Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel stressed at being left behind our friendship group

235 replies

Feelinadequate23 · 01/03/2023 21:50

DH and I are part of a really close friendship group from uni (where we met). We are all mid-thirties now so have been friends for 15 or so years and we spend a fair amount of time with this group.

At uni we all felt on the same level financially as we all had part time jobs but also all had some financial support from our parents. Then in our twenties we still felt pretty similar, as we all got professional jobs, rented for a bit and then bought 2 bed places with our other halves. DH and I bought in the cheapest place out of the group but we had a nice garden and were near a really fun pub we all used to hang out at, so we didn’t feel like the poor relations, even though we were in the least desirable area.

Then suddenly around the age of 30, it was like everyone else in the friendship group catapulted into a financial level above us out of nowhere. We all got married and had kids so people started moving out of starter homes into family homes. DH and I just upgraded to a 3 bed semi in the same area we were in, whereas everyone else bought really big houses with 4/5 bedrooms, 2/3 bathrooms and an extra study, all in very fancy areas. They’re now all suddenly talking about sending their kids to private primary school, whereas we hadn’t even considered doing that.

It’s starting to get us down as when we meet up it’s like they’re all speaking a different language to us (discussing which room to give to their nanny!) and their ideas of what’s normal are just so different to ours now. We suggested doing a group holiday with kids and were about to suggest a uk holiday cottage type trip, but somehow the conversation turned into them all planning a ski trip, which would mean we couldn’t afford any other trips that year.

The annoying thing is, we’re pretty sure we earn the most out of all the couples, so this money must be coming from their parents - I suspect they were all given hefty deposits and they also all get free holidays with family each year. It’s making us feel really inadequate and also like we can’t hang out with them so much anymore as we can’t join in a lot of the conversations and can’t afford to do some of the things they suggest. It’s very depressing when we work in stressful long hour corporate jobs and they all do nice 9-5s, working in charities and PR firms. But these are our closest friends so we don’t want to lose them.

Considering taking on even more stressful jobs to try to keep up with their lifestyle (which to be fair is very nice and we would love to be able to live like that). AWBU?

OP posts:
Martinisarebetterdirty · 02/03/2023 09:09

I think you need to be more upfront and say sorry we can’t finance a ski trip this year, saving for renovations. How about a cottage by the sea instead? Or if it really bothers you then do the ski trip with them and don’t have another holiday that year? Plenty of lovely cheap days out you can do as a family in the UK.
I understand it’s difficult. Incidentally we had a nanny for our children, it made more financial sense for us as we have two DC so cheaper than paying two sets of nursery fees and having the stress of having to be there in time for close, and I would have said at the time that nursery fees were a luxury I couldn’t afford.

Or you could just say things like oh we have excellent state schools locally so don’t need to go private, or we are maxing out pension contributions this year so skiing doesn’t work, let’s do something else instead.

CAJIE · 02/03/2023 08:58

My god.the materialism and conformity on here is so depressing.

ganvough · 02/03/2023 08:56

Why does it matter how they live their lives and what or who funds it? Groups of friends aren’t a homogenous mass who all evolve and achieve in exactly the same way. So it’s not sensible to expect this.

Do you know what makes you happy or is it based on what you think you should have, or what your friends have? Do they judge you for your lifestyle or is it your destructive inner voice playing that narrative?

I have a group of friend for 15 years. We all earn different amounts, but I’d say DP and I earn a bit less. Most of the others do have wealthier families and more parental help. However, they’ve always known that I enjoy different things than them which is reflected in my lifestyle, and there’s zero judgement. We are all middle class and uni educated - met when we joined a prestigious grad scheme but have taken different career paths since.

DP and I are city folk who never wanted the big house and stuff, and being mortgaged to the gills. We are both quite minimalist people and love our smaller place because it has everything we need. All my friends moved further out and have beautiful homes I love to visit but never covet. We still participate in conversations about renovations and nannies though, the same way we’d discuss politics in a country we’ve never visited - not doing something doesn’t stop you discussing it! I personally hate group holidays and my friends know this - DP and I have a shared hobby we do together and limited holiday time we want to spend together as we work long hours, and don’t get much couple time. It will be the same when we have kids as i think quality family time is important and tough to do when it’s a big group. Skiing is something we do as a group but there’s no pressure for everyone to join every year. It’s just a more cost effective way for those who do want it to do it. DP has been sometimes but only on years we have the funds. Private school is the one thing DP and I have to save for as my friends live in good school catchments and don’t have to worry - DP and I in inner city London do. But with a smaller mortgage and more frugal lifestyle we can manage this. My friends mostly travel first class and will have quite boring convos on collecting points, DP and I take tips but know we’ll never do it ourselves. What we save on travelling economy we put towards far more holidays (and private school fund).

As an aside I have a flat I rent out - I bought it completely on my own with no help, even before I met DP. But it was in a rough area that got completely gentrified and pays for itself - so I’ll never sell it. But I bought it when my friends were saving for big weddings and I saved for a deposit instead (never wanting big wedding). Different life choices at play again.

If you’re feeling judged, then you do need to make some new friends and not focus only on this group. Do you not have hobbies where you could make friends to share that aspect with?

I like my friends, and they me, because of our common history, sense of humour, politics, and just how easily conversation flows. I do not expect us to live exactly alike because that means we haven’t evolved at all in 15 years. You can maintain friendships and not let them dictate your happiness or the direction of your life - that way madness lies. Maybe focus more of your family and hobbies for some time to take some space from the group?

holygerbil · 02/03/2023 08:53

Once your kids all start school the group will be less tight in any event. Kids do stuff at weekends as they get older, commit to sports teams, music concerts, cubs camps etc. so the likelihood of you agreeing dates for holidays is going to get lower and lower. You seem to be measuring yourself in purely financial terms. Let that go; these are either good people that you want long term friendships with, or they aren't. If they are then be honest with them and they will understand. If they aren't and socialising as a family is important then start socialising with more local people who are likely to be at the same schools as your DC.

droneyg · 02/03/2023 08:53

Surely the fact that at least some of these friends went to private school themselves must make you realise it was likely they would send their own DC to private school too.

this is completely outdated. have you not seen how fees have increased & wages have stagnated? Plenty of people who went to private school can't afford to send their dc to it now.

pizzaHeart · 02/03/2023 08:52

I absolutely get it OP, it’s not about your jealousy at all, it’s about their assumptions. They just assume that prep school/ ski trip/or whatever is standard and everybody is talking about this confidently, with details and then they all are turning to you and it’s like you are pissing on their chips with your harsh reality of life! You are basically spoiling their conversation with your negative remarks.
It doesn’t matter that you are better then average nationally because in that room at that moment you are not, the dynamics’s changed and you can’t continue as before. So you are not asking about how grateful you should be for everything, I’m sure you are grateful, you are asking how to behave in a new situation.

I was in your situation with “prep conversation” when my friend asked if we were looking at local prep which’s so nice for our daughter ( who’s disabled). I didn’t think for a moment that my friend meant anything spiteful she was just blissfully unaware about realities (she was aware of disability by the way). I answered calmly no, explained briefly why, then came home and felt sad and cried.I know that life is not fair and so on but it sucks.
We are still friends many years down the line - it looks very differently, we both changed. My friend is more thoughtful with questions and I’m more confident and apt with my answers. No way I would be able to maintain a group, too difficult. So you may stay friends with one or two families but I don’t think you will be able to stay in a group, mentally and financially, sorry.

Gillyyy · 02/03/2023 08:52

You come across like you’ve been deceived by your friends keeping their first properties to let, as if no one told you that was what you needed to do when it’s just a financial decision for them to make. If you needed the money for your next property, it’s not an option for you and that’s ok. We all do the best we can in the situations we’re in. If they can keep hold of property it’s up to them and likely a good investment.

Also, what jobs do you and your husband have that you automatically think you outearn the group? There was a thread here the other day discussing annual salaries for different jobs that people wouldn’t expect. I also have friends that make/sell things online that make more money than you would expect, that they wouldn’t discuss openly.

Another thing you might not have considered is if any of the couples have received inheritance. You might luckily have family members where they do not.

In life, where money is concerned, you will always be in the middle, there are always people with a lot more and people with a lot less.

droneyg · 02/03/2023 08:51

I have friends in all sorts of different financial situations.

i think that's the difference though, if you live in a bubble that becomes your reality. I know i'm in a bubble because I didn't grow up in that english mc environment (i'm a 2nd gen immigrant). DH is not from a wealthy background but he is English so our 6 fig deposit came from his gps estate. His parents are also property millionaires. You can easily grow up very average but come into lots of money if your parents/gps bought yrs ago.

DappledThings · 02/03/2023 08:44

Feelinadequate23 · 02/03/2023 08:41

@Mumma212 well it does affect our friendships if we can’t go on most of the planned trips! They then start making new memories without us, their kids get closer to one another, etc. etc. We all used to do everything together so it’s not nice to be left out (even though I know they’re not doing it on purpose and are allowed to do things they can afford to)

Then you need to be more proactive with them about how you.meet up You said:
We suggested doing a group holiday with kids and were about to suggest a uk holiday cottage type trip, but somehow the conversation turned into them all planning a ski trip
Did you at any point pipe up to say actually we can't afford that, we were thinking about a UK holiday and actually push that idea? If you want to keep seeing them in this way it sounds like you need to swallow your pride and be honest about it.

Feelinadequate23 · 02/03/2023 08:41

@Mumma212 well it does affect our friendships if we can’t go on most of the planned trips! They then start making new memories without us, their kids get closer to one another, etc. etc. We all used to do everything together so it’s not nice to be left out (even though I know they’re not doing it on purpose and are allowed to do things they can afford to)

OP posts:
LosingMyPancakes · 02/03/2023 08:40

I'm not sure why you're friends with these people - you clearly resent them for having 'more'. Maybe stop fixating on the materialistic and learn to appreciate what you have.

Or one of your friends will fall sick or lose their job and they'll be poorer than you again. Assume that will make you feel better?

LadyDanburysHat · 02/03/2023 08:38

To be clear, non of the families are celeb-level wealthy, they don’t have yachts or mansions with pools or anything! Just nice, large-ish house, kids went to private school, couple of nice holidays a year.

Surely the fact that at least some of these friends went to private school themselves must make you realise it was likely they would send their own DC to private school too.

You need to find a way to not let this get to you. Or find friends on your level.

Kranke · 02/03/2023 08:29

I do see why they have to justify to you where their money is coming from? Does it really matter if it’s through a work bonus, or family giving them money. How they afford schools isn’t really any of your business.

Tandora · 02/03/2023 08:23

I agree with pp that this is a you problem and not something to do with your friends. They are not obliged to discuss the intricacies of how they got their money with you- that’s just odd. I have lots of friends sending their children to private school. I don’t feel inadequate when they discuss it with me. Even if I could afford private, I’m happy/ prefer to go with a state. You need to work on being comfortable with where you and your family are, and not worried so much what others are doing. You’re setting yourself up for a lifetime of misery otherwise.

Jooliusreezer · 02/03/2023 08:21

Either you're in with a very materialistic and shallow set or they're just living their lives and you're the materialistic and shallow one - it's hard to tell.

I suspect the latter. It may not be OP’s natural state, but she’s certainly become that way in her fixation with her friends’ financial situations.

YouSoundLovely · 02/03/2023 08:11

I think what I find oddest about your post, OP, is the lack of awareness you seemingly have that this level of apparent wealth and spending (whether it comes from credit, salaries, parental help or - likely - a mixture of the three is actually irrelevant) is really, really not the norm in any shape or form. But you're posting as if you're somehow owed it and are inexplicably missing out. I think, friendship group aside, it would benefit you to look outside your bubble.

I have friends in all sorts of different financial situations. It's not really a thing that comes up - of course we talk about what we're doing, but it doesn't seem to define us in the way you're describing. Either you're in with a very materialistic and shallow set or they're just living their lives and you're the materialistic and shallow one - it's hard to tell. Either way, I think some perspective would be helpful, and perhaps a view that includes measures of success and happiness that aren't money and wealth.

WimpoleHat · 02/03/2023 08:11

Of course we assumed everyone would sell their first home to buy their second but there appears to be an unwritten pathway on this that we weren’t told about.

This ties into what I was saying above about some people being more comfortable with more debt, though. There’s no “unwritten pathway”, it’s just taking more risk. They now have a much higher exposure to UK property than you do. In a rising market, they’ll have made a lot of money in 20 years time. If there’s a crash in the housing market, they’ll be much more exposed. It’s not some hugely sophisticated financial scheme. It sounds like you’re more conservative people who prefer to have savings in the bank than spending every last penny and some on the credit card on the next holiday.

MintyBinty · 02/03/2023 08:10

Get some new friends OP

droneyg · 02/03/2023 08:09

I'm shocked at this post during a CoL crisis when some families are genuinely going hungry or not being able to heat their homes.

This doesn't make sense.

AuntieJoyce · 02/03/2023 08:03

Feelinadequate23 · 01/03/2023 22:29

@warmlights yes, don’t get me started on them keeping their original flats and renting them out! That was another thing that wasn’t mentioned, and then you slowly realise it when they say they’re just popping back to that area to check on things and what they mean is check on the tenants… Of course we assumed everyone would sell their first home to buy their second but there appears to be an unwritten pathway on this that we weren’t told about. The wealth just escalates and escalates!

Of course it does

Hmm
Motnight · 02/03/2023 07:53

I am much older than you Op. My best friend owns several properties, and is financially extremely well off. I am doing fine financially and consider myself lucky, but have nowhere near as much money as she does. And it doesn't matter, it really doesn't. Be careful that all the joy that you have around your friendships isn't going to be sucked out by your envy.

Luana1 · 02/03/2023 07:52

Unfortunately it sounds like the friendships are unlikely to survive because of your jealousy - which is completely understandable, it’s human nature to compare oneself to others, and in this case you have found yourself lacking. I’m sure there are happy secure people who are content with their lot in life who are able to mix freely with people who are much wealthier than they are without it affecting their self esteem so much but sounds like that is not the case here.

I do wonder why you are blaming it all on being bank rolled by their parents. Lots of people keep their starter homes as rentals by switching to a buy to let mortgage for that property then they have an passive income from that, or they may be living on huge amounts of credit. By saying they are all free loading from their parents allows you to ramp up the feelings on unfairness in your mind.

Mumma212 · 02/03/2023 07:48

Feelinadequate23 · 01/03/2023 22:53

@hoorayhooray yes exactly. Not nice to feel lesser all of a sudden after always being equals until recently

Perhaps you could start hanging round in charity shops to make some new friends that you can feel 'better than'...it's starting to sounds like that's what you want.

Just because you felt 'equal' at uni doesn't mean you should now.

I'm shocked at this post during a CoL crisis when some families are genuinely going hungry or not being able to heat their homes.

WimpoleHat · 02/03/2023 07:46

The one thing that hasn’t been mentioned yet is the possibility that they’re doing a lot of this on credit. You talk about frugal living and savings - they may have borrowed a lot of money. A friend of mine went through a similar thought process - he works for a law firm where salaries were transparent and could never understand how people had such different lifestyles to him. And that was the answer, ultimately: he was very conservative and risk averse and was a saver, while some of these people were leveraged up to the hilt. For some, it paid off - a highly leveraged property investment 20 years ago would look very smart now. But equally, they may well have had some sleepless nights in the interim. Likewise, some people are far more comfortable running a credit card balance/taking a loan/having very little in savings.

Beautiful3 · 02/03/2023 07:45

I strongly doubt their parents are paying them enough pocket money to afford private school and the mortgage. They've obviously progressed career wise their salaries reflect that. You could do the same, or stay as you are. The same thing happened to my husbands friendship group. He can never afford to join them on holiday in Las vagas/america/skiing etc, but he still drinks with them once in a blue moon. They all have very nice detached houses, and most of their kids are in private education.

Swipe left for the next trending thread