Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Becoming a dad at 51

210 replies

50yearold · 01/03/2023 23:45

I've a lovely 5 year old daughter with my wife. We had fertility issues, down to me as I was on a mediciation that effected my sperm count and wife's age, we met when we were young, I was 29, she was 24, but thought we had loads of time for kids , so enjoyed lots of travel, building our careers, etc, and didn't start trying until she was in her late 30's.

We continued trying for years before we started IVF, we had our perfect girl, but at a later age than most. I was 45, wife was 41.

Now 5 years on, we are considering another child. We always thought we'd settle at one child, but we've talked about and love to add to our family.

Wife is reaching an age which the clinic are saying 'now or never' 46, if we wish to try again, we would have to go straight to double donation, which both of us have no problem at all, rather that than try with a 1% chance using wife's eggs and ICSI with my sperm. We'd love the baby the same.

My only worry is my age, I'm 50 already, would be 51 if the treatment works and the new baby is born, wife would be 47.

On the one hand, I'll leave those kids without a dad probably by the time their in their 30's, 40's. On the other hand at least they would have each other.

Some friends tell me 50+ is too old , others who say go for it.

We've got a lot of savings and big pension, from being childless for so long ( we would hate the idea of kids having to care for us in old age, so have really made provisions for this) .

I love being a dad , but can't help feeling I'm being selfish.

AIBU to want another child at 50+. ?

OP posts:
Travelationjubilation · 02/03/2023 11:34

I just don't think that 51 is that old, especially when you have a small child already so it's hardly going to be a shock to the system.

TheaBrandt · 02/03/2023 11:26

Can’t see why you would want to. Enjoy your life and your existing daughter - this is a risky enterprise.

RainbowBrightside · 02/03/2023 11:24

Sounds awful. I had my son when I was in my twenties and now he’s grown up. I was younger and able to cope with being up all night with him and doing all the stuff that little boys want to do. Now I’m in my forties, frankly, I can’t be arsed. I just want to chill at the weekend. My son is grown up and we have a lovely adult relationship which suits us all just fine. I’m looking forward to grandchildren now who I can hand back when they scream too much 😆

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 02/03/2023 11:23

You're not too old. Wishing you and your wife all the love and luck possible to grow your family.

justasking111 · 02/03/2023 11:20

AldiorLidl · 02/03/2023 08:53

@justasking111 59 + 20 is 79, nearly 80.

OP is 51

50yearold · 02/03/2023 11:17

DanRogersAndHisHorse · 02/03/2023 10:47

I don't think you come across as arrogant, OP.

anyway- is deciding 'no' something you think you will regret for the rest of your life? If so, then go for it. many people have children with less thought than you and your wife are clearly putting into it. You know the pitfalls, you are aware of all the implications. Think about what you wish for as a family.

Good luck with whatever you decide.

Thanks for your post.

If we decided no, I think we can happily live with just the 3 of us.

Even if we say yes, 70% chance IVF wont work with donor embryo...

OP posts:
savethatkitty · 02/03/2023 10:57

You & your wife sound lovely. Don't let age hold you back. Go for it! People are living longer these days, you may live well into your 90's

QueenCamilla · 02/03/2023 10:51

day after day children are being abused and not given a chance in life having no one who cares and adults who ruin their lives over and over again.... so makes me reconsider, so what if your older. The love and stability you can give a child is amazing.

What the heck has that to do with the parental age?
Plenty of parental abuse cases where the parents are of... advanced age.

I can't deduct how much love can OP give from an online post. Stability most definitely not though. Having old parents is very de-stabilising.

Sweetpotatopastapot · 02/03/2023 10:48

Two thoughts! One against and one for!

~It is isn’t looking after babies and toddlers that is hard as an older parent, it is parenting teens: waiting anxiously until
you hear front door at 2am, being called out in the early hours to rescue them and their their friend who has drunk too much,, driving them back and forth to uni, collecting them from distant railway stations and airports, and most exhausting of all; supporting them emotionally through various ups and downs, academic crises, relationship break ups, and dealing with push back and opposition when you just want the best for them and love them to death but they can’t quite comprehend
why you don’t think back-packing around
Tajikistan on your own for a month with £50 savings is a good idea

~Obviously large age gaps between dc can be difficult to manage from a parental pov but once those dc grow up those age gaps completely disappear and you are just adults together and hopefully get on well.

DanRogersAndHisHorse · 02/03/2023 10:47

I don't think you come across as arrogant, OP.

anyway- is deciding 'no' something you think you will regret for the rest of your life? If so, then go for it. many people have children with less thought than you and your wife are clearly putting into it. You know the pitfalls, you are aware of all the implications. Think about what you wish for as a family.

Good luck with whatever you decide.

Heavensalongwayaway · 02/03/2023 10:42

My grandad was 55 when my dad was born and my gran 41. DDad said it made no difference to him and that he was a great dad. If you want to then go for it.

GarveySister · 02/03/2023 10:42

donor sperm and eggs

GarveySister · 02/03/2023 10:41

QueenCamilla · 02/03/2023 10:32

What age will this end. What age is the cut-off morally and ethically?
Just because we (medically) can, doesn't mean we should.

I suspect there will be age-restrictions imposed on these procedures one fine day - no transition for under 18's, no babies for octogenarians.

I wouldn't say it to the face of a couple of 50 year olds having a baby, I'd just smile and nod, smile and nod.

I agree with this.

I would never say it to an older couple having a baby, because it’s their choice and it doesn’t hurt me. I’d be polite and happy for them personally. BUT…privately I do think that there needs to be some cut off point where you can honestly look at yourself and say ‘Yes, I am probably too old now’.

You can’t have it all. If you chose to have children later, and benefitted from that choice by having full lives, careers, financial stability etc, you also have to accept the fact that you may face fertility issues associated with age and you may not have the size family you want. That’s life. It’s not perfect.

But at some point you WILL be too old to have a child. At the point you’re 45-50 and having to contemplate donor speak AND egg, Id say that’s the time. Others may disagree, but I think there is a huge impact for a child having a parent in their 60s rather than say 30s or 40s, no matter how fit and spritely you are.

50yearold · 02/03/2023 10:36

KimberleyClark · 02/03/2023 10:36

Have you considered the potential child’s feelings at all re knowing they are not biologically related to either of their parents or their sibling?

Yes.

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 02/03/2023 10:36

Have you considered the potential child’s feelings at all re knowing they are not biologically related to either of their parents or their sibling?

Outnumbered99 · 02/03/2023 10:35

bellabed · 02/03/2023 01:31

I always thought that at a certain age was too old because of the potential future of bein older raising a teen for example. But today news finds a dead baby, day after day children are being abused and not given a chance in life having no one who cares and adults who ruin their lives over and over again.... so makes me reconsider, so what if your older. The love and stability you can give a child is amazing. So many children never have that

This. absolutely this. I say go for it, and i speak as someone who lost a parent relatively young and unexpected.

50yearold · 02/03/2023 10:35

SquanderedAgain · 02/03/2023 10:21

Please be mindful as someone who has gone through years of IVF and joined support groups, posting things like donation is "incredibly unethical." or "to have a baby that is no way related to either of you," is bloody awful , for many people using donor eggs, sperm, they are young couples who had cancer treatment, young couples who have issues beyond their control and simply want to bring a child into the world and love that child. At least argue your case, if its just there's no genetic link, then is all adoption wrong?

I'm not one who mentioned this before but -
Op, you're talking about creating a child with not just donor eggs OR sperm but both. You'd be mad to think there's no implications of that. If you do it, at least do some kind of assessment first and acknowledge that there may be drawbacks. People are right to have their own opinions and highlight the drawbacks to you.

Adoption is amazing, for those who choose it. PPs mentioned adoption because if you're going to have a child with no genetic link, why wouldn't you consider adoption? It suggests that biology isn't your priority here. Instead of creating another life, you could go down that path.

If you didn't want opinions (and these threads are always a bit pointless, you're going to try it anyway), then why ask?

I think I already posted, we approached adoption agenices and they told us as we have a child, they would steer us to adopt a younger child, so in our case, we have a 5 year old, they would prefer we adopt a toddler. So the age thing is still there.

Believe me we have looked at full implications of donor conception, our clinic demands we go through counselling, we have contacted the donor network, it took a LONG time for me to even accept this as a possibility and after very long research.

I've been reading every post here, so welcome other opinions, I hope I don't come across as arrogant, I don't mean to if that's the case, its just the donor side is such a huge subject, its a complete different debate, (as is adoption) I was focusing about age and being a dad.

the poll shows, roughly 50/50 which I think shows there's not one overwhelming view on this, this is my problem when I seek advice from friends and family!

OP posts:
Stopyourhavering64 · 02/03/2023 10:32

My dad was 50 when I was born ( dm was 40) ...I had the benefit of their wisdom and life experience when growing and time with him when he retired when I was a stroppy teen
Unfortunately my dad died 2 days before my 21st birthday....he never saw me graduate, marry or meet his grandchildren and 35 years later it still affects me deeply when I see my friends who still have their parents to love and support them
I know bereavement can happen at any stage in life but it's definitely something to bear in mind , and make sure you have a will/good financial arrangements in place for these eventualities

QueenCamilla · 02/03/2023 10:32

What age will this end. What age is the cut-off morally and ethically?
Just because we (medically) can, doesn't mean we should.

I suspect there will be age-restrictions imposed on these procedures one fine day - no transition for under 18's, no babies for octogenarians.

I wouldn't say it to the face of a couple of 50 year olds having a baby, I'd just smile and nod, smile and nod.

SquanderedAgain · 02/03/2023 10:29

@AnotherSpare PPs comment doesn't seem offensive. It's true, there's no genetic link. Same with an adopted child- doesn't mean they're not the parents still. Now that would be offensive to adoptees/adopters.

@darjeelingrose is saying that they're at an age where they have to have two lots of donor gametes and their two old. Completely different point to what youre getting at.

Comedycook · 02/03/2023 10:27

My first thought was too old whe I read your thread title...but then I saw you have a five year old so you are already parenting a little one so I can't see why you shouldn't have another. It will be nice for them to have a sibling.

Lesschubtolove · 02/03/2023 10:26

Aquamarine1029 · 02/03/2023 00:45

What if this potential child were born with very significant disabilities, which at your ages is a much greater possibility. This would impact your existing child significantly. Sorry, not wanting to be negative, but it's something, I feel, you really need to consider. It's very easy for other people to just say "Go for it!" when the possible consequences wouldn't affect them.

If they are using double donation that’s not really an issue, because biologically they child won’t be theirs.

I know you didn’t mention it either but, equally I think the principle of potentially dying when the child is in their 30s either isn’t the most compelling, we can’t control when we die. My father was 40 when I was born and I lost him in my 30s.

ultimately OP and his wife know their lives and how they feel and how a pregnancy might affect his wife, if they have support around them etc. I know someone who’s father was in their late 50s at primary school, passed away in her mid 30s. He met his grandkid and had a lovely relationship with them and was incredibly hands on and dearly loved

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 02/03/2023 10:26

You seem to have a good life, you already have one daughter. The next baby will not be linked to your daughter by birth. ID say no to trying for another child. You should enjoy the life you have. You have no idea how life will change in the next few years. Why are you complicating it? Your child will be fine as a only child. theyll make friends. You dont know if the next baby will be health or have any special needs or disabilities. Are you prepared to take onthat? Finances - will your finances be ok if you have any heath issues or get laid off work or cant work? So many variables. Its too risky imo. Id enjoy what I have and be content.

AnotherSpare · 02/03/2023 10:24

darjeelingrose · 02/03/2023 08:30

Yes you are too old. You are planning to have a baby that is no way related to either of you, because otherwise you couldn't and one of the factors that says that you can't is your age. That's what too old means. You shouldn't go ahead because if you really wanted to, you would have done it sooner.

Seriously? "In no way related to you"?
That's very offensive. Children conceived through donation are related to the parents who have them. The mother who carries them literally grows and forms them.
Would you also label adopted children as being in no way related to their parents?
Get off your high horse. Families come in all shapes and manners.

SquanderedAgain · 02/03/2023 10:21

Please be mindful as someone who has gone through years of IVF and joined support groups, posting things like donation is "incredibly unethical." or "to have a baby that is no way related to either of you," is bloody awful , for many people using donor eggs, sperm, they are young couples who had cancer treatment, young couples who have issues beyond their control and simply want to bring a child into the world and love that child. At least argue your case, if its just there's no genetic link, then is all adoption wrong?

I'm not one who mentioned this before but -
Op, you're talking about creating a child with not just donor eggs OR sperm but both. You'd be mad to think there's no implications of that. If you do it, at least do some kind of assessment first and acknowledge that there may be drawbacks. People are right to have their own opinions and highlight the drawbacks to you.

Adoption is amazing, for those who choose it. PPs mentioned adoption because if you're going to have a child with no genetic link, why wouldn't you consider adoption? It suggests that biology isn't your priority here. Instead of creating another life, you could go down that path.

If you didn't want opinions (and these threads are always a bit pointless, you're going to try it anyway), then why ask?