Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel stressed at being left behind our friendship group

235 replies

Feelinadequate23 · 01/03/2023 21:50

DH and I are part of a really close friendship group from uni (where we met). We are all mid-thirties now so have been friends for 15 or so years and we spend a fair amount of time with this group.

At uni we all felt on the same level financially as we all had part time jobs but also all had some financial support from our parents. Then in our twenties we still felt pretty similar, as we all got professional jobs, rented for a bit and then bought 2 bed places with our other halves. DH and I bought in the cheapest place out of the group but we had a nice garden and were near a really fun pub we all used to hang out at, so we didn’t feel like the poor relations, even though we were in the least desirable area.

Then suddenly around the age of 30, it was like everyone else in the friendship group catapulted into a financial level above us out of nowhere. We all got married and had kids so people started moving out of starter homes into family homes. DH and I just upgraded to a 3 bed semi in the same area we were in, whereas everyone else bought really big houses with 4/5 bedrooms, 2/3 bathrooms and an extra study, all in very fancy areas. They’re now all suddenly talking about sending their kids to private primary school, whereas we hadn’t even considered doing that.

It’s starting to get us down as when we meet up it’s like they’re all speaking a different language to us (discussing which room to give to their nanny!) and their ideas of what’s normal are just so different to ours now. We suggested doing a group holiday with kids and were about to suggest a uk holiday cottage type trip, but somehow the conversation turned into them all planning a ski trip, which would mean we couldn’t afford any other trips that year.

The annoying thing is, we’re pretty sure we earn the most out of all the couples, so this money must be coming from their parents - I suspect they were all given hefty deposits and they also all get free holidays with family each year. It’s making us feel really inadequate and also like we can’t hang out with them so much anymore as we can’t join in a lot of the conversations and can’t afford to do some of the things they suggest. It’s very depressing when we work in stressful long hour corporate jobs and they all do nice 9-5s, working in charities and PR firms. But these are our closest friends so we don’t want to lose them.

Considering taking on even more stressful jobs to try to keep up with their lifestyle (which to be fair is very nice and we would love to be able to live like that). AWBU?

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 02/03/2023 10:34

we’re pretty sure we earn the most out of all the couples, so this money must be coming from their parents

Yet they can ALL afford private schools/houses with studies and rooms for nannies?

Something doesn’t add up here?

maddy68 · 02/03/2023 10:31

You're jealous of them. They are perfectly entitled to plan a ski trip. If you can't afford to go then that's that

EllieQ · 02/03/2023 10:23

littleburn · 02/03/2023 09:21

I get what you're saying OP. It's the difference between being 'established' middle class (so going to uni and home ownership being established over several generations) and being the first in your family to do/have those things.

I was in a similar situation when I was married. ExH and I were both first in our families to go to uni and have professional jobs. My parents owned their home but his didn't, grandparents on both sides didn't own etc, so not much in the way of family money or inheritances. Basically everything we had we paid for ourselves. I have friends whose families are more 'established' - home ownership is the norm as is working in the professions - and they have benefitted from six figure inheritances from grandparents etc. Plus they married similar so it's on both sides of the family. It just is what it is and I don't begrudge them it, but it does make for significant difference ls in lifestyle (minimal mortgages, private schools, second homes etc), despite us all working in similar professions with similar salaries.

Maybe you feel it more because you've managed to maintain a very tight Uni friendship group? I have uni friends but we see each other quite sporadically and often one on one rather than as a group. I don't think we'd be able to align our diaries for regular meet ups and group holidays to be honest! I have lots of other friendships too. Having one tight group of friends from your late teens as your main friendship group sounds quite restricting, plus the group itself seems quite insular if they think everyone sends their kids to prep school etc.

I think this is a really good analysis of the situation, and it’s something I’ve become more aware of as I’ve got older. If you get a large inheritance from grandparents, money from parents for a house deposit, no student debt as your parents paid for everything, parents paying for private school fees, you’re better off than someone on a similar salary who didn’t get any of these things. I don’t have any of that, and I can see the different it makes - notably by comparing my life to my sister’s, as my BIL’s family was quite well off and they were given a house deposit and her PIL paid for private school. She is quite open about it with me, but may not be with other people.

I agree with the comments that you are in a bit of a ‘bubble’ if everyone you know is planning private schools and skiing holidays - you surely know that only a small percentage of the UK population have these things, and your friends sound quite materialistic and conforming to these middle-class conventions (to be fair, if I had the money, I might be want to do these things too!). Are they things you really want to do, or do you just feel you ought to do them as your friends are doing them? What’s really important to you?

It is quite usual to still be so close to a group of university friends, and has possibly made you a bit insular in your outlook. In my experience there’s some drifting away as people move for work, make other friends, and life gets busier.

Jooliusreezer · 02/03/2023 10:21

So OP, you actually know now that they’re being given these things, because you didn’t earlier? Do you know for certain that you earn more than them, or is that just what you’ve assumed?

Feelinadequate23 · 02/03/2023 10:18

@Willowtre1 yes that’s a good idea, will try to push for that if we can

OP posts:
Littleflowerseverywhere · 02/03/2023 10:11

I understand why you are upset as yes it’s shit if you can’t afford to join in. I part ways with you though when you state they are deceiving uou and should tell you what support parents are giving them, I strongly feel this is absolutely none of your business

in addition I also think you will be surprised at how much they earn, you mention two of the group, but not the rear and what each couple does, so I suspect a lot of this is they significantly out earn you and not every one has parents paying for them to go on holiday .

Willowtre1 · 02/03/2023 10:08

It's tough I totally get it. I would try and start an annual trip that is something like camping, pitched like it's the fun experience, kids get to run wild and it's within budget for you alongside your other family holiday. We do this with some wealthy friends. Then I would also try and add in some new friends who have a more similar lifestyle to you, that will balance things out and you won't always feel like the outlier. This is what we've done and it works perfectly. Our close friends (all wealthy through mostly family money) live further away so local friends are more like us, we've gravitated to people with similar lifestyles through natural circumstance

RedToothBrush · 02/03/2023 10:07

Feelinadequate23 · 01/03/2023 22:16

@droneyg yes, that’s it, nobody talks about it! I think we’d find it easier if they talked about how lucky they were to have this help but they just announce private school as if it’s a given for a couple working completely normal jobs (one for example is a state school primary teacher, another has a fundraising role for a small charity). So then you almost feel the need to explain/justify why you Cant afford all these things, rather than them explaining how on earth they can!

Don't engage with the justification thing.

Be blunt, I'm sorry 'but we can't afford that, we'd love to do something with you guys but can we adjust our budgets to something which will include everyone'. Throw the ball in their court including you.

If they do press about finances, say that it's a shame they are making you have to justify your finances as it's a) rude to be asking about your b) inconsiderate and tone deaf to be unaware of other people having affordability issues because they've not had deposits / inheritance c) they've made you feel like shit because they e made it feel like it's become 'keeping up with the Jones' and you simply aren't in a position to do that.

Ultimately if your friends value you, if you do this they are friends worth keeping. If they plough on and exclude you, you know exactly where you stand and know it's time to move on with a different stage in your life.

Money does get in the way of some friendships. It shouldnt but it does.

Feelinadequate23 · 02/03/2023 10:02

Thanks @DisappearingGirl yes, that’s it, it’s not about the money specifically, it’s about feeling left behind and no longer being able to fully participate in the group when we always used to be able to.

OP posts:
Feelinadequate23 · 02/03/2023 10:00

@littleburn yes! This is it, I think you’ve captured it - we didn’t realise there was a difference and thought once you went to uni and were in a graduate job, you were all on the same middle class footing. Think it’s just a shock to realise there’s a whole different level of class/wealth, which requires generations of the same class to maintain a certain lifestyle.

OP posts:
DisappearingGirl · 02/03/2023 09:56

I don't think you're being unreasonable OP because I think it's hard when you are suddenly "different" from the rest of your friendship group, for whatever reason. Could be wealth but could be something entirely different e.g. others are married but you are single, others in good health but you have a health issue, others have kids and you don't/couldn't, other kids are neurotypical but yours is neurodivergent or otherwise struggling, etc etc etc.

I wonder if the answer is to try and keep these friendships but also try and build other networks as well. That way you're likely to meet other people more like you (and me!) and it won't all be about your rich friends. And keep the one-to-one meet ups but skip the super expensive meals and holidays.

You may find things change again over the years - kids grow up, some couples split up. I know in my Uni friendship group many of us had babies around the same time while a couple of friends couldn't or didn't want to. The conversation always seemed to turn to kids no matter how much we tried otherwise, and I felt guilty about this (to be fair we were knackered and had done nothing except baby/toddler care!). Now the kids are older they are less of a focus when we meet up - they are mentioned in passing of course but no longer the sole topic of conversation. Maybe a similar thing will happen with your group. But I still think making sure it is not your "only" group might help put things in perspective.

Feelinadequate23 · 02/03/2023 09:56

@ThePaperTrail that actually looks like just what I need! Ordered!

OP posts:
Waitingforchid · 02/03/2023 09:54

OP we live surrounded by people that have had a leg up from parents and we didn’t - be proud that your achievements are your own .

ThePaperTrail · 02/03/2023 09:50

There's a book called Affluenza.

I recommend reading it.

Cats246 · 02/03/2023 09:50

Feelinadequate23 · 02/03/2023 09:48

@ganvough thanks for your post. This stood out to me "Do you know what makes you happy or is it based on what you think you should have, or what your friends have?"

I think we thought we knew what makes us happy, and would be very happy indeed with our lot if we didn't know this group. But now we're seeing everyone around us, with what we thought was a similar start in life (i.e. same uni), and they're all choosing the same, expensive lifestyle choices, and it's assumed that's what everyone can have if they want it. So now we're thinking well we would like those things in an ideal world, so should we be making bigger sacrifices to have those things? If not, what does that say about our choices in life? But in reality none of the group are making any sacrifices to have those things, they are just being given them, so of course they "want them" - we would happily take any of the things if they were given to us for free, we just can't work out how much of a sacrifice we're willing to make to get them (I think we would have to sacrifice time as a family, time as a couple and mental health with the extra stress).

We both currently work full time in corporate jobs by the way, so it's not like we're slacking at the moment! But have both decided not to go for the most extreme version of our jobs, if that makes sense.

You have no idea about people's circumstances. I work in banking and on a daily basis deal with people (often 'rich' appearing) who are ridiculously in debt.

Then some people normalise borrowing on credit cards and loans. I don't touch either.

Feelinadequate23 · 02/03/2023 09:48

@ganvough thanks for your post. This stood out to me "Do you know what makes you happy or is it based on what you think you should have, or what your friends have?"

I think we thought we knew what makes us happy, and would be very happy indeed with our lot if we didn't know this group. But now we're seeing everyone around us, with what we thought was a similar start in life (i.e. same uni), and they're all choosing the same, expensive lifestyle choices, and it's assumed that's what everyone can have if they want it. So now we're thinking well we would like those things in an ideal world, so should we be making bigger sacrifices to have those things? If not, what does that say about our choices in life? But in reality none of the group are making any sacrifices to have those things, they are just being given them, so of course they "want them" - we would happily take any of the things if they were given to us for free, we just can't work out how much of a sacrifice we're willing to make to get them (I think we would have to sacrifice time as a family, time as a couple and mental health with the extra stress).

We both currently work full time in corporate jobs by the way, so it's not like we're slacking at the moment! But have both decided not to go for the most extreme version of our jobs, if that makes sense.

OP posts:
RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 09:48

BOMAD.

I voted YANBU because it must be incredibly frustrating to know that however hard you work, you can never keep up.

But comparison is the thief of joy. Try not to let it ruin your friendships.

pizzaHeart · 02/03/2023 09:44

@Feelinadequate23 Flowers

follyfoot37 · 02/03/2023 09:44

This is one of the whiniest posts (as are the subsequent ones) written in quite some time
If you are that jealous (and yes, despite your protestations, it is writ-large) and resent the fact they won't 'own up' to having external money, then it is time to leave this group and find friends that don't get any extra to bolster their salaries

Cats246 · 02/03/2023 09:43

Blunt, but your friendships sound quite shallow and were originally based on proximity and mutual circumstance.

I'm surprised all of your friends were in the same financial situation at uni.

I would try to meet other types of people (volunteer, sport, meetup group) to get a sense of perspective. Wanting to change jobs to mirror this group is not healthy.

Feelinadequate23 · 02/03/2023 09:41

@pizzaHeart thank you, you seem to really understand where I'm coming from. It's the coming home after a meet-up and just feeling crap that we're struggling with.

OP posts:
Museya15 · 02/03/2023 09:37

Focus on your own lives and stop comparing. Sound like school kids.

littleburn · 02/03/2023 09:21

I get what you're saying OP. It's the difference between being 'established' middle class (so going to uni and home ownership being established over several generations) and being the first in your family to do/have those things.

I was in a similar situation when I was married. ExH and I were both first in our families to go to uni and have professional jobs. My parents owned their home but his didn't, grandparents on both sides didn't own etc, so not much in the way of family money or inheritances. Basically everything we had we paid for ourselves. I have friends whose families are more 'established' - home ownership is the norm as is working in the professions - and they have benefitted from six figure inheritances from grandparents etc. Plus they married similar so it's on both sides of the family. It just is what it is and I don't begrudge them it, but it does make for significant difference ls in lifestyle (minimal mortgages, private schools, second homes etc), despite us all working in similar professions with similar salaries.

Maybe you feel it more because you've managed to maintain a very tight Uni friendship group? I have uni friends but we see each other quite sporadically and often one on one rather than as a group. I don't think we'd be able to align our diaries for regular meet ups and group holidays to be honest! I have lots of other friendships too. Having one tight group of friends from your late teens as your main friendship group sounds quite restricting, plus the group itself seems quite insular if they think everyone sends their kids to prep school etc.

Arebella · 02/03/2023 09:20

You sound very jealous. It sounds like they all made better choices, and it sounds like you think you're the higher earners but are probably not. I cant imagine you've asked them all what they earn, because that would just be rude. Instead of comparing yourself to others, just do you.

PeonyRose80 · 02/03/2023 09:10

Another thought, is it a couple of couples have family wealth, the others actually feel like you and are in serious debt to keep up with the actual rich couples - thus creating the illusion everyone except you has help… ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread