Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked if this is true . State pension and benefits …?

539 replies

Springtimesoo · 01/03/2023 15:22

I have worked all my life apart from
4 year degree( 3 year plus prof qualification )
and
a period at home when I had 2 dc under two and we could not afford nursery fees.

have just checked my pension forcast Which says that although I have paid 35 years in full , i will not get a full pension .

it seems that to get a full pension i need to pay just over 3k .

my friend , who is by choice long term unemployed. ( long story) says that she will get a full pension as she is on benefits .

how is that fair ? Its not true is it ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
NevieSticks · 02/03/2023 10:56

ClaraSita · 02/03/2023 08:55

I called up HMRC a few years ago to pay my missing years (due to uni and a gap year and the gentleman I spoke to advised me NOT to top up, but instead to set up a savings account with the missing payments. Said I’d be better off

I have never received any advice like that and I don't think it is in their remit to do so. I did receive help as to how many gaps i had and he told me how many i needed to pay back to get the full pension but not all of them. This was fact and not his opinion.

My FA and I worked out that in 3 years I would recoup the amount paid to them. I posted about this above. The triple lock protection ( while admittedly frozen last year) will benefit you greatly compared to money sitting in a savings account. My pension will raise by 10.1% in April.

KikkisCat · 02/03/2023 10:42

I am one of the people who will have to pay more than 35 years NI contributions due to being contracted out. No complaints as I understand that I will have benefitted through my occupational pension pot instead. Person I spoke to at the Furlture Pensions Centre was really helpful advising exactly how many years I could make up and how much I would benefit - I will break even in less than 4 years once claiming my state pension. He also let me know that the cost for each year - currently £824.20 for me - will be going up around 10% after 5th April 2023 due to inflation, so if anyone is planning to make up gaps and has the funds available, then it is advantageous to do it before 5th April.

IClaudine · 02/03/2023 09:46

Sceptic1234 · 02/03/2023 09:24

I'm afraid this article just adds to confusion. People were contracted out of SERPS / second state pension.

Yes and that is why they may need to pay more than 35 years contributions to get the full amount of the new state pension!

pissssedofff · 02/03/2023 09:41

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/03/2023 08:59

National Insurance isn't insurance. It is a tax. No more, no less.

Wjat you are entitled to are benfits not pay outs or a "pot"

The name is just a sleight of hand by government to get public buy in to paying it.

Fundamentally disagree.

To get a pension pot that would give you a guaranteed (at present rate) £10k per year pension would require a 300k pension pot at least, currently the SP as a triple lock increase too, the downside is it dies with you but otherwise is there for as long as you live and is not means tested.

Someone on MW would never accrue that sort of pension by any other means.

State benefits just don't do this, incredible value for money.

Given our aging population, no Govt is going to get rid of it or stop increasing the SP.

Its insurance because on set age, we get the pension, yes that age has changed but we vote for that, we know the Tories will increase it to 68, so can vote accordingly if we wish.

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/03/2023 09:39

@Sceptic1234 yes because there a contributions based and income based benefits. The former depends on you having made NI contributions for a certain amount of time but that does not mean the amount of NI you paid has anything to do with what you get - it is jsut the fact you paid it.

When I was made redundant a few years ago I was eligible for contributions based JSA for 6 months on account of my NI contributions. It was the same amuont as income based JSA, but it just meant for 6 months my savings and partners income were disregarded and I didn't really get a lot of pressure from the job centre to look for work. I did look for work obviously.

Sceptic1234 · 02/03/2023 09:24

IClaudine · 02/03/2023 09:21

This explains why some people will need to make more than 35 years worth of contributions to get the maximum pension:

rtsfinancialplanning.co.uk/why-you-might-not-get-a-full-state-pension-even-with-35-years-national-insurance-contributions/

I'm afraid this article just adds to confusion. People were contracted out of SERPS / second state pension.

IClaudine · 02/03/2023 09:21

This explains why some people will need to make more than 35 years worth of contributions to get the maximum pension:

rtsfinancialplanning.co.uk/why-you-might-not-get-a-full-state-pension-even-with-35-years-national-insurance-contributions/

Sceptic1234 · 02/03/2023 09:13

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/03/2023 08:59

National Insurance isn't insurance. It is a tax. No more, no less.

Wjat you are entitled to are benfits not pay outs or a "pot"

The name is just a sleight of hand by government to get public buy in to paying it.

Yes it is a tax, but some of the benefits are only payable if a certain situation arises, so it is a tax that fulfils an insurance function.

A member of my family became suddenly and severely disabled in their late 50s. This allowed them to access benefits that the would not normally have had access to.

In fact that these benefits were means tested, and that they repeatedly had to undergo "fitness to work tests", and then appeal against these decisions. They were also subject to arbitrary sanctions for minor form filling errors, being unable to attend meetings on time etc. These took hours on the phone to sort out. However, this is all aother story........

IClaudine · 02/03/2023 09:11

Schnooze · 02/03/2023 00:34

So why does iclaudine think she has to pay 40 years?

My head is exploding. I so want to believe you are right.

@Schnooze and @PoliticallylLost

Both - I don't think this, I know it. And it's actually 42 years!

I checked this morning to be sure. To date I have paid 40 years of full NI contributions.

To get the maximum state pension I still need to make two more years of contributions before April of the year in which I reach State Pension age. I have quite a few years to go, so plenty of time to do this!

So in all I will have paid 42 years of contributions to get the maximum new State Pension, not 35. This will be because I was contracted out of the additional state pension.

Many (maybe most, but probably depends on how old you are?) people who were contracted out of the additional state pension will need to pay more than 35 years of full contributions to get the new full state pension.

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/03/2023 08:59

National Insurance isn't insurance. It is a tax. No more, no less.

Wjat you are entitled to are benfits not pay outs or a "pot"

The name is just a sleight of hand by government to get public buy in to paying it.

StatisticallyChallenged · 02/03/2023 08:55

Sceptic1234 · 02/03/2023 08:49

National insurance is that... insurance. It is not just a pension contribution. If you become critically ill or had a serious accident, then you will be able to receive benefits,

So you are getting something for your continued contribution. Benefits may not be generous, but look into how much you'd have to pay an insurance company for critical illness cover and it starts to look like good value.

I was meaning it purely in terms of pensions and as a contrast to those who contracted out and are saying it is unfair and they've lost out. If I'd contracted out prior to 2016 then I'd still hit full state pension yeara before retirement, and have additional private pension benefits resulting from the same contributions.

So from that perspective those who contracted out might be better off

ClaraSita · 02/03/2023 08:55

I called up HMRC a few years ago to pay my missing years (due to uni and a gap year and the gentleman I spoke to advised me NOT to top up, but instead to set up a savings account with the missing payments. Said I’d be better off

pissssedofff · 02/03/2023 08:54

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/03/2023 08:45

@Sceptic1234 although the the SERPs gap should be covered by the new compulsary NEST scheme.

Ha some NEST pensions have performed extremely badly & people don't have a clue how much you need in a pension pot to give a £5k or £6k yearly private pension & if you re in a low paid/nmw job, it will take forever to get this amount plus, as they are stock market based, are not guaranteed.

They also are not compulsory, anyone can opt out, once in it.

Seymour5 · 02/03/2023 08:51

@Ginmonkeyagain As well as the increasing numbers of retirees, we don’t die off as early! The pension bill must be enormous and growing. Another change that will also impact is the higher reliance on benefits than with previous feneratiins, and the rise in single person households. Two modest pension incomes make for a reasonable life, but I’m dreading trying to manage on one if DH goes first. He’d be even worse off if he was left, as his private pension never amounted to much due to illness curtailing his ability to build it up.

Sceptic1234 · 02/03/2023 08:51

No....its just spent like a tax. This is the big difference between us and Northern Europe....they keep national insurance equivalent as a separate fund. This is one reason why their schemes are so much more generous.

Ceryneianhind · 02/03/2023 08:49

BrigitteBond · 01/03/2023 16:11

That's because you earn over the NI lower limit, but less than the limit where it's actually paid. You get an NI credit for the year despite not contributing.

Unlike paying salaries, the business must be making a profit (after tax) in order to pay dividends. Because there is no national insurance on investment income it's usually a more tax efficient way to extract money from your business, rather than taking a salary.

So you 'earn' with dividends, but you don't pay into the ni system? (As you're paid under the threshold) How is this more deserving of a pension than someone on benefits?

pissssedofff · 02/03/2023 08:49

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/03/2023 08:38

@pissssedofff umm the state pension absolutely is a benefit, indeed it is the biggest share of the overall benefits bill.

If it is a "contract in law" where is the contract you signed? Where is your agreement?

The state pension can and is changed at will by government, when I started working at 16 my age of qualification was 60, it's now 68. No contract change or consultation with me needed. Just a change in how I qualify for a state benefit.

How? it is not universal and yes there is a contract, the law of the land (contracts don't always need to be signed)
If we vote in parties that then change the law (voting them in again and again...) who exactly is that on?

Yes pensions are lumped in with "benefits" but that just suits the Govt narrative, don't assist them.

Sceptic1234 · 02/03/2023 08:49

Fredoraly · 02/03/2023 08:29

I'll hit my full state pension 20 years before retirement age. I'll get no benefit from the additional 20 years of NI contributions

I'm the same. It's really annoying!

National insurance is that... insurance. It is not just a pension contribution. If you become critically ill or had a serious accident, then you will be able to receive benefits,

So you are getting something for your continued contribution. Benefits may not be generous, but look into how much you'd have to pay an insurance company for critical illness cover and it starts to look like good value.

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/03/2023 08:45

@Sceptic1234 although the the SERPs gap should be covered by the new compulsary NEST scheme.

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/03/2023 08:43

@Fredoraly the NI you pay does not go into a separate pot for your pension, it is all just tax. All the NI you have paid will have been long spent by the time you retire.

And thar is why we have an issue. The generation retiring now are much much larger than the generations below, especially Gens X and Y (eg those born beyween 1965 and 1995), and Gens X and Y need to pay the state pensions of those retiring now. It's known as the dependency ratio and it is beginning to get a little hairy.

Sceptic1234 · 02/03/2023 08:39

Schnooze · 01/03/2023 22:56

I was 21 at the time, newly graduated and pensions really weren’t on my radar. I just did what was recommended. I should imagine that a lot of people have been caught out purely by not realising, rather than through a lack of intelligence. It’s really not obvious when you check the forecast which i did several years ago.

I think this is the whole problem .... young people are not interested in pensions, but have to make decisions about them.

I was in same situation..... contracted out of SERPS but had occupational pension based on final salary.

The important thing is that nobody contracted out of the basic state pension. People contracted out of SERPS because they had a final salary, occupational pension which was guaranteed to pay them more. This was then replaced with the second state pension. You could still contract out of this.

Finally, in 2016, the "second state pensions" were abolished. The amount you get in the state pension depends on how many years service you had in the various old schemes.

In 1988 (google) people were allowed to contract out of the second pension and pay into a private pension, which did not guarantee an income. This was to encourage people to shift away from state pensions to the private sector. At the time the sector was very poorly regulated, and huge commissions fees were paid. Some of these people were clearly misold crap products on the basis of very poor advice. These are the only people who incurred a financial loss by contracting out. There have been court cases/ settlements over this. I think the decision to allow people to opt out in this way was one of the worst things thatcher ever did.

IMO abolishing SERPS was the real source of current pension issues. If you worked 44 years (men) then you would get the "old age pension", as it was known, and 25% of the difference between the pension and your final salary (there was an upper limit). This meant that ordinary people could actually afford to retire without involving private companies. However, you could only get SERPS if you worked. People on benefits, women at home on child benefit etc. got credits towards the basic pension but nothing else.

There is now only one pension, which is more generous as the "old age pension" .... the government highlights this bit. However, it's a lot less generous than pension plus SERPS, which they say less about!

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/03/2023 08:38

@pissssedofff umm the state pension absolutely is a benefit, indeed it is the biggest share of the overall benefits bill.

If it is a "contract in law" where is the contract you signed? Where is your agreement?

The state pension can and is changed at will by government, when I started working at 16 my age of qualification was 60, it's now 68. No contract change or consultation with me needed. Just a change in how I qualify for a state benefit.

Aphrathestorm · 02/03/2023 08:35

For SAHMs watch there was a catch when the law was changed around 2010/11 where you only get NI credits until your youngest is 12 rather than 16 as it had been previously.

Also you only get it for full tax years you claim child benefit so if your dc was born in May you won't get it until the next April and when they turn 12/16 you won't get it for the April until their birthday.

The 'complete year' thing is crazy.

For people who don't get the full state pension they will get pension credit instead, unless they have a high income partner/lots of savings (it's just an older people's UC).

Also there's an 80+ pension everyone gets.

There won't be homeless older people because of this!

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 02/03/2023 08:30

It seems sensible to credit those in receipt of benefits with NI/pension contributions. People have to have money to live on in old age. Surely it makes more sense to do it that way rather than a series of pension top up/subsistence payments?

Fredoraly · 02/03/2023 08:29

I'll hit my full state pension 20 years before retirement age. I'll get no benefit from the additional 20 years of NI contributions

I'm the same. It's really annoying!