Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think ‘the system is broken’ but…

211 replies

Blinddatez · 01/03/2023 23:49

We are also breaking the system.

From reading posts on here, it seems a lot of people don’t realise just how little we actually contribute to ‘the system’, how much things cost to implement, and therefore what level of service we can realistically expect from healthcare, education and so on.

40% of people are net recipients (they receive more from the state than they put in), but that doesn’t include pensioners. Yet the expectations on here of what should be provided by the state seem to be sky high - generous benefits, good quality but cheap housing for everyone, a 5* NHS, immediate and thorough mental health support, good pensions even for people who have never worked for dubious reasons.

AIBU to think, while the money could be better spent than it is right now, the expectation of what should be provided by the state on here is a bit head-in-the-clouds?

OP posts:
beguilingeyes · 02/03/2023 12:19

"40% of people are net recipients (they receive more from the state than they put in), but that doesn’t include pensioners."

Pensioners are taxpayers as well, you know. I get a company pension and my tax rate is the same as everyone else's.

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 12:16

when tenant’s income increases, they should be charged market rent if they want to continue living in a subsidized property that they got due to low earnings.

That won’t go down well on here…

Could they sell in more expensive areas though or would the tenants claim it’s their ‘right’ to stay there, and there would be a big hoo-ha about ‘moving social housing tenants to run down areas’? I feel that would be heavily criticised on here.

I agree though 🤷🏼‍♀️ I would also add, no single person or couple should be able to block a 2+ bed property. Again, that’ll go down like a sack of shit!

OP posts:
LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 02/03/2023 12:06

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 11:50

Have long term, affordable social housing Vs sending huge amounts of housing benefits to landlords with huge property portfolios of mixed quality

Genuinely though, how does that happen? Build new houses? Purchase existing ones? Would the tenants be paying ‘rent’? How would we balance the books? How many houses are needed? What about the cost of maintenance? Sorry not trying to hammer you with questions but ‘long term affordable houses’ is a bit like ‘Brexit means Brexit’, just a phrase unless we can work out how to realistically make it happen.

One idea: selling properties in high value area (Chelsea, etc) and buying in less expensive areas: x5-10 on the number of properties.

Maintenance could be subcontracted with a transparent selection process of the subcontractor, planned reviews, pre-defined penalties if the maintenance is not performed etc.

Also, when tenant’s income increases, they should be charged market rent if they want to continue living in a subsidized property that they got due to low earnings.
In the current economical situation, « they have lived there their whole life » is not enough to justify society paying more than needed to house someone. Private tenants (or even home owners) have to move from properties because of rent/mortgage increases, that’s life.

roarfeckingroarr · 02/03/2023 12:03

TooBigForMyBoots · 02/03/2023 01:14

No we don't @Deathbyfluffy.Hmm Since 2017, the state will only pay benefits for up to two children.

Tax credits perhaps but what about housing benefit for larger properties to accommodate morev

XanaduKira · 02/03/2023 12:00

ladykale · 01/03/2023 23:55

Completely agree.

U.K. has a very entitled population who expect to have a fantastic quality of life based on absolutely nothing.

Everyone talks as if they're overcontributors.

Totally agree with you & this Op.

roarfeckingroarr · 02/03/2023 11:56

ConfusedNT · 02/03/2023 00:10

Some MPs are claiming up to 200k a year in expense

That feels like a waste the MPs expectations of what MPs should expect from taxpayer is broken

This pops up time and time again.

MPS expenses cover their office costs (staff, equipment, rental) and travel (unfair to expect an MP for a Scottish constituency to travel back and forth weekly out of their own pocket). Some take the piss, far fewer these days now there's proper scrutiny in place. Even if all 650 MPs took the piss and spent 200k on Cornish pasties, it's a drop in the ocean of public spending,

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 02/03/2023 11:54

Hoowhoowho · 02/03/2023 09:05

Let’s talk about net recipients shall we?
Joe out there fixing your electric supply after a storm
Shirley making your coffee at Starbucks
George working backbreaking shifts at an Amazon warehouse
are all net recipients if you are talking about their individual tax contribution from their wages, there’s a fair possibility in fact that they all receive UC top ups.

But yet they are all vital cogs in the machine that should generate huge tax revenues for the government. If all the Shirley’s and George’s walked out tomorrow, companies like Starbucks and Amazon would collapse within weeks, their tax revenues (such as they are) lost completely.

So sure Shirley and George and Joe might be met recipients according to their wage packet but infact if you count the tax they contribute to (well would contribute to if certain companies paid their share) they become net contributors.

The top bosses don’t like that workers ultimately hold all the power, that’s why they are opposed to unionisation, it’s why wages are kept low and essential bills high, keep people desperate enough to labour for the man. But it’s not the CEO contributing his 40% tax which funds the NHS or the council houses. It’s the labour of Shirley and George and Joe because without them they’d be no CEO. The system works because of them.

One flaw in your logic is that if the Shirley or George did walk out, their employer could easily replace them, this is the difficulty for unskilled workers.
However, what about the Govt stop paying UC to people working full time and instead increases the min wage? If people need the current min wage + UC to live, then clearly min wage needs to go up.
This to me is the biggest scandal.
Yes, companies will have to pay more, and yes some won’t be able to and will go bankrupt, but if a company can’t pay their workers maybe their business model is flawed and having the state subsidize them is not the solution.

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 11:50

Have long term, affordable social housing Vs sending huge amounts of housing benefits to landlords with huge property portfolios of mixed quality

Genuinely though, how does that happen? Build new houses? Purchase existing ones? Would the tenants be paying ‘rent’? How would we balance the books? How many houses are needed? What about the cost of maintenance? Sorry not trying to hammer you with questions but ‘long term affordable houses’ is a bit like ‘Brexit means Brexit’, just a phrase unless we can work out how to realistically make it happen.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 02/03/2023 11:43

Completely agree. All these people who constantly say ‘they’ should give me more. Well ‘they’ are the taxpayer in reality
Or we spend what we have properly, stop allowing taxpayer money to get passed to the already wealthy and have a proper shake up.

Have long term, affordable social housing Vs sending huge amounts of housing benefits to landlords with huge property portfolios of mixed quality

Invest in making teaching more attractive by having more PPA time instead of having several academy chains with: teachers - head of department - associate director of subject for the trust - director of subject for the trust / head of school - executive head teacher - associate executive principal for the trust etc.

Make water companies sort their shit out (literally) instead of underinvesting for years, and then saying they've got no money left so they have to dump shit on beaches.

Stop bailing out rail franchises who run appalling services once they've pocketed what they want and spend the money on a nationalised, well funded and fairly priced service

Stop letting MPs claim a fortune in expenses with their lucrative lobbying gigs on the side.

It's all choices and it doesn't have to be normal average earners who get hammered.

whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 11:35

RainbowBrightside · 02/03/2023 11:33

Completely agree. All these people who constantly say ‘they’ should give me more. Well ‘they’ are the taxpayer in reality. People who work hard and are being hammered for sky high utilities/food/broadband bills (I could go on but you get the picture) There isn’t any more to give unless you take it from the taxpayer and then they’ll decide that they’re better off on benefits so it’s a higher benefits bill. It’s a horrible circle to get into and I’m not sure how to resolve it really 🤷‍♀️

I honestly don't ever hear people say "they should give me more". What I do hear if people expecting adequate public services. Health care, policing, schooling. And yes, making sure children aren't literally starving in one of the richest economies in the world.

RainbowBrightside · 02/03/2023 11:33

Completely agree. All these people who constantly say ‘they’ should give me more. Well ‘they’ are the taxpayer in reality. People who work hard and are being hammered for sky high utilities/food/broadband bills (I could go on but you get the picture) There isn’t any more to give unless you take it from the taxpayer and then they’ll decide that they’re better off on benefits so it’s a higher benefits bill. It’s a horrible circle to get into and I’m not sure how to resolve it really 🤷‍♀️

LolaSmiles · 02/03/2023 11:26

I think part of the issue is that the way the UK is run is a half way house. It's not REALLY a welfare state, and it's not really not at welfare state. People don't know what it is. Also the convervatives are not, ideologically, behind a welfare state so their policies are working to dilute that within the cultural context of an idolised NHS for example
The UK currently runs the image of a welfare state whilst privatising public services and sending a lot of taxpayer money to companies that are closely linked to people making the policy decisions. Privatise the profits, keep sending the money across, then nationalise the losses and nationalise the funds for infrastructure investment so the companies don't have to use their own money to improve their own infrastructure.

It's kleptocracy in action.

whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 11:18

I think part of the issue is that the way the UK is run is a half way house. It's not REALLY a welfare state, and it's not really not at welfare state. People don't know what it is. Also the convervatives are not, ideologically, behind a welfare state so their policies are working to dilute that within the cultural context of an idolised NHS for example.

RachelSq · 02/03/2023 11:17

YANBU, my household is definitely net-givers (high earners, no benefits of any kind and lucky enough to have very good health so haven’t used the NHS other than for vaccines in 5 years, including for our DS) but we don’t expect the world from services provided through this limited funding.

It’s frustrating when public money is wasted, but honestly the constant moaning of people who have a net-benefit does frustrate me. Where do they think this money comes from?

I’d love to benefit more from what I put in (even in a general sense of better infrastructure/healthcare/better education which would benefit everyone) but accept that with limited funds not everything can be funded as I’d choose.

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 11:14

In many cases our schools would not currently be functioning without refugee teachers. Students would be being sent home

I can tell you that for nothing

LolaSmiles · 02/03/2023 11:14

I don't think it's unreasonable for people to expect reasonable wages, decent terms and conditions and a decent standard of living.

The country has money. It just chooses to prioritise subsiding MP lunches and private flights over hungry children and freezing pensioners.

We COULD have investment in schools and decent terms for school staff so that all children get a decent education. What we actually have is a huge amount of public money being directed into academy chains and bloated layers of management with large salaries.

We COULD have affordable energy and affordable public transport, but we sold them all off so other people get to rake in the profits and expect the taxpayer to foot the losses.

Our country has chosen for decades to prioritise the wealthy at the expense of average citizens.

SweetSenorita · 02/03/2023 11:10

Blinddatez · 01/03/2023 23:49

We are also breaking the system.

From reading posts on here, it seems a lot of people don’t realise just how little we actually contribute to ‘the system’, how much things cost to implement, and therefore what level of service we can realistically expect from healthcare, education and so on.

40% of people are net recipients (they receive more from the state than they put in), but that doesn’t include pensioners. Yet the expectations on here of what should be provided by the state seem to be sky high - generous benefits, good quality but cheap housing for everyone, a 5* NHS, immediate and thorough mental health support, good pensions even for people who have never worked for dubious reasons.

AIBU to think, while the money could be better spent than it is right now, the expectation of what should be provided by the state on here is a bit head-in-the-clouds?

Two words: nail and head 🙂

whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 11:06

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 11:03

🤷🏼‍♀️

We all are; you, me, everyone. If we ignore finances and just focus on what makes you feel warm and fuzzy we won’t have a prosperous and safe future to offer asylum seekers anyway.

Disagree. People fleeing war shouldn't be assessed on their potential financial contribution. Or should we judge others who can't contribute in the same way? And if they don't end up net positive, what should we do with them? Asylum seekers are easy, just send them back to their deaths - not our problem. But what about the people in our own society? What would you have happen to them?

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 11:03

whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 11:01

If @Blinddatez is talking about genuine asylum seekers (as per official defintion) as streams of return that puts a serious bad taste in my mouth.

🤷🏼‍♀️

We all are; you, me, everyone. If we ignore finances and just focus on what makes you feel warm and fuzzy we won’t have a prosperous and safe future to offer asylum seekers anyway.

OP posts:
whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 11:01

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 10:58

I am very aware of this and you are very aware of this and I’m sure you are aware that there are different types of immigration and I’m sure you are aware that some streams provide less of a return than others and I’m sure you’re aware it is not right wing to point this out but I’m also sure you’re aware it’s easier to shut down the conversation by saying it is

what are you suggesting by this? Which “streams” provide less of a “return” @Blinddatez

If @Blinddatez is talking about genuine asylum seekers (as per official defintion) as streams of return that puts a serious bad taste in my mouth.

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 10:58

I am very aware of this and you are very aware of this and I’m sure you are aware that there are different types of immigration and I’m sure you are aware that some streams provide less of a return than others and I’m sure you’re aware it is not right wing to point this out but I’m also sure you’re aware it’s easier to shut down the conversation by saying it is

what are you suggesting by this? Which “streams” provide less of a “return” @Blinddatez

AbsolutePixels · 02/03/2023 10:49

@Kazzyhoward your experience seems to be replicated across business, society and politics: more and more management, less and less efficiency. There's a book called The Managerial Revolution (by James Burnham) that goes into this phenomenon. I haven't yet read it, but think I will do so.

whatadayforadaydream · 02/03/2023 10:42

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:39

Of course it doesn’t, but I think there’s a lot of needless research being done in areas that we don’t have a need for.

Sure. That doesn't mean that there isn't loads of excellent quality research and education going on as well. Which is the point I made which you disputed with this one example.

And really often you need to have a bunch of people doing a bunch of research of all different quality to achieve the really good stuff.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/03/2023 10:41

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 10:30

Nobody is saying ‘asylum seekers are thick’, they’re pointing out the obvious that their qualifications and language ability may well mean they will need years of training to be able to work in the field they previously did in their country of origin. Do we have the cash for this? I’m not sure.

It apparently costs around £25k to train a refugee doctor to practice medicine in the UK, compared to £200k - £250k to train a new doctor.

So if you're concerned about cash I'd be pursuing the refugee route if I were you.

sst1234 · 02/03/2023 10:41

RethinkingLife · 02/03/2023 10:36

Asylum seekers have a very specific definition.

There are some numbers here.

www.refugeecouncil.org.uk/information/refugee-asylum-facts/the-truth-about-asylum/

However, asylum seekers need permission to work and that is only granted after 12 months and with specific conditions.

People who have claimed asylum in the UK can apply for permission to work if they have been waiting 12 months for a decision, and they are not considered responsible for the delay. If permission is granted, the person will be allowed to take up jobs on the shortage occupation list only.

commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn01908/

People who have been granted asylum and settled status/other forms of right to remain or citizenship would be a different group.

What proportion is net contributor?

Swipe left for the next trending thread