Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if Civil Service annual leave might be negotiable?

60 replies

bambamalam · 01/03/2023 18:57

I'm thinking of applying for a civil service job. It's a level 7 specialist analytical role with a market supplement attached, which suggests that they've been struggling to recruit. The advert says it includes 25 days leave, rising to 30 after 5 years. I currently have 30 days leave (plus bank hols), so 25 would be a significant reduction. If it was a private company I might try to negotiate, but for the Civil Service would I be whistling in the wind?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/03/2023 20:15

tommika · 02/03/2023 17:11

@Vanillaradio
@kljk78
@Brazilianadventure

There are some contract terms in the MoD that still feature the full 2.5 days of sovereign, extra Xmas and Maundy Thursday half day - but these are specific ones such as for shift workers etc
Different government departments do have different terms of service, but it’s the standard that 1.5 privilege days will have been removed

Existing staff on the change date who have not had promoted since will have the 1.5 as extra annual leave, new starters won’t get them unless in a specific role type which has them in the terms of service

Government intended to remove all privilege days from the civil service in 2013 but the sovereigns birthday dates back to 1748 and they were promptly told by the palace to reinstate the day.
With the Queen passing rumours have been made about withdrawing the day, but with 275 years of history and its retention being enforced a decade ago it’s a little unlikely to go

My department don’t have the privilege day but we have 32.5 days off as standard. I was on 30 days at my old department plus privilege day, so I gained 1.5 days on moving.

moppa · 02/03/2023 20:03

Christmas shopping days are still an unofficial thing in my Dept.. lol

It's done in a "you're off tomorrow, aren't you James" 😉 kinda way

"Sarah.. you're off on Thursday.. Louise, you're off Friday, right?"

ArnoldBee · 02/03/2023 20:01

Unlikely but if you don't ask you don't get!
What you need to be thinking about is your working pattern so people do 10 over 9 or 5 over 4 for example.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/03/2023 19:55

Balloontea · 01/03/2023 19:24

Its not up for debate, its absolutely non negotiable for someone external.

OP see what other options there are ie flexi, buying additional leave or whatever.

I agree that the situation @RedCarsGoFaster had is completely different. Honouring the arrangements of another dept is quite standard, negotiating with external candidates absolutely isn’t.

As others have said, it’s an equal pay issue.

They are usually good at giving unpaid special leave or letting you buy leave though.

Brazilianadventure · 02/03/2023 19:48

@tommika 😭😭

tommika · 02/03/2023 19:28

Brazilianadventure · 02/03/2023 17:42

@tommika thanks , I was aware of that, it was why I was surprised some posters still had privileged days.

I do remember Frances Maud in 2012 -diamond Jubilee year wanting to get rid of the QB and being told he would have to ask the Queen. 😭

I’ll trump the ‘unofficial’ privilege days ……

When I began my career in the last century (mid 1980s)

There was a ‘Christmas shopping day’, but the way it worked was that you would write on your leave sheet in pencil, and hand it up the chain getting approved in pencil
As long as nobody saw you off work it would get rubbed out

This ‘process’ lasted until I gained some authority and pointed out that not only were people getting a free day off but they were documenting a conspiracy to defraud complete with everyone’s initials from the individual, supervisor, branch manager and unit head.
The shopping day continued but without the evidence

Many years later after the shopping day had ended …..

One year in the lead up to Christmas a general proposed an energy saving initiative proposed to shut down buildings for a long Christmas stand down. For the army they could close, but for civilians special permission was obtained to grant a free week off due to the short notice and inability to suddenly demand how leave was used

When I faxed around the plans I was called over to be told that I wouldn’t believe that the grapevine had fully kicked in and that one of the branches were in uproar. Their manager was on his way with the complaints that with an extra week off they wouldn’t have time to plan their shopping day rota.

After a few choice words were exclaimed I recommended that someone needed to get him on his mobile and engage his brain before he has to explain to me not only why they are still continuing a long gone fiddle but why 5 free days off aren’t good enough

moppa · 02/03/2023 17:46

Flexi time is the way forward here.

I'm a looooong term civil servant with my 30 days but lots of my newer colleagues have requested and been turned down.

Brazilianadventure · 02/03/2023 17:42

@tommika thanks , I was aware of that, it was why I was surprised some posters still had privileged days.

I do remember Frances Maud in 2012 -diamond Jubilee year wanting to get rid of the QB and being told he would have to ask the Queen. 😭

tommika · 02/03/2023 17:11

@Vanillaradio
@kljk78
@Brazilianadventure

There are some contract terms in the MoD that still feature the full 2.5 days of sovereign, extra Xmas and Maundy Thursday half day - but these are specific ones such as for shift workers etc
Different government departments do have different terms of service, but it’s the standard that 1.5 privilege days will have been removed

Existing staff on the change date who have not had promoted since will have the 1.5 as extra annual leave, new starters won’t get them unless in a specific role type which has them in the terms of service

Government intended to remove all privilege days from the civil service in 2013 but the sovereigns birthday dates back to 1748 and they were promptly told by the palace to reinstate the day.
With the Queen passing rumours have been made about withdrawing the day, but with 275 years of history and its retention being enforced a decade ago it’s a little unlikely to go

NatMoz · 02/03/2023 14:37

New joiners at my place are the same, 25 days but 3 at Christmas and 26 flexi days a year on top.

kljk78 · 02/03/2023 14:35

@Vanillaradio depends on the organisation, I was new and I got the additional privilege days, it was a quirk of our ALB.

Vanillaradio · 02/03/2023 14:31

It's not negotiable no.
New starters will not get Maunday Thursday or Christmas privilege day.
As for the King's birthday- check if this is still a thing. We've been told that the King will have to decide if we continue to get this and management are not sure if we get it this year.
As for flexi time this is in theory great. However you may find you are in a position where you are refused flexi leave by management due to "pressure of work" so built up a lot of hours and cannot take the leave

ScentOfAMemory · 02/03/2023 14:27

It would be very unusual in your role for it not to be flexi which means potentially another 18-24 days a year. I'm no longer a CS but when I was, apart from the 25 which is standard across the service afaik, plus the perks like the royal extra days and bank holidays, I also made 24 Flexi days a year.

kljk78 · 02/03/2023 14:21

@RainbowBrightside now you mention it there is a way of being able to use other public sector roles as part of your "continuous service" accrual, I vaguely remember when moving it coming up but as my public sector job previously had been spun out into a charity it wasn't applicable.

RainbowBrightside · 02/03/2023 14:19

BobSacamono · 01/03/2023 19:00

I think there is no harm in asking, I assume the entitlement would be set on onboarding.

I’m kicking myself for not asking to be put to the top of my NHS grade when I got a new job a couple of years ago, as the level up resulted in a pay cut in real terms.

They wouldn’t have done that anyway on an Agenda for Change contract. A new starter starts on the lowest banding of their salary.

RainbowBrightside · 02/03/2023 14:17

My husband moved to the CS from the NHS and was allowed to negotiate. E.g. in the CS, you get an extra day a year up to 30. He’d been in the NHS for a year so they allowed him to have 26 days to reflect that he’d been in the NHS for a year. It was still a reduction from 27 days but it was a much preferable job in the CS so compromises had to be made 🤷‍♀️

TrickorTreacle · 02/03/2023 13:19

I was only there for a year and I had all of the days that I mentioned + 25 days AL. It was 8 years ago though, so probably just before the days got removed. I stand corrected :-)

Brazilianadventure · 02/03/2023 12:56

@kljk78 😂 that’s why I was surprised by @TrickorTreacle response

kljk78 · 02/03/2023 12:14

@Brazilianadventure an ALB I was in a couple of years ago still had the Christmas privilege days, it was a bit under the the radar though, we always knew we weren't supposed to mention to anyone in our parent department ha.

Brazilianadventure · 02/03/2023 11:49

@TrickorTreacle it is very unusual for depts to still have 27th Dec, Maundy Thursday pm as separate privilege days for new starters. Most departments absorbed them into annual leave for existing staff and removed them for new starters around 2015/16. The Kings Birthday is still separate.

TrickorTreacle · 02/03/2023 11:31

You'll get 10.5 bank holidays. That's the normal 8, plus 27th Dec, the King's birthday and Mournday Thursday. That plus 5 weeks leave is quite generous.

The standard working week is only 37 hours.

You can build up to 15 hours flex, so up to 2 days of flex.

YABU OP.

Bells3032 · 02/03/2023 09:34

it's non negotiable - the T&Cs are pretty much the same for everyone and there isn't any wiggle room. However, you can build up flexi so can easily add another 5 days or more to your leave!

tommika · 02/03/2023 09:24

Just an update having confirmed the policy on 25 to 30 days in 5 years
(Based on MoD civil service policy)

It is starting with 25 days leave, plus bank holidays, plus 1 privilege day for the sovereigns official birthday

Rising 1 extra day of annual leave per year to a total of 30 at the 5 year point

The annual leave year is from 1st May to 30th April.
There is a leave calculator to enable new starters and leavers to calculate the appropriate portion of leave for a part year
(Note that for a part year you get the bank holidays and privilege day if they fall into the period)

If a proportioned period resulted in a part day of leave then it is rounded up

The sovereigns privilege day is to be taken on either the Friday or Tuesday on either side of the spring bank holiday
(so if a person starts in June then they don’t get that years privilege day)

The extra day per year might get added on your anniversary rather than on the 1st of May, but as long as you work the full year it’s an extra day in your second year - this will be a technicality in the calculation if you leave before the 5 years have brought you up to 30 days

As the OP has 30 days + BHs and are facing 25 + 1PD + BHs it will take 4 years to get the same total, and a 5th year to have one extra on top
(There is of course less choice as to when to take the PD)

Iwasntgettingasandwich · 01/03/2023 21:25

Not in the civil service. But as PPs have said there may be flexitime and the option to buy holiday. And it will be 25 days plus bank holidays.

Blowyourowntrumpet · 01/03/2023 21:24

It's definitely not negotiable. My department allows up to 2 Flexi days per month and you can buy up to 5 days additional annual leave.

Swipe left for the next trending thread