Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Becoming a dad at 51

210 replies

50yearold · 01/03/2023 23:45

I've a lovely 5 year old daughter with my wife. We had fertility issues, down to me as I was on a mediciation that effected my sperm count and wife's age, we met when we were young, I was 29, she was 24, but thought we had loads of time for kids , so enjoyed lots of travel, building our careers, etc, and didn't start trying until she was in her late 30's.

We continued trying for years before we started IVF, we had our perfect girl, but at a later age than most. I was 45, wife was 41.

Now 5 years on, we are considering another child. We always thought we'd settle at one child, but we've talked about and love to add to our family.

Wife is reaching an age which the clinic are saying 'now or never' 46, if we wish to try again, we would have to go straight to double donation, which both of us have no problem at all, rather that than try with a 1% chance using wife's eggs and ICSI with my sperm. We'd love the baby the same.

My only worry is my age, I'm 50 already, would be 51 if the treatment works and the new baby is born, wife would be 47.

On the one hand, I'll leave those kids without a dad probably by the time their in their 30's, 40's. On the other hand at least they would have each other.

Some friends tell me 50+ is too old , others who say go for it.

We've got a lot of savings and big pension, from being childless for so long ( we would hate the idea of kids having to care for us in old age, so have really made provisions for this) .

I love being a dad , but can't help feeling I'm being selfish.

AIBU to want another child at 50+. ?

OP posts:
RogersOrganismicProcess · 02/03/2023 03:22

I was the child in this situation. My dad was 49 when I was born. I spent young childhood grappling with why everyone would refer to him as my grandad. As soon as I became aware of death, I lived with the terror he might die because he did look considerably older than the other dads, and in my childhood mind old people die. I spent my teenage years mortified because his age made me stand out, the girl with the pensioner dad. Adulthood was spent worrying about and caring for his increasing needs.

RoseFl0wers · 02/03/2023 03:19

I think 46 and 50 are too old, sorry. My parents are 50. Also, 6 years is a large age gap between dc so they might not have a super close relationship, although you can’t guarantee this with any age gap. Chromosomal disorders and other disabilities are much higher in babies born to older parents.

PersonaNonGarter · 02/03/2023 03:08

Go for it. You’ll be fine and it will be fun.

Strawberries2023 · 02/03/2023 03:05

Forgot to mention, my older sister is 11yrs older than me and we're very close. We're the closest amongst our siblings.

I know some mumsnetters will start lunging at their keyboards protesting the truth of this post. My dad was obviously a few years older than my mum too.✊

Strawberries2023 · 02/03/2023 02:57

OP, this is mumsnet where majority who post encourage 15yr olds to have sex etc. You're a more sensible parent and adult which is why your are thinking and rethinking things. Your child will be planned for and well loved.

These people had a PM who had children in his late 50s, they didn't protest against it for the sake of the children, even though he already has adult children. It's these same people who spew venom on landlords however accidental, even if only one property which perhaps the LL had b4 they got married and decided to rent it out etc. Yet they're happy for Charles to continue holding on to numerous amounts of property, in fact he's the largest land owner in the UK. The COL is challenging for many young families yet they're about to fund an extravagant coronation. In their eyes you're the peasant and should not look out for yourself and your family.

I say go ahead and I hope you succeed. My dear mum had me in her late 20s but sadly died before I was 7. My dad then re-married within a year. My step-mum was simply focused on having kids, had her first within 9 months and focused on them only.

I have three friends who married within 3years of graduation and are widows now. Yet I have relatives in their 80s and 90s. No one knows how long anyone will live. The wise thing is to evaluate your current health status and go ahead based on the findings.

I'm also mid 40s and my hubs is mid 50s too. We've had several IVFs, all private even though we've paid so much taxes all our lives. We'll continue to try and pray this is our year. All the best.

MintJulia · 02/03/2023 01:53

My ex was 56 when ds was born. He has provided financially for ds, but has been a poor father in every other way.

It has nothing to do with his age though, it is his attitude. He can't be bothered to get involved, thinks children are 'women's work' and has generally been no role model at all.

I taught ds to swim and to catch a ball. I spent hours teaching ds to ride his bike. I can talk Minecraft tactics if necessary. Ex would rather poke sticks in his eyes.

As long as you want to be an involved dad and enjoy your child, go for it. But if you have an 'old man' attitude to children, don't. Children deserve better.

NeverApologiseNeverExplain · 02/03/2023 01:43

Your brother sounds like a right bundle of laughs...
Does he have any tips to mitigate the risks of "things going South"?

NeverApologiseNeverExplain · 02/03/2023 01:41

Why did you wait 5 years OP, when time was not on your side? I agree that a 6 year gap is quite tricky, and it's possibly more of a disincentive than your age for all the logistical reasons described by a PP.

My Mum was 6 years younger than her brother and they were not at all close. I'm nearly 5 years older than my brother and we are close now, but weren't as kids and teens.

I am 49 with a 6 year-old born after IVF. My husband is a few years younger her than me. I was ambivalent about a second and my husband was not at all keen but would have gone with it if I had pushed. In the end we just never got round to it and now it's too late, but I can see so many advantages of our family of three. Who knows what the future will bring, you'll drive yourself mad trying to arbitrage it. My Dad died suddenly at 53 and my Mum at 66, but my 45 year old husband still has both parents and two grandparents with all their faculties intact at over 90.

If you only have one child you'll both have more time and energy to look after yourselves. Does your child have good cousin relationships? I'd be lying if I said I didn't worry about my son being left all alone, but I'm sure I'd still be pretty worried about dying in the next 20 years even if I had 2 or more kids! All I can do is hope that he forms strong relationships outside the family.

Finally, I know a couple in which the woman is late thirties and the man is over 50 (second marriage for him). Nobody batted an eyelid when they had two kids. It's less of a big deal in the real world than it is on here.

Good luck deciding.

Threeboysandadog · 02/03/2023 01:37

Dh was 58 when our youngest was born. My ddad died at 53 so I was well aware of the risks but I don’t wish I hadn’t been born “just in case”. There’s an 8 year gap between ds2 and ds3 but, now they’re older, they are great friends. We have no regrets. If you and your wife both want another child it doesn’t matter what anyone else thinks.

50yearold · 02/03/2023 01:33

mellicauli · 02/03/2023 01:14

6 years is a big gap between kids. (I know I have that gap). I don't regret it but be aware it means an amount of tag-team parenting. That can be a bit lonely: you want to do things as a family but the number of things you can do are limited by the gap.

It means one of you will be taking the 5 year old to a kids party while the other one is taking the other one to their sporting fixture. If you take your kids swimming one of you will have to look after the little one while the other one messes around with the older one. One of you will be sitting on the floor playing Duplo while the other one plays Monopoly. One parent will be playing tennis in the park while the other pushes on the swings. You'll have to work hard to find a film everyone likes or a holiday that suits them both.

So, take into account you will be limiting what your child will do by having a sibling much younger than them. 5-12 are the golden parenting years but you will lose a lot of the fun by having a younger one to accommodate.

You seem convinced you are going to live til 80 but there is also the potential that they might end up their siblings guardian too, which you wouldn't wish on any young person. As a 55 year old, I have noticed a big increase in friends dying..I believe doctors call age 50-60 sniper's alley.

So no, sorry, I wouldn't do it.

But I don't feel convinced I'll live to 80 at all. My wife and I have siblings , with children and when we drafted my will, we discussed who will look after my daughter and any potential new child. My wife is in super good shape, I'm healthy, but my brother is a doctor, (chest) so he reminds me how things can go south , quickly in middle age...

But your points about the gap are true and something for us to think about seriously , thank you. Good points here.

OP posts:
bellabed · 02/03/2023 01:31

I always thought that at a certain age was too old because of the potential future of bein older raising a teen for example. But today news finds a dead baby, day after day children are being abused and not given a chance in life having no one who cares and adults who ruin their lives over and over again.... so makes me reconsider, so what if your older. The love and stability you can give a child is amazing. So many children never have that

AnotherSpare · 02/03/2023 01:30

You'll have comments on both sides here. In my experience mumsnet is either "go for it" or "over 35 is too old for parenting". No one knows you or your life better than yourself. If it's something you want to try then go for it. I'm about to have IVF, age 45 too, same as your wife. Good luck to both of us!

NeverApologiseNeverExplain · 02/03/2023 01:20

Aquamarine1029 · 02/03/2023 00:45

What if this potential child were born with very significant disabilities, which at your ages is a much greater possibility. This would impact your existing child significantly. Sorry, not wanting to be negative, but it's something, I feel, you really need to consider. It's very easy for other people to just say "Go for it!" when the possible consequences wouldn't affect them.

Not true, they have said they will use donor egg and sperm. There is no greater risk of disability in that scenario simply because the woman carrying the child is older. Get your facts right before you stay dispensing advice.

NeverApologiseNeverExplain · 02/03/2023 01:18

ladykale · 02/03/2023 00:23

Particularly with parents that will be older when your kid is 30, would be nice to have a sibling.

I feel sorry for only children generally

Oh do keep your faux sympathy to yourself!

Aquamarine1029 · 02/03/2023 01:18

50yearold · 02/03/2023 00:50

We have. Wife's a 46 year old, and my sperm count low and aged 50, that's why consultant suggests double donation of donor egg and sperm ( from donors in their 20's)

Which still doesn't rule out the potential of having a severely disabled child. How do you think you'd be able to cope?

mellicauli · 02/03/2023 01:14

6 years is a big gap between kids. (I know I have that gap). I don't regret it but be aware it means an amount of tag-team parenting. That can be a bit lonely: you want to do things as a family but the number of things you can do are limited by the gap.

It means one of you will be taking the 5 year old to a kids party while the other one is taking the other one to their sporting fixture. If you take your kids swimming one of you will have to look after the little one while the other one messes around with the older one. One of you will be sitting on the floor playing Duplo while the other one plays Monopoly. One parent will be playing tennis in the park while the other pushes on the swings. You'll have to work hard to find a film everyone likes or a holiday that suits them both.

So, take into account you will be limiting what your child will do by having a sibling much younger than them. 5-12 are the golden parenting years but you will lose a lot of the fun by having a younger one to accommodate.

You seem convinced you are going to live til 80 but there is also the potential that they might end up their siblings guardian too, which you wouldn't wish on any young person. As a 55 year old, I have noticed a big increase in friends dying..I believe doctors call age 50-60 sniper's alley.

So no, sorry, I wouldn't do it.

50yearold · 02/03/2023 01:09

CC4712 · 02/03/2023 00:15

DH and I have a similar age gap to yourselves, also met in our 20's and didn't start TTC till early 30's once married. We TTC 13yrs, 3 losses, rounds of IVF and no children, despite no cause for sub-fertility being found.

Its a personal thing OP and only the 2 of you can decide what is right for you. If I'd been fortunate enough to have a living child, I'd be very grateful for that. I don't though, so can't say. I'm almost 45 and we decided against going down the donor egg route- something only mentioned for the very first time a few months ago! Best of luck whatever you decide.

Thanks @CC4712

The exhausting rounds of IVF, we did so many cycles, spent a fortune, I wasn't ready to think about donor eggs and sperm at that stage and to be honest, we were both exhausted of fertility treatment. Its impossible to describe if one hasn't gone through it. I think if we didn't get lucky, and the bottom line for all the expensive treatment and methods, it boils down to luck, we would have stopped 5 years ago. My poor wife, she was at breaking point.

As an IVF 'veteran' I completely understand why you would say enough, and not want the donor route too. Best of luck to you too and thanks for your advice.

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 02/03/2023 00:56

Having a sibling doesn’t mean you will have someone around once your parents have died. My DB walked away from my family many years ago. Didn’t reappear when DF died. DM is elderly now and he hasn’t been around to help with her care.

If you are going for double donation there won’t be a blood link between the siblings, so maybe very different (nature v nurture)

50yearold · 02/03/2023 00:52

Jadviga · 02/03/2023 00:48

You'll hear answers going both ways on here. What really matters though is what YOU want and feel comfortable with.

Personally I think you're skirting the edge but not quite too old yet. Life expectancy in the UK is 80, which means your child would be around 30 when you die. They will be old enough to manage life as an independant adult. (not to mention plenty of people lose their parents young for many different reasons).

And your daughter might find it beneficial to have a sibling, especially if there aren't a lot of aunts/uncles/cousins they're close to.

Obviously as an older parent there are things you will find harder to do - you will have less energy to do physical things. But you are comfortable financially so you will be able to afford help when you need it, and your child won't miss out.

If you were any older I'd say no, but you still have time. So if this was my choice I'd do it. And I'd have a clear time limit that if it doesn't work within one year I'd give up on the idea.

But it's not my choice, it's yours. And your wife's. I think you need to sit down, write down what you truly want to do, and give each other the paper - this way there is no temptation or pressure to say what you think the other wants to hear.

Another thing that might help is to think long and hard about the reasons why you hesitate.

  • Are you worried about what other people will think ? (and do you really want to let that shape your decision ?)
  • Are you worried about the child losing their parents young ? (many people lose their parents young for many reasons).
  • Are you worried about your energy levels ? (sounds like you can afford help so you can dedicate what energy you do have to your kids - I expect that won't leave you worse off than a young parent rushed off their feet by minimum wage work, housework, extra hours to try and make ends meet, etc)

Close your eyes and imagine your Christmas dinner ten or twenty years from now. Who's at the table ?

I think you already know what you want to do, you just need to reassure yourself that it's the right decision.

Thanks for taking the time @Jadviga brilliant post, really really helpful.

Thank you.

OP posts:
Smineusername · 02/03/2023 00:50

Yeah if you're serious about having a second when you're over 40 and have struggled to conceive you don't leave it 5 years. I think neither of you want a second, it's the departing fertility hormones messing with your head

50yearold · 02/03/2023 00:50

Aquamarine1029 · 02/03/2023 00:45

What if this potential child were born with very significant disabilities, which at your ages is a much greater possibility. This would impact your existing child significantly. Sorry, not wanting to be negative, but it's something, I feel, you really need to consider. It's very easy for other people to just say "Go for it!" when the possible consequences wouldn't affect them.

We have. Wife's a 46 year old, and my sperm count low and aged 50, that's why consultant suggests double donation of donor egg and sperm ( from donors in their 20's)

OP posts:
Jadviga · 02/03/2023 00:48

You'll hear answers going both ways on here. What really matters though is what YOU want and feel comfortable with.

Personally I think you're skirting the edge but not quite too old yet. Life expectancy in the UK is 80, which means your child would be around 30 when you die. They will be old enough to manage life as an independant adult. (not to mention plenty of people lose their parents young for many different reasons).

And your daughter might find it beneficial to have a sibling, especially if there aren't a lot of aunts/uncles/cousins they're close to.

Obviously as an older parent there are things you will find harder to do - you will have less energy to do physical things. But you are comfortable financially so you will be able to afford help when you need it, and your child won't miss out.

If you were any older I'd say no, but you still have time. So if this was my choice I'd do it. And I'd have a clear time limit that if it doesn't work within one year I'd give up on the idea.

But it's not my choice, it's yours. And your wife's. I think you need to sit down, write down what you truly want to do, and give each other the paper - this way there is no temptation or pressure to say what you think the other wants to hear.

Another thing that might help is to think long and hard about the reasons why you hesitate.

  • Are you worried about what other people will think ? (and do you really want to let that shape your decision ?)
  • Are you worried about the child losing their parents young ? (many people lose their parents young for many reasons).
  • Are you worried about your energy levels ? (sounds like you can afford help so you can dedicate what energy you do have to your kids - I expect that won't leave you worse off than a young parent rushed off their feet by minimum wage work, housework, extra hours to try and make ends meet, etc)

Close your eyes and imagine your Christmas dinner ten or twenty years from now. Who's at the table ?

I think you already know what you want to do, you just need to reassure yourself that it's the right decision.

Aquamarine1029 · 02/03/2023 00:45

What if this potential child were born with very significant disabilities, which at your ages is a much greater possibility. This would impact your existing child significantly. Sorry, not wanting to be negative, but it's something, I feel, you really need to consider. It's very easy for other people to just say "Go for it!" when the possible consequences wouldn't affect them.

50yearold · 02/03/2023 00:39

Thanks for everyone's replies. Lots of different opinions.

I think the poster who said child would be 9, when I'm 60, this is what scares me, but then I think of my daughter now, with no-one when we're gone!

OP posts:
Pigletnotatwiglet · 02/03/2023 00:30

No, too old. You will be 60 when your child is 9. Not fair.

Swipe left for the next trending thread