Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU not going to my nephew's christening?

308 replies

headlessduck · 01/03/2023 19:24

Hey, my sister has just had her first baby and they have decided to christen him. None of our family is religious, but my BIL's parents are quite religious. I think they are mostly christening him because of them. I think that raising your child to be religious is deeply unethical. I think it is wrong to teach kids their ludicrous beliefs which there is almost no evidence for as if they are facts. It actively discourages critical thinking. You are facilitating a religion that is deeply misogynistic and homophobic, even if you conveniently ignore these parts of the Bible. Christenings are promising to do just that. At best it is a hypocritical promise. In this case, I think this is all it is. I feel uncomfortable supporting this, and I find religious ceremonies infuriating and boring. I told her I would not be going for these reasons. It is their choice. I am not trying to stop them from doing this, I just don't want to go myself. However, she told me this was "ridiculous" and "pathetic" and that it was "mostly just an excuse for a party." What does everyone think of this? AIBU not going to my nephew's christening?

OP posts:
ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 09:47

x2boys · 03/03/2023 09:45

Ah the irony,nobodies bullying the Op,,posters are respectful of her atheist beliefs ,what they are not respectful of us her intolerance to other people,s beliefs ,but I don't think the Op is coming back.anyway.

If posters were respectful of OP's atheist beliefs, they wouldn't disrespect her strongly held beliefs by telling her to 'suck it up and go'. So yes, it is bullying and it's disrespectful and it would not be done to a Hindu or Muslim or anyone else. Only atheists.

x2boys · 03/03/2023 09:45

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 09:25

I also think Christening/Baptism is completely different from a wedding or funeral. Those involve adults.

A christening involves putting religious beliefs on a baby who cannot speak for themselves. Many of us have problems with that specific aspect.

People talking about functions that adults choose with full will, such as weddings, or originally pagan holidays like Christmas or Easter is simply desperate whataboutery.

In the end, it's obvious the OP is hostile to Christianity and doesn't believe in Christenings. So, why can't people accept that and stop trying to bully her to engage with something she does not want to do? You might not agree with her reasons, but at least respect her wishes and leave her alone.

Ah the irony,nobodies bullying the Op,,posters are respectful of her atheist beliefs ,what they are not respectful of us her intolerance to other people,s beliefs ,but I don't think the Op is coming back.anyway.

user1492757084 · 03/03/2023 09:41

Christenings are focussed on the child - the love of God towards that child and asking for God's help in the important task of raising it. It is a celebration of life and parenting and it seems like you are not going to be able to be happy there.
You either put your feelings aside and support your sister with out complaint or rubbishing their beliefs or stay well away and visit with your sister another time..

ThighMistress · 03/03/2023 09:33

The OP sounds insufferably pompous. Imagine telling somebody you wouldn’t attend their religious event because other deities were made-up/homophobic/misogynistic etc etc.

I am not a religious person but I have been to all sorts - Jewish, Muslim and Hindu weddings and funerals as well as various types of Christian ones - including happy clappy ones (the worst!).

Clearly Strict Atheism does not embrace tolerance. Which makes it in my book just as bad as any “official” religion.

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 09:30

There's no evidence of the OP's sister "continuing to bully" her.

Only that her sister called her ridiculous and pathetic after she subjected her to a long speech about the evils of religion in response to an innocent invitation to a family event, when she could have simply said, "oh sorry I can't make it, I already have a wedding/hen do/holiday" booked over that date, or "great, looking forward to it" and then cried off sick at the last minute.

Or she could have said, "sorry, I don't do religion, could I just join you for the party afterwards?" without the massive, rude and hurtful speech. In which case if her sister then said, "no, you absolutely must participate in our family's religious rite even if you don't believe in it, and if you don't I will cut you off and by the way you're going to hell", in which case you and the OP would have a point.

But that didn't happen. Or if it did, that would be quire the drip feed.

Conkersinautumn · 03/03/2023 09:29

I'm with you. Totally wrong to subject children to the lies and manipulation of religious groups.

lazycats · 03/03/2023 09:28

The cowardly op seems to have fucked off but I've been to plenty of christenings despite seeing god as father christmas for adults. There are many social rituals which you can be part of while thinking they're unnecessary.

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 09:25

I also think Christening/Baptism is completely different from a wedding or funeral. Those involve adults.

A christening involves putting religious beliefs on a baby who cannot speak for themselves. Many of us have problems with that specific aspect.

People talking about functions that adults choose with full will, such as weddings, or originally pagan holidays like Christmas or Easter is simply desperate whataboutery.

In the end, it's obvious the OP is hostile to Christianity and doesn't believe in Christenings. So, why can't people accept that and stop trying to bully her to engage with something she does not want to do? You might not agree with her reasons, but at least respect her wishes and leave her alone.

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 09:22

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 09:20

Once again, for the hard of reading, @ItsShiela:

"I told her I would not be going for these reasons."

Do you honestly think her sister doesn't know her own sister is strongly atheist? So why would she continue to bully the OP to attend something she doesn't want to do?

Why can't she accept no?

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 09:20

Once again, for the hard of reading, @ItsShiela:

"I told her I would not be going for these reasons."

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 09:18

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 09:12

This is nonsense.

I think most people - including most Christians - would agree that telling everyone who doesn't share their beliefs that they are going straight to hell is completely unacceptable.

That's the equivalent of what the OP, and other militant atheist bores, is doing here.

It's quite incredible that you can listen to the OP's own account of treating her sister to a diatribe about the Christian religion being unethical, misogynistic, homophobic, discouraging critical thinking, accusing her sister of being a hypocrite, and saying she doesn't want to go because she'll feel uncomfortable but also because the ceremony will be "infuriating and boring", and come to the conclusion that the OP is being bullied for her beliefs, rather than the other way around.

The OP's sister hasn't said the OP is being ridiculous and pathetic for not being religious, whereas the OP has in fact said that Christians are stupid, bigoted and hypocritical because of their beliefs.

You can't say such awful things to someone and expect them to just smile and say "oh OK then, I respect your right to think those things about me and my family, no hard feelings".

No, your extrapolation is nonsense. OP was telling us her reasoning. No where does she say she said all that to her sister. I think her sister would already know her beliefs on Christianity, don't you? So that conversation wouldn't have even needed to have happened and likely didn't. Actually, that sister knows OP's views and still bullies her to attend, is extra proof of my point.

The only one that we know that has actually been abusive, is the OP's sister. She called the OP "pathetic" and "ridiculous" for not wanting to go to something. It exactly proves my point that with some (not all) Christians, respect is only one way. Even the replies that OP should 'suck it up and go' would NEVER be said to someone of a sacred religious belief. Only atheists are fair game by disrespectful people.

Usernameisunavailable · 03/03/2023 09:18

YABU. Have you never been to a church wedding or funeral because of your beliefs? I’m an atheist and I’ve been to lots of religious events for other people whatever their faiths because it’s about them, not about you. You sound very sanctimonious. I agree with your sister, pathetic and ridiculous sounds about right. I wouldn’t be surprised if you’re that family member who’s always hard work.

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 09:17

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 09:06

Where does it say she gave her sister that speech? She was explaining to us her beliefs. She never said she told her sister that. If you read the OP, the sister won't take no for an answer and called the OP "pathetic" and "ridiculous" just for saying no. Re-read the OP.

I think you need to re-read the OP.

Specifically, the part where she says, "I told her I would not be going for these reasons."

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 09:15

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 09:08

There are many reverts (converts) in families, and whether it's likely or not, you'd have a Muslim friend or co-worker.

Most Muslims would not attend a Christening. This is common knowledge. It's against their beliefs.

Where is your evidence that they would not attend a Christening? I know plenty of Muslims who happily attend church weddings, and indeed non Muslims who have attended Muslim weddings.

Not everyone is so narrow minded to think that they can only support their loved ones in major life milestones with religious rites attached if they belong to exactly the same religion and believe exactly the same things.

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 09:12

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 09:00

I think a lot of people share op's views but would never say anything about it.

Yep, and from the bullying and disrespectful replies to the OP we can see why. Stand up for your Christian beliefs, ok.
Stand up for your Islamic beliefs, ok.
Stand up for your Jewish beliefs, ok.
Stand up for your Wiccan beliefs, ok.
Stand up for your Hindu beliefs, ok.

Stand up for your atheist beliefs? NoT EvEryThIng is about you! Just 'suck it up'. You're "pathetic". Etc etc.

What gives? Why the double standards? Why can't people accept a No with respect, appreciation and grace?

This is nonsense.

I think most people - including most Christians - would agree that telling everyone who doesn't share their beliefs that they are going straight to hell is completely unacceptable.

That's the equivalent of what the OP, and other militant atheist bores, is doing here.

It's quite incredible that you can listen to the OP's own account of treating her sister to a diatribe about the Christian religion being unethical, misogynistic, homophobic, discouraging critical thinking, accusing her sister of being a hypocrite, and saying she doesn't want to go because she'll feel uncomfortable but also because the ceremony will be "infuriating and boring", and come to the conclusion that the OP is being bullied for her beliefs, rather than the other way around.

The OP's sister hasn't said the OP is being ridiculous and pathetic for not being religious, whereas the OP has in fact said that Christians are stupid, bigoted and hypocritical because of their beliefs.

You can't say such awful things to someone and expect them to just smile and say "oh OK then, I respect your right to think those things about me and my family, no hard feelings".

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 09:08

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 09:05

Well, it's far less likely that a devout Muslim would be the sister of someone baptising her child into the Christian religion.

But why are you assuming that a devout Muslim wouldn't go to a Christening ti support their loved ones?

That's pretty narrow minded.

There are many reverts (converts) in families, and whether it's likely or not, you'd have a Muslim friend or co-worker.

Most Muslims would not attend a Christening. This is common knowledge. It's against their beliefs.

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 09:06

HoppingPavlova · 03/03/2023 09:02

I can’t believe you gave your sister that self-righteous speech, rather than saying ‘sorry, I won’t be able to make it’. Fucking hell.

Where does it say she gave her sister that speech? She was explaining to us her beliefs. She never said she told her sister that. If you read the OP, the sister won't take no for an answer and called the OP "pathetic" and "ridiculous" just for saying no. Re-read the OP.

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 09:05

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 08:56

One thing I've noticed is that if you're an atheist, bullying atheists seems to be accepted practice in a way it wouldn't be with Muslims, Hindus, Judaism, or even Witchcraft.

What is it about the absence of a religious belief that makes atheists fair game to coerce and browbeat and insult? These people who think the OP should 'suck it up' would never say the same to a devout Muslim who didn't want to go to a Christening. It's such double standards and such blatant disrespect.

Well, it's far less likely that a devout Muslim would be the sister of someone baptising her child into the Christian religion.

But why are you assuming that a devout Muslim wouldn't go to a Christening ti support their loved ones?

That's pretty narrow minded.

HoppingPavlova · 03/03/2023 09:02

I can’t believe you gave your sister that self-righteous speech, rather than saying ‘sorry, I won’t be able to make it’. Fucking hell.

MyLittlePonyWellies · 03/03/2023 09:01

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 08:56

One thing I've noticed is that if you're an atheist, bullying atheists seems to be accepted practice in a way it wouldn't be with Muslims, Hindus, Judaism, or even Witchcraft.

What is it about the absence of a religious belief that makes atheists fair game to coerce and browbeat and insult? These people who think the OP should 'suck it up' would never say the same to a devout Muslim who didn't want to go to a Christening. It's such double standards and such blatant disrespect.

I have never experienced this and have met a number of atheists who are very keen to 'convert' me. Much more so than anyone who has a faith (excepting street Preachers and the like).

If you've experienced that, that's terrible though and your lack of faith ought to be respected as much as my faith ought to be

FeinCuroxiVooz · 03/03/2023 09:00

I'm sure you can skip the ceremony and just come to the party (with a nice gift)

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 09:00

I think a lot of people share op's views but would never say anything about it.

Yep, and from the bullying and disrespectful replies to the OP we can see why. Stand up for your Christian beliefs, ok.
Stand up for your Islamic beliefs, ok.
Stand up for your Jewish beliefs, ok.
Stand up for your Wiccan beliefs, ok.
Stand up for your Hindu beliefs, ok.

Stand up for your atheist beliefs? NoT EvEryThIng is about you! Just 'suck it up'. You're "pathetic". Etc etc.

What gives? Why the double standards? Why can't people accept a No with respect, appreciation and grace?

MyLittlePonyWellies · 03/03/2023 08:58

Oh and my eldest's godfather is a gay man. He had no issues with being part of the christening, renouncing Satan and all the rest. So if you're abstaining on behalf of all gay people, it may be misplaced.

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 08:56

One thing I've noticed is that if you're an atheist, bullying atheists seems to be accepted practice in a way it wouldn't be with Muslims, Hindus, Judaism, or even Witchcraft.

What is it about the absence of a religious belief that makes atheists fair game to coerce and browbeat and insult? These people who think the OP should 'suck it up' would never say the same to a devout Muslim who didn't want to go to a Christening. It's such double standards and such blatant disrespect.

MyLittlePonyWellies · 03/03/2023 08:56

It doesn't look as if op has been back.

I think a lot of people share op's views but would never say anything about it.

I am fairly churchy...well, less so these days. But if I felt as strongly as op does, I'd probably just have turned down the invitation and not said why.

I would happily go to an atheist naming ceremony. In fact, I was the child's 'guardian' (like godmother) at one of these. I'd also go to a baptism at churches outside my own faith or from other religions entirely. I don't know any Christian who would refuse to go to an atheist ceremony, whether it be a wedding, funeral or christening. I would draw the line at something like a Satanist ceremony or whatever, but I don't know any parents who'd choose that for their baby's naming day anyway.

Swipe left for the next trending thread