Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send my child to the local comp?

58 replies

Whatwouldyoudododo · 01/03/2023 14:49

A bit more complex than the title implies.
Long story short: Mother in law has offered to pay for my eldest to attend a private school for secondary education. My child has started year 7 at the local comp and would like to stay there because of friends. The school is much worse than I had hoped but thought we would give it a shot.

Don't want to force child away from friends but the school is really struggling and I imagine it'll take a number if years to improve.

WWYD?

OP posts:
Whatwouldyoudododo · 01/03/2023 15:15

@ZacharinaQuack if I'm honest I'm not sure my other children will mind where they go! So yes, I'd probably send them to the private school if the local comp has not improved by then.

OP posts:
Obeythedancecommander · 01/03/2023 15:10

What is your mil's financial position? Would she pay up front (I.e give the cash to you) to pay for all of the children? Things change; what if she's happily paying and something happens that means she can no longer continue to pay? Would you be able to pick up where she left off? I can imagine it would be quite shit if you had to move your child back to the comp or couldn't give all of your children the same opportunity.

Quartz2208 · 01/03/2023 15:10

Not all local comps are equal. If it was good or above, good language and arts etc and no bullying and they were happy I wouldn’t.

but the school you describe in special measures in a heartbeat

skgnome · 01/03/2023 15:10

Bullying and ofsted special measures would put me on the “take the offer” side
however - you said it’s your eldest, would your other kids benefit from the same offer?
are there any strings attached? Or is it just a generous offer from a loving grandparent who you have a good relationship with?
also, can you afford the “extras” (uniform, lunches, compulsory trips )?
being on the same school as your primary school friends is not really a consideration- they do tend to make new friends in high school, and they can keep in touch

thaegumathteth · 01/03/2023 15:09

I can understand - it's a tricky decision. For me the class segregation would be the deal breaker being totally honest, it's just not something I'm comfortable with at all but I wouldn't judge anyone else for making a different decision

Gruelle · 01/03/2023 15:09

Firstly you would need to be able to choose from your own shortlist - not just a single school chosen by your MIL.

Secondly your child has to apply and be accepted. If a school is worth paying for (from an academic pov) there’ll be an entrance exam and interview, and they won’t just take anyone who can pay. Presumably you’re now looking (quite late!) at yr 9 entrance - which would mean a very traditional public school?

So you need to know what she’s offering. If she says you don’t get a choice - you’d be better off to decline her generous offer. If she’s ready to work with you and her grandchild to find the best school for them - that’s worthy of consideration.

(And the right school will be one your child feels excited to be joining.)

Whatwouldyoudododo · 01/03/2023 15:09

@MadamArcati99 no idea what your talking about none of my kids are privately educated at present.

OP posts:
Sleepingmole · 01/03/2023 15:09

If they aren’t great I’d definitely do some tours of schools to get a feel for the alternatives

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 01/03/2023 15:09

Whatwouldyoudododo · 01/03/2023 14:58

@CallCollect yes I've done ok, but it was a struggle and in spite of difficulties that I would have loved to have not had to face.

I was perfectly happy with the local comp which is why we enrolled there but after the first month I wanted to take my child out. The bullying, lack of arts and languages etc, the recent Ofsted special measures award @Siennahh . It's been a bloody disappointment.

Have I read this right and understood? Your yr7 child is unhappy in some way despite having friends there, and you are unhappy at the local comp?

And your MIL had offered to pay for private education for all your DCs?

Friends can be remade and kept in touch with. Their friends change a lot from ur 7- Yr 11 so I wouldn't let that stop me if I thought ultimately it'd be a happier and better education experience for my child. I have 3 DCs two at uni now and saw how much their friends changed. It's short term pain for long term gain in a school move if you prefer the private school

I'd be inclined to take MIL up in her offer once I'd looked around the school with DD.... it's a very generous offer

ZacharinaQuack · 01/03/2023 15:09

Whatwouldyoudododo · 01/03/2023 15:02

@ZacharinaQuack I had fairly similar experience. I've done well but did not enjoy my time at high school. It was a struggle and I had no opportunities.

I was actually really lucky with my school in terms of what it offered. It was a big school and could offer things like drama, music, art, languages (though we didn't start a second language as early as they normally introduced it, because they couldn't recruit/keep German teachers). They also had been told by Ofsted that they weren't doing enough for able pupils so they had introduced schemes like moving selected kids up a year (so I got out sooner!) and offering extra GCSEs after school in things like art. But I still think I shouldn't have gone there, and your DC's school sounds way less good than mine (which was eventually forcibly merged with another failing comp, turned into an academy, and later closed down altogether).

I don't think your son being happy is the only thing that matters here. Unless he's very self-motivated, he probably will do less well at the comp overall, which he might well regret later. He could be just as happy at the private school, even if he doesn't think so now. And would you consider taking up MIL's offer for the siblings if you don't for the eldest? If not (I'd probably want them all at the same school), you can't let the eldest decide for everyone.

Whatwouldyoudododo · 01/03/2023 15:08

I mean pretty crap! Not great!

OP posts:
Whatwouldyoudododo · 01/03/2023 15:08

@thaegumathteth it does which is why I've never taken up the offer before, the offers been on the table since the kids started reception but primary school has been great, I enjoy the kids being part of a community and I've never felt they lacked anything and also am uncomfortable with the idea of class segregation.

That being said, things are pretty great and I don't want my child missing out.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 01/03/2023 15:07

Just read he’s already started. Not so sure

Maybe visit and see

MadamArcati99 · 01/03/2023 15:06

If the other kids have gone private, why did she start at the comp?
of course you should move her! a parent's job is to make decisions that the child doesnt have the life experience or maturity to make themselves.
what are you going to say to her in 20 years when she asks you why didnt have a private education that was on offer.

MarshaBradyo · 01/03/2023 15:05

I’d take the generous offer

How many grand dc are they paying for in total?

Very nice of them

Siennahh · 01/03/2023 15:04

Bullying, and then Ofsted special measures would be the 2 things I was guided by. In a heartbeat.

thaegumathteth · 01/03/2023 15:04

Whatwouldyoudododo · 01/03/2023 15:03

@thaegumathteth I wouldn't owe anyone anything either way!

I don't mean literally and perhaps it's just my view but I'd just feel uncomfortable with someone else paying for it if that makes sense?

Maryandherlamb · 01/03/2023 15:03

I think I'd visit the other school, try to encourage your eldest to see it with an open mind, and go from there. I'd want to be able to afford the extra curricular activities though as they're usually more costly at private schools.

Whatwouldyoudododo · 01/03/2023 15:03

@thaegumathteth I wouldn't owe anyone anything either way!

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 01/03/2023 15:02

I'd move them. It's good to hear DC views and talk to them, but I've never understood the trend for some parents allowing 11 year olds to dictate where they're going to school. It's a big issue with longer term implications than who you'll see at playtime.

I've worked in a struggling school and wouldn't send my own children to a school like that if I had the means to avoid it.

If you think that the fees would be free of strings and MIL would do the same for all DC then I'd thank her for the offer and grab it with both hands.

Sleepingmole · 01/03/2023 15:02

I went to a big comp and have done fine. However, school was tough and working wasn’t encouraged. If your son is happy though then that’s the main thing.
It’s a tough decision (but hopefully a good one) to make

Whatwouldyoudododo · 01/03/2023 15:02

@ZacharinaQuack I had fairly similar experience. I've done well but did not enjoy my time at high school. It was a struggle and I had no opportunities.

OP posts:
ZacharinaQuack · 01/03/2023 14:59

PS: meant to say I was miserable because being swotty with a middle-class accent was not the sort of thing that made you popular at my school!

Whatwouldyoudododo · 01/03/2023 14:58

@CallCollect yes I've done ok, but it was a struggle and in spite of difficulties that I would have loved to have not had to face.

I was perfectly happy with the local comp which is why we enrolled there but after the first month I wanted to take my child out. The bullying, lack of arts and languages etc, the recent Ofsted special measures award @Siennahh . It's been a bloody disappointment.

OP posts:
ZacharinaQuack · 01/03/2023 14:58

I went to a 'rough', crappy comp and I did well academically but I was pretty miserable (being a bit swotty didn't make me popular!). If I hadn't been clever and academically inclined, I probably wouldn't have done that well. My parents had been advised to put me in for scholarships to private schools but 10-year-old me insisted I wanted to go to the local school. With hindsight, I think they should have made that decision for me (taking into account my preferences) as I wasn't old or mature enough to make a decision that was going to affect the next 5-7 years of my education. If MIL is also willing to pay for the other children, I think you should go for it (and if so, it's not just about what your eldest prefers right now).