Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked if this is true . State pension and benefits …?

539 replies

Springtimesoo · 01/03/2023 15:22

I have worked all my life apart from
4 year degree( 3 year plus prof qualification )
and
a period at home when I had 2 dc under two and we could not afford nursery fees.

have just checked my pension forcast Which says that although I have paid 35 years in full , i will not get a full pension .

it seems that to get a full pension i need to pay just over 3k .

my friend , who is by choice long term unemployed. ( long story) says that she will get a full pension as she is on benefits .

how is that fair ? Its not true is it ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
BrigitteBond · 01/03/2023 21:55

Schnooze · 01/03/2023 21:48

Just posted this on the other NI thread. Bugger.nobly realised this today after reading this thread.

Bloody hell between me and dh we will be £300 per month worse off when we retire than we thought.

We’ve both got 35 years and it says we get the £185 each and it can’t be improved. We thought we’d get this as well as our private pensions, but I’ve just learnt today that because we both opted out, £300 per month of that won’t be paid to us via the state pension but is supposed to be made up from the private pensions. We just assumed our private pension was additional income! Bugger!

Does anyone know for definite that any additional years we earn on top of the 35 years won’t make a difference to this? Say we do another 5 years will that affect the £300? I assume not from what I’ve read.

I assume the other way. I think the figure on the gov.uk site is what you'll get as state pension and anything else is on top of that.

Schnooze · 01/03/2023 21:48

Just posted this on the other NI thread. Bugger.nobly realised this today after reading this thread.

Bloody hell between me and dh we will be £300 per month worse off when we retire than we thought.

We’ve both got 35 years and it says we get the £185 each and it can’t be improved. We thought we’d get this as well as our private pensions, but I’ve just learnt today that because we both opted out, £300 per month of that won’t be paid to us via the state pension but is supposed to be made up from the private pensions. We just assumed our private pension was additional income! Bugger!

Does anyone know for definite that any additional years we earn on top of the 35 years won’t make a difference to this? Say we do another 5 years will that affect the £300? I assume not from what I’ve read.

PoliticallylLost · 01/03/2023 21:46

lindyloo57 · 01/03/2023 19:10

@ilovesooty I'm just saying he's never worked but will get a full pension even though he's been claiming benefits all his working life. And he's not disabled or ill, just lazy.

So what’s the difference between him receiving benefits now and a state pension at SPA. Should he just get cut off when he’s 67?

Rightsraptor · 01/03/2023 21:46

I haven't read all the posts, so please forgive if this has been mentioned 10 000 times already, but Martin Lewis did a really good 1.5 hr show on pensions one or two weeks ago. On ITV Catchup.

PoliticallylLost · 01/03/2023 21:40

Mossstitch · 01/03/2023 18:10

I don't think it's so much not understanding but more that we weren't told, or it was not clearly communicated to us, which is much the same as the complaint of the waspi women (of which I am one). Now many might say it was our responsibility as adults to check it out but you would need some understanding to ask the questions. I consider myself to be reasonably intelligent, have a professional degree but when enrolled in the NHS pension scheme I definitely was not given any information about being contracted out of state pension. I only discovered that 13 years later when I decided to take my pension early🤷

You were not contracted out of the state pension. You were contracted out of an additional state pension at the time called SERPS.

PoliticallylLost · 01/03/2023 21:36

PoliticallylLost · 01/03/2023 21:33

SERPS was for people who did have another pension that they were a member of. People who were contracted in paid higher NI contributions to provide them with an additional pension over and above the normal state pension. You have not lost out or been diddled.

**correction
SERPS was for people who did NOT have another pension they were a member of ….

deliberately avoided using the phrase “paid into” as some public sector schemes would have been non contributory schemes back in the day.

PoliticallylLost · 01/03/2023 21:33

Schoolchoicesucks · 01/03/2023 18:01

In my case, you couldn't choose not to opt out without opting out of the whole pension scheme. So it was either opt out and get a work pension contribution, or pay full NI and lose the work contribution. There was no option to pay full NI contributions and join the workplace scheme.

SERPS was for people who did have another pension that they were a member of. People who were contracted in paid higher NI contributions to provide them with an additional pension over and above the normal state pension. You have not lost out or been diddled.

PoliticallylLost · 01/03/2023 21:24

bellac11 · 01/03/2023 17:11

I always thought that if you took your employers pension then it was your SERPs pension that got affected not your main state pension. This is why Im surprised by this.

Think of the old SERPS pension as the difference between the new full state pension and what most people will receive who were contracted out.

im on track to receive £185.15 per week as long as contribute one more year between now and when I reach state pension age. I have been in the public sector for over thirty years and contracted out for the majority of those years. I think the confusion is in the name. If they still referred to the additional state pension or higher level instead of ‘full’ I think some people wouldn’t be so confused

PoliticallylLost · 01/03/2023 21:17

bellac11 · 01/03/2023 17:05

I always understood the concept was that the state pension is for all, and everyone gets the same. But some people might want to pay extra into a private or work pension to top that up. Thats not unreasonable, they're still paying NI at this point but not benefiting from it. No one is arguing (I think) for less pension for others, but simply that they get their full pension. Thats only fair

And you still get the basic state pension. But those that didn’t have an occupational pension scheme paid higher NI to get an additional element of state pension. You have not lost out.

PoliticallylLost · 01/03/2023 21:15

catsrus · 01/03/2023 16:39

Same thing happened to me @Springtimesoo - I had 38yrs paying in and was sure I was due full pension - got a real shock when I checked my forecast - I was "missing" payments due to being contracted out "back in the day" (which we had no control over!). I paid a similar amount - around £3k - to top up. I worked out that so long as I lived another 3yrs I would get that back in the increased pension. Only 2 more yrs to go!

You did have control. You could have opted out of your occupational pension scheme and paid the higher NI contribution

The current state pension is a NEW pension. You don’t qualify for the higher rate because you were contracted out. I’m the past those people that were not contracted out received an additional amount over and above the basic state pension. That is what the full state pension currently is. You will still receive the ‘basic’ state pension

Language Watch Edit The State Earnings Related Pension Scheme (SERPS), originally known as the State Earnings Related Pension Supplement, was a UK Government pension arrangement, to which employees and employers contributed between 6 April 1978 and 5 April 2002, when it was replaced by the State Second Pension. Employees who paid full Class 1 National insurance contribution between 1978 and 2002 earned a SERPS pension. Members of occupational pension schemes could be "contracted out" of SERPS by their employer, in which case they and the employer would pay reduced NI contributions, and they would earn virtually no SERPS pension.

BrigitteBond · 01/03/2023 21:12

IneedanewTV · 01/03/2023 20:58

If state pension is £185 week how does your husband get £320 a week? Is the extra a private pension?

There used to be extra pension based on the earnings that your NI contributions had been based on. So a higher earner would pay more NI and receive a higher pension.

Once you've earned the right to that higher pension they don't (usually) take it away.

BrigitteBond · 01/03/2023 21:01

BorgQueen · 01/03/2023 20:54

35 years ONLY applies after 2016.
Everyone else is under transitional rules and it could take 40 or even 50 years worth of contributions, depending on being contracted out.

The 'transitional rules ' are that you get the higher of what you'd have got under the old systems and what you'd get under the new system. For most of us (including me, and I had 35 years by 2016) that means the new system.

Off the top of my head the only people who the 35 years isn't relevant for is people who had considerable amounts built up under SERPS who are going to receive more than the full state pension anyway.

BorgQueen · 01/03/2023 21:01

No the extra is under SERPS, which no longer exists.

KievsOutTheOven · 01/03/2023 21:00

XenoBitch · 01/03/2023 20:24

Where are the figures for this "large amount" of piss takers? Or is this purely anecdotal bollocks like "my neighbour's niece has never worked due to a bad back and gets £3k a month" benefit bashing crap that gets trotted out every time a thread like this pops up?

Around 40% of people that claim UC are actually in work. That is a real large amount that it not workshy. The rest... most would be looking for work, or not able to work.

I’m in work and claiming UC and I’m not going to work any more hours until my baby starts school, because it’s not beneficial for me to do so. The problem lies with the system.

IneedanewTV · 01/03/2023 20:58

MadameMatisse · 01/03/2023 19:25

@oldsu "dh STATE PENSION WILL BE JUST OVER £320 A WEEK FROM aPRIL" is misleading. It's all his pensions together.

If state pension is £185 week how does your husband get £320 a week? Is the extra a private pension?

tomissmymum · 01/03/2023 20:56

Moonicorn · 01/03/2023 15:23

I don’t know if it’s true but if it is it’s fucking shocking 🤷🏼‍♀️ If you’re on benefits you seem to get everything in life cheap or free. Yep, flame me.

My mum’s been on some sort of benefits since 1989 due to severe and enduring mental illness. She’s now got early onset dementia and is very slowly dying in a nursing home before she’s 60 . She’ll never see her pension. She never had a proper holiday . Could never afford food without worrying about it . Could never afford nice clothes . Could never keep the heating on . We never went on days out or weekends away .

But I’m glad you think that she’s had everything for cheap or free .

BorgQueen · 01/03/2023 20:54

35 years ONLY applies after 2016.
Everyone else is under transitional rules and it could take 40 or even 50 years worth of contributions, depending on being contracted out.

Ginmonkeyagain · 01/03/2023 20:51

The 35 years qualification is for people who have retired or will retire after 2016, not people who only started paying NI after 2016.

PoliticallylLost · 01/03/2023 20:50

icelolly12 · 01/03/2023 16:26

Do you really want to see pensioners begging, homeless or dying on the streets

No but I think that I should get a full state pension as I have worked, in addition to my employer pension. Instead I'll be no better off in retirement than someone on benefits, probably worse off as they'll get housing allowance council tax reduction and god knows what else plus a full state pension.

If you were contracted out why should you receive a higher state pension than those who paid the full NI contribution ?

BrigitteBond · 01/03/2023 20:48

BorgQueen · 01/03/2023 20:45

35 years only applies to those who started paying NI in 2016+ - it’s irrelevant for anyone else.
If you were a SAHM or earning under the LEL for a time then Child benefit would have given you NI credits.
You’ve either got time to make up the years or you can pay

I started paying NI in 1981 and the 35 years certainly applies to me and everyone I know of my age

PoliticallylLost · 01/03/2023 20:45

Scottishgirl85 · 01/03/2023 16:13

Can someone please explain what contracted out means. I have paid into a pension scheme in every job I've had, as I presume everyone does.

www.gov.uk/contracted-out
I’m no expert but my basic understanding is as follows:
the current state pension is a new system. When you were contracted out you were contracted out of SERPS (State Earnings Related Pension Scheme) as you were in an occupational pension scheme. You would have had a reduced level of NI deductions taken from your monthly salary

You would still be getting the ‘old age pension’. Now that he state pension has a higher and lower level. I think the lower level is still the equivalent of what we used to refer to as the ‘old age pension’. You haven’t lost out but you can pay in for make up for your reduced NI contributions.

BorgQueen · 01/03/2023 20:45

35 years only applies to those who started paying NI in 2016+ - it’s irrelevant for anyone else.
If you were a SAHM or earning under the LEL for a time then Child benefit would have given you NI credits.
You’ve either got time to make up the years or you can pay

Ginmonkeyagain · 01/03/2023 20:44

You couldn't contract out of the basic statr pesnion. There was something called SERPs that was an additional state pension related to earnings.

Many people with good occupational pensions could vontract out of that and either - pay lower NI or pay the NI that would have gone to SERPs to.their occupational pensions.

You haven't missed out - you either got the money when you were earning OR it is in your occupational pension.

DaSilvaP · 01/03/2023 20:43

MamaCanYouBuyMeABanana · 01/03/2023 15:32

Long term unemployed by choice and gets benefits?

It doesn't work like that.

It doesn't work like that?

Maybe not in theory, but in practice it does.

I've known of a number of people who are nowhere near being some kind of evil geniuses who keep gaming the system to no end.

And of others in genuine need who are ignored or being fobbed off.

Yes, the system is broken. Thanks to Labour as much as to Tories.

MaidOfSteel · 01/03/2023 20:40

If you've been contracted out of the state pension, I believe it means that you've been paying lower national insurance contributions because you've been paying into an occupational pension scheme.