Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send my child to the local comp?

58 replies

Whatwouldyoudododo · 01/03/2023 14:49

A bit more complex than the title implies.
Long story short: Mother in law has offered to pay for my eldest to attend a private school for secondary education. My child has started year 7 at the local comp and would like to stay there because of friends. The school is much worse than I had hoped but thought we would give it a shot.

Don't want to force child away from friends but the school is really struggling and I imagine it'll take a number if years to improve.

WWYD?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
maeveiscurious · 03/03/2023 08:35

I would definitely take up the offer.

Life opportunities are few. Our DCs have been through a good comp, but a good private school would have added extra curriculum activities. If the school is poor, it will narrow the opportunities in the future .

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 03/03/2023 08:26

TinklyLaughTime · 01/03/2023 15:25

The only way I'd accept would be if the person offering to pay would be willing to gift the full amount of the private education to Y11 at least, in full and in advance. Either directly to us or through a trust.

It doesn't matter how much money they have or how happy/young/healthy they are. No one is immune from divorce, death, serious illness, family arguments and a host of other reasons that may be the case of them stopping paying in future.

This is such a choosing beggar response 😱 Please don't listen to this PP .

It's possible the funds for each year comes from interest or income generated each year, not just savings.

If there's divorces etc in future, that's the way life goes and much more would change.

The offer by MIL to pay for private schooling is very generous.

Bluetrews25 · 01/03/2023 17:57

Is there a place for her and does she meet admission criteria?
No point getting hopes up (perhaps) if not.
Extra curriculars are not all expensive but will all be optional. Not everyone in private is rich. Many on full or partial bursaries.

lizzielizard · 01/03/2023 16:55

It's a school in measures and your son is being bullied. I'd be snatching her hand off! Give your DC this great opportunity - he'll make new friends.

Workawayxx · 01/03/2023 16:06

I'd definitely take them up on it if the school isn't great. Can you persuade your DC on the basis of the bullying? Maybe look round a couple of private schools with them to show them all that's on offer.

We have good schools where I live so DC will go there (and wants to) but my parents have also offered. If he doesn't get on well, I'll look into moving him. My sibling will probably take them up on the offer as they don't have very good secondary schools where they live.

pontipinemum · 01/03/2023 16:01

I'd take her offer. I went to both a private and a comp school. Firstly private because the area we lived in had really bad comp schools something like 1 in 20 finishing GCSE (could be exaggerating). We then moved and I went to the local comp which was excellent.

Mariposista · 01/03/2023 15:45

I'd be moving them. Your child needs to be focussing on learning, not batting off bullies, having lessons disrupted by bad behaviour, constant turnover of teachers and heck knows what else.
Of course some comps are excellent, nothing against them, but the one your kid is in sounds dreadful. Friends is not a good enough reason to keep them there. They will have and make many friends over their lifetime.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 01/03/2023 15:44

Do the private school offer taster days? If your DC could go for one day and see what it is actually like he may prefer it. Eg, if the people are nicer, classrooms calmer and he feels safer. Obviously not all private schools will be better than all comps (many are considerably worse) but the only way to know properly is to try it.

DashboardConfessional · 01/03/2023 15:42

I've thought about this due to our own situation and decided we'd probably say yes for an offer for secondary, no for primary.

nutbrownhare15 · 01/03/2023 15:41

I'm not a fan of private education at all but in your shoes OP I'd be strongly considering it. Maybe look round the school and see what you think. Will bullying be a factor there too?

ZacharinaQuack · 01/03/2023 15:40

If you really think you'll take the offer for your other DCs, I reckon you should just go for it with the eldest, assuming you can get him in to a school you like. Things turned out okay for me so I didn't really blame my parents but I did have a couple of moments of thinking 'why did you let a 10/11 year old make that decision?!' which would have been worse if I'd had younger siblings who all got the opportunity I'd been allowed to turn down.

Sleepingmole · 01/03/2023 15:39

If your son has been bullied then it’s a no brainer. Find the right school that suits him

Wnikat · 01/03/2023 15:38

If my kid was being bullied I’d bite her hand off

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 01/03/2023 15:33

I would do it.
There's a huge difference between a good comp and a poor one ( we moved so our third dc wouldn't have to go). There's world's between a good private and a poor comp!

pickledpies · 01/03/2023 15:28

will your child be able to move back to the comp if they don't like the private or will the position get filled?

What I have learnt is that as long as they have the right friends, children thrive academically where they are happy.

StopitSarah · 01/03/2023 15:26

I’d accept her offer. But is there a place at a good local independent school? I would probably move my children from a terrible comp to an ok independent but would (obviously) be aiming for an excellent independent school that would cater for my child’s areas of interest (academic/music/sport/drama etc)

Whatwouldyoudododo · 01/03/2023 15:25

@ZacharinaQuack I do agree with you. Also she has worked incredibly hard to be in this position and she pays for all her family to be privately educated in the country from which they are originally from (where life is very hard) so I don't think it's quite the same as using her as a cash cow!

@Yazo there is no pressure at all just the reassurance it is there should be wish to use it. They know my sending my children to the local comp has been from the best of intention. It's purely because the school has literally rock- bottomed in the last year and my child had to put up with so much bullying.

OP posts:
TinklyLaughTime · 01/03/2023 15:25

The only way I'd accept would be if the person offering to pay would be willing to gift the full amount of the private education to Y11 at least, in full and in advance. Either directly to us or through a trust.

It doesn't matter how much money they have or how happy/young/healthy they are. No one is immune from divorce, death, serious illness, family arguments and a host of other reasons that may be the case of them stopping paying in future.

pickledpies · 01/03/2023 15:25

take the kid on a tour round the new school then leave it up to the child to decide. They may change their mind with a tour

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 01/03/2023 15:22

The thing is, what private school has she got in mind? Because they aren't all brilliant simply by virtue of being private.

How much choice would you and your dc have over choosing which schools to apply to? Would your DC get in, especially as in year admissions can be tricky? Would you have to tutor to get them into a selective private school?

Quite a few issues to think through. It's not as simple as just deciding and doing.

shropshire11 · 01/03/2023 15:21

You should move your child - it might not be a decision they will thank you for today, but they will in future.

It's a shame to part from friends, but they will make new friends in the new school. Having a private education will be a gigantic advantage for them for the rest of their lives.

Yazo · 01/03/2023 15:20

I'd keep them in, my MIL called my husband the other day to talk secondaries, I think she should mind her business!

If it were I'd politely decline and suggest the money could go towards university or starting out in some other way. My in laws are saving for that and I prefer that as it's between them and my kids. What if you went private and your child hated the school or didn't get on well there? It certainly happens.

Igniteyourbones · 01/03/2023 15:19

I would accept the offer in a heartbeat.

Warrensrabbit · 01/03/2023 15:18

I would seize the opportunity with both hands. when I look at the opportunity peers of mine who were privately educated had I am incredibly jealous.

ZacharinaQuack · 01/03/2023 15:16

If MIL has lots of money, and would like to leave it to your DH and/or your children, she may also see this as a good way to benefit them now while avoiding inheritance tax. If she does see it like that, maybe that takes away some of the discomfort about 'someone else paying for it'? i.e. this is money that would be going to the grandchildren anyway in the end.