Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU not going to my nephew's christening?

308 replies

headlessduck · 01/03/2023 19:24

Hey, my sister has just had her first baby and they have decided to christen him. None of our family is religious, but my BIL's parents are quite religious. I think they are mostly christening him because of them. I think that raising your child to be religious is deeply unethical. I think it is wrong to teach kids their ludicrous beliefs which there is almost no evidence for as if they are facts. It actively discourages critical thinking. You are facilitating a religion that is deeply misogynistic and homophobic, even if you conveniently ignore these parts of the Bible. Christenings are promising to do just that. At best it is a hypocritical promise. In this case, I think this is all it is. I feel uncomfortable supporting this, and I find religious ceremonies infuriating and boring. I told her I would not be going for these reasons. It is their choice. I am not trying to stop them from doing this, I just don't want to go myself. However, she told me this was "ridiculous" and "pathetic" and that it was "mostly just an excuse for a party." What does everyone think of this? AIBU not going to my nephew's christening?

OP posts:
RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 13:57

whumpthereitis · 03/03/2023 13:51

Oh no, not the ‘not a nice person’! It’s also entirely possible that she does know her sister as well as she thought, and that’s why her sister has reacted as she has.

She could just let her sister get on with being butthurt, or they could talk it out and agree to respect one another’s views. Someone being offended by what you said does not mean you automatically owe them an apology.

Remind me how deliberately saying something she knows will offend her sister is respecting her sister's views then?

If this is how you go about treating the people you care about with respect, I have to wonder how many friends and family you have fallen out with.

whumpthereitis · 03/03/2023 13:51

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 13:46

Either she knew her sister would be offended by her comments and made them anyway, in which case she's not a nice person, or she doesn't know her sister as well as she thought and should apologise for being so rude.

Oh no, not the ‘not a nice person’! It’s also entirely possible that she does know her sister as well as she thought, and that’s why her sister has reacted as she has.

She could just let her sister get on with being butthurt, or they could talk it out and agree to respect one another’s views. Someone being offended by what you said does not mean you automatically owe them an apology.

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 13:46

whumpthereitis · 03/03/2023 13:37

OP knows the relationship she has with her sister, and how they normally talk to one another. I doubt it’s the first time the sister has heard OP’s views, and for all we know she’s shared them. I also imagine she shared her views because simply declining would likely prompt her sister to ask for an explanation.

It appears the sister isn’t having a christening because she earnestly believes in it, she’s having a christening for the sake of her husband and in-laws, and for the party. OP isn’t attacking a faith she believes her sister to hold, and nor is she trying to stop her sister. She just doesn’t want to be involved, and gave her reasons as to why.

Either she knew her sister would be offended by her comments and made them anyway, in which case she's not a nice person, or she doesn't know her sister as well as she thought and should apologise for being so rude.

whumpthereitis · 03/03/2023 13:37

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 13:04

Right, so the OP said that she thought her sister was being a dickhead for having her child baptised, the sister replied that she thought the OP was being a dickhead for being so rude, and now the OP is posting on Mumsnet asking if she is being unreasonable.

Yes, she is. There are many less offensive ways she could have turned down this invitation. But she couldn't resist putting the boot in, apparently.

OP knows the relationship she has with her sister, and how they normally talk to one another. I doubt it’s the first time the sister has heard OP’s views, and for all we know she’s shared them. I also imagine she shared her views because simply declining would likely prompt her sister to ask for an explanation.

It appears the sister isn’t having a christening because she earnestly believes in it, she’s having a christening for the sake of her husband and in-laws, and for the party. OP isn’t attacking a faith she believes her sister to hold, and nor is she trying to stop her sister. She just doesn’t want to be involved, and gave her reasons as to why.

AllOfThemWitches · 03/03/2023 13:21

I think it is wrong to teach kids their ludicrous beliefs which there is almost no evidence for as if they are facts.

I mean, OP has a good point here.

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 13:05

AllOfThemWitches · 03/03/2023 12:21

If I told my sister I thought her beliefs were unethical, ludicrous, misogynistic, homophobic and hypocritical, and demonstrative of a lack of critical thinking, I wouldn't expect our relationship to be unaffected by it.

Really? I mean which part would you argue is untrue?

All of it. Because these are opinions, not facts.

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 13:04

whumpthereitis · 03/03/2023 12:21

They’re not her sister’s beliefs though, are they? They’re her sister’s excuse to have a party, in her own words.

Relationship dynamics between siblings differ depending on the individuals involved. I have a relationship with my brother where I can say if I think he’s being a bit of a dickhead, and he can say the same to me. We have a strong relationship, and trust each other to speak plainly, even if it’s likely to piss one of us off. Clearly to some this would be considered rude and outrageous. To each their own.

Right, so the OP said that she thought her sister was being a dickhead for having her child baptised, the sister replied that she thought the OP was being a dickhead for being so rude, and now the OP is posting on Mumsnet asking if she is being unreasonable.

Yes, she is. There are many less offensive ways she could have turned down this invitation. But she couldn't resist putting the boot in, apparently.

AllOfThemWitches · 03/03/2023 12:24

I have a relationship with my brother where I can say if I think he’s being a bit of a dickhead

Same. If either my sister or I decided we wanted to convert to <insert name of religion> we'd both be comfortable enough to ask 'wtaf is everything OK with you?'

whumpthereitis · 03/03/2023 12:21

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 12:13

If I told my sister I thought her beliefs were unethical, ludicrous, misogynistic, homophobic and hypocritical, and demonstrative of a lack of critical thinking, I wouldn't expect our relationship to be unaffected by it.

Nor would I post a thread on Mumsnet asking if I was unreasonable to say all those things and complaining about being called ridiculous and pathetic (both of which I think are fairly tame in comparison) in return.

They’re not her sister’s beliefs though, are they? They’re her sister’s excuse to have a party, in her own words.

Relationship dynamics between siblings differ depending on the individuals involved. I have a relationship with my brother where I can say if I think he’s being a bit of a dickhead, and he can say the same to me. We have a strong relationship, and trust each other to speak plainly, even if it’s likely to piss one of us off. Clearly to some this would be considered rude and outrageous. To each their own.

AllOfThemWitches · 03/03/2023 12:21

If I told my sister I thought her beliefs were unethical, ludicrous, misogynistic, homophobic and hypocritical, and demonstrative of a lack of critical thinking, I wouldn't expect our relationship to be unaffected by it.

Really? I mean which part would you argue is untrue?

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 12:13

whumpthereitis · 03/03/2023 12:10

She’s not telling her sister to not have the christening, or actively trying to prevent it. She shared her opinion with her sister, something that is fairly normal for siblings.

If I told my sister I thought her beliefs were unethical, ludicrous, misogynistic, homophobic and hypocritical, and demonstrative of a lack of critical thinking, I wouldn't expect our relationship to be unaffected by it.

Nor would I post a thread on Mumsnet asking if I was unreasonable to say all those things and complaining about being called ridiculous and pathetic (both of which I think are fairly tame in comparison) in return.

whumpthereitis · 03/03/2023 12:10

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 12:05

Her diatribe about religion is not respecting her sister's decision.

Nobody needs to hear the OP's inner monologue about this subject. At best, it's boring.

She’s not telling her sister to not have the christening, or actively trying to prevent it. She shared her opinion with her sister, something that is fairly normal for siblings.

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 12:09

Elphame · 03/03/2023 11:22

Of course it’s unethical.

The child is being baptised into a faith and once it’s done it’s done and can’t be undone.

Trying to get off the CoE baptismal register is all but impossible and the church uses those registers to justify its claim that it is entitled to impose itself on the country and how the rest of us live our lives.

Some churches don’t baptise infants any more and it’s more than time the CoE followed suit but hey look at all the income they’d lose and “membership “ ( different from attendance which is already collapsing) numbers would be negligible when those of us who are included against our will die off.

Some people think eating animal products or having an abortion is unethical.

That doesn't mean we need to see them protesting with placards in places where they aren't wanted or boring the tits off everyone who disagrees with them about it.

FrustatedAgain · 03/03/2023 12:08

YABU, a christening is also a celebration of a baby and welcoming them to the world. Its a nice occasion and a happy family get together.
You sound like an overthinking killjoy tbh! Just go along and enjoy it for what it is, a beautiful day celebrating the baby.

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 12:07

AllOfThemWitches · 03/03/2023 11:34

Scorn? What has she said that's 'scornful' or even untrue?

I'd say the comments about critical thinking and hypocrisy are pretty scornful.

As for truth, everything she has said is a matter of opinion, not fact.

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 12:05

whumpthereitis · 03/03/2023 12:00

Yet it’s atheists that are expected to suck it up and go along with something they fundamentally disagree with in the name of family harmony. A christening is a religious decision made on behalf of a child, which is quite different to religious decisions made by adults on behalf of themselves.

OP isn’t trying to stop her sister, she knows full well she can make whatever decision she likes. OP spoke plainly, yes, to her sister. I speak plainly to my brother, and he does with me. That’s the nature of our (good) relationship, as it may well ordinarily be the nature of OP’s.

OP can respect her sister’s decision to go ahead and have a christening, and the sister can respect OP’s decision to not be involved.

Her diatribe about religion is not respecting her sister's decision.

Nobody needs to hear the OP's inner monologue about this subject. At best, it's boring.

Bellaboo01 · 03/03/2023 12:04

JudgeJ · 01/03/2023 19:30

With such aggressive views I wouldn't want you there and you certainly wouldn't be welcome to the party afterwards.

This. Why does everything have to be so over-thought. Just go, have fun wth your family and enjoy yourself.

whumpthereitis · 03/03/2023 12:00

x2boys · 03/03/2023 10:05

I didn't eartheN should go and in fact I have read many other posters telling the Op to stay away a
why is the Op.in your opinion allowed to be openly hostile about christianity?
the world would be a much nicer place if people could respect other people's beliefs and not be hostile about demand that works both ways .

Yet it’s atheists that are expected to suck it up and go along with something they fundamentally disagree with in the name of family harmony. A christening is a religious decision made on behalf of a child, which is quite different to religious decisions made by adults on behalf of themselves.

OP isn’t trying to stop her sister, she knows full well she can make whatever decision she likes. OP spoke plainly, yes, to her sister. I speak plainly to my brother, and he does with me. That’s the nature of our (good) relationship, as it may well ordinarily be the nature of OP’s.

OP can respect her sister’s decision to go ahead and have a christening, and the sister can respect OP’s decision to not be involved.

AllOfThemWitches · 03/03/2023 11:34

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 11:14

You don't think the outpouring of scorn in the OP is hostile?

Ok then...

Scorn? What has she said that's 'scornful' or even untrue?

Elphame · 03/03/2023 11:22

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 02/03/2023 01:04

A bit of water on a baby’s head is unethical?

Lets face it, 99% of people these days have a christening for the party and their child never hears a thing about God ever again and then they don’t see their godparents ever.

Of course it’s unethical.

The child is being baptised into a faith and once it’s done it’s done and can’t be undone.

Trying to get off the CoE baptismal register is all but impossible and the church uses those registers to justify its claim that it is entitled to impose itself on the country and how the rest of us live our lives.

Some churches don’t baptise infants any more and it’s more than time the CoE followed suit but hey look at all the income they’d lose and “membership “ ( different from attendance which is already collapsing) numbers would be negligible when those of us who are included against our will die off.

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 11:14

AllOfThemWitches · 03/03/2023 10:41

She hasn't been hostile. Why are we accusing people of being 'hostile' and 'Aggressive?' when they're really not? It smacks of gaslighting.

We don't have to respect ridiculous beliefs, does mumsnet on the whole respect the belief that 'transwomen are women,' for example?

You don't think the outpouring of scorn in the OP is hostile?

Ok then...

AllOfThemWitches · 03/03/2023 10:41

x2boys · 03/03/2023 10:05

I didn't eartheN should go and in fact I have read many other posters telling the Op to stay away a
why is the Op.in your opinion allowed to be openly hostile about christianity?
the world would be a much nicer place if people could respect other people's beliefs and not be hostile about demand that works both ways .

She hasn't been hostile. Why are we accusing people of being 'hostile' and 'Aggressive?' when they're really not? It smacks of gaslighting.

We don't have to respect ridiculous beliefs, does mumsnet on the whole respect the belief that 'transwomen are women,' for example?

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 10:12

x2boys · 03/03/2023 10:05

I didn't eartheN should go and in fact I have read many other posters telling the Op to stay away a
why is the Op.in your opinion allowed to be openly hostile about christianity?
the world would be a much nicer place if people could respect other people's beliefs and not be hostile about demand that works both ways .

I believe in free speech and so I believe that - provided you are not committing some sort of hate crime or illegally discriminating against someone - you should be allowed to be openly hostile about Christianity.

What you can't expect is to be openly hostile about Christianity in response to a loved one inviting you to a family event and expect them to be polite and respectful to you in response.

x2boys · 03/03/2023 10:05

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 09:47

If posters were respectful of OP's atheist beliefs, they wouldn't disrespect her strongly held beliefs by telling her to 'suck it up and go'. So yes, it is bullying and it's disrespectful and it would not be done to a Hindu or Muslim or anyone else. Only atheists.

I didn't eartheN should go and in fact I have read many other posters telling the Op to stay away a
why is the Op.in your opinion allowed to be openly hostile about christianity?
the world would be a much nicer place if people could respect other people's beliefs and not be hostile about demand that works both ways .

RosaBonheur · 03/03/2023 09:51

ItsShiela · 03/03/2023 09:47

If posters were respectful of OP's atheist beliefs, they wouldn't disrespect her strongly held beliefs by telling her to 'suck it up and go'. So yes, it is bullying and it's disrespectful and it would not be done to a Hindu or Muslim or anyone else. Only atheists.

I can't speak for anybody else, but I certainly haven't said the OP should suck it up and go. On the contrary, I think my first comment was along the lines of, "I bet you're fun at parties (not)."

I think the OP should have been more respectful of her sister and her sister's family by not treating her to an unsolicited polemic about why she shouldn't be having her baby baptised.

Why is it OK for atheists to be intolerant, but not people with religious beliefs? Why the double standards?

And once again, how exactly do you interpret the OP to mean that the OP's sister is bullying her, rather than the other way around?