Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think ‘the system is broken’ but…

211 replies

Blinddatez · 01/03/2023 23:49

We are also breaking the system.

From reading posts on here, it seems a lot of people don’t realise just how little we actually contribute to ‘the system’, how much things cost to implement, and therefore what level of service we can realistically expect from healthcare, education and so on.

40% of people are net recipients (they receive more from the state than they put in), but that doesn’t include pensioners. Yet the expectations on here of what should be provided by the state seem to be sky high - generous benefits, good quality but cheap housing for everyone, a 5* NHS, immediate and thorough mental health support, good pensions even for people who have never worked for dubious reasons.

AIBU to think, while the money could be better spent than it is right now, the expectation of what should be provided by the state on here is a bit head-in-the-clouds?

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 10:16

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 10:09

How many? What proportion of asylum seeker are net contributors?

Why do you think there is any link between being an asylum seeker and NOT being a net contributor?

Do you know many?

I know refugees who are doctors, engineers, craftsmen, graphic designers, airline pilots, legal experts, journalists, footballers....

I also know many who are children, and will most likely grow up to be net contributors...

I simply don't understand why you are blindly assuming they won't be? Where is this coming from? It is completely unreasonable, and makes no sense to me at all

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 10:14

many are very highly qualified, experienced professionals.

Lol.

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 10:09

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 10:02

many are very highly qualified, experienced professionals.

Many others are not that right now, but become so later

How many? What proportion of asylum seeker are net contributors?

whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 10:04

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 01:46

Thank you @VoteTurnipGetTurnip and @sst1234 for explaining low productivity.

Depressing that the workforce is so poorly skilled given how hard HE has been pushed in the last 25 years. It seems that many of our universities are little more than diploma mills.

The nature of our democracy is part of the problem, I think. The media is full of Westminster gossip and discussion of trivial, ephemeral events while the public remains in ignorance of the big issues. Our politicians are focussed on the next election cycle and how they can bribe an infantilised electorate with pledges of yet more spending. No one seems to be looking to the long-term national interest.

I'm no Liz Truss fan, but she was at least trying to confront some of these deep-rooted economic problems. Her proposals didn't sound that wacky to me, and I'm pretty leftish. Why do you think the Bank of England, etc and the markets reacted so badly?

This is entirely the wrong conclusion. The UK has discouraged higher education, training and specialism loads. No support for the majority of students and huge student loans. Many countries known for increased productivity and innovation offer free education and student grants to allow everyone to upskill - not only those who can afford and/or are heading for a lucrative career. This means that people are well trained/ educated across the board. E.g in the Nordics nursery workers have degrees to become nursery workers. They aren't just 18 year olds with an evening course under their belts. Can you imagine how beneficial it is to society and OVERALL productivity to have people who are well trained and well educated across the board? Not just in "professions".

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 10:02

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 10:01

It takes warning more than £40k a year to be a net contributor. And earning it on permanent basis, not jus a few years. Do all or even most asylum seekers end up in those jobs?

many are very highly qualified, experienced professionals.

Many others are not that right now, but become so later

NattyNamechanger · 02/03/2023 10:02

ladykale · 01/03/2023 23:55

Completely agree.

U.K. has a very entitled population who expect to have a fantastic quality of life based on absolutely nothing.

Everyone talks as if they're overcontributors.

👏

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 10:01

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 09:57

what makes you say that? That isn't true in my experience

It takes warning more than £40k a year to be a net contributor. And earning it on permanent basis, not jus a few years. Do all or even most asylum seekers end up in those jobs?

Catspyjamas17 · 02/03/2023 09:58

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 09:43

I think in many ways a three day week for a living wage should be the norm. This would allow many more currently economically inactive people to be in the workforce, and for longer. Some of those owning the means of production want to crack the whip and for human beings to do more but if some people were a little less greedy, not the 1% but the 0.1% - the key to this is not hoping that they will somehow do the right thing but countries getting together to minimise tax/law loopholes for corporations and individuals- then this could be achieved and also tech can help to pick up the slack rather than completely replace humans.

Ain’t gonna happen. It would be ‘nice’, but it’s very much fairy land. I feel a lot of posters on here live there (just me?!).

A four day week and working from home for loads of people was fairyland a few years ago.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/03/2023 09:58

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 01:19

Here is an example of something that people should be very worried about. But most people wouldn’t even know about it. Corporation tax is about to increase from 19% to 25%. ‘Let the fat cats pay through the nose’, I hear you say. Well, here’s some news, the loathed big corporations just take their business elsewhere. Like Astra Zeneca which is choosing to build its mega plant in ROI now, because of its low corporation rates. I mean it’s not like this country needs high skilled jobs in life sciences, anyway.

Heathrow, once the business airport in the world and then Europe until very recently, is basically a European backwater now. The transatlantic route was very lucrative. But decades of mismanagement since the late 90s, pearl clutching by environmentalist and incompetence by governments has caused major damage. Yes, let’s all be poorer and March to net 0 while China adds more coal production soon being accounting for 1/3 of global emissions.

Low productivity is not solved by people working more hours. It is solved by automation and private sector investment and by having better infrastructure like roads, airports. Which company would want to do business in a country where corporation tax is so high, infrastructure is poor and the workforce he’ll bent on working no more than 16 hours a week in case their benefits get cut?

You want higher pay, better public services. Who is going to pay for it? You think MPs claiming a few thousand less than in expenses is going to fix the problem? Or CEOs (in the private sector, I might add) taking smaller bonuses will fix the deep economic issues? Anyone who is so economically illiterate so as to believe this, should not have the vote. They are dangerous.

It isn't as simple as lower / higher corporation tax = more / less business.

CT tax has been lower in the UK (19%) than in Germany (30%), France (26.5%), Spain (25%), Netherlands (25.8%), Canada (26.5%), Brazil (34%), USA (21%), China (25%), India (34.94%), Japan (30.62%), Egypt (22.5%), Nigeria (30%), Australia (30%) and New Zealand (28%) for some time, yet we haven't seen a glut of companies rushing to move here.

Why? Because CT is only a small piece of the business pie. Infrastructure, market size and access, workforce, ease of trade, access to key resources, legislation, country outlook aligning with global outlook, etc, etc are all far more important to a business than CT, especially as CT is only paid on profit, so companies can reduce/avoid it by investing in their company. The trick is offering a whole package that encourages / makes companies invest their revenue in your country.

Just raising CT tax to 25% wouldn't make a company leave the UK alone, more likely there are wider issues impacting businesses (I wonder what they could possibly be) and that would be the straw that breaks the camels back.

One of the areas we should be absolutely be pursuing relentlessly is the "march to net zero". There is something like £140 trillion in AUM in the Glasgow Finacial Alliance for Net Zero, £100 trillion in under the control of organisations aligned to the UN PRI framework, and a further £59 trillion in the Net Zero Asset managers initiative, all of which aim to raise and release capital for sustainable/net zero projects and investments.

The UK is already leading player in the net zero sphere (although we're still not doing anywhere near enougg) and a world leader in renewable technology, especially wind, which has huge potential in terms of generation potential for domestic consumption and export. If we just embrace the idea and stop trying to appease the dinosaur crowd we could be leaders in both manufacturing and expertise too.

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 09:57

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 09:37

we have people sitting in hotels unable to work because we cannot process claims fast enough.

They’re net recipients in the making though. They’re not going to be working jobs which are high paid enough that they’ll be net contributors. They’ll go into a low paid job and UC.

what makes you say that? That isn't true in my experience

RethinkingLife · 02/03/2023 09:52

QuietlyConfident · 02/03/2023 07:42

This is a decent introductory article on the productivity problem and why Truss's budget was not the answer. It's short on headline answers of its own though.
www.niesr.ac.uk/blog/why-uk-productivity-low-and-how-can-it-improve

That was a helpful read, thank you.

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 09:49

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 09:49

In fact re immigration from what I can see and my own experience, the highest quality and most productive immigration we had was from Eastern Europe. Such a shame we don’t have that anymore.

Well given that this country doesn’t welcome foreigners, and signalled as much with Brexit, what do you expect.

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 09:49

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 09:46

Of course they do. Well, some of them; same as anywhere. But it’s very likely they cannot speak English to the level required, that their qualifications will need to be refreshed to meet U.K. standards or requirements and so on.

When did I say they would claim benefits and ‘not work’? You’re just making things up now 🤷🏼‍♀️

They’re net recipients in the making though. They’re not going to be working jobs which are high paid enough that they’ll be net contributors. They’ll go into a low paid job and UC

This you? You’re assuming they’ll have benefits and be in low paid jobs?

People can and do learn English and can and do work here and do very well. You’re assuming that they don’t speak English. They may well do already!

But you’re assuming that they will all be taking out more than they give. Which might be the case for a short space of time and then, with support, they’ll do well.

It’s quite a cynical mindset.

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 09:49

In fact re immigration from what I can see and my own experience, the highest quality and most productive immigration we had was from Eastern Europe. Such a shame we don’t have that anymore.

OP posts:
Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 09:46

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 09:45

Because you put people into this boxes and assume that they’re net givers or takers and that’s the end of it.

And you assume all asylum seekers have no skills or ability to learn and improve? Can you imagine what motivation it takes to drag yourself and your children across the world to make a better life for yourself?

Why do you think all asylum seekers would want to claim benefits and not work? If you were a little less ignorant, you’d know that not to be true.

Of course they do. Well, some of them; same as anywhere. But it’s very likely they cannot speak English to the level required, that their qualifications will need to be refreshed to meet U.K. standards or requirements and so on.

When did I say they would claim benefits and ‘not work’? You’re just making things up now 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 09:45

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 09:42

It’s all very well calling it ‘nasty’ but the problem with treating everything as a moral issue is that you cannot get away from the fact things cost money. And what has your own situation got to do with it? I wasn’t talking about you.

Because you put people into this boxes and assume that they’re net givers or takers and that’s the end of it.

And you assume all asylum seekers have no skills or ability to learn and improve? Can you imagine what motivation it takes to drag yourself and your children across the world to make a better life for yourself?

Why do you think all asylum seekers would want to claim benefits and not work? If you were a little less ignorant, you’d know that not to be true.

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 09:43

I think in many ways a three day week for a living wage should be the norm. This would allow many more currently economically inactive people to be in the workforce, and for longer. Some of those owning the means of production want to crack the whip and for human beings to do more but if some people were a little less greedy, not the 1% but the 0.1% - the key to this is not hoping that they will somehow do the right thing but countries getting together to minimise tax/law loopholes for corporations and individuals- then this could be achieved and also tech can help to pick up the slack rather than completely replace humans.

Ain’t gonna happen. It would be ‘nice’, but it’s very much fairy land. I feel a lot of posters on here live there (just me?!).

OP posts:
Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 09:42

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 09:40

Gosh that’s a bit of a ignorant assumption to make.

How the fuck do you know that?

I was born here, my mum was a single mum, had a job, then had a massive mental health breakdown and ended up on benefits. I ended up in foster care.

So I was not a net “contributor” in your eyes.

Then I had state help with social services support, went to university and now I’m a higher rate taxpayer. And have been for many many years. So a net contributor.

Where do I sit on your nasty little scale?

It’s all very well calling it ‘nasty’ but the problem with treating everything as a moral issue is that you cannot get away from the fact things cost money. And what has your own situation got to do with it? I wasn’t talking about you.

OP posts:
Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 09:40

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 09:37

we have people sitting in hotels unable to work because we cannot process claims fast enough.

They’re net recipients in the making though. They’re not going to be working jobs which are high paid enough that they’ll be net contributors. They’ll go into a low paid job and UC.

Gosh that’s a bit of a ignorant assumption to make.

How the fuck do you know that?

I was born here, my mum was a single mum, had a job, then had a massive mental health breakdown and ended up on benefits. I ended up in foster care.

So I was not a net “contributor” in your eyes.

Then I had state help with social services support, went to university and now I’m a higher rate taxpayer. And have been for many many years. So a net contributor.

Where do I sit on your nasty little scale?

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 09:39

Our politicians are focussed on the next election cycle and how they can bribe an infantilised electorate with pledges of yet more spending. No one seems to be looking to the long-term national interest.

Well put. The issue is the money needs to go on things we won’t get an immediate return on and are longer term projects, but the public are a bit selfish and short sighted and instead will just put the X next to whoever keeps them personally better off.

OP posts:
Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 09:37

we have people sitting in hotels unable to work because we cannot process claims fast enough.

They’re net recipients in the making though. They’re not going to be working jobs which are high paid enough that they’ll be net contributors. They’ll go into a low paid job and UC.

OP posts:
sst1234 · 02/03/2023 09:36

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 09:10

the obvious interventions include immigration increases and planning reform

Should we simply concrete over the countryside and open the borders to all comers? No, this country is a beloved home, not a globalist economic hub. Wealth is more than just pounds and pence.

And this, ladies and gentleman, sums up why we are in this mess.

Don’t gives businesses the workforce they need, don’t build anything, yet keep the freebies flowing for those with Little Britain mentality.

Money does not grow on trees. It is either acquired through production in the economy, for which you need people and infrastructure. Or you print or borrow it. How has the printing and borrowing turned out?

Like I said, it’s worrying that the economically illiterate have the vote. They are dangerous.

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 09:34

Catspyjamas17 · 02/03/2023 09:06

We have many excellent SMEs who are fantastic employers and actually make and build things, still, in this country, in spite of successive governments' attempts to turn us into a massive corporation complete services and leisure based economy as that is all the ...go to a top school...go to a top university...graduate in Politics Philosophy and Economics...work as an intern for a politician...work as a SPAD for a politician...become a politician...understand. Most people are actually employed by SMEs.

The government's role particularly in the last 13 years seems to have been to wholly bugger things up for small and medium sized businesses.

Quite. Because they have been in thrall to investment banks, hedge fund donors who haven’t a clue about genuine wealth creation.

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 09:33

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 09:10

the obvious interventions include immigration increases and planning reform

Should we simply concrete over the countryside and open the borders to all comers? No, this country is a beloved home, not a globalist economic hub. Wealth is more than just pounds and pence.

Immigration goes both way and people should be able to come and go (and they do!). Look at the state of our immigration system - we have people sitting in hotels unable to work because we cannot process claims fast enough. If that was solved, we can welcome people here to contribute and we can send people back if they don’t have a claim. Instead they’re sitting there in limbo to satisfy the wet dreams of the daily mail.

planning isn’t just about concreting over the country side.

It’s about having decent buildings built to a decent standard, about allowing changes of use, about stopping land banking and encouraging local economies to have a mix of buildings and public space.

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 09:10

the obvious interventions include immigration increases and planning reform

Should we simply concrete over the countryside and open the borders to all comers? No, this country is a beloved home, not a globalist economic hub. Wealth is more than just pounds and pence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread