Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked if this is true . State pension and benefits …?

539 replies

Springtimesoo · 01/03/2023 15:22

I have worked all my life apart from
4 year degree( 3 year plus prof qualification )
and
a period at home when I had 2 dc under two and we could not afford nursery fees.

have just checked my pension forcast Which says that although I have paid 35 years in full , i will not get a full pension .

it seems that to get a full pension i need to pay just over 3k .

my friend , who is by choice long term unemployed. ( long story) says that she will get a full pension as she is on benefits .

how is that fair ? Its not true is it ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
SueVineer · 02/03/2023 15:17

fitzwilliamdarcy · 02/03/2023 15:08

There is no such thing as a contractual right to a state pension based on “the law of the land”.

If the UK government wanted to abolish the SP it could do it tomorrow. You haven’t a “contract” with them, you couldn’t sue them, and you certainly couldn’t use as an argument that some sort of nebulous “law of the land” required the government to provide it to you anyway. It’s nonsense.

Exactly- it’s a contribution based benefit. It can be abolished at any time

SueVineer · 02/03/2023 15:16

It’s not really scandalous no because you’re only in this situation because you chose to contract out and pay less NI. You should also have a private pension if that’s the case

Isleoftights · 02/03/2023 15:12

Because of the news we all need to check our pension forecast as we can only fill in the gaps by April 2023.

That isn't true. Normally you can fill in gaps going back 6 years. At the moment that's been extended beyond 6 years, but will revert to 6 years again from April 2023.

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/03/2023 15:11

Indeed. Exactly that.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 02/03/2023 15:08

pissssedofff · 02/03/2023 13:06

Care to explain why?

There is no such thing as a contractual right to a state pension based on “the law of the land”.

If the UK government wanted to abolish the SP it could do it tomorrow. You haven’t a “contract” with them, you couldn’t sue them, and you certainly couldn’t use as an argument that some sort of nebulous “law of the land” required the government to provide it to you anyway. It’s nonsense.

Branster · 02/03/2023 15:02

So confusing.
May I please ask, if Government Gateway shows you quality for full state pension, do we believe it?
Because of the news we all need to check our pension forecast as we can only fill in the gaps by April 2023, I was talking to my sister about this today.
She took early retirement (because she could, redundancy so it works for her), had 3 years of contracted out situation but otherwise her profile shows 41 full years of contributions.
Not working anymore so she doesn't need to pay NI (only voluntarily if she wants to as far as we understand). Is this correct? We can't ascertain for sure.
The forecast shows she will get the full state pension when she reaches pension age. There is no indication that additional contributions are required for this.
How do we know that is correct?

My own profile shows I'll get full state pension if I contribute fir x number of future years. So that was clear and simple.

But reading this thread just made us question her own situation.

Sharkpenis · 02/03/2023 14:26

@Moonicorn whos drip feed?

Everanewbie · 02/03/2023 14:09

Sceptic1234 · 02/03/2023 14:06

A full year of class C NI contributions is about £800 and is guaranteed to give you about £5 per week, index linked for the rest of your life. That is about £250 per year...... a return of about 31%.

You would need to invest at least £8,000 to get anywhere near that return, and that would come with no adjustment for inflation. To get a guaranteed, index linked return would cost a lot, lot more.

Investing £3000 will give you nothing like the return you would get by filling in gaps on your NI record.

Excellent. Did this for a client a few years ago, couldn't remember the figures.

Sceptic1234 · 02/03/2023 14:06

Everanewbie · 02/03/2023 12:26

OP, do your sums here. Remember that state pension increases with inflation. You might be happy to hold back that money now, but if you live 15 years or more you will be way out of pocket.

A full year of class C NI contributions is about £800 and is guaranteed to give you about £5 per week, index linked for the rest of your life. That is about £250 per year...... a return of about 31%.

You would need to invest at least £8,000 to get anywhere near that return, and that would come with no adjustment for inflation. To get a guaranteed, index linked return would cost a lot, lot more.

Investing £3000 will give you nothing like the return you would get by filling in gaps on your NI record.

Moonicorn · 02/03/2023 14:02

Sharkpenis · 02/03/2023 14:01

Wow. Im on benefits. Feeling pretty shitty now

Then I await the drip feed with anticipation.

Sharkpenis · 02/03/2023 14:01

Wow. Im on benefits. Feeling pretty shitty now

Everanewbie · 02/03/2023 13:56

ClaraSita · 02/03/2023 08:55

I called up HMRC a few years ago to pay my missing years (due to uni and a gap year and the gentleman I spoke to advised me NOT to top up, but instead to set up a savings account with the missing payments. Said I’d be better off

They should not have told you that. For a start it is financial advice, which cannot be provided because they are not authorised to advise. Secondly it may be wrong, depending on how long you live, inflation, interest rates/investment returns and how much you depend on income v. capital.

pissssedofff · 02/03/2023 13:46

@Ginmonkeyagain We aren't going to agree on this and perhaps there should be more of a contributions based element for higher rate tax payers, then again, they do get 40% tax relief on pension contributions.

Yes i know the NI isn't ring fenced, something people don't always realise.

For me a state benefit is something free, a safety net if you like, the state pension is something we have "paid into" to qualify (for want of a better phrase)

Seymour5 · 02/03/2023 13:38

viques · 02/03/2023 10:56

Why is your state pension only £90? Were there NI credits you failed to claim? If you were working which I assume you were to earn a private pension this seems low. And how much is your modest occupational pension? If it is less than £47 PW you would still qualify for pension credit.

No NI credits for being a SAHM when my children were small. Low paid temp work when I paid reduced rate (Married womens) NI contributions for some years. That option ceased a long time ago. My occ pension is thankfully a little more than £47 a week!

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/03/2023 13:23

@pissssedofff NI is a tax - it pays for all sorts of things. State pensions aren't paid out of some kind of special NI pot you contriute to, it is just another tab on the big book of stuff government uses out taxes to pay for.

Yes you are right the state pension is a good deal for very low earners in terms of what they put in, but that doesn't mean it is not a benefit. If it behaved like an acutal pension higher rate tax payers would get a hell of a lot more than £185 a week!

pissssedofff · 02/03/2023 13:21

24KaratCucumber · 02/03/2023 13:13

Bullshit.

The number of long term unemployed people in the UK is a tiny tiny percentage and amounts to around 270k people.

The myth of all those many millions of long term.i employed is a media driven propaganda to push the narrative.of benefit claimants being Scroungers and cause division between the haves and have nots.

And unlike the people.amkong wild claims, there's plenty of sources with actual figures. www.statista.com/statistics/284187/uk-unemployment-figures-by-length/#:~:text=Number%20of%20people%20unemployed%20in,2022%2C%20by%20length%20of%20unemployment&text=As%20of%20December%202022%2C%20there,for%20more%20than%20a%20year.

Yes vast majority of the 1.2m people unemployed are just churn, they are not the same people.

There are approx 2.5m on long term sick and economically in active, there are 7m people on waiting lists for medical treatment.

Its a very high bar to claim sickness benefit and be expected to not work at all.

On "common sense" whose Common Sense? everybody's definition of CS is very different.

Aphrathestorm · 02/03/2023 13:14

Silversalt The 21 years is based on a lower retirement age. Retirement age is now 68, most women do not live until 89

This is what people don't understand about life expectancy. The figure of 82 for women and 79 for men is the life expectancy from birth.

Only people get to retirement age their life expectancy is much older.

See below life expectancy of 65 yo UK women is 21 extra years.

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/life-expectancy-at-older-ages-is-the-highest-its-ever-beenn*

24KaratCucumber · 02/03/2023 13:13

DumpedinKilburn · 02/03/2023 12:21

I think more people are gradually waking up to this and the oft used. 'benefit bashing' response is losing some of its gilt edged beyond reproach golden silencer effect.

And about bloody time. For every one who genuinely can't work, there is one taking the piss.

The usual response to this is some prissy, 'How do you know? Please quote your source'

Well, I know because I have the evidence of my own eyes.

The response to this is usually, 'many disabilities are often hidden and you just don't know individual circumstances.

Well, I have my own common sense to back up the judgement of my eyes and luckily, it seems that more people are also discovering that they have the same.

Bullshit.

The number of long term unemployed people in the UK is a tiny tiny percentage and amounts to around 270k people.

The myth of all those many millions of long term.i employed is a media driven propaganda to push the narrative.of benefit claimants being Scroungers and cause division between the haves and have nots.

And unlike the people.amkong wild claims, there's plenty of sources with actual figures. www.statista.com/statistics/284187/uk-unemployment-figures-by-length/#:~:text=Number%20of%20people%20unemployed%20in,2022%2C%20by%20length%20of%20unemployment&text=As%20of%20December%202022%2C%20there,for%20more%20than%20a%20year.

To be shocked if this is true . State pension and benefits …?
pissssedofff · 02/03/2023 13:06

fitzwilliamdarcy · 02/03/2023 12:13

yes there is a contract, the law of the land (contracts don't always need to be signed)

This is absolute nonsense.

Care to explain why?

Mossstitch · 02/03/2023 12:26

NevieSticks · 02/03/2023 10:56

I have never received any advice like that and I don't think it is in their remit to do so. I did receive help as to how many gaps i had and he told me how many i needed to pay back to get the full pension but not all of them. This was fact and not his opinion.

My FA and I worked out that in 3 years I would recoup the amount paid to them. I posted about this above. The triple lock protection ( while admittedly frozen last year) will benefit you greatly compared to money sitting in a savings account. My pension will raise by 10.1% in April.

Could it have been because clarasita was so young that she would end up paying more than the necessary years by the time she retired anyway. Eg I had missing early years in my teens but now I'm in my 60s I have 44 qualifying years and entitled to full state pension (even with 13 years contracted out) so it would have been a waste of my money to pay those missing years previously🤷

Everanewbie · 02/03/2023 12:26

Springtimesoo · 01/03/2023 16:18

It seems unfair have to pay over 3k within 6!weeks . Great idea re poss invest it instead . Thanks . Hope you all get sorted .

OP, do your sums here. Remember that state pension increases with inflation. You might be happy to hold back that money now, but if you live 15 years or more you will be way out of pocket.

DumpedinKilburn · 02/03/2023 12:21

Situaciones · 01/03/2023 15:53

It doesn't make sense that one person can sit on their arse for 35 years and the person working has to pay to make up years if they've missed them. It's not fair at all.

I think more people are gradually waking up to this and the oft used. 'benefit bashing' response is losing some of its gilt edged beyond reproach golden silencer effect.

And about bloody time. For every one who genuinely can't work, there is one taking the piss.

The usual response to this is some prissy, 'How do you know? Please quote your source'

Well, I know because I have the evidence of my own eyes.

The response to this is usually, 'many disabilities are often hidden and you just don't know individual circumstances.

Well, I have my own common sense to back up the judgement of my eyes and luckily, it seems that more people are also discovering that they have the same.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 02/03/2023 12:13

pissssedofff · 02/03/2023 08:49

How? it is not universal and yes there is a contract, the law of the land (contracts don't always need to be signed)
If we vote in parties that then change the law (voting them in again and again...) who exactly is that on?

Yes pensions are lumped in with "benefits" but that just suits the Govt narrative, don't assist them.

yes there is a contract, the law of the land (contracts don't always need to be signed)

This is absolute nonsense.

PoliticallylLost · 02/03/2023 11:18

IClaudine · 02/03/2023 09:11

@Schnooze and @PoliticallylLost

Both - I don't think this, I know it. And it's actually 42 years!

I checked this morning to be sure. To date I have paid 40 years of full NI contributions.

To get the maximum state pension I still need to make two more years of contributions before April of the year in which I reach State Pension age. I have quite a few years to go, so plenty of time to do this!

So in all I will have paid 42 years of contributions to get the maximum new State Pension, not 35. This will be because I was contracted out of the additional state pension.

Many (maybe most, but probably depends on how old you are?) people who were contracted out of the additional state pension will need to pay more than 35 years of full contributions to get the new full state pension.

I’ve managed to get back into the gateway this morning. I have 38 years of full payments and 1 year of incomplete (not sure why as I had full years before and after whilst I was still in education). I need one more year to get full state pension but will probably be contributing for a further 12 years. I’ve only been in uninterrupted full time employment (so actually paying NI contributions from my salary) for 34 years.

but if the state pension forecast indicates that @Schnooze is on track to receive £185 she should believe it

viques · 02/03/2023 10:56

Seymour5 · 02/03/2023 07:27

Just be glad you’re not on the old basic state pension like those who retired before 2016! DH get the full, old state pension of £141, after over 40 years of contributions. Because I have a very modest occupational pension, plus my state pittance of around £90 a week, we don’t qualify for pension credit. However, if he’d retired after 2016, we’d be £45+ better off each week, non means tested.

How is that a fair system?

Why is your state pension only £90? Were there NI credits you failed to claim? If you were working which I assume you were to earn a private pension this seems low. And how much is your modest occupational pension? If it is less than £47 PW you would still qualify for pension credit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread