Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Becoming a dad at 51

210 replies

50yearold · 01/03/2023 23:45

I've a lovely 5 year old daughter with my wife. We had fertility issues, down to me as I was on a mediciation that effected my sperm count and wife's age, we met when we were young, I was 29, she was 24, but thought we had loads of time for kids , so enjoyed lots of travel, building our careers, etc, and didn't start trying until she was in her late 30's.

We continued trying for years before we started IVF, we had our perfect girl, but at a later age than most. I was 45, wife was 41.

Now 5 years on, we are considering another child. We always thought we'd settle at one child, but we've talked about and love to add to our family.

Wife is reaching an age which the clinic are saying 'now or never' 46, if we wish to try again, we would have to go straight to double donation, which both of us have no problem at all, rather that than try with a 1% chance using wife's eggs and ICSI with my sperm. We'd love the baby the same.

My only worry is my age, I'm 50 already, would be 51 if the treatment works and the new baby is born, wife would be 47.

On the one hand, I'll leave those kids without a dad probably by the time their in their 30's, 40's. On the other hand at least they would have each other.

Some friends tell me 50+ is too old , others who say go for it.

We've got a lot of savings and big pension, from being childless for so long ( we would hate the idea of kids having to care for us in old age, so have really made provisions for this) .

I love being a dad , but can't help feeling I'm being selfish.

AIBU to want another child at 50+. ?

OP posts:
Crazykefir · 02/03/2023 07:50

I think if you have doubts knock it on the head. I had an older father who had poor health not a bundle of laughs for a teenager.

Marchforward · 02/03/2023 07:50

Jadviga · 02/03/2023 00:48

You'll hear answers going both ways on here. What really matters though is what YOU want and feel comfortable with.

Personally I think you're skirting the edge but not quite too old yet. Life expectancy in the UK is 80, which means your child would be around 30 when you die. They will be old enough to manage life as an independant adult. (not to mention plenty of people lose their parents young for many different reasons).

And your daughter might find it beneficial to have a sibling, especially if there aren't a lot of aunts/uncles/cousins they're close to.

Obviously as an older parent there are things you will find harder to do - you will have less energy to do physical things. But you are comfortable financially so you will be able to afford help when you need it, and your child won't miss out.

If you were any older I'd say no, but you still have time. So if this was my choice I'd do it. And I'd have a clear time limit that if it doesn't work within one year I'd give up on the idea.

But it's not my choice, it's yours. And your wife's. I think you need to sit down, write down what you truly want to do, and give each other the paper - this way there is no temptation or pressure to say what you think the other wants to hear.

Another thing that might help is to think long and hard about the reasons why you hesitate.

  • Are you worried about what other people will think ? (and do you really want to let that shape your decision ?)
  • Are you worried about the child losing their parents young ? (many people lose their parents young for many reasons).
  • Are you worried about your energy levels ? (sounds like you can afford help so you can dedicate what energy you do have to your kids - I expect that won't leave you worse off than a young parent rushed off their feet by minimum wage work, housework, extra hours to try and make ends meet, etc)

Close your eyes and imagine your Christmas dinner ten or twenty years from now. Who's at the table ?

I think you already know what you want to do, you just need to reassure yourself that it's the right decision.

Life expectancy maybe 80 but often with years of ill health before. That means your adult child will be in their 20s and dealing with this.

Apollonia1 · 02/03/2023 07:47

I had my twins at 47.

My parents were in their 40s having my siblings and me, and are healthy (now 92/93).

I loved having older parents as a kid. I was proud my mum had a career (back in the 60s) before having kids.

One of my friends is 45 (husband 51) and they are trying for a second with double donation.

Greenfairydust · 02/03/2023 07:45

Sorry, but this is selfish.

You might be fit and healthy still at the moment, but you would be a pensioner when the child is a teenager and you would saddle someone in their 20s potentially having to deal with his elderly father needing care.

Because you could have another child does not mean you should.

I had an older father and it became a big issue. I spent my teenage years seeing him in hospital because he had health issues. We never had any kind of bond because he was of a completely different generation with really old-fashioned ideas and he was always too tired to do any kind of activity with me.

picklemewalnuts · 02/03/2023 07:40

I'm going to raise the spectre of the implications of double donation.

Your child will have no genetic link to any of its family. It will lose you earlier than most.
Pregnancy with donated eggs is apparently riskier to both mum and baby.

Even if it's unsuccessful, your DD will know she wasn't enough and you wanted more.

My DS hated his little brother from about 6months until 7. They are fab now, but it was a trying few years.
I'm almost 54. I can't imagine anything worse than going through that again!

screamingj · 02/03/2023 07:39

It won't be easy for your wife to go through what it takes to have a child and then be bounced straight into menopause.

RampantIvy · 02/03/2023 07:37

At 71 DH is still working to support DD through university.
He also has health issues.

Just something to consider.

honeylulu · 02/03/2023 07:36

We had our youngest when I was nearly 40 and husband was 53. That wasn't the plan, our eldest was nearly 10 and we planned a much smaller gap but had a lot of bad luck in between. No regrets, youngest has brought balance and so much love and happiness into our family. We have plenty of money and space (paid off mortgage the year she was born) which helps. But I will say that I worry sometimes about being older parents and how long we'll stay alive and well for her, especially my husband who is now 62 (she is 9). All OK so far but two of his siblings have died and the other has just been diagnosed with cancer so I'm acutely aware things can change so quickly. His parents are dead and never knew youngest, mine are doddery and have been much less involved this time. I'm fit and well and actually found motherhood less tiring and difficult this time around. But husband seems much more worn out with it and I often take youngest out at the weekend and he stays at home for a rest. As I say no regrets but in an ideal world we would have completed our family when I was mid 30s and he was late 40s.

DanRogersAndHisHorse · 02/03/2023 07:35

DH was 57 when ours was born. he's (perhaps obviously!) alot older than me. He has no other children.

Pros- we were settled in careers and he was able to take a big step back as he was very senior so had loads of time with DS as a baby and as a toddler
-he's now retired so does alot of hands on parenting now DS is ateen
-financially solvent
-he was (is) thrilled to have a child after never thinking he would
-he is very fit and has more energy than I do

Cons

  • there is a biological reality here- DH will most likely die when DS is quite young- he keeps himself in tip top condition tho0ugh and at 70 is extremely fit and looks 10 years younger
  • people confuse him for Granddad!
  • people were critical and probably are still critical- but so what?

I firmly believe that families come in all shapes and sizes and the only thing that matters is that children are loved, protected, and their emotional, social and educational needs are met.

englishmummyinwales · 02/03/2023 07:34

My DH was 50 when we had DS1 and 51 when we had his brother. I’m 10 years younger. We have kept healthy and active and I really don’t think we are different from other families. As long as you keep engaged and involved with your children’s lives and are physically well, it’s not a problem. DH has just celebrated his 65th birthday with our two teenagers - he is still working (from home so no commute which helps conserve energy) and still has two fairly healthy parents, age 89 & 92 so clearly has good genes. Like you, I wanted two children so they have each other. You will know the statistical risks involved with having babies later although it’s slight and not as huge a risk as many seem to think. I hope it works out for you, good luck.

Ginger1982 · 02/03/2023 07:32

I don't want to derail the thread but it's sad that people still trot out old tropes about only children. We're fine, we don't need pity and we build our own families and friend networks. We are not lonely or alone.

But back to your situation, for me personally 47 and 51 would be too old. I also wonder, and I say this from a place of ignorance on the subject, whether any second child might feel strange knowing they have no biological link?

Anything can happen. My dad was 30 when I was born and died when he was 43. It's really a decision only you can make.

JacquelinePot · 02/03/2023 07:28

Bit old, sorry, and egg "donation" is incredibly unethical.

MamOfFive · 02/03/2023 07:26

To old, not fair that your young potential child would have to take care of two aging parents.

Name999999 · 02/03/2023 07:24

Too old sorry. I say this from seeing my Grandmother having her last baby in her 40s. My uncle is young in his 40s now but has a lot on taking care of his ageing parents. It’s not fair on him at all.

Nimbostratus100 · 02/03/2023 07:12

Have you considered fostering? You sound like lovely caring people with a secure home, and could potentially raise a child who already exists, but doesn't have the love and care that they need

Im99912 · 02/03/2023 07:09

my ex has a baby at 51
he has grandkids the same age as his youngest and his oldest - my son is 29 this year all of his kids think he is mad
I think he’s an idiot / his dad died when he was only 57
but he’s the type who has a kid with every relationship to “ seal the relationship as such

he does have a young fun attitude so maybe that helps

I couldn’t imagine having a baby at your wife’s age
but if you are happy go for it

Dustyblue · 02/03/2023 07:05

Bard6817 · 02/03/2023 06:53

You’d be very brave to be a new dad in your 50’s.

I was in same boat - and now I’m on GP duties (step daughters) it’s a killer and I struggle with more than a day or two. Also, we have to be more understanding of kids these days, lots more ‘issues’ are known about - and the clip round the ear we got as kids that taught us right from wrong, or what danger was, has to be handled as though we have degrees in psychology now.

So my much younger partner and I discussed the idea of our own - and I’m just too long in the tooth, too old, too grumpy, too much of the ‘man up’ generation - for it to be the right decision. Im a perfect GP though. For about a day or two.

Do you have the energy? We sail, 8 hour shifts Atlantic crossings, poor weather, hard work, bad sleep…. Easy peasy, having a kid at 50…. Not for the feint hearted.

Great post, some wise words here!

Bard6817 · 02/03/2023 06:53

You’d be very brave to be a new dad in your 50’s.

I was in same boat - and now I’m on GP duties (step daughters) it’s a killer and I struggle with more than a day or two. Also, we have to be more understanding of kids these days, lots more ‘issues’ are known about - and the clip round the ear we got as kids that taught us right from wrong, or what danger was, has to be handled as though we have degrees in psychology now.

So my much younger partner and I discussed the idea of our own - and I’m just too long in the tooth, too old, too grumpy, too much of the ‘man up’ generation - for it to be the right decision. Im a perfect GP though. For about a day or two.

Do you have the energy? We sail, 8 hour shifts Atlantic crossings, poor weather, hard work, bad sleep…. Easy peasy, having a kid at 50…. Not for the feint hearted.

cptartapp · 02/03/2023 06:44

My friend was 50 when he and his 47 year old wife had their second set of twins.
All well now and they're gorgeous, but statistically, however fit and active and young minded you are in your fifties, you have the physiological biology of someone that age and are far more likely to leave your DC fatherless in their thirties. And that's presuming you make it to 80 plus.

Dustyblue · 02/03/2023 06:36

OP your story resonates with me somewhat. We also met in our 20's and put off having kids due to worry about housing security, career direction, finances etc. Started trying when I was 35. Six years & two miscarriages later we had our boy.

He's now 6, DH is almost 50, I'm 48. We are freaking knackered! In the newborn phase when I was a sprightly 41, I said to DH "If I were 10 years younger and 10 times wealthier, I still wouldn't do this again".

However, your circumstances sound quite different. I can't tell you what's best for you two.

On the older parent issue- I agree there are probably more negative aspects than positive, in all honesty. The main positive I can think of is that DS will get his hands on a substantial inheritance at a young-ish age. With no siblings to argue with over it.

Hopefully he can set himself up earlier in life than his parents did and break that cycle.

Good luck in making a good decision.

HistoryFanatic · 02/03/2023 06:29

There are four and a half years between our two IVF children. My DH was 51 when our youngest was born last year. He does find it tiring but he plays and chases them in soft play all the time. I am younger than your wife though. Just found out I am pregnant again. All being well he will be 52. If you feel up to it why not?

mediumbrownmug · 02/03/2023 03:57

I believe the clinic already gave you the answer when they told you you’re right on the line. You are, and some will say you’re already over and others will say not, because it’s a close run thing. It’s a bit now or never, as they told you.

Totally your choice. Either way is fine.

icefishing · 02/03/2023 03:48

I think that having a child who isn't genetically related to either of you could have a significant impact on their mental health when they are older particularly as first dc is genetically related to both of you.
That combined with your age means that I would give it hard swerve. It is hard with ivf, we ended up having only one pregnancy.
I would focus on what you do have.

Lucylock · 02/03/2023 03:42

I think it's a personal decision., but ethically if you're having to use donor eggs because of your wife's age then surely that tells you that you're too old.

Men can become parents for longer, but it doesn't mean that they should.

FourFour · 02/03/2023 03:37

mellicauli · 02/03/2023 01:14

6 years is a big gap between kids. (I know I have that gap). I don't regret it but be aware it means an amount of tag-team parenting. That can be a bit lonely: you want to do things as a family but the number of things you can do are limited by the gap.

It means one of you will be taking the 5 year old to a kids party while the other one is taking the other one to their sporting fixture. If you take your kids swimming one of you will have to look after the little one while the other one messes around with the older one. One of you will be sitting on the floor playing Duplo while the other one plays Monopoly. One parent will be playing tennis in the park while the other pushes on the swings. You'll have to work hard to find a film everyone likes or a holiday that suits them both.

So, take into account you will be limiting what your child will do by having a sibling much younger than them. 5-12 are the golden parenting years but you will lose a lot of the fun by having a younger one to accommodate.

You seem convinced you are going to live til 80 but there is also the potential that they might end up their siblings guardian too, which you wouldn't wish on any young person. As a 55 year old, I have noticed a big increase in friends dying..I believe doctors call age 50-60 sniper's alley.

So no, sorry, I wouldn't do it.

We have a 6 year age gap and yes we are split with each of their needs. BUT they have the most precious relationship. My 6yo ds is absolutely the best with his sister. We don't have the competitiveness and fighting as you would with 2 kids with a smaller age gap. And at 6yo he is so independent and does most things for himself so I can focus on the baby. My ds is so helpful as well, he's always running first if she cries and is so protective over her, he reads to her and plays with her. I don't think the age gap is a problem at all, only you and your dw will know if this is the right decision for your family. A big concern for us was also my ds being an only later in life if we are not around. Best of luck.