Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if Civil Service annual leave might be negotiable?

60 replies

bambamalam · 01/03/2023 18:57

I'm thinking of applying for a civil service job. It's a level 7 specialist analytical role with a market supplement attached, which suggests that they've been struggling to recruit. The advert says it includes 25 days leave, rising to 30 after 5 years. I currently have 30 days leave (plus bank hols), so 25 would be a significant reduction. If it was a private company I might try to negotiate, but for the Civil Service would I be whistling in the wind?

OP posts:
QueueEtwo · 01/03/2023 21:21

We can actually sell our annual leave this year as we're going back down to 10 days carry forward after being allowed to carry forward 15 during Covid!

Not that I am selling any! 🙄

Lauralozzle · 01/03/2023 21:11

It's not negotiable.

It's not always negotiable when you move between departments, as you join on the new departments terms and conditions but your continuing service counts. I lost 5 days moving between departments because terms and conditions (length of service) for 31 days was different in different departments. I fought it, and HR said no. Was worth the move though for the pay rise/promotion.

There's flexi time, you can accrue time and use that as a day off. Longer hours building it up. I save up 2 days, use 2 days flexi and 3 days annual leave for a week off, which can work nicely if you put the work in. Makes holiday leave last longer.

There are caveats with building time if you're working to a target/KPI. Say in a day you had to do 15 pieces of work, you couldn't just take longer/take your time and add an extra hour, they'd expect an extra hours worth of work.

Croissantsandpistachio · 01/03/2023 20:50

I did actually negotiate salary coming in as a 7, but it was a shortage area.

In my department you can buy up to 10 days leave- works out nicely from a tax perspective as well. 7s don't get flexi in my dept but we do have good flexible working practices and the leave purchase scheme.

tommika · 01/03/2023 20:22

The Civil Service aims to provide flexibility, so unless there’s a good reason to prevent it then you will be able to have flexi time, which doesn’t give you more days but does allow you to work longer each day to top up a bit or have early Fridays etc

Each flexi scheme has its rules so you can’t just make up 5 days and take a week off but will be able to accrue a day or two across to the next period

tommika · 01/03/2023 20:18

As others have said it won’t hurt to ask but there won’t really be much negotiation.

The market supplement does show that you have a desirable specialism, but I’m aware of a department that does have the standard grade pay scales plus a supplement to retain specialists / particular roles.

You will still have bank holidays to add, plus as some have mentioned potential privilege days which can slightly differ between departments

I would expect you to get 25 days leave, plus bank holidays plus 1 privilege day as the sovereigns birthday.
The 25 rising to 30 over 5 years is likely to be one extra day per year

Historically the civil service had 2.5 privilege days which government removed, but the Queen pointed out that the sovereigns day was granted by the king rather than a government term of service.
I believe that there are one or two job types that still have 2.5 privilege days, but they are a rarity.

For me I have ‘lost’ 1.5 of the privilege days, but they are in the terms of my contract due to when I started so I instead have 31.5 days leave + BHs + 1 PD
(That means I get to choose when to use my 1.5 as leave rather than the set periods when they were privilege days)
If I take promotion again or transfer department then my contract will change and I’ll lose the 1.5 days

You of course have nothing to lose over asking for going straight to 30 days (unless you don’t accept the offer, saying you want 30 days or don’t join and they then say no)

CatOnTheChair · 01/03/2023 19:56

Actual days holiday won't be negotiable, but as others have said look at other ways to get extra days off - unpaid leave, 0.95 working, TOIL.
DH also seems to get random extra days ontop - queens birthday (I guess Kings birthday now) plus other oddities.

seratoninmoonbeams · 01/03/2023 19:50

I get 31 days now as been there years ....and can accrue two days flex a month ..... and have the option of buying up to two weeks holiday PA. So definitely worth asking as there will definitely be some way to make it similar or better time off than you have now probably 😆

kljk78 · 01/03/2023 19:40

@BarbaraofSeville obviously, but it's fairly easy to build up time in the week without going into overload, with a shorter lunch break, slightly longer day (especially when WFH- the time I used to spend commuting!) or when travelling to another location on work time, the key is being able to then take the time off in bulk and a time that suits us. I barely notice the few additional hours in the week, but really feel the "extra" 1-2 weeks of leave.

BarbaraofSeville · 01/03/2023 19:37

SausageMonkey2 · 01/03/2023 19:19

Ask to be put up a band or two due to the difference though

Yeah, like that's going to happen Hmm

All those going on about flexitime, you do realise you have to work the hours on other days to make up for it and it's there to get the work done, not top up your holiday allowance.

kljk78 · 01/03/2023 19:36

@RedCarsGoFaster that is a slightly different situation, it's a bit like when you level transfer and you don't go down to your new department's salary if it's lower than what you had already, you wouldn't be expected to lose what you accrued. I have accrued 4 days leave from 4 years service as my department lets you accrue a day a year, but if I moved to a department that made you wait 5 years for 5 days I would not lose the 4 days.

That said I still think OP should negotiate (at job offer stage) because they can only say no, and you never know you might get a sneaky manager willing to informally gift you days...not condoning it but I've seen worse!

Gingersay · 01/03/2023 19:31

In our department you wouldn't be allowed to negotiate. However ours is very generous 30 days plus 12 bank hols the only ones which are not flexible are Xmas and new year. We can also take 1 day flexi a week (or 30 hours a month) so if you work it well you can pretty much have 90 days a year!!

Silvers11 · 01/03/2023 19:30

Not -negotiable - and I wouldn't ask at Interview if I were you! These kind of things are negotiated with unions in the Civil Service

But flexi time is very likely to be an option and that would be reasonable to ask.

Iizzyb · 01/03/2023 19:29

I can buy an extra week's leave but the leave entitlement itself is non-negotiable

Warringstars · 01/03/2023 19:27

As you’re new to civil service and don’t know the rules, I don’t see what possible harm it could do to ask. Remember in Civil service you get more days than just Bank holidays on top of your leave entitlement you also get “privilege days” which vary according to region. So enquire about that too and you may be closer to your net total leave than in private sector when that’s accounted for.

Balloontea · 01/03/2023 19:24

RedCarsGoFaster · 01/03/2023 19:21

Well, it's definitely negotiable - I internally transferred from a gvt agency where you get 30days at 5yrs to one where you only get it at 10yrs. I asked for this to be honoured and it was. Whether its negotiable as an external candidate is up for debate.

Its not up for debate, its absolutely non negotiable for someone external.

OP see what other options there are ie flexi, buying additional leave or whatever.

DisappointingAvocado · 01/03/2023 19:22

Unlikely to be negotiable, but I get 25+11.5 (12.5 this year) and Flexi time so actually take a lot more than just 5 weeks. After 4 years it will go up to 30+11.5 for me.

RedCarsGoFaster · 01/03/2023 19:21

Well, it's definitely negotiable - I internally transferred from a gvt agency where you get 30days at 5yrs to one where you only get it at 10yrs. I asked for this to be honoured and it was. Whether its negotiable as an external candidate is up for debate.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 01/03/2023 19:20

Definetly worth asking!! I didn't ask at my last move (into a similar role) and when I got there loads of people had different leave entitlements that they had negotiated at interview

SausageMonkey2 · 01/03/2023 19:19

Ask to be put up a band or two due to the difference though

SpyouttheLand · 01/03/2023 19:18

I don't think the leave entitlement will be negotiable, but you might be able to negotiate annualised hours or a week's unpaid leave.

angerelle · 01/03/2023 19:17

In my civil service job we can buy more leave, so that may be an option if you don't get anywhere with negotiating!

kljk78 · 01/03/2023 19:16

I tried to no avail (specialist also) always worth trying. Remember flexi enables you to book extra leave, I tag flexi onto all my leave periods which affords me at least an extra week a year.

Thankfully in a department that lets you accrue a day a year though rather than wait 5 years, and if you change jobs within the civil service you keep that entitlement, so despite me changing jobs frequently I do still have my days accrued.

Brazilianadventure · 01/03/2023 19:15

YABU to expect to negotiate as its an Equal pay issue.

However, you will find its 25 days plus 8 BH plus the Kings Birthday (unless they scrap it as it was the Queen’s Birthday) = 34 days.

kegofcoffee · 01/03/2023 19:14

It won't be negotiable, but my experience of public sector is you're likely to be able to built up 12-18 flexi days a year and will also get 3-5days closure at Christmas.

So you're likely to actually get 40 - 48 days a year.

SometimesMaybe · 01/03/2023 19:13

No not negotiable but depending on the role likely you will get Flex Time which is worth a least a day a month.
CS are usually good at giving unpaid leave etc so that might be a way to get the same leave (though at a £££ cost).