Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the GP receptionist should have asked, 'Are you ok'?

160 replies

shonapop · 01/03/2023 13:18

My mood has been slowly spiralling downwards. I've had many gentle suggestions from family that perhaps it's time to think about increasing my anti depressants.
I've been really putting it off, trying to fix myself with all the usual exercise, meditation, etc. Just getting worse.
Plucked up the courage to call the GP today, feeling like a total failure and on my way to rock bottom.
Told the receptionist 'I think I need to tweak my antidepressants' she said 'I can't get you a phonecall with a GP until next week ' that was it. Didn't ask if I was ok, was it an mental health emergency? Or even what direction was I wanting to tweak them.
What if it was someone AT rock bottom? Suicidal? Can't believe the lack of compassion.

OP posts:
HallucinationQ · 01/03/2023 14:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Logburnerperils · 01/03/2023 14:47

Na not their job to do that. They are not a personal samaritans hotline.

HallucinationQ · 01/03/2023 14:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Debbehthchosenmum · 01/03/2023 14:45

This happened to my MIL when she was feeling suicidal. Her husband rang back complaining and saying it was an emergency and they apologised and the head GP rang her back that day.

She ended up seeing a psychologist not long after and got diagnosed with Bipolar, and has been on the wrong meds for 20 years with all sorts of negative side effects.

Flowershoppe · 01/03/2023 14:34

If you'd have said I really can't wait until then she might well have escalated and done more, but she isn't a mindreader.

Flowershoppe · 01/03/2023 14:33

I do get it, I have been where you are and understand that things like this can be really distressing almost (not sure how else to describe it); but as has been said the reality is that the receptionist is limited in what they can do- what would you expect them to do bearing in mind the confines of their role if you said actually no I'm not? The reality is they can't magic more appointments out of thin air nor are they trained to give medical advice. Sure they could have signposted to if you can't wait til then phone 111 or whatever, but then some would find them intrusive- it's a hard balance.

By all means give feedback to the practice manager and it might be that they can review the processes, but I wouldn't feel badly towards someone doing their job and not stepping out of the role. If they gave incorrect advice they'd be in serious trouble s probably would the surgery.

I'd look at it as she listened and booked you an appointment without probing etc so evidently felt that you do need to see someone and that your needs are important.

RunningFromInsanity · 01/03/2023 14:30

When I had (undiagnosed) depression and it culminated into a bit of a breakdown when I rang the GP the receptionist couldn’t have been more compassionate and helpful.
I literally just said ‘I need help’ and broke down in tears and she was so kind, asked me to stay on hold and said she would see what she could do for me, and I ended up having a GP call me back within a couple of hours.

I was so grateful as I probably wouldn’t have had the strength to stay on hold or wait several days for an appointment etc

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 01/03/2023 14:23

Our GP receptionists do ask questions, so I'm not sure you are being unreasonable.

They have it on the surgery website, and also say you don't have to answer the questions, but imply that it helps them prioritise appointments.

Ideally there would be more training on mental health for receptionists, and GP's, but that's another issue.

Soakitup37 · 01/03/2023 14:18

“I'm going to be ok but what about the next person who calls that isn't?”

when you’re feeling off-kilter it’s common to feel an overwhelming sense of need to worry about others and to fix things on the wider spectrum. This can actually exacerbate your own mh. Your thinking if I’m not ok someone else may feel the same or worse is well placed but not your problem at this moment in time.

it’s ok to be selfish and only worry about yourself when you feel like this, you don’t need to worry about the next person along.

hope you’re feeling better op 💐

QuitsAmidCrisis · 01/03/2023 14:16

MotherofBingo · 01/03/2023 14:01

Sadly, some GP receptionists aren't the most compassionate - I have rung up and literally said, I am severely depressed I need help and I need an emergency appointment (something I've been told to get by the GP when I'm in crisis) and been told 'well I hardly think that's an emergency is it'. Saying I think I need to tweak my antidepressants could have meant something like they were giving some nasty side effects, or even that you want to decrease the dosage. So it might just be that she didn't think about it.

This is unacceptable behaviour from a receptionist. I am sorry you were treated this way. Just awful.

OP, your situation is not really the same. Try to move on from this.

twoandcooplease · 01/03/2023 14:16

If you had told her a bit more I'm sure she would have been more sympathetic. Tweaking your medication could mean bringing the dose down not up. I'm sorry you're not feeling low and hope you feel better after a dr app xxx

QuitsAmidCrisis · 01/03/2023 14:14

Some GP receptionists should have a kinder tone; many can sound so rude. But as it’s so endemic, I presume it is the result of a wider issue. They are the front face of the surgeries and probably end up with all the unfiltered rudeness and frustration of patients. I am sorry if she was rude.

But she is in no way a trained MH clinician. She cannot do a brief risk assessment on the phone. Indeed it could be more risky for her to do so. Are there crisis lines where you live? That would be more suitable if you are in crisis. The way things are currently, the fact you got through and were offered an appt next week, is not that bad going ☹️ Things are awful and even worse in some places. It’s not right though.

Good luck OP. But try not to dwell on this. It’s the wrong focus for your negativity right now.

Regularsizedrudy · 01/03/2023 14:13

Wow never thought I’d feel sorry for a gp receptionist!

Sorry you’re having a hard time but your expectations are way off. It’s not their job to support you, and someone else may have found the follow up questions you suggest very intrusive.

2023b · 01/03/2023 14:11

Hi @shonapop
I started a thread recently about the current ridiculous system most GP surgeries have in place for getting an appointment. Well done for even getting through on the phone.

What exactly did you expect from the receptionist? They are exactly that - receptionists. Not healthcare professionals. It is not their role to ask if patients are okay. There are probably several dozen more trying to get through. Genuinely curious what you expected from the receptionist - ask if you are ok then what, signpost you to what? They aren't trained to do this. I also think they aren't trained to triage but that's another issue. They are basically a medium through which you can get an appointment because its not a good use of GP time to be answering the phone.

Truckinghell · 01/03/2023 14:10

Alittlebitofbreadandsomecheese · 01/03/2023 13:21

GP receptionists can't win.

If they don't ask questions they are called 'uncaring' but if they do ask questions they are being 'nosey' or 'intrusive'. 🙄

Why are you rolling your eyes at someone who is clearly having a very difficult time?

Plenty of people have made your point without being a dick.

Darthwazette · 01/03/2023 14:08

When I’ve needed urgent mental health help I’ve said I’m struggling, I usually sound like I’m struggling and I’ve always been offered a same day appointment. I can’t fault my GP for that.

OnlyheretovoteonAIBU · 01/03/2023 14:04

Since you have posted this on AIBU I’m going to be honest and say you are being completely unreasonable. Sorry you’re feeling so bad, but you’re being completely unfair to expect an underpaid, overworked GP receptionist to offer a listening service on the basis of “I think my antidepressants need tweaking”.

I worked in this sort of job in another life and I also am a long term user of antidepressants so I can see both sides of the coin. GP receptionists get the most vile abuse and shit for things completely out of their control, and you’re being incredibly unfair to someone doing the job they’ve been trained to do, which is not that of a counsellor.

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 01/03/2023 14:03

shonapop · 01/03/2023 13:48

On the automated message before the call was taken it said 'you are about to talk to one of our highly trained receptionists' I would have thought that the mention of anti depressants should be something that would make her ears perk up.

Unfortunately the reality of how the nhs works what your asking isn't possible I think 1 in 4 gp appointments are about mental health and I would think about a 1/3 of any drs patients lists are on antidepressants. There's a good chance the receptionist herself is taking them. If you are in crisis and need urgent help you literally need to say the words and to be fair, even then you might not get much help but you would have a better chance

MotherofBingo · 01/03/2023 14:01

Sadly, some GP receptionists aren't the most compassionate - I have rung up and literally said, I am severely depressed I need help and I need an emergency appointment (something I've been told to get by the GP when I'm in crisis) and been told 'well I hardly think that's an emergency is it'. Saying I think I need to tweak my antidepressants could have meant something like they were giving some nasty side effects, or even that you want to decrease the dosage. So it might just be that she didn't think about it.

samsmum2 · 01/03/2023 14:00

@afinishedkiss what a tone deaf, insensitive response...

Mumofnarnia · 01/03/2023 13:59

GP receptionists are not counsellors, they are not trained to ask if you are ok regarding your depression unless you give them a reason to think you are not ok. They are not qualified to help you and they are not mind readers and just saying you want to ‘tweak your medication’ isn’t going to make them think anything other than you want to tweak your medication. They are there to book appointments and make sure you are booked in with the correct person who will then be qualified to ask those sort of questions. Receptionists handle a huge volume of phone calls and face to face enquiries on a daily basis and most people they encounter are not ok otherwise they wouldn’t be contacting the GP practice.

LimeWire · 01/03/2023 13:57

shonapop · 01/03/2023 13:48

On the automated message before the call was taken it said 'you are about to talk to one of our highly trained receptionists' I would have thought that the mention of anti depressants should be something that would make her ears perk up.

Hey @shonapop, so sorry your struggling. I totally get where you're coming from. I've made that call several times to the GP. The previous posters are right though -- you have to tell them you are in crisis and need an urgent appointment to speak to your GP.

Millions of UK residents are on antidepressants. That means the receptionist has likely had dozens of calls that week about people wanting to adjust/review/increase/switch their ADs.

Getting the right mental health support seems impossible sometimes. But I promise you that if you call back and say exactly how bad it is, you won't get fobbed off. You may not get a same-day appointment, or they may refer you to 999 if you are at risk of danger. But you will get help.

It sucks. I know it does. But keep advocating for your care, and don't misplace your anger on the receptionist. They are simply doing their job. Take care, and get better soon 💐

Darkstar4855 · 01/03/2023 13:56

She probably had twenty more callers on the line waiting to get through. If she asks you if you’re ok and you say no, then what does she do? She’s not a trained counsellor. What about the next person who rings up saying they’re in pain? Or the mum worried about their baby not feeding well? Should she be asking them if they’re ok too?

What about the person with mental health issues who can’t get through at all because it’s taking too long?

Sorry OP but her job is to try and triage everybody as efficiently as possible. There are many numbers like 111, local mental health crisis teams, Mind, Samaritans etc. for people to ring who need mental health support who can handle it far more effectively than a GP receptionist.

SleepyRich · 01/03/2023 13:56

shonapop · 01/03/2023 13:48

On the automated message before the call was taken it said 'you are about to talk to one of our highly trained receptionists' I would have thought that the mention of anti depressants should be something that would make her ears perk up.

The mention of antidepressants wouldn't even make their ears tingle, it's a completely normal and routine thing to be seeing the GP for.

KarmaStar · 01/03/2023 13:52

Hi op,I think you've taken this to heart as you wanted a friendly ear and she was simply professional,you're comment about tweaking could be interpreted either way so I don't think she's done anything wrong.
Can you speak to MIND or a similar charity in the meantime?
Have you any idea of the cause of your low mood?
Have you considered CBT therapy?
The root of your happiness would be better addressed if that's possible.
🌈