Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked if this is true . State pension and benefits …?

539 replies

Springtimesoo · 01/03/2023 15:22

I have worked all my life apart from
4 year degree( 3 year plus prof qualification )
and
a period at home when I had 2 dc under two and we could not afford nursery fees.

have just checked my pension forcast Which says that although I have paid 35 years in full , i will not get a full pension .

it seems that to get a full pension i need to pay just over 3k .

my friend , who is by choice long term unemployed. ( long story) says that she will get a full pension as she is on benefits .

how is that fair ? Its not true is it ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Alexandra2001 · 02/03/2023 08:18

I'll hit my full state pension 20 years before retirement age. I'll get no benefit from the additional 20 years of NI contributions

Yes this is unfair isn't it? i think in some countries, you can claim the state pension once you ve done the correct contributions.

For me, i'm £154 short of NI payments, meaning i get just £1 a week less, i have until March 2024 to make good this shortfall.... only £1 but a no brainer & i ve retired, so it works out about right.

pissssedofff · 02/03/2023 08:15

Cadburysucks · 02/03/2023 01:49

The state pension is a benefit.

It most certainly is NOT, it is a right, an agreed contract in law & is contribution based.

Unlike say UC which is there regardless of any amount contributed.

No more a benefit than my private or final salary pensions are.

StatisticallyChallenged · 02/03/2023 08:10

Schnooze · 02/03/2023 00:34

So why does iclaudine think she has to pay 40 years?

My head is exploding. I so want to believe you are right.

Your starting amount would be lower if you were contracted out.

Think of it like this. The new state pension is a bucket that, under the new approach, takes 35 years to fill.
Those of us who had NI contributions before 2016 already had some water to pour in to that bucket. But we had different amounts. If you contracted out you have less water to pour in than someone who didn't.

So now, everyone has poured their water in and they've measured how much space is left in each bucket and worked out how long it will take to fill.

Someone who contracted out has more space to fill so will take longer, but they can still fill it.

If you hit the full state pension yeara before retirement age then you're going to better off as a result of contracting out, as you are actually seeing a benefits for your additional years of working.

I'll hit my full state pension 20 years before retirement age. I'll get no benefit from the additional 20 years of NI contributions.

StatisticallyChallenged · 02/03/2023 07:52

MRex · 02/03/2023 06:23

Mine seems to only want 30 years of contributions, not 35. Why would that be, does anyone know?

There's a few of us in this position on the thread - I think it's to do with the way the starting amount is calculated.

When they transferred over to the new state pension they calculated what entitlement you already had to basic state pension + additional state pension under the old rules. Then they calculated what your previous contributions would have earned you under the new system. Whichever was the higher value became your starting amount.

If your earned pension was higher under the old system then the gap you have to make up to reach the maximum is smaller, so takes fewer years of contributions to buy.

I think we're probably all people who didn't contract out, and for us 1 year under the scheme was worth more than 1 year under the new scheme.

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/03/2023 07:31

Generally if you have a occupational pension opting out of SERPs was not a bad thing.

When I was in the local government scheme we all had to attend a talk about it and our advisor said it was the best thing as the momey that would have gone to SERPs was instead re routed as additional contributions in to our defined benefit scheme.

Seymour5 · 02/03/2023 07:27

Just be glad you’re not on the old basic state pension like those who retired before 2016! DH get the full, old state pension of £141, after over 40 years of contributions. Because I have a very modest occupational pension, plus my state pittance of around £90 a week, we don’t qualify for pension credit. However, if he’d retired after 2016, we’d be £45+ better off each week, non means tested.

How is that a fair system?

TheTeenageYears · 02/03/2023 06:32

You will get the benefit of that money in your private pension unlike others who didn't opt out of SERPS and that money has disappeared into the big pot. The only benefit to someone who didn't opt out of SERPS is that they may not need to pay the full 35 years of contributions to get a full state pension however if they are working above the NI threshold they have no choice but to continue paying into the system beyond how ever many years are required for their full pension. There are people who could pay for the best part of 50 years for no extra benefit despite being told at the time they would have a state earnings related pension scheme based on what they paid in. If you opted out think yourself lucky, you have that money elsewhere and still have the option to top up a shortfall of 3k to end up with over £200 pw from next month.

MRex · 02/03/2023 06:23

Mine seems to only want 30 years of contributions, not 35. Why would that be, does anyone know?

Murdoch1949 · 02/03/2023 02:40

Although it is unfair, calculate the difference paying the three grand will make to your monthly pension. It will probably really be worth it.

sashh · 02/03/2023 02:35

PoliticallylLost · 02/03/2023 00:09

You will get the full £185 and the private pension. Where does it say that you won’t?

I actually asked my MP this, they didn't answer.

I receive an occupational pension from the NHS.

I also receive contribution based ESA, so my ESA has money taken from it because I have a pension.

So I have paid into two systems but only receive 1/2 from one of them. I'm sure the state pension will go the same way.

Cadburysucks · 02/03/2023 01:49

The state pension is a benefit.

PoliticallylLost · 02/03/2023 01:02

Schnooze · 02/03/2023 00:34

So why does iclaudine think she has to pay 40 years?

My head is exploding. I so want to believe you are right.

I don’t know. Maybe she’s worked for 35 years but not every year qualified

but you said earlier
“We’ve both got 35 years and it says we get the £185 each and it can’t be improved.”

I assume you took this from the government gateway? Unless you have reason to believe they have recorded your NI history incorrectly you should accept what it says. If it says your state pension forecast is £185 then that is what you will get. The COPE figure is not a deduction from the £185

24KaratCucumber · 02/03/2023 00:48

Universal credit claimants move on to pension credit claim. Which currently tops up your weekly income to about 180 for a single person.

Life of luxury.there.

Please feel free to fuck your job in and do what your friend is doing. Put your mouth where you ass is.

Schnooze · 02/03/2023 00:34

So why does iclaudine think she has to pay 40 years?

My head is exploding. I so want to believe you are right.

PoliticallylLost · 02/03/2023 00:27

£185 divided by 35 x number of qualifying years

PoliticallylLost · 02/03/2023 00:26

Schnooze · 02/03/2023 00:17

Dh won’t be paying enough years.

Anyway I’ve got to sleep now. Sleep tight everyone.

@Schnooze

The COPE estimate is not related to the number of qualifying years and isn’t an indication of a shortfall of qualifying years . If his records on the government gateway show he’s on target to receive £185 then that is what he will get. The state pension is calculated as (£185.15/35)* qualifying years

Schnooze · 02/03/2023 00:17

Dh won’t be paying enough years.

Anyway I’ve got to sleep now. Sleep tight everyone.

To be shocked if this is true . State pension and benefits …?
converseandjeans · 02/03/2023 00:11

@Springtimesoo

Agree with @Moonicorn

It doesn’t surprise me although all sorts of excuses will be made for her here.

According to Mumsnet everyone who gets benefits deserves them & there's always an excuse for why they shouldn't worry about working.

I think it's also the case that when someone who has never worked and so never owned a house needs to rent they still get housing benefit. To be fair it wouldn't be possible to survive on a state pension if you had rent to pay. But it's hard to take when you have struggled to pay a mortgage & put money aside for a pension.

PoliticallylLost · 02/03/2023 00:09

Schnooze · 02/03/2023 00:05

I know in reality I’m not being fiddled as the money will be coming via a different investment vehicle aka private pension. Just a realisation that our total retirement income will be less than expected as we expected the full £185 and the private pension. It’s our ignorance but however you dress it up our retirement income will be less due to dh”s age and not enough time to pay more years. Which I realised today.

Thanks again for your patience guys.

You will get the full £185 and the private pension. Where does it say that you won’t?

Schnooze · 02/03/2023 00:07

IClaudine · Yesterday 23:54
Then you get less than whatever the max amount is by the time you get your pension.

Dibbydoos · 02/03/2023 00:07

WilmaFlintstone1 · 01/03/2023 15:26

You will also likely die much younger.

I don't think that's true! People on benefits are typically offered worse housing in more socially deprived or run down areas with higher crime rates and poorer facilities inc health care. I thunk being in that env typically reduces life expectancy by 20 years.

But coming back to tge OP, I think what you've found out is correct. It's a farce it really is.

Triflenot · 02/03/2023 00:05

I think you are overthinking this Schmooze

Schnooze · 02/03/2023 00:05

I know in reality I’m not being fiddled as the money will be coming via a different investment vehicle aka private pension. Just a realisation that our total retirement income will be less than expected as we expected the full £185 and the private pension. It’s our ignorance but however you dress it up our retirement income will be less due to dh”s age and not enough time to pay more years. Which I realised today.

Thanks again for your patience guys.

PoliticallylLost · 02/03/2023 00:05

See the picture below “…this will not affect your state pension forecast…”

To be shocked if this is true . State pension and benefits …?
PoliticallylLost · 02/03/2023 00:02

Schnooze · 02/03/2023 00:00

Dh hasn’t got time to make up extra years to compensate for his £51 cope figure so will get less than the £185.

Hence why I’m suddenly realising we’ll be much worse off than we originally expected.

I only have a £19 cope figure so hopefully I’ll sort that out over the next few years and thus will get the full £185.

No he won’t. The COPE figure is not a deduction from the state pension