Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if this is jealousy

60 replies

Feelslikespring2 · 01/03/2023 20:43

So long story short I have always struggled with women

When I was at school I had a few good friends but I would always hear about girls in my year who I'd never spoken to and some I didn't even know who apparently 'hated me' and 'had it in for me' and would try and turn other girls against me.

Then as an adult some of my friends will compliment each other on a night out but not me. I'm not saying I deserve a compliment bit surely you would say something at least out of politeness if giving one to everyone else.

My Dh always says 'they're probably jealous' but I feel like this is something he says to make me feel better because that's what husbands do.

Aibu to wonder if this could actually be the case though?

I feel like this would somewhat be easier to accept then just being so repellent that women simply don't like me or want much to do with me.

If you have treated someone differently because you've been jealous what did you do and why? Also, anyone else had a similar experience with other females?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Timesawastin · 02/03/2023 18:33

JudgeRudy · 02/03/2023 00:19

Jealousy seems to be the 'go to' emotion that women are accused of simply because they weren't nice or were mean to someone. I've never understood that. If someone doesn't like me I'd never assume it was because they were jealous myself, I'd think I irritated them, or maybe they disagreed with a view point.
Also, not being nice is just that. It doesn't have to be unkind but maybe you weren't invited somewhere or no one chose to partner you in sport...that just means they prefer other people. I'd put not complementing someone in this box.
It's quite self obsessed to think everyone has an opinion on you.

This. But woe betide anyone acknowledging this, as witnessed by several 'yes, hun, jus jelus because you're so ace' comments here. You all sound like you're at secondary school.🙄

Timesawastin · 02/03/2023 18:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

63 going on 14 apparently

Feelslikespring2 · 02/03/2023 13:36

@moksorineouimoksori im certainly not paranoid about it just curious. I too said my husband was probably just easing my feelings. Was just looking to see if anyone had experienced similar. The friendship group might need to be looked at you are right

OP posts:
moksorineouimoksori · 02/03/2023 11:06

The girls who were mean to you at school were probably just stupid and insecure teenagers. What reason would they have to be jealous of you if they barely knew you? I wouldn't dwell on it.

Once you reach adult life, this type of thing shouldn't really happen anymore and if it does you're perfectly within your right to drop "friendships". But how likely is it that every single one of your adult female friends is just secretly uncontrollably jealous of you?

Your husband is just trying to soothe your feelings. It's an empty platitude.

It's not helpful to become paranoid that every other woman is jealous Not to mention, it's an unpleasant stereotype and as much as you might try to distance yourself from it, you'll be affected by it too as a woman, so you're shooting yourself in the foot.

Feelslikespring2 · 02/03/2023 10:37

@SisterAgatha exactly the same experience. I got 'oh she loves herself' at school even though I felt isolated and had the beginnings of low self esteem and anxiety attributed to the way I was being treated.

It seems there's a mix bag of responses but they have all been helpful. I'm not saying all women I've ever encountered have taken a dislike to me. It's just felt more that way then them actively wanting to include me or boost my confidence.

OP posts:
Roselilly36 · 02/03/2023 07:15

I would say I have noticed, the thing most women are envious of IMHO are those of us fortunate enough to be in happy, longterm marriages, could this be an issue with your “friends” jealous of your life?

saltwater1985 · 02/03/2023 03:11

Some women are scary. They give off an 'I don't like you' vibe even if they don't actually say anything unkind.

I've found this a lot. I'm definitely not beautiful (I'd say average at absolute best).
I do have a very small group of friends and in my 40s am making more effort to be nicer (I think I may have inadvertently been aloof absolutely without meaning to).

NastyNiff · 02/03/2023 02:20

I've experienced this myself in the place where I currently live. I blended in a lot more in places where people were generally in better health. Luckily I have a solid core of female friends.

Allgreen · 02/03/2023 02:18

And men (typical straight, "masculine" men) can be really bitchy too when they get started, worse than woman!

Allgreen · 02/03/2023 02:17

Ok so I definitely think "they're being mean to you because of jealousy" is a thing. I used to think it was an excuse and far too flattering towards oneself, but I've genuinely experienced it myself – people in a certain workplace warming up to me when they found out my life wasn't as perfect/expensive as it might look, for example.

That said, pretty girls/women are usually the most popular even among other girls/women. There might be 1 or 2 jealous people but they won't be the majority. If you generally have good relations with other women, then I'd say it's jealousy. If you generally have issues with most women, then I'd say the issue lies with you.

I think men are equally prone to jealousy & competitiveness too btw. It's just that they don't tend to compliment each other anyway so differential treatment isn't that obvious.

NastyNiff · 02/03/2023 02:12

Companyofwolves · 01/03/2023 21:35

Women can be very insecure, competitive & bitchy around beauty. It’s a sad fact given we all want to hold up & support each other but not those women who feel your beauty is a threat to them. It’s mating competition. Even if you’re all coupled up /married /other. We are all monkeys at the end of the day, primitive & territorial. If it is beauty go hang out with some bonobos. They’re generally more chill.

Yes

Siepie · 02/03/2023 01:29

If you always look nice, people may not feel the need to say anything. For example if A has always got her nails done, but B has done it as a one off for the night out, I'm probably more likely to comment on B's.

However, if you've "always struggled with women", and it's not just about the occasional missing compliment, I agree with PP that there could be something about your behaviour that puts other women off. Confidence and insecurity can both come off as cockiness sometimes. I know I sometimes used to show off in search of compliments when I was younger, and in hindsight it didn't come across well.

TortolaParadise · 02/03/2023 01:25

I started a new job in the midst of Covid in a mask. Wore my mask for several months so no one had ever seen my face. I was treated fine, with warmth and friendliness when masked. After several months I removed my mask. I was immediately treated differently by the women. They slowly became distant and the atmosphere hostile. Behaviours included general uncooperativeness, commenting and audible remarks - nothing I could make stick but it absolutely happened to me. I noticed that they even began to imitate my style (make up).

A friend also had a similar experience in her workplace when she got dressed up for a Christmas do. Up until that point she had only ever been seen in uniform, hair swept up and minimal face on. Well the next day at work was a whole different experience for her - not in a positive way.

I'm unsure whether it is jealousy or a form of bullying. I could not even report it because I sounds nuts but I know what I experienced.

I think you are being perfectly reasonable. This is a real 'thing'. Sadly women on women get less air time than men on women issues in my opinion.

Sorry op that you are experiencing this. This is no humble brag either.

Imtryingnottobother · 02/03/2023 01:16

I think some women can be awful for a multitude of reasons, mostly unfathomable to me.
I would say be careful it hasn’t become self fulfilling, because of your earlier life experiences, that ‘s now coming across in your body language and general demeanour.
I think sometimes it’s worth looking
at your own behaviours and perhaps journaling to see if you can see a common theme in these interactions.

MissingMoominMamma · 02/03/2023 00:50

One of my friends has always been avoided by other women. She’s so kind and lovely, but she’s very tall, elegant and self assured. I’ve heard her described as stand offish, up her own arse, arrogant… she’s none of those things!

JudgeRudy · 02/03/2023 00:44

MissEira · 01/03/2023 21:22

Definitely sounds like jealousy.
People here say women dont act like that, but lots really do.

@MissEira
I'm being genuine here, not goady. What makes you so sure (definite!) that it's jealousy? Why not irritation, fear, disinterest etc. Why jealousy? I've been envious, but my feelings arent negative as such and theyre internal not towards that person. Occasionally l think lve been jealous but that usually involves attention from others which I find irritating eg when a work colleague does a presentation and (in my eyes) it's mediocre and everyone's fawning over them like it was special, or maybe a celebrity is revered as beautiful and I think, she's just a little bit pretty with a great stylist and a ton of money....I don't want to be that person, Il might even 'rate' myself higher. I don't even want the attention they're getting, I just want everyone to have a reality check and stop fawning. That feeling would make me avoid that person, and I definitely won't pay them a compliment because I don't thing it's appropriate.

IWineAndDontDine · 02/03/2023 00:37

Choconut · 01/03/2023 21:22

The pretty/confident girls I've known have always been the most popular IME. I would say they either think you're quite aloof, rate yourself a little too highly, try too hard or are too flirty with men. These are the reasons I have found women take again women that could be described as pretty and confident. You might not be or you might not think you are but sometimes people come across to others in ways they don't realise or don't mean to.

Agree with this. In my experience, the (mostly) only time women are jealous of good looking women is if they act like they know they are good looking. In my early 20s I got a lot of attention, and many girls immediately disliked me. I get on with almost all women now and the only thing that has changed is I'm way less cocky and generally a much nicer person, so I realised it wasn't my looks, it was my personality.

I personally do not believe women don't get on with women just because they are jealous of their beauty, or success or whatever. There must be something else that maybe you aren't aware of, something you are doing that's coming across a certain way?

Maybe its the "I just get on with men waaaay better" attitude. I tend to avoid those people admittedly. It gives off a "I'm different to the other girls x" vibe

JudgeRudy · 02/03/2023 00:29

Stopthebusplease · 01/03/2023 21:04

'Littleflowerseverywhere' what a horrible thing to say, and a horrible way to say it too! I bet you're one of those, that accepts compliments but doesn't give them out, or worse still, makes fake compliments and then talks behind the person's back. Sometimes I really dislike other women!

@Stopthebusplease
Is it so horrible? OP hinted at this herself....and why would you assume @Littleflowerseverywhere is 'one of those people....' I'd actually imagine she's really not that bothered about receiving complements and when she does she's likely to agree and think "Yes, I'm pleased I chose to wear my hair up/I pleased all my hard work resulted in a good grade/ thanks, I made it myself. I could do one for you..."

JudgeRudy · 02/03/2023 00:19

Jealousy seems to be the 'go to' emotion that women are accused of simply because they weren't nice or were mean to someone. I've never understood that. If someone doesn't like me I'd never assume it was because they were jealous myself, I'd think I irritated them, or maybe they disagreed with a view point.
Also, not being nice is just that. It doesn't have to be unkind but maybe you weren't invited somewhere or no one chose to partner you in sport...that just means they prefer other people. I'd put not complementing someone in this box.
It's quite self obsessed to think everyone has an opinion on you.

MrsRosieBrew · 02/03/2023 00:17

Your DH correct, it’s jealously. There is no other reason for other women to dislike you and ‘have it in for you’ when they don’t actually know you - but do know how you look. How to prevent it? Don’t waste time even thinking about this. Concentrate on your real friends who know that you’re a good person.

Mammyloveswine · 02/03/2023 00:12

ouch321 · 01/03/2023 23:39

The first line tells the whole story.

The fact that you've "always struggled with other women" makes it clear cut that it's you, not them.

This... any woman who says "other women don't like me" or "I've always gotten along better with men"...

Fwiw my best friend is absolutely beautiful, supermodel standard..she was my bridesmaid and probably absolutely looked soo much better than me... however I didn't care! My husband wasn't marrying her.. my friends and family all hugged me and were there to see me.. my photos are just love and beauty! I'm not s stunner but I looked radiant because I was so happy!!

Could you be giving off an "aloofness" or "unapproachable" vibe?

EllieM27 · 02/03/2023 00:10

It is most likely jealousy, due to the way women form and maintain friendships in what psychologists sometimes call a “flattened hierarchy.” I’ve had similar issues which I always attributed to a lack of female socialization when I was very young even though people told me many times that it was jealousy. It took me quite some time to come around to the idea that it was down to that. (I still have a hard time with it. I rewrote that last sentence about seven times and look how vague it is! Not receiving appropriate compliments/accolades from your female peers can really do a number on your self-image over the years. It’s not the same when it’s only from men.)

Anyway, there’s a lot of good research about it in terms of relational aggression. I recently picked up a few books about RA and women, particularly in the workplace.

SisterAgatha · 01/03/2023 23:58

Jellyx · 01/03/2023 23:53

Oh I wish that were the case. Plenty of older women pick on young , attractive females 🥲

This happens all the time. I’ve seen it a lot and feel so awful for the younger woman, knowing that in years past it has been me and my friends on the receiving end wondering wtf we had done wrong when it was someone else’s issue and nothing to do with us. This is why now I am older I see more and more that it’s jealousy.

Littleflowerseverywhere‘s posts have nailed it really. Plenty of women don’t give compliments, they give scathing remarks dressed up as “honesty” or “advice”.

Jellyx · 01/03/2023 23:53

NellietheElephantpackedhertrunks · 01/03/2023 21:05

Are you extremely beautiful? That can bring out the bitchy side in girls but one would hope not when they have grown up!

Oh I wish that were the case. Plenty of older women pick on young , attractive females 🥲

Jellyx · 01/03/2023 23:52

Littleflowerseverywhere · 01/03/2023 20:58

God I hate to say it, but if you like someone you find it easy to compliment them,. I get why you’d think every single female friend is envious of you.,but I think you know deep down, it’s not true. Your partner is just trying to soften it. But bottom line is if a woman likes another woman they will compliment them, I get though why it’s easier for you to wish it’s envy and not you’re just not liked.

sorry op. But you already knew it. Deep down. You knew.

What an unkind thing to say. Perhaps you're the type not giving compliments.

I think make an effort to meet new friends. You want to spend time with kind, confident people