Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think ‘the system is broken’ but…

211 replies

Blinddatez · 01/03/2023 23:49

We are also breaking the system.

From reading posts on here, it seems a lot of people don’t realise just how little we actually contribute to ‘the system’, how much things cost to implement, and therefore what level of service we can realistically expect from healthcare, education and so on.

40% of people are net recipients (they receive more from the state than they put in), but that doesn’t include pensioners. Yet the expectations on here of what should be provided by the state seem to be sky high - generous benefits, good quality but cheap housing for everyone, a 5* NHS, immediate and thorough mental health support, good pensions even for people who have never worked for dubious reasons.

AIBU to think, while the money could be better spent than it is right now, the expectation of what should be provided by the state on here is a bit head-in-the-clouds?

OP posts:
Catspyjamas17 · 02/03/2023 09:08

Hoowhoowho · 02/03/2023 09:05

Let’s talk about net recipients shall we?
Joe out there fixing your electric supply after a storm
Shirley making your coffee at Starbucks
George working backbreaking shifts at an Amazon warehouse
are all net recipients if you are talking about their individual tax contribution from their wages, there’s a fair possibility in fact that they all receive UC top ups.

But yet they are all vital cogs in the machine that should generate huge tax revenues for the government. If all the Shirley’s and George’s walked out tomorrow, companies like Starbucks and Amazon would collapse within weeks, their tax revenues (such as they are) lost completely.

So sure Shirley and George and Joe might be met recipients according to their wage packet but infact if you count the tax they contribute to (well would contribute to if certain companies paid their share) they become net contributors.

The top bosses don’t like that workers ultimately hold all the power, that’s why they are opposed to unionisation, it’s why wages are kept low and essential bills high, keep people desperate enough to labour for the man. But it’s not the CEO contributing his 40% tax which funds the NHS or the council houses. It’s the labour of Shirley and George and Joe because without them they’d be no CEO. The system works because of them.

Also they need Shirley, George and Joe to spend money on things other than their gas bill. Capitalism seems to be eating itself at the moment.

Catspyjamas17 · 02/03/2023 09:06

We have many excellent SMEs who are fantastic employers and actually make and build things, still, in this country, in spite of successive governments' attempts to turn us into a massive corporation complete services and leisure based economy as that is all the ...go to a top school...go to a top university...graduate in Politics Philosophy and Economics...work as an intern for a politician...work as a SPAD for a politician...become a politician...understand. Most people are actually employed by SMEs.

The government's role particularly in the last 13 years seems to have been to wholly bugger things up for small and medium sized businesses.

Hoowhoowho · 02/03/2023 09:05

Let’s talk about net recipients shall we?
Joe out there fixing your electric supply after a storm
Shirley making your coffee at Starbucks
George working backbreaking shifts at an Amazon warehouse
are all net recipients if you are talking about their individual tax contribution from their wages, there’s a fair possibility in fact that they all receive UC top ups.

But yet they are all vital cogs in the machine that should generate huge tax revenues for the government. If all the Shirley’s and George’s walked out tomorrow, companies like Starbucks and Amazon would collapse within weeks, their tax revenues (such as they are) lost completely.

So sure Shirley and George and Joe might be met recipients according to their wage packet but infact if you count the tax they contribute to (well would contribute to if certain companies paid their share) they become net contributors.

The top bosses don’t like that workers ultimately hold all the power, that’s why they are opposed to unionisation, it’s why wages are kept low and essential bills high, keep people desperate enough to labour for the man. But it’s not the CEO contributing his 40% tax which funds the NHS or the council houses. It’s the labour of Shirley and George and Joe because without them they’d be no CEO. The system works because of them.

Catspyjamas17 · 02/03/2023 08:59

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 08:52

In work benefits hugely contributes to this issue. The government should not have to top up wages, it benefits businesses which should be paying adequate wages

Agree, I've always thought this. Taxpayers are subsidising employers so that they can get away with paying low wages. This is socialism for the rich.

Yes, if the cost of labour goes up, some businesses will move overseas. But most low-waged people work in supermarkets, nurseries, warehouses etc which cannot be easily off-shored.

And as wages throughout the world become more equal, off-shoring makes even less sense.

SquirrelSoShiny · 02/03/2023 08:58

VoteTurnipGetTurnip · 02/03/2023 01:04

Yes. Productivity increases when there is significant investment in tech, infrastructure and education.

None of that happens in a low wage economy topped by asset hoarding.

Honestly, we are fucked. There are so many countries on the rise that have got this better than we do and now we've left the trading union that was our buffer.

I hate to agree but I agree.

Catspyjamas17 · 02/03/2023 08:56

I'm glad some places are moving towards a 4 day week and working from home is permitted in so many jobs now. Don't forget we peasants were working a seven day week not long ago, you were lucky if you got an afternoon off. the cost of living crisis is making some people have to go back this way.

I think in many ways a three day week for a living wage should be the norm. This would allow many more currently economically inactive people to be in the workforce, and for longer. Some of those owning the means of production want to crack the whip and for human beings to do more but if some people were a little less greedy, not the 1% but the 0.1% - the key to this is not hoping that they will somehow do the right thing but countries getting together to minimise tax/law loopholes for corporations and individuals- then this could be achieved and also tech can help to pick up the slack rather than completely replace humans.

Partly an adjustment was due across the globe as standards of living equalise more between different countries and people quite rightly stop being exploited. But there is a big problem with the super rich hoarding wealth and the gaps between the rich and everyone else becoming even more profound.

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 08:53

thecatsthecats · 02/03/2023 08:36

Agreed.

I took over running a company that had a lot of mealy-mouthed box tickers in management, a senior director working 70h weeks but totally ineffective, and a grumpy staff.

I revamped the entire business approach, cut working hours (plus a payrise) and increased the autonomy of the general staff by eliminating unproductive layers of management.

So much 'looking busy' work was cut, and every hour spent was far more productive. And the staff were happy!

But I've talked about this approach with other companies, and they seem desperately scared of the idea of giving up pen pushers, or cutting staff hours etc.

Sounds great to me although I’d be interested to know if that was kept up, how the company was doing now and what staff felt about it.

I find it interesting that people at different levels of an organisation have very different views about what is and isn’t needed. Those with the most power end up influencing how things are done, but they may not necessarily have the right answers.

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 08:52

In work benefits hugely contributes to this issue. The government should not have to top up wages, it benefits businesses which should be paying adequate wages

Agree, I've always thought this. Taxpayers are subsidising employers so that they can get away with paying low wages. This is socialism for the rich.

Yes, if the cost of labour goes up, some businesses will move overseas. But most low-waged people work in supermarkets, nurseries, warehouses etc which cannot be easily off-shored.

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/03/2023 08:41

The welfare state need scaling back to only provide help to the very disabled who absolutely cannot work and those where all adults in the household are working at least 37 hour per week.

That’s all well and good but the infrastructure isn’t there to support all adults working 37 hours per week. I have a child with complex additional needs, she’ll go to a specialist provision school for high school in August, she will still need after school care for me to be able to work. I cannot for love nor money find a childcare setting that will take a 12 year old child. It’s not a case of not being able to afford it - I’m very fortunate that finances aren’t an issue - it’s simply not available.

Many families are absolutely hog tied by the cost of childcare and can’t find anything that works around shift work, for example. It’s an easy thing to say every adult must work, but practically it often looks different.

autienotnaughty · 02/03/2023 08:41

@Believeitornot yes you are right

thecatsthecats · 02/03/2023 08:36

VoteTurnipGetTurnip · 02/03/2023 01:10

I don't understand why our productivity is so low though, as people in the UK work long hours in comparison with other countries?

Productivity isn't really to do with how hard you work. It's more about what gains you realise in return for your activity.

If you have a country full of low waged workers with poor tech, poor infrastructure investment and who are poorly educated then your productivity will be low. Individual people can work as hard as they like, but if the overall economic conditions are bad then the country will have poor productivity.

Agreed.

I took over running a company that had a lot of mealy-mouthed box tickers in management, a senior director working 70h weeks but totally ineffective, and a grumpy staff.

I revamped the entire business approach, cut working hours (plus a payrise) and increased the autonomy of the general staff by eliminating unproductive layers of management.

So much 'looking busy' work was cut, and every hour spent was far more productive. And the staff were happy!

But I've talked about this approach with other companies, and they seem desperately scared of the idea of giving up pen pushers, or cutting staff hours etc.

DryIce · 02/03/2023 08:30

Talking about net beneficiaries always gets people very sneery about people on benefits, when actually you need to earn something like £45k+ to be a net contributor , so a large amount of working people are also essentially beneficiaries.

It's absolutely a deliberate angle to keep people fighting over who deserves it less. This country earns a lot of money - look how many companies are announcing record profits. Just under capitalism that is all funnelled back into the owners , rather than the state. Get angry about that not someone on your street that doesn't work

Spendonsend · 02/03/2023 08:29

I dont really understand why we cant afford decent council housing to be honest. We seemed to manage it after a war when the country was bankrupt. My mum was moved out a london slum to a nice 3 bed with indoor bathroom and heating.

So much of the countries 'wealth' seems to be tied up in paying a mortgage or paying rent. All that money could be circulating around on other things. Even much of the benefit bill is going to private landlords.

I feel if we tackled housing alone the uk would be so much better.

TrinnySmith · 02/03/2023 08:24

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 08:18

How au fait are you with the causes of drug abuse?

Stress, poor education, trauma I would guess but is Scotland the only place to have those problems.
What do you suggest would fix this problem?

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 08:19

TrinnySmith · 02/03/2023 08:15

We have the worst drug problem in Europe here in Scotland.

Now why is this - it could be a sort of poor me attitude, everyone else is to blame for my difficult life (especially Westminster) but there's got to be more to it than that but I can't fathom what it is.

I can understand it’s easier to blame individuals for drug abuse than consider also the impact of wider economic choices made by governments.

It can be both! One can make the other worse….

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 08:18

TrinnySmith · 02/03/2023 08:15

We have the worst drug problem in Europe here in Scotland.

Now why is this - it could be a sort of poor me attitude, everyone else is to blame for my difficult life (especially Westminster) but there's got to be more to it than that but I can't fathom what it is.

How au fait are you with the causes of drug abuse?

TrinnySmith · 02/03/2023 08:15

We have the worst drug problem in Europe here in Scotland.

Now why is this - it could be a sort of poor me attitude, everyone else is to blame for my difficult life (especially Westminster) but there's got to be more to it than that but I can't fathom what it is.

BoredBetsy · 02/03/2023 08:12

It's because wages are so low and housing costs are so high.
Why are working people claiming benefits and using food banks?
People are working perfectly decent jobs yet struggle to put food on the table. It's disgusting.

Worldgonecrazy · 02/03/2023 08:07

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 00:41

It’s this kind of nonsense that keeps people stupid. Oversimplifying the problem to a lazy primary school soundbite.

The problem is low productivity in our economy which affects every single working age person in the country. Low wages, low skills, high tax, no incentive for industry to invest in automation, build new infrastructure. An incompetent and corrupt government. A population that is economically illiterate and thinks you can print money or borrow your way out of a problem. Try building a factory, road, runway, and type of infrastructure anywhere and they come out with placards.

To be honest, the competence the of the government reflects the general intellect of the population. It really is no wonder, the country in a mess it’s in.

This!!

We have the government we deserve - shameful as it is to admit!

Decades of teaching kids to pass exams to ensure schools can fight for their place on league tables, trite such as Big Brother or Love Island, distraction through encouragement of material goods to demonstrate status rather than promoting self worth. And several strata of society with a massive sense of entitlement- the country is a mess.

I have no idea how we fix it as a nation, but on a personal level, avoiding too much social media and focusing on critical thinking when reading other media, is a start.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 02/03/2023 08:06

VoteTurnipGetTurnip · 01/03/2023 23:59

Yanbu.

We all need higher wages.

Well, the majority of us do. Some people are coining it in. There aren't very many of them, but they are taking an insanely high amount of the income generated by trade and industry in the UK. If they took even 20% less, from the millions they have every year, then the rest of us would get 25-30% more than we do now.

And unlike them a good chunk of what we'd get would go back into general circulation. More tax revenue, increased leisure and discretionary spending, the lot.

Wages have been effectively frozen for around 15 years while our national bank has printed money which makes them worth even less.

You can temporarily shore up low wages with benefits. But you can't run an economy, long term, on the basis of the majority of workers having no pay increase for a generation, and you certainly can't run it in that scenario while you are printing money. As we are now finding.

Yep!

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 08:06

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 02/03/2023 08:03

I agree re expectations. The state should provide enough for people to survive: accommodation, food, health, education and safety.
However we should not expect more than the minimum when the economic situation is as bad as it is.
Maybe there is a need to focus on what is critical: schools for ex need to function, no way around that. On the other hand, council funded community events / Christmas lights / new playground … as much as I enjoy these, when so many people are using food banks and struggling with their energy bills maybe these projects should be put on hold for a while.
Just examples of course. I can think of many more « nice, important but not critical » things funded by councils/govt.

But it doesn’t.

And the money used to fund Christmas lights is a different pot to that funding homelessness for example. Councils cannot cross fund.

We already have a thin welfare state as it is. The problem is that we don’t have an infinite supply of money in the economy. Too much of that money sits with the very wealthy. And that’s why the rest of us are poorer.

Pointing the finger at those who are already on the margins and taking even more away isn’t the answer, never is and never will be.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 02/03/2023 08:03

I agree re expectations. The state should provide enough for people to survive: accommodation, food, health, education and safety.
However we should not expect more than the minimum when the economic situation is as bad as it is.
Maybe there is a need to focus on what is critical: schools for ex need to function, no way around that. On the other hand, council funded community events / Christmas lights / new playground … as much as I enjoy these, when so many people are using food banks and struggling with their energy bills maybe these projects should be put on hold for a while.
Just examples of course. I can think of many more « nice, important but not critical » things funded by councils/govt.

nosyupnorth · 02/03/2023 08:00

It's hilarious and cute how some of you still believe the fairytale that productivity rises will increase the general standard of living. Any gains from productivity will be skimmed off into the pockets of the already wealthy.

The fun of working for a major company is they publically announce the billions in profits they make each year - all of which goes to a handful for shareholders and owners, largely outside this country - and they demand more and more work from the low level people on the arguement of 'productivity is good' but none of the gains of that go into pay for me to take home or have taxed, they will burn me out and eventually make me another burden on the NHS but who cares as long as the shareholders can buy another yacht.

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 07:55

LetThemEatTurnips · 02/03/2023 07:48

It is this kind of total economic nonsense that blows my mind.

It costs a bloody fortune paying the BTL mortgages of private landlords, social housing is a) cheap and b) a national asset.

If you don't pay for housing you will have families on the street.

Humans are a nation's greatest asset, it is completely insane to want to throw British people on the street because you think it will make your country stronger.

Exactly!
Having worked for a housing association and seen the cost of building and maintaining housing stock - it can be done much more cost effectively than by private landlords. As soon as you introduce a profit motive or try and do it on the cheap, it all falls apart.

LetThemEatTurnips · 02/03/2023 07:48

Grumpybutfunny · 02/03/2023 07:44

YNBU I often wonder what party represents those that fund the system. To me I'm happy to pay for education, health and security beyond that I'm not happy to contribute more (net contributor). The welfare state need scaling back to only provide help to the very disabled who absolutely cannot work and those where all adults in the household are working at least 37 hour per week.

I would also end council housing and leave it in the hands of private landlords, why are we funding someone else having a house they can't afford at market rates (social rent).

It is this kind of total economic nonsense that blows my mind.

It costs a bloody fortune paying the BTL mortgages of private landlords, social housing is a) cheap and b) a national asset.

If you don't pay for housing you will have families on the street.

Humans are a nation's greatest asset, it is completely insane to want to throw British people on the street because you think it will make your country stronger.

Swipe left for the next trending thread