Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Becoming a dad at 51

210 replies

50yearold · 01/03/2023 23:45

I've a lovely 5 year old daughter with my wife. We had fertility issues, down to me as I was on a mediciation that effected my sperm count and wife's age, we met when we were young, I was 29, she was 24, but thought we had loads of time for kids , so enjoyed lots of travel, building our careers, etc, and didn't start trying until she was in her late 30's.

We continued trying for years before we started IVF, we had our perfect girl, but at a later age than most. I was 45, wife was 41.

Now 5 years on, we are considering another child. We always thought we'd settle at one child, but we've talked about and love to add to our family.

Wife is reaching an age which the clinic are saying 'now or never' 46, if we wish to try again, we would have to go straight to double donation, which both of us have no problem at all, rather that than try with a 1% chance using wife's eggs and ICSI with my sperm. We'd love the baby the same.

My only worry is my age, I'm 50 already, would be 51 if the treatment works and the new baby is born, wife would be 47.

On the one hand, I'll leave those kids without a dad probably by the time their in their 30's, 40's. On the other hand at least they would have each other.

Some friends tell me 50+ is too old , others who say go for it.

We've got a lot of savings and big pension, from being childless for so long ( we would hate the idea of kids having to care for us in old age, so have really made provisions for this) .

I love being a dad , but can't help feeling I'm being selfish.

AIBU to want another child at 50+. ?

OP posts:
Fundays12 · 02/03/2023 10:19

I am in 2 minds about that’s this. We have 3 kids. The youngest is nearly 4 and dh is 50 now. I am 42 but feel to old to have more kids. Being honest I think dh is to old to have more too but we have 3 kids so it’s a lot to deal with anyway. We might feel differently if we had one child.

However it hasn’t affected our ability to do activities etc with them as we do lots of things like swimming, football, homework, park trips etc. It’s actually quite the opposite that a lot of the young parents in the dcs school do very little with there kids. They seem more fixated on themselves, social media and there social life. Off course that’s not all of them but it’s so noticeable my oldest dc who is 11 has commented on it and made reference to it a few times so age doesn’t necessarily come into how hands on a parent you are.

You do need to seriously consider how can you care for a child if they have disabilities. The risks do improve with age. I personally would think long and hard how you will feel having a 11 year old and 5 year old potentially etc.

Greatly · 02/03/2023 10:18

I think when I was a teen it would have mattered that my sibling wasn't biologically related to me.

Ponoka7 · 02/03/2023 10:16

I agree with the posters saying that having a sibling doesn't mean that they are close, emotionally or in physical distance. This is going to be controversial but they won't be biologically related and that matters to some people. It can also be a point of contention the difficult teen years.

TheCraicDealer · 02/03/2023 10:15

In your particular set of circumstances I wouldn’t. I think the risk of your combined ages is the real issue, not the fact that you would be 51 (assuming you’re successful). 51 isn’t that old, but normally the other partner is a good bit younger which offsets many of the negatives/risks of one being an older parent. I think the point a poster made about your DD potentially having to be a guardian for any later potential child is a really good one.

Your wife’s advanced age (plus a donor conception) make pregnancy and childbirth riskier for her. Not just the risk of death but also injury, which could effect the whole family’s quality of life. Plus there’s the inherent stresses and anxieties around the treatment itself- however you try to insulate your DD from that it will have an impact on family life.

Having another child who is not genetically related to any of the three of you (unlike your existing child) is also potentially going to be a lot for that child to deal with as they age. It’s a huge, huge difference between them and your DD and I would not underplay it. And when they really start thinking about it and becoming aware of it, that’s when you and your wife could be dealing with your own health issues or navigating the teen/uni years with your elder child, which isn’t a walk in the park either. The worst case scenario there would be that you’re not there to explain or just be there for them as they navigate that.

I know a major factor is wanting to give your child a sibling, but six years is a big gap. It will probably take until the teen years for your younger one for them to be on the same level, plus there’s no guarantees with any sibling relationship that they’ll get on nevermind be close. I’ve known a few siblings with that sort of gap and they’re just like ships in the night. Strangely, the ones with bigger gaps that do get on seem to have another sibling- perhaps because when it’s only two the dynamic is more like two only children rather than a sib-set. Yes there’s a chance another child could be your DD’s best friend, but they could just as likely have a non-existent or difficult relationship and be of no support when you’re incapacitated/gone.

I would agree with posters who’ve said if having a second was of the upmost importance to you you would have cracked on immediately after DD was born. Of course it’s not as easy as that. I’m sure there was a massive amount of trauma and distress that you as a couple needed to actually recover from before it even entered your headspace. But it does seem like you’ve been told “last chance saloon guys, one for the road?”, and you’re now talking yourselves into it.

A good friend of mine is an only child (older mum in his case) and spent his childhood being put through prep school and travelling the world to really exotic locations during the holidays (and even now tbf!), going on road trips with his dad to football matches and gigs. Just loads of amazing memories and an enviable quality of life. Personally, if it were me, I’d rather be chasing that sort of childhood for my DD rather than a sibling.

CallCollect · 02/03/2023 10:15

Greatly · 02/03/2023 09:50

Kids don't need life experience from a parent. They need a healthy, engaged parent.

Agreed - but there's no reason 50 year old new parents can't be this!

DanRogersAndHisHorse · 02/03/2023 10:13

CallCollect · 02/03/2023 10:03

Just be matter of fact with your kids about ages if they get teased - say - yes - we're older than the average parent but that doesn't mean it's a problem - if they mention getting teased keep it matter of fact/non emotional/the 'non issue' that it is - remember- they could also be teased for having young parents, being richer or poor than the average school demographic, etc etc

It might change of course but DS has never been teased because of his dad's age. Although to be fair his cohort of peers tend to have slightly older parents anyway - mid to late 50s currently rather than 70, but even so. DH is at the school gate every single day so it's not like the kids don't see him at all.

Once a teacher assumed DH was granddad but we all thought it was funny and laughed. Poor teacher was mortified but we assured him about it.

I recall when I was pg I mentioned to the midwife that we were older parents. She shrugged and said 'as long as the combined age is not more than 90 it does not matter'. I laughed and said the combined age was 94. She then admitted she had just plucked a figure out of the air. Grin

I get more stick for being much younger (which apparently for the hard of thinking makes me a god digger Hmm ) than DH has ever got for being older.

Greatly · 02/03/2023 10:13

I believe that using donor eggs and sperms is unethical. That isn't "hateful". Just enjoy the child you have.

CallCollect · 02/03/2023 10:09

@Whydoitry
Totally agree with everything you've said!

theleafandnotthetree · 02/03/2023 10:04

Especially in your later posts, you sound quite arrogant OP. Clearly you see yourself and your wife as pretty amazing and successful and as people who should get everything they want. Including in this case using donated sperm AND eggs to have a second child when you have frankly spent a lot of years when you could have been trying not trying, if it was that important to you. For what it's worth, I think this is a pretty terrible idea for many, many reasons. You are too old, both of you. And you did ask.

CallCollect · 02/03/2023 10:03

MicroSoftTeamz · 02/03/2023 09:51

I personally would think about when your youngest starts school etc and you being older parents and how they may get teased for that..
I personally think its a bit too old.

Just be matter of fact with your kids about ages if they get teased - say - yes - we're older than the average parent but that doesn't mean it's a problem - if they mention getting teased keep it matter of fact/non emotional/the 'non issue' that it is - remember- they could also be teased for having young parents, being richer or poor than the average school demographic, etc etc

Whydoitry · 02/03/2023 10:00

50yearold · 02/03/2023 00:39

Thanks for everyone's replies. Lots of different opinions.

I think the poster who said child would be 9, when I'm 60, this is what scares me, but then I think of my daughter now, with no-one when we're gone!

I hate the "my child will have no-one when I'm gone" mentality. Plenty of people don't like their siblings. Only children make friends. It's a terrible reason imo to have a second child.

Tbh when my parents die, my sibling won't be much comfort as I never see them. They live in New Zealand.

But if you want another one for the joy of it, no I don't think 51 is too old. My partner was older than that because we met later in life, and it's wonderful seeing him with DC.

threeplusmum · 02/03/2023 09:59

@Farmageddon

I know his sperm is healthy and he is extremely fertile because he had it checked at Harley street and that is what the doctor told him, this was when he was with a previous partner. I'm not just making empty assumptions.

CallCollect · 02/03/2023 09:56

blebbleb · 02/03/2023 09:51

@CallCollect I agree with you re the heathy lifestyle. My father in law in 63 and in a terrible states due to obesity and alcoholism. The effects started to show early to mid 50s.

Yeah that's the thing - people tend to feel the effects of being unhealthy at this age in a way they wouldn't fo at 30

50yearold · 02/03/2023 09:54

JacquelinePot · 02/03/2023 09:49

Putting a woman at risk of harm in order to extract her eggs so that a 3rd party can have a baby who will never know it's genetic mother is extremely unethical. I'm sorry if it hurts your feelings, but it's true.

You can of course choose to do it, it is legal. If you do, I suggest you try to care less about what strangers on the Internet think.

Best of luck whatever you decide.

Doesnt hurt my feelings at all.

As much as I find your obviously deeply researched views on donor conception fascinating , my AIBU is if I'm too much a old geezer to have a baby, just in case you missed the big block of text at the top of this page.

😊

OP posts:
blebbleb · 02/03/2023 09:51

@CallCollect I agree with you re the heathy lifestyle. My father in law in 63 and in a terrible states due to obesity and alcoholism. The effects started to show early to mid 50s.

MicroSoftTeamz · 02/03/2023 09:51

I personally would think about when your youngest starts school etc and you being older parents and how they may get teased for that..
I personally think its a bit too old.

Greatly · 02/03/2023 09:50

Kids don't need life experience from a parent. They need a healthy, engaged parent.

CallCollect · 02/03/2023 09:49

You'll make a great new dad at 51 - think of all that life experience.

However if I were to become a parent at 50 plus I'd consider keeping my BMI down to about 20. This way I'd feel fitter to deal with all the challenges kids can bring. I do think a 50 year old can make a great new parent but I also think 'fat at 50' is a very different kettle of fish from 'fat at 30' - hence my motivation to stay slim. Also I'd quit smoking and only drink occasionally. While a 50 with their life experience can make an excellent new parent, I also think 50 plus is the time when overweight, excessive drinking and smoking can catch up with people - so time to obliterate the latter 3 - fast!

Greatly · 02/03/2023 09:49

All I can say is that dh and I are in our 50s and can't wait for our kids to leave home so that we can enjoy life on our own terms for a bit in case either of us get ill in our 60s. Can't imagine doing it all again at this age!

JacquelinePot · 02/03/2023 09:49

Putting a woman at risk of harm in order to extract her eggs so that a 3rd party can have a baby who will never know it's genetic mother is extremely unethical. I'm sorry if it hurts your feelings, but it's true.

You can of course choose to do it, it is legal. If you do, I suggest you try to care less about what strangers on the Internet think.

Best of luck whatever you decide.

HeyBearILoveYou · 02/03/2023 09:46

I am 35, my husband is 52. Our first pregnancy ended at 5 months, when he was 50. We went on to have our daughter last year.

He has two older daughters (11 and 17) so there's no question of us having any more - we have quite enough daughters - but he has admitted to actually enjoying this time round more. He's not so pressured at work, he's able to spend more time with her etc.

Personally, from experience, I'd say go for it but everyone's situation is different. We're both fully aware that he may have less time with her than I will, but we make every effort to do as much as we can and enjoy every single minute. Anything could happen at any time with anyone, and we are doing everything we can to make sure she had as much time and as many memories with her wonderful dad as possible.

Greatly · 02/03/2023 09:46

he is nearly 55 yet he is fitter and more fertile then men half his age

How on earth do you know this 🤣

Farmageddon · 02/03/2023 09:45

threeplusmum · 02/03/2023 00:02

Me and my partner who we share a 22 year age gap are about to have our second child together - he is nearly 55 yet he is fitter and more fertile then men half his age. My own dad had me in his late forties and he is now in his eighties ! Age is just a number I think you should go for it. I'd of hated to be an only child.

Why do people say this? I'm sorry but that's just not true - there is no way that he is biologically healthier or that his sperm count and quality is better than the average healthy 27/28 year old - that's just not possible. There is a reason that most athletes retire early, because no matter how much they train they just don't get the same results anymore.

He may well be fit and healthy, and faring better than his similar aged peers, but cellular ageing happens to everyone and there is only so much that diet and exercise can do to slow it down.

Endlesssummer2022 · 02/03/2023 09:44

Everyone will have their own opinion or agenda based on their personal circumstances. Ignore everyone, including me! but I think you should go for it. Do what you feel is right for your family.

As an aside, I think the comments about only children earlier in the thread are completely out of order. I know many very happy only children who stayed that way into adulthood. If you think only children have to be sad and lonely, you lack imagination.

blebbleb · 02/03/2023 09:41

If you want to do it, go for it. As long as you're an active and engaged parent I don't think your children will care or notice. My mum had me at 21, and she was always old to me even then! Parents are seen as old whatever age they had you, especially when kids are little. Yes you might not be around when they're 40 or 50 but a long life isn't guaranteed for anyone anyway.

Swipe left for the next trending thread