Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked if this is true . State pension and benefits …?

539 replies

Springtimesoo · 01/03/2023 15:22

I have worked all my life apart from
4 year degree( 3 year plus prof qualification )
and
a period at home when I had 2 dc under two and we could not afford nursery fees.

have just checked my pension forcast Which says that although I have paid 35 years in full , i will not get a full pension .

it seems that to get a full pension i need to pay just over 3k .

my friend , who is by choice long term unemployed. ( long story) says that she will get a full pension as she is on benefits .

how is that fair ? Its not true is it ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
PoliticallylLost · 04/03/2023 00:41

Sceptic1234 · 03/03/2023 07:19

Yes they did. I paid less Ni because I was contracted out. Someone who was not contracted out would have paid more NI. That means more money was taken off their pay every month.

When the rule changed in 2016 and contracted out status was abolished, my NI contributions increased. From that point on everyone paid the same.

Yep, I absolutely paid less NI. My pay statements clearly stated ‘contracted out NI’.
and then it became ‘NI D’ which indicated contracted out and in Apr 16 it changed to ‘NI A’ and my deduction increased by about £22 per month.
And I can in my NI history of hover gateway the jump when the contracted out rate changed

sashh · 03/03/2023 10:27

pissssedofff · 02/03/2023 13:46

@Ginmonkeyagain We aren't going to agree on this and perhaps there should be more of a contributions based element for higher rate tax payers, then again, they do get 40% tax relief on pension contributions.

Yes i know the NI isn't ring fenced, something people don't always realise.

For me a state benefit is something free, a safety net if you like, the state pension is something we have "paid into" to qualify (for want of a better phrase)

But a lot of benefits are only available to people who have 'paid in' and as I said earlier I paid into NI and I paid into a pension so I should get both, but I don't.

Seymour5 · 03/03/2023 07:24

AmandaJonah · 02/03/2023 17:22

Yep. My DH is unemployed and not counted as he is not entitled to benefits because of my earnings.

Doesn’t he sign on to get his NI credit? DH did that once he was well enough to start looking for work, even though he wasn’t entitled to means tested benefits because I worked.

Sceptic1234 · 03/03/2023 07:19

TheTeenageYears · 03/03/2023 00:55

@Sceptic1234 The only thing I would note from your explanation is no one paid any more NI in either scenario, they paid the same NI but it went to two different places depending on if you were opted out of SERPS or not.

Yes they did. I paid less Ni because I was contracted out. Someone who was not contracted out would have paid more NI. That means more money was taken off their pay every month.

When the rule changed in 2016 and contracted out status was abolished, my NI contributions increased. From that point on everyone paid the same.

TheTeenageYears · 03/03/2023 00:55

@Sceptic1234 The only thing I would note from your explanation is no one paid any more NI in either scenario, they paid the same NI but it went to two different places depending on if you were opted out of SERPS or not.

BooseysMom · 02/03/2023 20:18

Sceptic1234 · 02/03/2023 18:23

The thing to understand is that, until 2016, there was not one state pension, but two.

The basic state pension £141 a week, and a second, earnings related state pension.

If you worked in a job that had an occupational.pension, you played less NI but only built up entitlement to the basic state pension. When you retired, you would get this, and your occupational pension. You were "contracted ouf" of the second pension, but not the basic pension.

If you worked in a job that had no occupational pension, you paid more NI, but effectively got two state pensions once you retired.

Since 2016 there is only 1 state pension - the new state pension, which is worth £185 a week. The concept of being "contracted out" disappeared so people with occupation pensions started paying more national insurance.

I have just started getting my state pension. It consists of two parts. Pre 2016 I was paying contributions towards the basic state pension....£141. Post 2016 I was paying increased NI towards the new state pension.

I recieved £175 a week, which is more than I would have got under the pre 2016 scheme but less than the new state pension. So even though I had 44 years of contributions, I get less than the full pension, because I paid less NI for most of my working life. However, I also get an occupational pension which more than makes up the difference.

That's useful info thanks 😊

Sceptic1234 · 02/03/2023 18:26

Under the pre 2016 scheme someone on benefits would only get credit towards the basic state pension.

Sceptic1234 · 02/03/2023 18:23

cadburyegg · 02/03/2023 17:58

I really don't get these posts.

Of course work pays. The majority of people in work will contribute to a private pension scheme which they will get on top of their state pension. For some people this amounts to thousands. People who have just been on long term benefits will just get their state pension and nothing else.

I'm confused as to how anyone who has worked all their life wouldn't be eligible for a full state pension, even if they did take a degree and a few years out to raise young kids. I have contributed 18 years already, I'm 35 and need to contribute another 18 years to be eligible, although I'll be working for at least another 30 years. You must have taken more years out than you realise

The thing to understand is that, until 2016, there was not one state pension, but two.

The basic state pension £141 a week, and a second, earnings related state pension.

If you worked in a job that had an occupational.pension, you played less NI but only built up entitlement to the basic state pension. When you retired, you would get this, and your occupational pension. You were "contracted ouf" of the second pension, but not the basic pension.

If you worked in a job that had no occupational pension, you paid more NI, but effectively got two state pensions once you retired.

Since 2016 there is only 1 state pension - the new state pension, which is worth £185 a week. The concept of being "contracted out" disappeared so people with occupation pensions started paying more national insurance.

I have just started getting my state pension. It consists of two parts. Pre 2016 I was paying contributions towards the basic state pension....£141. Post 2016 I was paying increased NI towards the new state pension.

I recieved £175 a week, which is more than I would have got under the pre 2016 scheme but less than the new state pension. So even though I had 44 years of contributions, I get less than the full pension, because I paid less NI for most of my working life. However, I also get an occupational pension which more than makes up the difference.

NevieSticks · 02/03/2023 18:09

Mossstitch · 02/03/2023 12:26

Could it have been because clarasita was so young that she would end up paying more than the necessary years by the time she retired anyway. Eg I had missing early years in my teens but now I'm in my 60s I have 44 qualifying years and entitled to full state pension (even with 13 years contracted out) so it would have been a waste of my money to pay those missing years previously🤷

That is what i said - that when I spoke to them on the phone they told me exactly how many years to payback to get full pension but not to pay anymore.

cadburyegg · 02/03/2023 17:58

I really don't get these posts.

Of course work pays. The majority of people in work will contribute to a private pension scheme which they will get on top of their state pension. For some people this amounts to thousands. People who have just been on long term benefits will just get their state pension and nothing else.

I'm confused as to how anyone who has worked all their life wouldn't be eligible for a full state pension, even if they did take a degree and a few years out to raise young kids. I have contributed 18 years already, I'm 35 and need to contribute another 18 years to be eligible, although I'll be working for at least another 30 years. You must have taken more years out than you realise

AmandaJonah · 02/03/2023 17:22

Yep. My DH is unemployed and not counted as he is not entitled to benefits because of my earnings.

Aphrathestorm · 02/03/2023 17:13

'Unemployment' stats only count those actively seeking and available for work.

Most non working people don't claim whatever Jobseeker's Allowance is now that it comes under UC.

Until the 2010s mums with any DC under 16 or under 18 still in school weren't counted.

Anyone signed off sick or on ESA/old incapacity benefit isn't counted.

People supported by parents/partner arent counted.

People claiming carers allowance or carers credit arent counted.

DumpedinKilburn · 02/03/2023 16:32

24KaratCucumber · 02/03/2023 13:13

Bullshit.

The number of long term unemployed people in the UK is a tiny tiny percentage and amounts to around 270k people.

The myth of all those many millions of long term.i employed is a media driven propaganda to push the narrative.of benefit claimants being Scroungers and cause division between the haves and have nots.

And unlike the people.amkong wild claims, there's plenty of sources with actual figures. www.statista.com/statistics/284187/uk-unemployment-figures-by-length/#:~:text=Number%20of%20people%20unemployed%20in,2022%2C%20by%20length%20of%20unemployment&text=As%20of%20December%202022%2C%20there,for%20more%20than%20a%20year.

Total unadulterated bollocks I'm afraid.

Branster · 02/03/2023 16:29

Thank you @Bchagall
That's reassuring to get clear confirmation.

Bchagall · 02/03/2023 16:22

Branster · 02/03/2023 15:02

So confusing.
May I please ask, if Government Gateway shows you quality for full state pension, do we believe it?
Because of the news we all need to check our pension forecast as we can only fill in the gaps by April 2023, I was talking to my sister about this today.
She took early retirement (because she could, redundancy so it works for her), had 3 years of contracted out situation but otherwise her profile shows 41 full years of contributions.
Not working anymore so she doesn't need to pay NI (only voluntarily if she wants to as far as we understand). Is this correct? We can't ascertain for sure.
The forecast shows she will get the full state pension when she reaches pension age. There is no indication that additional contributions are required for this.
How do we know that is correct?

My own profile shows I'll get full state pension if I contribute fir x number of future years. So that was clear and simple.

But reading this thread just made us question her own situation.

Your sister will get the full state pension when she reaches state pension age. She has enough contributions and the website is saying she will get a full pension.

I'm in the same position as I have 39 years of contributions. I've already qualified for the full state pension. However I'm still paying NI as I'm still working.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 02/03/2023 16:19

pissssedofff · 02/03/2023 16:08

@fitzwilliamdarcy Good, at last you agree, we have an expectation and thats good enough, just as i have an expectation of school for my kids and healthcare for my medical needs.

Contracts can and do change & of course Parliament can change the law and abolish the SP or state health or education but realistically, it will never happen, as i keep saying they want to get elected.

I’m glad that you now understand that the SP is not a contract but an expectation that you have, and that what you expect might not happen because the SP can be abolished.

That may be unlikely (I disagree, I think it will be abolished) but it doesn’t mean that it cannot be done. If it is done there is nothing you can do as you have no contractual rights.

ancientgran · 02/03/2023 16:14

ancientgran · 02/03/2023 16:13

So does your husband have SERPS/S2P? If not he has a private pension that has increased due to his contracted out payments. If he was contracted out he wouldn't be getting £45 extra.

Sorry that should have been to Seymour not Viques.

ancientgran · 02/03/2023 16:13

viques · 02/03/2023 10:56

Why is your state pension only £90? Were there NI credits you failed to claim? If you were working which I assume you were to earn a private pension this seems low. And how much is your modest occupational pension? If it is less than £47 PW you would still qualify for pension credit.

So does your husband have SERPS/S2P? If not he has a private pension that has increased due to his contracted out payments. If he was contracted out he wouldn't be getting £45 extra.

pissssedofff · 02/03/2023 16:08

@fitzwilliamdarcy Good, at last you agree, we have an expectation and thats good enough, just as i have an expectation of school for my kids and healthcare for my medical needs.

Contracts can and do change & of course Parliament can change the law and abolish the SP or state health or education but realistically, it will never happen, as i keep saying they want to get elected.

BooseysMom · 02/03/2023 16:03

BodyShapeWoes · 01/03/2023 17:07

looks like I’ve been contracted out ffs…

i am actually debating on the logic of working, I should go part time claim benefits and still have more than I earn now
what a crock of shit

earn to much to get help but still don’t earn enough to live what a fucking joke

Yep, a crock of shit alright! I work part-time just above min wage and upped my hours without realising I would be paying as much as £70 tax p/m!! I then pay £65 into a pension (NHS) I hardly earn enough to cover that, bills, run the car to get me to bloody work in the first place. It certainly feels that work doesn't pay as a pp said.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 02/03/2023 15:53

You do not have a contract with the UK Government to provide you with a pension, @pissssedofff. Contracts of employment are entirely different, because they are actually contracts. And yes I’m well aware that a contract need not be in writing, but it needs to be in some form other than you thinking one exists due to “the law of the land”.

You have an expectation of receiving the SP but no more than that. You may be right that it’ll never be abolished due to it being electoral suicide but that doesn’t change the fact that it can be.

pissssedofff · 02/03/2023 15:46

fitzwilliamdarcy · 02/03/2023 15:32

Nobody is saying this would be a good thing, and maybe at best you could argue that having to pay NI for the reason set out by the government - to obtain a pension - would make it remarkably unfair if they did abolish it, but governments do remarkably unfair things all the time.

The UK government has been increasing state pension age gradually, changing the goal posts for many on this thread. If we all had contractual rights as @pissssedofff says, then how had it been possible for the UK government to do that?

Ridiculous argument... no Govt is going to abolish the SP pension, they all want to be re elected!
I have had several contracts of employment, various employers have changed my T&C's & aside from resigning, there is nothing i can do about it, all they have to show is a business need, consult and be reasonable

Yes Govt have changed pension ages and normally with many years of advanced warning.

Contracts are not set in stone.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 02/03/2023 15:32

SueVineer · 02/03/2023 15:17

Exactly- it’s a contribution based benefit. It can be abolished at any time

Nobody is saying this would be a good thing, and maybe at best you could argue that having to pay NI for the reason set out by the government - to obtain a pension - would make it remarkably unfair if they did abolish it, but governments do remarkably unfair things all the time.

The UK government has been increasing state pension age gradually, changing the goal posts for many on this thread. If we all had contractual rights as @pissssedofff says, then how had it been possible for the UK government to do that?

Everanewbie · 02/03/2023 15:29

So, OP. In conclusion you're projected state pension is reduced as you contracted out of SERPS/S2P for a number of years enhancing your workplace pension rather than paying full NI contributions towards state pension accrual. Mystery solved. If anyone is at fault it is the administrators of your workplace scheme for not telling you about this, or you for not taking this on board. But you now have the option to use a small amount of capital to make up for those years where you contracted out and receive a full BSP. Up to you, but by feeling is that unless you plan on dying in the next 2 or 3 years, are already in receipt of a high income or literally do not have the money, it is probably a good idea to do so.

There are many debates to be had about state benefits and when and how they should be paid, but irrespective of that, you have not been done over.

SueVineer · 02/03/2023 15:22

State pensions currently cost uK gov about £100billion a year.it’s a lot