Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think ‘the system is broken’ but…

211 replies

Blinddatez · 01/03/2023 23:49

We are also breaking the system.

From reading posts on here, it seems a lot of people don’t realise just how little we actually contribute to ‘the system’, how much things cost to implement, and therefore what level of service we can realistically expect from healthcare, education and so on.

40% of people are net recipients (they receive more from the state than they put in), but that doesn’t include pensioners. Yet the expectations on here of what should be provided by the state seem to be sky high - generous benefits, good quality but cheap housing for everyone, a 5* NHS, immediate and thorough mental health support, good pensions even for people who have never worked for dubious reasons.

AIBU to think, while the money could be better spent than it is right now, the expectation of what should be provided by the state on here is a bit head-in-the-clouds?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 03/03/2023 19:45

Why do you think mundane jobs are always the low paid ones? And therefore can be automated?

I didn't say mundane jobs are always the low paid ones.

It’s very clear that many low paid jobs aren’t necessarily the ones that could be automated.

Some are, some aren't. The point is that investment in automation and higher tech industries creates more value per hour. Therefore if we do more of those things, overall productivity in the economy increases, and therefore there is more money available for salary rises and public services. We need to make the UK an investable proposition again for this to happen. That means investment in infrastructure and education, as both are woeful. It also means removing completely illogical bottlenecks in the tax system so that it's worthwhile for people to upskill and progress their careers without being massively penalised by tax, and rejoining the single market and customs union.

Believeitornot · 03/03/2023 19:12

SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 03/03/2023 17:16

No, it's often about working smarter and getting more out of doing fewer hours. But the point is that employers don't always see it that way and encourage presenteeism.

It's not primarily driven by that either. It's about developing high margin industries and creating an environment where businesses can invest in technology so that people aren't wasting time doing mundane, low value jobs that can be automated.

Why do you think mundane jobs are always the low paid ones? And therefore can be automated?

It’s very clear that many low paid jobs aren’t necessarily the ones that could be automated.

SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 03/03/2023 17:16

No, it's often about working smarter and getting more out of doing fewer hours. But the point is that employers don't always see it that way and encourage presenteeism.

It's not primarily driven by that either. It's about developing high margin industries and creating an environment where businesses can invest in technology so that people aren't wasting time doing mundane, low value jobs that can be automated.

WulyJmpr · 03/03/2023 11:20

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 07:09

The outcome of privatising the energy companies and water companies is a clear example of why relying on the private sector to invest in infrastructure is naive.

Look where we are decades later? They prioritise profit and always will! That’s the job of government, to ensure investment and it’s better for them to do it directly.

Exactly. I'd much rather have "some jobsworth" at the local authority meticulously checking the water PFAS levels than what seems to be going on with water quality recently.

beguilingeyes · 03/03/2023 06:13

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 02/03/2023 11:54

One flaw in your logic is that if the Shirley or George did walk out, their employer could easily replace them, this is the difficulty for unskilled workers.
However, what about the Govt stop paying UC to people working full time and instead increases the min wage? If people need the current min wage + UC to live, then clearly min wage needs to go up.
This to me is the biggest scandal.
Yes, companies will have to pay more, and yes some won’t be able to and will go bankrupt, but if a company can’t pay their workers maybe their business model is flawed and having the state subsidize them is not the solution.

I'm not sure that's true at the moment. The number of unfilled jobs in the UK at the moment is huge, since we sent all of the Europeans home.
Maybe it'll be a seller's market for a while.

beguilingeyes · 03/03/2023 06:09

Catspyjamas17 · 02/03/2023 15:45

I don't see people wanting a fantastic quality of life for nothing. But I think everyone working full time (which should be fewer hours than it currently is) should be able to afford more than just the basics, and have some enjoyment and pleasure in their lives.

And it is completely, not just morally wrong, but economically wrong that people are working all the hours and are still having to choose between paying the gas bill or eating.

I also think we should look after those who are unable to work through the welfare state and they should also have a good quality of life.

If this is entitlement, then I'm happy to be called entitled.

Bravo. This isn't the middle aged. Nobody who works full time should have to use food banks. There's something very wrong about that.
The money is there...it's just all sitting at the top.
I read recently that Jeff Bezos (whose workers have to piss in bottles because they don't get proper breaks) could give his workers $85000 each and he'd still have more money than before the pandemic. How much is enough for these people?

Moreorlessmentallystable · 02/03/2023 19:20

Believeitornot · 02/03/2023 07:55

Exactly!
Having worked for a housing association and seen the cost of building and maintaining housing stock - it can be done much more cost effectively than by private landlords. As soon as you introduce a profit motive or try and do it on the cheap, it all falls apart.

But people that work full time and contribute more than they take from the system still have to pay mortgages- really high ones btw, where banks are making a profit, and this is after getting heavily taxed...that's how capitalism work...

Grumpybutfunny · 02/03/2023 18:27

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 14:07

This means the government could build between 74,000 - 210,000 new "average" houses a year, if they weren't paying out any housing benefit

Have we not lost enough green space as it is without cheap housing ruining what is left? How many wildlife habitats will be destroyed in the process?

High rise building could help with this

Catspyjamas17 · 02/03/2023 15:45

I don't see people wanting a fantastic quality of life for nothing. But I think everyone working full time (which should be fewer hours than it currently is) should be able to afford more than just the basics, and have some enjoyment and pleasure in their lives.

And it is completely, not just morally wrong, but economically wrong that people are working all the hours and are still having to choose between paying the gas bill or eating.

I also think we should look after those who are unable to work through the welfare state and they should also have a good quality of life.

If this is entitlement, then I'm happy to be called entitled.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 02/03/2023 15:35

Then that 40% figure needs to drop, benefits should be only for people that really need them, should not be for life unless you have a an impediment/disability, is not the tax payers fault you want to have kids and only work part time...or that you can't afford housing... We can all have a bad patch and is good the benefits system is there, but why should people get subsided housing for life, uniforms and school meals for free for years, vouchers when kids are on holiday, whilst others have to work for it and still scrape by? Unfortunately service cuts affect mostly to those that are contributing..i.e. teachers strikes affect full time working parents more because of all the disruption...

Catspyjamas17 · 02/03/2023 15:33

SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 02/03/2023 14:27

Productivity isn't necessarily about "working harder". This is what I mean. If people don't grasp the basic economic principles driving the decline then no wonder they've not been pressuring their MPs to actually introduce policies that would be effective in improving things. Instead it always degenerates into moaning and people fighting over the scraps that are left.

No, it's often about working smarter and getting more out of doing fewer hours. But the point is that employers don't always see it that way and encourage presenteeism.

SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 02/03/2023 15:25

The average cost to build a new house is betwee. £1500-£3000 per m2, with the average house in the UK measuring 76m2 this gives an average cost of between £114k - £228k per house.

You have to own the land to build on firsf. Land is the main component in building costs now. Or does your £1.5k-£3k figure include the land itself? If so that seems very low.

Throwncrumbs · 02/03/2023 15:07

ladykale · 01/03/2023 23:55

Completely agree.

U.K. has a very entitled population who expect to have a fantastic quality of life based on absolutely nothing.

Everyone talks as if they're overcontributors.

Yes entitled people who are ‘entitled’ to anything and everything! You see it on here daily ‘ I will be worse off if I work’ gets on my nerves!

SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 02/03/2023 15:05

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 09:49

In fact re immigration from what I can see and my own experience, the highest quality and most productive immigration we had was from Eastern Europe. Such a shame we don’t have that anymore.

Yep. Study after study showed how they were propping up the British economy: more skilled and educated, young and fit, paid more tax and used fewer services than British nationals. This country is completely insane. Not satisfied with having spent a couple of decades shooting itself in the foot repeatedly it decided to shoot itself in the face as well.

beguilingeyes · 02/03/2023 14:53

Fixing this is going to take radical steps and I fear that our current politicians are to unimaginative/cowardly/disinterested to do anything bold.
They're also also only largely looking as far as the next election rather than long term planning.
I also feel that the likes of Rupert Murdoch and Paul Sacred and have such a stranglehold on British media that rocking the boat can be career suicide.

SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 02/03/2023 14:53

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/03/2023 08:41

The welfare state need scaling back to only provide help to the very disabled who absolutely cannot work and those where all adults in the household are working at least 37 hour per week.

That’s all well and good but the infrastructure isn’t there to support all adults working 37 hours per week. I have a child with complex additional needs, she’ll go to a specialist provision school for high school in August, she will still need after school care for me to be able to work. I cannot for love nor money find a childcare setting that will take a 12 year old child. It’s not a case of not being able to afford it - I’m very fortunate that finances aren’t an issue - it’s simply not available.

Many families are absolutely hog tied by the cost of childcare and can’t find anything that works around shift work, for example. It’s an easy thing to say every adult must work, but practically it often looks different.

As a lone parent of children with disabilities, I've always had to use private nannies.

SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 02/03/2023 14:27

Catspyjamas17 · 02/03/2023 07:14

I've tried pointing out on here before that living standards cannot rise until productivity increases,

It's the other way round. Productivity cannot increase unless living standards improve. People are too unwell and too demotivated to work harder.

Productivity isn't necessarily about "working harder". This is what I mean. If people don't grasp the basic economic principles driving the decline then no wonder they've not been pressuring their MPs to actually introduce policies that would be effective in improving things. Instead it always degenerates into moaning and people fighting over the scraps that are left.

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 14:18

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 14:13

improve pubic transport, and build on carparks - double win- people can live closer to work!

More detail needed. This is what I mean, all these somewhat meaningless phrases like ‘improve this or that’ but doesn’t say how.

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 14:16

honestly, the amount of space given over to carparking in this country with so many people unable to afford a home - that system is well and truly broken! Cars that might actually only be in use for 2% of their life - space for them is given precedence over housing!

break the cycle of private car ownership - it is a very recent and totally unsustainable thing, and the housing issue will magically disappear!

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 14:13

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 14:07

This means the government could build between 74,000 - 210,000 new "average" houses a year, if they weren't paying out any housing benefit

Have we not lost enough green space as it is without cheap housing ruining what is left? How many wildlife habitats will be destroyed in the process?

improve pubic transport, and build on carparks - double win- people can live closer to work!

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 14:07

This means the government could build between 74,000 - 210,000 new "average" houses a year, if they weren't paying out any housing benefit

Have we not lost enough green space as it is without cheap housing ruining what is left? How many wildlife habitats will be destroyed in the process?

OP posts:
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/03/2023 14:04

Blinddatez · 02/03/2023 11:50

Have long term, affordable social housing Vs sending huge amounts of housing benefits to landlords with huge property portfolios of mixed quality

Genuinely though, how does that happen? Build new houses? Purchase existing ones? Would the tenants be paying ‘rent’? How would we balance the books? How many houses are needed? What about the cost of maintenance? Sorry not trying to hammer you with questions but ‘long term affordable houses’ is a bit like ‘Brexit means Brexit’, just a phrase unless we can work out how to realistically make it happen.

The government currently spends somewhere between £17b - £24b a year subsiding rent / paying housing benefit (different reports are giving different figures).

The average cost to build a new house is betwee. £1500-£3000 per m2, with the average house in the UK measuring 76m2 this gives an average cost of between £114k - £228k per house.

This means the government could build between 74,000 - 210,000 new "average" houses a year, if they weren't paying out any housing benefit (obviously that's not going to happen overnight)

The average annual payment to someone in receipt of housing benefit is around £4980 pa or £415 pcm, meaning there is between 3.4m-4.8m people claiming housing benefit. The average rent in the UK is £1175, meaning tenants in private rentals who receive housing benefit are paying c.£760 pcm themselves to a private landlord.

Now on to the point of this, the government could have taken that £42.5b they've spent on a vanity project trainline that only benefits a tiny fraction of the county and instead built between 186,00-372,000 new houses.

They then could have moved 186k-372k people from private rentals to the new houses, stopped the housing benefit payments to them and generated some additional income from the tenants share of rent. Hell, they could even lower the rent so tenants in the new properties only paid £500pcm instead of £760.

This would save £910m-£1.8b in year 1 in housing benefits and generate between £93m-£186m in rental payments (using my £500pcm figure), which could be reinvested.

They could then take the further £70b earmarked for HS2 and build a further 307k -£614k new homes and do the same. Thus would refuce the total number of housing benefit recipients by c.500k-980k, saving between £2.5b-£4.8b pa, and generating between £250m -£490m pa in rental payments.

Again reinvest the money saved into building new properties and within a decade or so you've reached the point where there's no need to be paying out housing benefit.

This would also bring the rental market under control and potentially reduce house prices too, and ensure people living in social housing were living in good properies/conditions. You also don't just have to build new houses, building flats or buying existing properties could probably get you to this point much quicker.

Obviously it's not as black and white as that as you'll have ongoing O&M costs and what not, but the lack of affordable housing and all the issues surrounding it is solely down to government choice.

Ask yourself this, would it be more beneficial to the country to have up to a million new, well-insulated, desirable and affordable houses or a one passenger train line that saves 20 minutes when traveling from London to Birminghan or Manchester?

definitelyadaffodil · 02/03/2023 13:41

YANBU But I'm wondering why the salaries are so so low here compared to many other developed countries.
We also don't protect local citizens on getting a job. In the U.K. no one seems to care if the whole IT department just got relocated to a different part of the world for example. Many other EU countries have things in place to stop this sort of thing from happening.

bigbabycooker · 02/03/2023 12:28

And people will be really cross that I said that because they think NI is somehow linked to healthcare and pensions entitlement, but it isn't in any way ring fenced and if it was the case that people had to pay for their healthcare on an insurance basis like in Germany etc, they would be paying a shit tonne more for it (and would actually value it).

bigbabycooker · 02/03/2023 12:26

@beguilingeyes

Actually, it isn't, because you don't pay national insurance, which really needs to change because unfortunately the ageing population has not paid enough in tax to be retired and claiming pension and healthcare for potentially more than 20 years...

Swipe left for the next trending thread