Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the inclusion/equality is for people with learning disabilities?

235 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 12:36

Or if you prefer, people with academic disabilities.

For full disclosure I have a secondary-aged DC who was initially diagnosed with global developmental delay. This was upgraded to ‘academic/learning disability’ when DC failed to catch up by the age of 5.

Mainstream school isn’t equipped to support inclusion for DC who can’t more or less keep up with the curriculum at the pace of the rest.

Specialist placements mean mixing only with other families of DC with learning disabilities.

Hobbies and clubs are difficult unless specially for DC with learning disabilities so again no mixing outside of that limited circle.

Support groups are usually targeted at Downs Syndrome or ASD etc so no welcome there.

Those with physical disabilities eg wheelchair users, those with CP, those who are Deaf regularly make a point like this: ‘I’m in a wheelchair/Deaf/etc, I don’t have a learning disability, so don’t talk to me as if I were stupid.’ All very well but where is the solidarity for DC like mine? Is it ok to talk to them as if they’re stupid because they do have a learning disability?

Even those with ASD, who make up a sizeable proportion of my DC’s peers at the specialist placement, are keen to point out that it’s any learning disability, not ASD, that is really disabling, again taking care to distance themselves from any solidarity with those like my DC.

AIBU to wonder what is left for us?

OP posts:
ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 01/03/2023 17:27

Sorry I’m trying really hard to understand the issues here but am struggling.

I think you’re saying that your child is in SEND provision which is meeting their academic needs but you want them to be exposed to peers who are neurotypical rather than those with learning disabilities? What does your child want? (Sorry if I’ve missed this), my DS is able to relax and be himself with his peers who have additional needs, he doesn’t have to try and mask the things he is struggling with in order to fit in and then breakdown later as it’s too much. Or perhaps your child doesn’t identify himself as being like those other kids and I’ve missed it.

In terms of activities, there are lots of options out there which PPs have suggested, swimming in particular doesn’t need a specific club or anything surely? Just take them swimming. If you’re looking for something with more of a community, there are often clubs out there which are pretty supportive - I’d tend to go for something which caters to adults as well as kids so that the activity can be adapted to different needs and abilities and the adults can offer extra support if needed.

bigbabycooker · 01/03/2023 17:25

Gosh, this is very difficult and you have my sympathy, OP. I have seen on here people trying to split hairs about what is ASD and what is LD, so I can see the issue.

As an adult, unlike PP, I would have no issue having a friend at a hobby with an intellectual disability. I don't really have group hobbies at the moment - young kids and work - but I'd be happy to spend time with someone doing the same type of activity as me. I think hobbies would be an ideal "bridge", because I think at the moment work and kids occupy a lot of headspace and that might be less accessible to someone with severe LDs, depending on their situation.

As a child, I guess it can be quite difficult (though shouldn't be insurmountable), just because kids are still learning themselves. I think sometimes adults get it wrong in the planning - I recall having a girl with DS as a group helper when I was a brownie and she was a ranger and I really struggled as an 8 or 9 year old to process the fact that the grown ups were telling us that she was someone who should be treated as if she was one of the adults telling us what to do, when it was clear that she didn't understand the instructions as well as us and needed a lot of help herself. As an adult, I have a lot more empathy and realise that the adults had set her up to fail by trying to position her in this way and that they could have given more thought to the special responsibilities she could be given (ie not "discipline" but setting up and helping with activities etc) alongside encouraging her to bond with us as proxy peers too. She must have found it quite lonely to be put in that position where she couldn't really be in either camp.

Vegrocks · 01/03/2023 16:54

Op can you have a really open chat with his school? About this very issue

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 16:40

You put it really well @Jellycatspyjamas I worry sometimes that we have done wrong by moving area- away from the kids who have grown up with my DC as ‘the eldest child of our parents’ friends who is the same sort of age as us and although a bit different has always been around at social events…’ I think that familiarity counted for something. The educational provision is much better here though…

You are also kinder than me in terms of understanding PPs

OP posts:
CremeEggsForBreakfast · 01/03/2023 16:39

I don't have any children of my own but a close relative of mine has learning disabilities (and ASD) and I work with a few children with learning disabilities and I completely agree with you, OP.

I hate the whole "I'm deaf, don't treat me like I have a learning disability" thing. An adult (or in your case a teenager) with a learning disability is still an adult (or teenager). You don't need to talk to them like they're 3. You may need some patience while the person processes the information and forms a response and a good ability to explain things clearly but for goodness sake, acknowledge that this person still has all the same rights as you as has just as much of a valid contribution to make to discussions as anyone else.

I completely understand that adapting the supervision requirements for a club to allow for more vulnerable people is expensive but it's not actually any more complicated than having a ramp or lift installed for wheelchair users, is it!?

I saw a comment section of a newspaper article that suggested an adult with learning disabilities should be allowed to continue attending a children-only attraction and that to deny him was discrimination. So few people understood that actually, consigning him to children's activities only was both discriminatory to the children AND to him. So very few people even gave thought to how the adult equivalent of said activity should be adapting to have him attend.

Jellycatspyjamas · 01/03/2023 16:21

I know what you mean @AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman, my DD has a specialist placement for high school in August which is great because her educational needs will be met. But finding places where she can develop social skills with non-disabled kids is very hard going - and she will need those skills to function in wider society. Providing specific clubs, activities and events that meet her current developmental stage means she doesn’t mix with her peer group and while I understand a PP saying they didn’t want a friend with LD in childhood, nor in adulthood it means kids like mine face a lifetime of exclusion or tokenism and who would want that.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 16:07

All of the suggestions of clubs are kind and well meaning. I will definitely look into them. Actually, DC wants to do swimming and dancing. I don’t think it should be too much to ask to get to choose an activity you want to try- they aren’t very outlandish and everyone else sees choosing as a really unremarkable thing.

But also, it’s about more than the clubs. That’s a tiny thing. It’s about all of life.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 16:02

McGonagallshatandglasses · 01/03/2023 14:20

This conversation is complicated by a lack of shared language.

Somehow in the uk 'academic disability' is used for what we in Australia would say are 2 entirely seperate groups (with potential crossover).

Here it's 'intellectual disability' or ID for someone with an IQ below 70. Moderate if 50-70, severe if below 50. My sister falls into this category.

Alternatively we use the term 'learning disabilty' LD to describe people with dyslexia, dyscalculia and dysgraphia. People who have something blocking their ability to learn in a typical manner but with an IQ in the average or above average range.

Many with an LD will be successful in mainstream schools with the right supports and it doesn't preclude independent adult life. But an ID is different. And that's what you are describing.

For what it's worth, my mother fought to keep my sister in a mainstream environment. At 16 we had no option anymore and we spent quite a long time trying to work out what options were open to us. At 31 she's living independently, with support workers helping with almost all life domains. She will never be safe to drive. No possible workplace has been identified despite lots of expert supports. Learning still happens, but it's sloooooowww.

I'm sorry you are struggling to find a place you feel like your child can be included. You are right, your child should be welcome in sports and clubs but often that welcome will be hollow. And all children should be able to have their needs met in their local school and community- but England really doesn't do inclusive education well, and specialist provision does have some benefits. For my sister, it wasn't till her late teens that she was ever in a space where she was successful and the 'best' at something. I think she'd have been happier if we'd found somewhere earlier that gave her that.

Thank you for your post @McGonagallshatandglasses. I understand what you mean about being ‘best’ at something and I’m sorry to hear about your family’s struggle to support your sister. It is just really hard to know even what a good outcome might be, let alone how to reach it.

You’re right about the language used - its really convoluted and changes, meaning it’s not easy to talk to others with a common understanding, especially across borders or if diagnosed during different time periods.

Another effect of that is if I say ‘My DC is disabled’ people will say ‘oh, how?’ If I then say ‘DC has a learning disability’ they will say ‘yes, but how?’ ‘But what kind of learning disability?’ Even special school receptionists.

Or they will say ‘yes but my DC has ASD and epilepsy’ (for example) by which they mean ‘my DC has clear and defined needs so we get the seat nearest the bathroom because you can’t even express yourself.’

OP posts:
givemushypeasachance · 01/03/2023 16:02

In terms of an open-access activity, have you got any junior parkruns locally? They're 2km events on a Sunday morning, for 4-14 year olds, all run by volunteers. You just sign up and turn up and can take part as much or as little as you like - you can run it, or hop skip and jump, or walk it, everyone is welcome. There's an informal warm up beforehand and people usually do some hanging around and chatting, so gentle socialisation with a range of aged kids. And they need volunteers, from the kids as well as adults. So if he's interested in that side of things he could help out by marshalling and clapping and cheering everyone on as they go past, or giving out finish tokens at the end, or tail walking and being the last 'runner' to make sure everyone finishes safe. Parkrun is intended as a very inclusive event and hopefully your local group would welcome him giving it a try, it's very rewarding getting wristbands for the number of runs completed and helping out with volunteering and so on.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 15:41

@cheapskatemum no I haven’t heard of Ros Blackburn. Curious. In what way similar?

OP posts:
Marblessolveeverything · 01/03/2023 15:26

Sorry to hear how challenging it is to see inclusion in social spaces.

Our local GAA football club (Ireland) set up an All Stars programme - they provide 1:1 support where needed and aim to be a space where all children up to teen years can enjoy sports/social events etc.

There is no criteria just open to all - several families I know found it great as all the family could attend and engage with the social elements.

There is local litter picking - tidy town groups, etc that are open to all, supported swimming lessons, and riding for those with additional needs, pitch and putt run one to one supports, local bowling alley does "quite nights" which have young staff give a hand.

We are in an area where there are several specialist schools so that shapes our community. Being a smaller country provision is very patchy, but tends to be more inclusive as numbers dictate it needs to be to secure funding etc.

Yazo · 01/03/2023 15:24

It's really hard and definitely all clubs or activities are not inclusive. Really feel for you. I don't have any answers but I hope you find some support out there and fun stuff for you and your child.

Stillcountingbeans · 01/03/2023 15:13

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 14:27

@Timesawastin yes, ‘so-called inclusion’ is rubbish for everyone if it’s not really working for the most vulnerable and yes, a good specialist placement can be fantastic as far as school goes.

But my DC has always wanted to be very sociable, and was actually quite popular in mainstream until the others’ interests really outpaced DC. Now DC is surrounded by kids who struggle especially with social interaction- that doesn’t make it easy to make friends.

Also why should DC be hidden away with only other disabled kids all the time? If I want to host a birthday party for DC, why do I who am already exhausted from caring, have to host a room full of kids with behavioural issues? I could do parties in mainstream with a handful of kids with ASD and learning disabilities and the other 20 kids from the mainstream class and I was good at it. I just can’t cope with a whole class full of kids with additional needs- but that hurts my DC and their classmates that it doesn’t happen now.

This is another issue - the way most provision is for LD lumped together with ASD. Just because lots of people have both.

So a young person who is very, very slow to learn, but who has totally normal emotional reactions, and no ASD behavioural issues, is lumped in with people with severely abnormal behaviours and emotional interactions.

The LD people don't get much chance to make friends with people who match their profile in terms of "normal" behaviour and emotions.

(Sorry if the word 'normal' offends, can't think how else to explain)

cheapskatemum · 01/03/2023 15:06

To echo a pp, I was amazed at the amount of communication DS2 needed to use during RDA lessons: he had to listen to the instructor and physically convey the command to the horse. It was great for his receptive communication.

@AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman have you heard of Ros Blackburn? She has ASD, but you voice similar arguments to her.

Ariela · 01/03/2023 14:57

To follow up on the RDA, horse riding is immensely good for strengthening core muscles. I would highly recommend going for a look/trial.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 14:55

Sorry @Swimmingagainstthewide and others if I’ve upset you with my flippant comment about the riding. I found it grimly funny on first reading, but I’m not discounting the activity and what you describe sounds lovely from the point of view of DC’s interaction with the horses. We actually looked into riding twice in the past through funded schemes but were talked out of it because it was hugely expensive to the LA and DC was considered able to access cheaper stuff. But we’ve moved area since and time has passed so I’m genuinely grateful for the recommendation and will look into it again.

OP posts:
Balloontea · 01/03/2023 14:50

I get what you mean OP. My cousin is similar, he couldn't access mainstream education but the provision he was indeed fortunate to get wasn't overly suited either. He was with children who had much greater needs, and it meant he didn't really have anyone to socialise with and the teaching was very much above his understanding so he didn't really thrive.

Very lucky around here though in that the college had a fantastic course in which he made some great friends and was a much better balance between learning and socialising.

Also agree about clubs, there is a martial arts academy who provide lessons to those who require additional support for various reasons, but it's not accessible due to the price really. Understandable they charge more as they require more staff, but it's just a further disadvantage for many.

Provision is indeed patchy and there isn't much in between mainstream and requires a lot of support and additional care. For those who would be able to access clubs etc but with additional support there also aren't many opportunities for this.

Not suggesting it's a box of roses for any children or adults with disabilities, learning needs or anything else though- funding and support is lacking across the board sadly.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 14:49

RollerGirl7 · 01/03/2023 14:41

There was loads I didn't know that I've learned reading through this thread. Seems like a difficult situation for the children and parents dealing with this situation and you have my sympathy for having to struggle as much as you do to get your DC included.

Not sure what the answer is but hope that society is moving in the right direction and that it improves at some point.

Thanks @RollerGirl7 glad it was interesting 😊

OP posts:
RollerGirl7 · 01/03/2023 14:41

There was loads I didn't know that I've learned reading through this thread. Seems like a difficult situation for the children and parents dealing with this situation and you have my sympathy for having to struggle as much as you do to get your DC included.

Not sure what the answer is but hope that society is moving in the right direction and that it improves at some point.

WiddlinDiddlin · 01/03/2023 14:37

I don't know about the other stuff but curious that you have discounted Riding for the Disabled out of hand without actually doing any research at all?

Riders are matched with very steady horses, usually pretty 'short', chunky small cobs/big ponies - they are supported in EVERY way, so sometimes an able bodied rider behind them, and walkers either side holding onto knees/lower leg, plus someone leading the horse.

He stands more chance of injury in your car than on an RDA horse (as I doubt there are up to three people supporting him plus helmet and body protector in your car), but everything in life involves a certain element of risk - how far do you go down that route before he can do nothing at all?

The grim truth is, there isn't much for disability of any kind, and even less as we become adults.

Meeting the needs of a huge range of people with disabilities at the same time, in one club/activity, is damn near impossible, so trying to find activities that include everyone... pissing in the wind there, if there is something, chances are it's not something your DS is interested in anyway.

In some cases whilst inclusion within main-stream seems like the gold standard, it is just not possible and fighting against that isn't going to help your son right now.

Fighting for our rights - well we'd all like not to have to do that! (It's also the Equality Act you need to look at, it replaced the Disability Discrimination Act in 2010).

Be a bit more open minded about what he can do, where, with whom - don't narrow the options further by discounting things out of hand without research.

Be prepared to fight for it - yeah, we shouldn't have to but... we do.

Take the opportunities that are there, you'll be better off on the train pissing out than running down the platform trying to piss in!

countrygirl99 · 01/03/2023 14:35

Badbudgeter · 01/03/2023 14:28

I’d check this out locally. It’s generally done by charities who fundraise and the cost is just a couple of quid a session. A friends 10yo goes and it’s really positive. They aren’t romping through the fields though, The horse is walked on a short rein and they play games often involving throwing hoops or beanbags. Simple stuff but kids really enjoy it. She had a birthday party for some friends there and my children absolutely loved it.

It’s actually quite hard to fall off a horse that isn’t moving at speed. Other stuff that is available locally is a disabled swimming club and the local kayak group does a weekly disabled session run in the pool. Might vibe different in your area but both things worth checking out.

That's right the centres are very heavily subsidised by fund raising and dependent on volunteers. Some riders will never get past walk with 2 helpers, others will go further. A few centres have carraifmge driving as an option. Un mounted pony patting/brushing sessions are often available too.
One of my abiding memories is when we re-opened after covid and had riders back for meet the pony sessions and to update their assessments how many parents/carers said the riders were too excited to sleep the night before and how many buried their faces in their favourite ponies mane and cried they had missed them so much.

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/03/2023 14:34

I think people are confusing the term learning difficulty with learning disability. They are not the same.

A learning difficulty may be something like dyslexia which had no bearing on IQ whereas a learning disability refers to an IQ under 70.

Badbudgeter · 01/03/2023 14:28

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 13:45

Thanks for the recommendations. Not being funny @Swimmingagainstthewide, really, but if DC is already struggling with a learning disability, is risking a blow to the head a great plan? Imagine would also be at more risk than the average rider of falling off as balance and poor core strength are issues. Apart from that it honestly sounds like a great idea. Assume it’s very expensive.

I’d check this out locally. It’s generally done by charities who fundraise and the cost is just a couple of quid a session. A friends 10yo goes and it’s really positive. They aren’t romping through the fields though, The horse is walked on a short rein and they play games often involving throwing hoops or beanbags. Simple stuff but kids really enjoy it. She had a birthday party for some friends there and my children absolutely loved it.

It’s actually quite hard to fall off a horse that isn’t moving at speed. Other stuff that is available locally is a disabled swimming club and the local kayak group does a weekly disabled session run in the pool. Might vibe different in your area but both things worth checking out.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 14:27

@Timesawastin yes, ‘so-called inclusion’ is rubbish for everyone if it’s not really working for the most vulnerable and yes, a good specialist placement can be fantastic as far as school goes.

But my DC has always wanted to be very sociable, and was actually quite popular in mainstream until the others’ interests really outpaced DC. Now DC is surrounded by kids who struggle especially with social interaction- that doesn’t make it easy to make friends.

Also why should DC be hidden away with only other disabled kids all the time? If I want to host a birthday party for DC, why do I who am already exhausted from caring, have to host a room full of kids with behavioural issues? I could do parties in mainstream with a handful of kids with ASD and learning disabilities and the other 20 kids from the mainstream class and I was good at it. I just can’t cope with a whole class full of kids with additional needs- but that hurts my DC and their classmates that it doesn’t happen now.

OP posts:
McGonagallshatandglasses · 01/03/2023 14:20

This conversation is complicated by a lack of shared language.

Somehow in the uk 'academic disability' is used for what we in Australia would say are 2 entirely seperate groups (with potential crossover).

Here it's 'intellectual disability' or ID for someone with an IQ below 70. Moderate if 50-70, severe if below 50. My sister falls into this category.

Alternatively we use the term 'learning disabilty' LD to describe people with dyslexia, dyscalculia and dysgraphia. People who have something blocking their ability to learn in a typical manner but with an IQ in the average or above average range.

Many with an LD will be successful in mainstream schools with the right supports and it doesn't preclude independent adult life. But an ID is different. And that's what you are describing.

For what it's worth, my mother fought to keep my sister in a mainstream environment. At 16 we had no option anymore and we spent quite a long time trying to work out what options were open to us. At 31 she's living independently, with support workers helping with almost all life domains. She will never be safe to drive. No possible workplace has been identified despite lots of expert supports. Learning still happens, but it's sloooooowww.

I'm sorry you are struggling to find a place you feel like your child can be included. You are right, your child should be welcome in sports and clubs but often that welcome will be hollow. And all children should be able to have their needs met in their local school and community- but England really doesn't do inclusive education well, and specialist provision does have some benefits. For my sister, it wasn't till her late teens that she was ever in a space where she was successful and the 'best' at something. I think she'd have been happier if we'd found somewhere earlier that gave her that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread