Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think ‘the system is broken’ but…

211 replies

Blinddatez · 01/03/2023 23:49

We are also breaking the system.

From reading posts on here, it seems a lot of people don’t realise just how little we actually contribute to ‘the system’, how much things cost to implement, and therefore what level of service we can realistically expect from healthcare, education and so on.

40% of people are net recipients (they receive more from the state than they put in), but that doesn’t include pensioners. Yet the expectations on here of what should be provided by the state seem to be sky high - generous benefits, good quality but cheap housing for everyone, a 5* NHS, immediate and thorough mental health support, good pensions even for people who have never worked for dubious reasons.

AIBU to think, while the money could be better spent than it is right now, the expectation of what should be provided by the state on here is a bit head-in-the-clouds?

OP posts:
ConfusedNT · 02/03/2023 10:40

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 10:20

Just asking for numbers. You knowing people doesn’t make it a statistical reality.

Do you have numbers to prove your point?

Kazzyhoward · 02/03/2023 10:40

thecatsthecats · 02/03/2023 08:36

Agreed.

I took over running a company that had a lot of mealy-mouthed box tickers in management, a senior director working 70h weeks but totally ineffective, and a grumpy staff.

I revamped the entire business approach, cut working hours (plus a payrise) and increased the autonomy of the general staff by eliminating unproductive layers of management.

So much 'looking busy' work was cut, and every hour spent was far more productive. And the staff were happy!

But I've talked about this approach with other companies, and they seem desperately scared of the idea of giving up pen pushers, or cutting staff hours etc.

I saw the opposite and it was like watching a car crash in slow motion. I was an external accountant working in practice, and one of our clients was a fast growing small manufacturing business. When I first started going (one day per month), it was husband and wife with about 10 staff. Yes, they worked hard and long hours, but the work got done, it was highly profitable, excellent reputation, and the staff were very well paid plus bonuses etc. None of the staff were particularly qualified/experts, they were just "growing" in ability with the business. Eg the production manager previously owned a hardware shop, so was a whiz on stock control, purchase ordering, etc., and "learned on the job" on the shop floor for supervising/managing the production staff, but had not qualifications nor experience in production management - but it worked!

It grow rapidly (doubling in size every few months). I started going 2/3 days per month, then weekly, and ultimately ended up working full time there as their finance director. As it grew, it got less and less productive, margins fell, complaints rose etc. As well as taking on me (a qualified accountant) to do "the books", they also took on a managing director to run it, qualified purchasing manager, a qualified IT manager and even some programmers, a qualified HR manager, a whole new sales team, qualified design engineers etc. Productivity/efficiency plummeted. It turned into just one meeting after another, and became VERY "top heavy" with more "office dwellers" than productive workers. Despite turnover being something like 100 times what it was when I first got involved, profit was virtually the same!

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:39

whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 10:38

Ah yes I am sure this one stupid Phd (which the University is looking into complaints about) proves that all UK research is a load of wank (pardon the pun) 🙄

Of course it doesn’t, but I think there’s a lot of needless research being done in areas that we don’t have a need for.

OP posts:
Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:39

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 10:36

So what are you suggesting?

What are you suggesting?

OP posts:
whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 10:38

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:33

Ah yes I am sure this one stupid Phd (which the University is looking into complaints about) proves that all UK research is a load of wank (pardon the pun) 🙄

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 10:36

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:34

I am very aware of this and you are very aware of this and I’m sure you are aware that there are different types of immigration and I’m sure you are aware that some streams provide less of a return than others and I’m sure you’re aware it is not right wing to point this out but I’m also sure you’re aware it’s easier to shut down the conversation by saying it is.

So what are you suggesting?

RethinkingLife · 02/03/2023 10:36

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 10:09

How many? What proportion of asylum seeker are net contributors?

Asylum seekers have a very specific definition.

There are some numbers here.

www.refugeecouncil.org.uk/information/refugee-asylum-facts/the-truth-about-asylum/

However, asylum seekers need permission to work and that is only granted after 12 months and with specific conditions.

People who have claimed asylum in the UK can apply for permission to work if they have been waiting 12 months for a decision, and they are not considered responsible for the delay. If permission is granted, the person will be allowed to take up jobs on the shortage occupation list only.

commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn01908/

People who have been granted asylum and settled status/other forms of right to remain or citizenship would be a different group.

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:34

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 10:33

I am sure you are very well aware that the country has been shown in many studies to benefit financially from taking in immigrants and refugees, and I am sure you are very well aware that people with certain political ideologies will do all they can to try and prove otherwise

I am very aware of this and you are very aware of this and I’m sure you are aware that there are different types of immigration and I’m sure you are aware that some streams provide less of a return than others and I’m sure you’re aware it is not right wing to point this out but I’m also sure you’re aware it’s easier to shut down the conversation by saying it is.

OP posts:
Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:33

I mean is this necessary research?!

amp.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/aug/11/manchester-university-phd-masturbating-to-comics-of-young-boys

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 10:33

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:30

Nobody is saying ‘asylum seekers are thick’, they’re pointing out the obvious that their qualifications and language ability may well mean they will need years of training to be able to work in the field they previously did in their country of origin. Do we have the cash for this? I’m not sure.

I am sure you are very well aware that the country has been shown in many studies to benefit financially from taking in immigrants and refugees, and I am sure you are very well aware that people with certain political ideologies will do all they can to try and prove otherwise

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 10:32

there is excellent quality education and research happening all over UK universities

Agree, important research is carried out at elite universities. But many lower tier institutions have a business model based on the exploitation of young people who'd be better off spending their time, money and energy on something else.

whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 10:31

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:30

Nobody is saying ‘asylum seekers are thick’, they’re pointing out the obvious that their qualifications and language ability may well mean they will need years of training to be able to work in the field they previously did in their country of origin. Do we have the cash for this? I’m not sure.

You on one hand this UK education and research is pointless, but on the other think that immigrants from other countries will take years to have qualifications that can benefit the UK society. Which is it?

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:30

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 10:16

Why do you think there is any link between being an asylum seeker and NOT being a net contributor?

Do you know many?

I know refugees who are doctors, engineers, craftsmen, graphic designers, airline pilots, legal experts, journalists, footballers....

I also know many who are children, and will most likely grow up to be net contributors...

I simply don't understand why you are blindly assuming they won't be? Where is this coming from? It is completely unreasonable, and makes no sense to me at all

Nobody is saying ‘asylum seekers are thick’, they’re pointing out the obvious that their qualifications and language ability may well mean they will need years of training to be able to work in the field they previously did in their country of origin. Do we have the cash for this? I’m not sure.

OP posts:
whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 10:30

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:28

What excellent research? I don’t think anyone is going to argue against medical/tech research, but some of it does seem almost pointless.

Well medical and tech are big ones. Sciences. Social sciences. The things that help develop society and the economy. Innovation. What is it that you find pointless?

whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 10:28

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:25

Not really. I don’t think it’s ‘mean’ or ‘bigoted’ to want immigration to benefit our country. With all the other issues piling up we don’t have the cash to spend on long term programs to teach English, get people qualified, help them job hunt and prop them up in the meantime. It hasn’t exactly worked with our own population, who all get their 13+ years of education but many apparently still cannot find a job.

I say that with tongue in cheek though, there are many jobs out there, it’s just the British don’t want to do a lot of them.

Immigration, generally, is positive for the economy. 1) it hasn't cost the state money looking after the immigrants from birth till working age, so that saves a bunch 2) many immigrants return to their home countries on retirement 3) most - depite what the DM would have you believe - are here to work. They are literally here to earn money and thereby contribute to the econonmy. They don't just come here for the good weather.

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:28

whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 10:24

It's not all dire. Some might be, but there is excellent quality education and research happening all over UK universities. There's this weird perception and disdain for HE in British society, exactly this notion that it's all micky mouse degress and has no real value unless you are off to be a doctor or a lawyer.

What excellent research? I don’t think anyone is going to argue against medical/tech research, but some of it does seem almost pointless.

OP posts:
Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:27

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 10:22

@whatadayforadaydream I'm not necessarily opposed to HE being publicly funded, but the quality of what's on offer at present is dire: Ex-polytechnics offering McDegrees to young people who'd be better off doing apprenticeships and gaining actual skills, while the more prestigious institutions peddle neo-Marxist claptrap.

HE should be funded in areas where we have skills shortages. I don’t think anyone should be able to ‘borrow’ 50k from the state to study dance, gender studies or similar. Where is the benefit to the country there? After 13 years of education it just feels like kicking the can down the road to avoid getting a ‘normal’ job. Most of the people I went to school with don’t work in a job related to their degree at all unless it was something like nursing, medicine, engineering etc

OP posts:
GobbieMaggie · 02/03/2023 10:25

25% of the working population pay ZERO income take.

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:25

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 09:49

They’re net recipients in the making though. They’re not going to be working jobs which are high paid enough that they’ll be net contributors. They’ll go into a low paid job and UC

This you? You’re assuming they’ll have benefits and be in low paid jobs?

People can and do learn English and can and do work here and do very well. You’re assuming that they don’t speak English. They may well do already!

But you’re assuming that they will all be taking out more than they give. Which might be the case for a short space of time and then, with support, they’ll do well.

It’s quite a cynical mindset.

Not really. I don’t think it’s ‘mean’ or ‘bigoted’ to want immigration to benefit our country. With all the other issues piling up we don’t have the cash to spend on long term programs to teach English, get people qualified, help them job hunt and prop them up in the meantime. It hasn’t exactly worked with our own population, who all get their 13+ years of education but many apparently still cannot find a job.

I say that with tongue in cheek though, there are many jobs out there, it’s just the British don’t want to do a lot of them.

OP posts:
whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 10:24

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 10:22

@whatadayforadaydream I'm not necessarily opposed to HE being publicly funded, but the quality of what's on offer at present is dire: Ex-polytechnics offering McDegrees to young people who'd be better off doing apprenticeships and gaining actual skills, while the more prestigious institutions peddle neo-Marxist claptrap.

It's not all dire. Some might be, but there is excellent quality education and research happening all over UK universities. There's this weird perception and disdain for HE in British society, exactly this notion that it's all micky mouse degress and has no real value unless you are off to be a doctor or a lawyer.

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 10:22

@whatadayforadaydream I'm not necessarily opposed to HE being publicly funded, but the quality of what's on offer at present is dire: Ex-polytechnics offering McDegrees to young people who'd be better off doing apprenticeships and gaining actual skills, while the more prestigious institutions peddle neo-Marxist claptrap.

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 10:20

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 10:16

Why do you think there is any link between being an asylum seeker and NOT being a net contributor?

Do you know many?

I know refugees who are doctors, engineers, craftsmen, graphic designers, airline pilots, legal experts, journalists, footballers....

I also know many who are children, and will most likely grow up to be net contributors...

I simply don't understand why you are blindly assuming they won't be? Where is this coming from? It is completely unreasonable, and makes no sense to me at all

Just asking for numbers. You knowing people doesn’t make it a statistical reality.

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 10:19

industrial chemist...

In fact, these people contribute more over their life time than british nationals, as we have paid nothing at all for their education and training

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 10:18

translators

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 10:17

o, and teachers - I know quite a lot of refugees who are teachers, heads of department ( my HOD, actually) deputy heads....

also in shortage subjects