we should?

I think the view of society revolving around who pays for what is short sighted for humanity development as a whole. It means the gene pool is very limited, war torn countries, areas with poor healthcare essentially in time die out, and only those with access to wealth access the resources to pass on genes. Which means lack of diversity in the gene pool, more genetic disorders and mutations long term.

I think society as a whole needs to be revised tbh. Different way of contributing. But I don't have the brains to know how any of that would work. I don't think anyone should sit around and mooch from others, but I also don't think people should gatekeep life and feel entitled enough who deserves to live or die :(

LetThemEatTurnips · 02/03/2023 07:37

QuietlyConfident · 02/03/2023 07:33

It's not really about how hard individuals work. The productivity problems are structural.

Truss was right about the need for major focussed intervention, though she went about it in a catastrophically ill-judged way. The problem is that the obvious interventions include immigration increases and planning reform which would go down like a cup of cold sick with the Tory party.

Latest research shows one thing really affecting UK recovery/productivity is the declining health of the nation, caused by the Tories decision to underfund the NHS.

Unaffordable healthcare and transport don't bloody help, it costs a fortune to work in this country. Everyone knows parents who are working for nothing, and parents who gave up because the economics make no sense.

hattie43 · 02/03/2023 07:37

@Believeitornot

Any amount given could be spent elsewhere and it's not just physical money that drains the system also consider the costs of the various bodies dealing with these ferals , police , social workers , probation, councils etc .
The costs of these people far outweigh anything they contribute .
They cause nothing but misery and live outside the norms of a functioning society .

LetThemEatTurnips · 02/03/2023 07:34

hattie43 · 02/03/2023 07:30

We have too many people who don't contribute to society . Lifelong benefits should not be allowed unless you are disabled and benefits should be given in your hour of need based on how much you've put into the pot .

Oh Biscuit

Look at the House of Lords if you want to get rid of 'lifelong benefits'. Or some of the minor royals perhaps. Or ongoing tax evaders.

Tax evasion is a far bigger problem. The investigative resources going into long term benefits claimants are huge, while tax evasion by the rich is pretty much ignored.

QuietlyConfident · 02/03/2023 07:33

Catspyjamas17 · 02/03/2023 07:14

I've tried pointing out on here before that living standards cannot rise until productivity increases,

It's the other way round. Productivity cannot increase unless living standards improve. People are too unwell and too demotivated to work harder.

It's not really about how hard individuals work. The productivity problems are structural.

Truss was right about the need for major focussed intervention, though she went about it in a catastrophically ill-judged way. The problem is that the obvious interventions include immigration increases and planning reform which would go down like a cup of cold sick with the Tory party.

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 07:33

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 02/03/2023 07:25

I think it’s very convenient to blame offshore wealth and the 1%. I’m sure there’s a problem there too, but I think many in UK society are way too quick to expect the state to pick up the tab and lacks accountability for their own actions which contribute to a crappy society. See how teachers are treated, and how people refuse to look after their own health, for example.

You’re making ridiculous statements though.
Most people are decent and don’t take the piss. If you think otherwise, that says more about you than anything.

Most of us don’t have a much choice in terms of wages etc and we have massive inequality as a result. To brush aside the 1% is just naive.

napody · 02/03/2023 07:32

VoteTurnipGetTurnip · 02/03/2023 00:09

Well, quite.

People want a decent standard of living in return for spending 50 years of their lives working.

If that isn't happening (and it isn't, a lot of the time, in the UK) then there's a problem.

The fact that so many people are net recipients should set alarm bells ringing that something is very wrong. We're all working, doing our best, but we're not earning much.

A low wage economy with a high cost of living is not a pleasant place to be and is getting on for being a busted state.

This, exactly.

LetThemEatTurnips · 02/03/2023 07:31

YABU. There is no reason we can't have the standards of living other European nations have, other than the political choices this country made/makes.

The demographics in the UK are not much different than other European nations, but the costs families in particular face (housing, food, heating, childcare, transport) are much higher than in many.

British families are much poorer than French families - research on this was published last year. Standard of living much lower.

British people deserve better government. Better government would give us better quality of life.

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 07:31

hattie43 · 02/03/2023 07:30

We have too many people who don't contribute to society . Lifelong benefits should not be allowed unless you are disabled and benefits should be given in your hour of need based on how much you've put into the pot .

The number of people on lifelong benefits is tiny. The number of scroungers is tiny.
focus your energy elsewhere.

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 07:30

picklemewalnuts · 02/03/2023 07:25

How does productivity work in employment areas that aren't productive?

Take 'care', for example. We are already desperately short of carers across the board- elderly, assisted living, adults with disabilities. We're going to need ever more carers as the population ages.

How does that contribute to productivity? If we suck up huge numbers of workers into care roles, does that increase productivity in any way? Does it siphon workers away from more productive jobs?

Sorry for my ignorance.

Productivity isn’t a measure of worker output. It is a measure of investment in and what you get out.

So if we need more care workers, that can be invested in with higher wages and better conditions etc. those higher wages will boost the local economy as people have money to spend…. And by being well paid, they’ll more likely be in better health.
That is a good thing.

hattie43 · 02/03/2023 07:30

We have too many people who don't contribute to society . Lifelong benefits should not be allowed unless you are disabled and benefits should be given in your hour of need based on how much you've put into the pot .

droneyg · 02/03/2023 07:29

It’s not loopholes for higher earnings taxed through PAYE ie who earn salaries that are the problem. Those loopholes are few and far between.

yes it's not about income more so wealth.

Florissant · 02/03/2023 07:29

Completely agree. The appetite grows with the eating.

Theconceptoftime · 02/03/2023 07:28

Pointing out the level of net recipients to me just highlights the huge level of inequality that people start out with. If people all had a fairer deal from the start they wouldn't be so far behind. If they didn't have so much less they wouldn't need so much more.

It's not the so called takers that are the problem. It's the ones that have put people in a position where they have everything and lead others to live a life of scrambling for the leftovers.

Let's not blame people who haven't been dealt the upper hand in life. Many of who are extremely hard working.

There is wealth to afford a better standard of living for everyone, it just isn't in most people's hands. The people who have the resources are too busy clinging on to it so they don't have to lose their own status, power and security which they feel they are more entitled to than everyone else.

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 02/03/2023 07:25

I think it’s very convenient to blame offshore wealth and the 1%. I’m sure there’s a problem there too, but I think many in UK society are way too quick to expect the state to pick up the tab and lacks accountability for their own actions which contribute to a crappy society. See how teachers are treated, and how people refuse to look after their own health, for example.

picklemewalnuts · 02/03/2023 07:25

How does productivity work in employment areas that aren't productive?

Take 'care', for example. We are already desperately short of carers across the board- elderly, assisted living, adults with disabilities. We're going to need ever more carers as the population ages.

How does that contribute to productivity? If we suck up huge numbers of workers into care roles, does that increase productivity in any way? Does it siphon workers away from more productive jobs?

Sorry for my ignorance.

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 07:23

autienotnaughty · 02/03/2023 07:20

Higher taxes/less loopholes for high earners and large businesses

It’s not loopholes for higher earnings taxed through PAYE ie who earn salaries that are the problem. Those loopholes are few and far between.

It is loop holes for those who earn money in other means, held in offshore trusts etc - that’s where the real problem lies.

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/03/2023 07:20

YABVU. Wages are extremely low. Of course people are paying less tax comparatively as a result. That will continue to happen, while employers are able to make ever increasing profit, while stagnating the wages of their employees.

Low wages are a double whammy too - employees pay less tax and then take out of the system in the form of in work benefits. If companies paid a realistic wage tax intake would go up and benefit payments decrease.

Swipe left for the next trending thread