Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel stressed at being left behind our friendship group

235 replies

Feelinadequate23 · 01/03/2023 21:50

DH and I are part of a really close friendship group from uni (where we met). We are all mid-thirties now so have been friends for 15 or so years and we spend a fair amount of time with this group.

At uni we all felt on the same level financially as we all had part time jobs but also all had some financial support from our parents. Then in our twenties we still felt pretty similar, as we all got professional jobs, rented for a bit and then bought 2 bed places with our other halves. DH and I bought in the cheapest place out of the group but we had a nice garden and were near a really fun pub we all used to hang out at, so we didn’t feel like the poor relations, even though we were in the least desirable area.

Then suddenly around the age of 30, it was like everyone else in the friendship group catapulted into a financial level above us out of nowhere. We all got married and had kids so people started moving out of starter homes into family homes. DH and I just upgraded to a 3 bed semi in the same area we were in, whereas everyone else bought really big houses with 4/5 bedrooms, 2/3 bathrooms and an extra study, all in very fancy areas. They’re now all suddenly talking about sending their kids to private primary school, whereas we hadn’t even considered doing that.

It’s starting to get us down as when we meet up it’s like they’re all speaking a different language to us (discussing which room to give to their nanny!) and their ideas of what’s normal are just so different to ours now. We suggested doing a group holiday with kids and were about to suggest a uk holiday cottage type trip, but somehow the conversation turned into them all planning a ski trip, which would mean we couldn’t afford any other trips that year.

The annoying thing is, we’re pretty sure we earn the most out of all the couples, so this money must be coming from their parents - I suspect they were all given hefty deposits and they also all get free holidays with family each year. It’s making us feel really inadequate and also like we can’t hang out with them so much anymore as we can’t join in a lot of the conversations and can’t afford to do some of the things they suggest. It’s very depressing when we work in stressful long hour corporate jobs and they all do nice 9-5s, working in charities and PR firms. But these are our closest friends so we don’t want to lose them.

Considering taking on even more stressful jobs to try to keep up with their lifestyle (which to be fair is very nice and we would love to be able to live like that). AWBU?

OP posts:
butterfliedtwo · 01/03/2023 23:18

Feelinadequate23 · 01/03/2023 22:34

A few people have asked if they judge us… no I don’t think they do, but maybe worse, I think they might be starting to pity us a bit! Which is just so galling when we work so bloody hard and in stressful roles to make a nice life for our family. I guess it’s quite an ego bruise.

Maybe it's time for new friends. You are seriously unreasonable to consider taking on even more stressful jobs to keep up with the Joneses. Come on, OP. You must know that.

droneyg · 01/03/2023 23:12

@Kokeshi123 yes, someone I used to work with & had a very ordinary background, immigrant parents one was a nurse & one was a teacher has just inherited a house worth about 2m that her parents bought yrs ago in Hackney when nobody wanted to live there.

Kokeshi123 · 01/03/2023 23:05

I have a feeling we will see more of this kind of thing in the future. As the boomers pass away, some people will, in middle age, come into a lot of money, while others will not (because some elderly parents did not own property, owned less valuable property, or had to sell it to pay for long term nursing care). It will lead to some interesting dynamics among established friendship groups.

Kokeshi123 · 01/03/2023 23:03

one for example is a state school primary teacher, another has a fundraising role for a small charity

Are we talking about two people married to each other who have these kinds of jobs? Or individuals married to spouses who possibly have quite different jobs? It's possible for one half of a couple to have this kind of job while the other is a major earner. My husband and I are probably a little bit like this (though not as extreme as your friends, perhaps. And we certainly don't have that kind of house!).

It's understandable that you feel a bit left out if they are planning things you can't afford. Are you OK with levelling with them a bit (actually saying "a ski trip is not possible for us as we've spent a lot of money on our housing deposit; if anyone would be interested in doing a less expensive get-together before/after that, we'd be up for that instead?" I have friends who I know are a lot less well off than me; we just plan fun, affordable things to do, like picnics in the park, or asking them to suggest the restaurant or activity so that they can choose something they have the budget for. If you care about a friend, you are (discreetly) sensitive about this kind of thing, but it's possible your friends just haven't twigged that your income is lower than theirs.

As for the talk (talking about nannies), OP, I know this can be hard, but you have to just decide that you don't care and stop letting it get to you. If you own your own property and have no financial worries, you're doing better than half the people in this country. And your friends do have the right to talk about their nannies or expensive holidays; you can't exactly ask them to stop talking about things that are relevant to their lives.

Bunce1 · 01/03/2023 23:03

did you not ever go back with these uni mates to their parental homes? I had some very comfortably off mates at uni which I had no idea about until I spent a weekend with them. The friend seemed like me- had no airs and was just a lovely person.

I think though for such good friends for none of them to say in a slightly self deprecating way “well we were given a bit of early inheritance/a bit of a lump to start us off/ we got lucky with the property market and dads help” then I would feel like it was some sort of deception. And that’s the bit that would bug me.

my very close friend and I have been until very recently level pegging in terms of jobs/lifestyles and then she decides to sell up and move to the countryside. Her lifestyle is more extravagant now, but it makes no odds as she knows she’s been canny with flipping her property and I’m happy she decided to do that. She goes on multiple
holidays and has designer things now. We still meet for our weekends away and it doesn’t get in the way. We do stuff we enjoy together that is in budget. She wouldn’t embarrass me by saying let’s go to the savoy for tea. It’s tacit what can be afforded.

on the other hand. One friend has gone from wealth to breadline in 3 short years and that’s also hard.

it shouldn’t change how you feel about people. I’d say ride it out.

Emmamoo89 · 01/03/2023 23:01

Yabu

EarringsandLipstick · 01/03/2023 23:01

Grr. Posted too soon.

I wonder if the friendship is as meaningful as you think, if it is so predicated on shared activities costing a lot of money?

droneyg · 01/03/2023 23:00

It’s weird that that sort of family wealth has only become obvious when you are all in your 30s, and for all of your friendship group except you. Did you not realise that your friends were all from huge wealth?

I think so much is tied up in housing that the money is only accessible when people get older & the older generations die.

emsie12345 · 01/03/2023 23:00

You know what else makes you feel insecure and lacking somehow, because you just can’t keep up?
Hunger. Think yourself out of it pet.

EarringsandLipstick · 01/03/2023 23:00

Feelinadequate23 · 01/03/2023 22:55

@EarringsandLipstick absolutely. We are extremely fortunate. This post is not at all about not having enough money. It’s about how to maintain friendships when the group dynamics constantly make you feel unsuccessful, insecure and lacking somehow, because you just can’t keep up.

I do get that.

It feels a little like the dynamics might be off then - once you all have a certain level of wealth, ie all employed, homeowners, reasonable disposable income, then I think the disparity shouldn't matter.

I w

Genevieva · 01/03/2023 23:00

Unless the school fees are paid for by the grandparents, they will feel the pinch once they start paying those for two or three kids. They will also find that their children have friends who live a half hour drive away. Meanwhile your kids will have friends within walking distance of home and will be learning much the same sorts of things in school. I would stick to your current choices.

My husband and I are, like our parents, very abstemious. We live in a smaller house than most of our friends. I love it - it is old and beautiful with stunning views of the countryside. I would never leave simply because of the view from the kitchen sink. I used to be a bit self-conscious about not having a dining room for dinner parties and all that jazz, but I learnt not to be, not least because we now have no mortgage. It is an amazing feeling owning the roof over your head outright. I have no desire to borrow more money for a bigger house. As time has gone on I have been amazed by the discoveries I have made of friends who borrow the maximum the bank will allow and stretch themselves to the limit. It will all come crashing down for some of them at some point. I just hope it isn't too painful.

Genie321 · 01/03/2023 22:58

You sound jealous of your friends. I have friends that have more than me, others who have less. It doesn't change our friendship. You should celebrate each other, not bitch about their holidays/house/children's schools. You sound toxic.

emsie12345 · 01/03/2023 22:56

3.9 million children in poverty. Yes, it's a wider issue. Fuckng holidays? Look down, mate.

Feelinadequate23 · 01/03/2023 22:55

@EarringsandLipstick absolutely. We are extremely fortunate. This post is not at all about not having enough money. It’s about how to maintain friendships when the group dynamics constantly make you feel unsuccessful, insecure and lacking somehow, because you just can’t keep up.

OP posts:
FakeBilly · 01/03/2023 22:54

Feelinadequate23 · 01/03/2023 22:48

@FakeBilly i think the issue is the holidays probably wouldn’t have been too much of a stretch for us pre-kids as we had a smaller mortgage and overall much less outgoings. Once we moved to our house all money got a lot tighter whereas for them money seemed to get much more available! I think that’s the shock here, that none of them have felt

But can’t they tell this? Don’t you say? I’m just trying to think how my friendship groups manage huge disparity of incomes — I think I’m just very upfront about saying ‘Can’t afford it’, and I’m also aware that things I do without having to count the cost are out of the reach of some of our friends. We mostly see one another in our houses or the pub, and everyone’s pretty honest and tactful about what’s in and out of individual budgets.

Shamoo · 01/03/2023 22:53

If a state school teacher with a partner with a similar paying job is able to have a nanny, send the kids to private school, live in an expensive area in a 4/5 bed house, go skiing and on other expensive holidays each year - then they are being funded by their family in the many 10s of thousands every year. It’s weird that that sort of family wealth has only become obvious when you are all in your 30s, and for all of your friendship group except you. Did you not realise that your friends were all from huge wealth?

Feelinadequate23 · 01/03/2023 22:53

@hoorayhooray yes exactly. Not nice to feel lesser all of a sudden after always being equals until recently

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 01/03/2023 22:53

I was set go by sympathetic

I was set to be sympathetic, that should read.

EarringsandLipstick · 01/03/2023 22:52

I was set go by sympathetic but I'm finding it hard, after reading all your posts OP.

You are clearly well off - you say yourself you are likely the highest-earning couple.

I too find it hard to believe that they can all have such significant family wealth to accommodate such lifestyles. It's odd.

But you must be doing fine, right? You might not have all they have but you are comfortable with a nice life? I'm a single parent in a reasonably paying role, but with insufficient support from ex, kids are permanently with me, & all the same issues as everyone else (CoL, energy crisis etc) I'm really struggling. And I know in turn, there are many much worse off than me.

I can understand the feeling but I think you need to shake yourself a bit.

Feelinadequate23 · 01/03/2023 22:51

@FakeBilly i get what you mean about having richer friends and not letting it impact you. I think for us it’s more that everyone else is rich together and we’re the one couple/family left behind everyone else. It’s not so much that we want what they have, more that we don’t want to be the only ones without it (because it pushes us out of the group a bit)

OP posts:
hoorayhooray · 01/03/2023 22:51

I know what you mean. I am older... but feel like this.
It's not necessarily the monetary thing
It's the feeling left behind

Pootleplum · 01/03/2023 22:51

I can relate to this OP. Most of my friends have similar wealth levels to me which is to say absolutely fortunate, home owners, able to afford holidays abroad etc. but one of my friends is incredibly wealthy because her parents bankroll her and it's not that I can't enjoy her company but I can't relate to her at all. She has tons of properties, so is just accumulating them and keeping them (and then complaining about the hassle of tenants). Her children are at private school, she doesn't work. I just don't relate to her. She does mad stuff like refuse to vaccinate her kids because they have private healthcare and has a nutritionist who costs £500 per hour and encourages her to follow an incredibly restricted diet.

droneyg · 01/03/2023 22:49

DH and I got no parental money, ever — our parents are poor, we got through university entirely on scholarships, and we’ve both been helping support them since getting our first jobs. We have friends with substantial trust funds, multiple children at public school, yachts. They’re also wonderful. Measuring, or resenting, that isn’t someone I want to be.

I think you are misunderstanding my point. Where did I say it was good to be resentful? I said explaining it away as materialistic ignores the huge inequality in this country & the issues around social mobility. Look at public services now, all the strikes due to little wage growth for years. It's all part of a wider issue & how wealth is increasingly going to a smaller pool.

Feelinadequate23 · 01/03/2023 22:48

@FakeBilly i think the issue is the holidays probably wouldn’t have been too much of a stretch for us pre-kids as we had a smaller mortgage and overall much less outgoings. Once we moved to our house all money got a lot tighter whereas for them money seemed to get much more available! I think that’s the shock here, that none of them have felt

OP posts:
neilyoungismyhero · 01/03/2023 22:46

My heart bleeds for you...