Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the inclusion/equality is for people with learning disabilities?

235 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 12:36

Or if you prefer, people with academic disabilities.

For full disclosure I have a secondary-aged DC who was initially diagnosed with global developmental delay. This was upgraded to ‘academic/learning disability’ when DC failed to catch up by the age of 5.

Mainstream school isn’t equipped to support inclusion for DC who can’t more or less keep up with the curriculum at the pace of the rest.

Specialist placements mean mixing only with other families of DC with learning disabilities.

Hobbies and clubs are difficult unless specially for DC with learning disabilities so again no mixing outside of that limited circle.

Support groups are usually targeted at Downs Syndrome or ASD etc so no welcome there.

Those with physical disabilities eg wheelchair users, those with CP, those who are Deaf regularly make a point like this: ‘I’m in a wheelchair/Deaf/etc, I don’t have a learning disability, so don’t talk to me as if I were stupid.’ All very well but where is the solidarity for DC like mine? Is it ok to talk to them as if they’re stupid because they do have a learning disability?

Even those with ASD, who make up a sizeable proportion of my DC’s peers at the specialist placement, are keen to point out that it’s any learning disability, not ASD, that is really disabling, again taking care to distance themselves from any solidarity with those like my DC.

AIBU to wonder what is left for us?

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 02/03/2023 18:12

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 02/03/2023 17:54

Ah, ‘if they’re able’. Like ‘of course disabled shoppers are welcome, if they’re able to get up the steps into the shop.’

No, not like that at all. Like you're welcome to come fishing....if you have a rod. You're welcome to come GoKarting....if you can see, you're welcome to join in Scouts if you're able to follow simple instructions (to keep everyone safe), you're welcome to watch the play/cinema/band provided you're able to sit reasonable quietly and not screach/cry throughout...
Reasonable adaptions need to be reasonable. If your child takes twice as long to understand something, or maybe will never truely understand, what adaption do you want? I'm not being deliberately awkward. I don't get what you want and how society (we) can help.

HedgeRin · 02/03/2023 18:08

Before it’s implied it was behavioural. She has never been aggressive, or acted out. I’m talking risk more that she was asked to leave at 2am and she’d do as she was told, leaving the door open. Or she’d leave the gas on. Or she’d give the address to nutters who thought she’d give them her benefits or had access to a nice house. She was passive in herself and complied. Her own harmful acts were self harms and attempts.

Its hard to describe how difficult it becomes to manage a very attractive older teen/ young adults told by the job centre they must attend courses (she can’t navigate transport, they’d expect her to be dropped off!). It’s horrible, but girls like this are a massive target sexually and financially

HedgeRin · 02/03/2023 18:02

Vegrocks · 02/03/2023 15:15

What support has she received since the diagnosis?

Supported housing was the main thing. A social worker as needed, before being passed over to a charity. They manage things like housing benefit claims.

She was in a cycle of vulnerability and her mental health spiralled. I couldn’t keep the children safe with her behaviour and those drawn to her. The mental health team though kept saying they couldn’t manage her learning needs and bouncing her off from support.

Her ESA claim was moved to the group where she was constantly failing work related training, eg turning up to the job centre and not ‘complying’ as she can’t log onto a computer. Her social worker found housing. She was previously housed with others, but didn’t fill in forms or manage rent and was evicted. She attracted people who preyed on her. She had a minor police record for something nobody with full capacity would have been given, shoplifting related but being taken there and told what to do.

I could go on for ages. Basically she was engaging in dangerous and risky behaviour I couldn’t manage, due to becoming a target for characters that meant harm on a college course she was entered on but dropped out of. She couldn’t understand such basic things, like they’d read a letter out loud and say it said she had to give money or do something fraudulent. I had very young children and she was here but I couldn’t keep them safe and support enough.

Since she’s had support she has not engaged in any similar behaviour, has built up her mental health and made a happy life.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 02/03/2023 17:54

Ah, ‘if they’re able’. Like ‘of course disabled shoppers are welcome, if they’re able to get up the steps into the shop.’

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 02/03/2023 17:53

Vegrocks · 02/03/2023 16:11

I’d also be interested in what your point was about who you invite to parties?!

I'm confused here too. It seems she's saying when her son went to mainstream school she would happily host a party for 'mainstream' kids....but now he's at a 'special school' the majority of his friends have 'special needs'. She feels society should be 'inclusive' but doesn't want to include her sons friends because their behavioral problems are hard to manage/not what she wants to deal with. I'm can't see what the difference is. 5 pages on im still unsure what she wants/expects.

bigbabycooker · 02/03/2023 17:51

@AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman

I can understand why you are upset with the comment.

I think inclusion can a really tricky one, actually, as kids grow up. I think that running (parkrun) is probably a good example where you can find inclusion (because everyone can do it to a degree) or amateur dramatics where you can match for skill etc. or riding or sailing, where most people will do it as a hobby with no real expectations of getting to a certain level by a certain point.

The harder ones are the skills leading towards particular levels or competitions - I imagine that most people who do ballet, swimming or gymnastics lessons etc above a certain age are probably getting really adept at it and taking grades etc, so it is perhaps then harder to find someone of the same age just doing it for fun to mix with. I agree that there should be more of a range of social or fitness focused clubs that people with learning disabilities can be included in, though.

I went to a basketball social/for fun club alongside playing full competitively in my youth and the coach would ensure that there was a mix of abilities in each team; there were some really good teenage players (including his son) who could make all the baskets they wanted to, but were put in assistant coaching roles and played in those teams that had weaker players so that they could keep the team in the game and set up plays that would keep weaker players involved. This kind of thing could absolutely work and there should be more of it.

I can understand that a learning disabled child in an environment geared to children with ASD or physical disabilities without learning disabilities would be in a tough place.

JudgeRudy · 02/03/2023 17:31

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 02/03/2023 16:07

I’ve got a few minutes and I’m just really, really bothered by the ‘with his own kind’ comment from @JudgeRudy. Possibly that was their intent.

Read that back replacing ‘learning-disabled’ person with ‘black’ or ‘Jewish’ person. Ugh. It’s so obvious then.

It really feels like having a learning disability is the last minority where it is acceptable to exclude, to hold prejudice, to direct hateful views and hurtful comments. And like society is really pretty happy with that overall.

@AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman Hi there, I haven't looked through previous comments but I wasn't intending to offend or concern. I'm pretty sure I've said I have no issues with anyone joining in with anything....if they're able. You're suggesting exchanging learning disabled for eg Jews but that's really not the same. It would be like exchanging learning disabled with eg persons above 120cm or people with a drivers licence.
By 'kind' I wasn't implying someone was a separate breed....but clearly a LD child would probably not get much from attending a poetry recital event, in the same way I don't want to attend a jazz concert, a rugby match or a bridge tornement. I have no interest in the first two and no skill in the last. Id love to go skiing but im excluded because i cant affird it. Id also like to be in a band but im not musical.
Perhaps 'tribe' would be a better word, so they're able to form real friendships with people who connect on the same level. I'm not suggesting complete segregation.
I'm still unsure what AIBU or want is.

Vegrocks · 02/03/2023 16:11

Vegrocks · 02/03/2023 10:45

I want to host a birthday party for DC, why do I who am already exhausted from caring, have to host a room full of kids with behavioural issues? I could do parties in mainstream with a handful of kids with ASD and learning disabilities and the other 20 kids from the mainstream class and I was good at it.

can you elaborate on this op? Why would you have to host a room full of kids with behavioural issues? Surely you just invite whomever your son is friends with / wants to invite? I’m struggling with that point to find anyone to “blame” for not being inclusive in this scenario.

I’d also be interested in what your point was about who you invite to parties?!

Vegrocks · 02/03/2023 16:10

You really don’t want to answer my question Op re whether actual examples of clubs and activities where the organisers have precluded your son from joining

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 02/03/2023 16:07

I’ve got a few minutes and I’m just really, really bothered by the ‘with his own kind’ comment from @JudgeRudy. Possibly that was their intent.

Read that back replacing ‘learning-disabled’ person with ‘black’ or ‘Jewish’ person. Ugh. It’s so obvious then.

It really feels like having a learning disability is the last minority where it is acceptable to exclude, to hold prejudice, to direct hateful views and hurtful comments. And like society is really pretty happy with that overall.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 02/03/2023 15:49

Sorry, lots of people have commented but we’ve had teacher strikes here today. I’ll probably have more time later to read and respond

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 02/03/2023 15:48

Seaweasel · 02/03/2023 07:20

I work in mainstream education with a very diverse group of children and I just want to say, I hear you, OP. I don't know if I can comment constructively on solutions but I absolutely recognise the issues that you put forward. ASD, ADHD and epilepsy have all been addressed and recognised in my school through English and topic work, which is as it should be. Cognitive impairment, much less so. We have a lot of work to do here still.

Thanks @Seaweasel, it helps to know others see it too.

Language is so interesting isn’t it. I know the ‘d’ in ‘ASD’ is controversial- others prefer a ‘c’. I don’t really have skin in that game and I’ve said ‘ASD’ in this thread more or less without thinking. But ‘cognitive impairment’. It’s pretty blunt isn’t it. I’m not taking offence, but it is awfully interesting.

OP posts:
Vegrocks · 02/03/2023 15:15

HedgeRin · 02/03/2023 13:16

My sister is in this bracket, looks’normal’ as people comment. Behaviour is broadly typical, in the sense she is quiet/ withdrawn mostly- ie not a bother. It’s a nightmare getting her needs met, even professionals seem to just she ‘should’ve able to do things after looking at her.
We had a big thing with adult services, until her IQ was formally assessed as below 70. Couldn’t access anything. Despite a long history of needs and reports, it turned out that was the magic box adult services needed.

What support has she received since the diagnosis?

ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 02/03/2023 13:17

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/03/2023 09:41

And this is where as parents we come in. We engineer and create situations which allow our kids to access things in the way they want to (as much as possible).

Absolutely it’s for parents to support their kids in accessing as many opportunities as possible, however despite many varied attempts finding a mainstream gymnastics club, dance group, drama group, after school clubs who all say they cater to children with additional support needs when what they mean is they’re autism friendly. They don’t have the knowledge and understanding of GDD or developmental trauma and how those issues impact children and strategies for autism don’t tend to work with less understood or more complex issues.

I’ve offered to train staff/volunteers in these issues, agreed care plans and processes, I’ve yet to be taken up on the offer of training by any of the groups or clubs (I do this professionally so know what I’m talking about) and care plans invariably fall by the way side. Some of those relationships have ended disastrously when staff have worked against the care plan in place and have caused harm to my child because they think they know better.

Inclusion is a myth if the only way to “include” is to put all the kids with additional needs into a group or club separate from kids without those needs.

I’m sorry you’ve had that experience, whilst I’ve had some similar experiences it’s not all been like that for DS. But one of the things I’ve done (as well as training etc and volunteering so I could support participants and the staff) was set up my own groups which were open to all.

Don’t get me wrong, it’s not easy but it is possible.

And I totally agree with your last sentence.

HedgeRin · 02/03/2023 13:16

My sister is in this bracket, looks’normal’ as people comment. Behaviour is broadly typical, in the sense she is quiet/ withdrawn mostly- ie not a bother. It’s a nightmare getting her needs met, even professionals seem to just she ‘should’ve able to do things after looking at her.
We had a big thing with adult services, until her IQ was formally assessed as below 70. Couldn’t access anything. Despite a long history of needs and reports, it turned out that was the magic box adult services needed.

ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 02/03/2023 13:13

Elisheva · 02/03/2023 09:32

Ideologically, society should be completely inclusive of anyone with a difference.
I think this is a myth, that has actually become very harmful for many children with additional needs. Parents have been pedalled the idea that any school can be inclusive of their child if only the school tries hard enough, but it’s not true. And then these children are being denied a decent education.
Mainstream classes can only be differentiated so far. I work every day with children who will not be able to access and understand what is being taught in class, no matter how much support they have. It’s such a waste of their time, and so bad for their mental health and self esteem.
The myth of inclusion and the subsequent lack of spaces in special schools is criminal.

That’s why I said ideologically.

The reality is that this isn’t possible as things stand, if we stand by our principles we have the potential to damage our kids. So we adapt to do the best we can in difficult circumstances.

gogohmm · 02/03/2023 11:59

@AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman

I highly recommend riding, its heavily subsidised where dsd goes. I'm not sure why you mention a bump to the head, it's no more or less dangerous to your dc than others. Choirs are usually pretty inclusive, we had two with significant ld's in our church choir choristers and they were treated really well, despite one not actually singing! (He loved the robesSmile)

I think you need to try out different clubs, even branches because so much is down to the volunteers running them, some are more inclusive.

As to school, I fought for full inclusion and won, they wanted dd sent to special school

JusteanBiscuits · 02/03/2023 11:44

Just to clarify a little about our session.

We hold 3 sessions of the club. Unfortunately, due to it's nature, having mixed ability groups doesn't work as it would put the less able at risk, and also hold the more able back. So to over come the social aspect - which is very important - 5 of the kids from the earlier sessions also take part in the session for kids with additional needs to provide the social aspect and also to provide support and encouragement. So it's a 50/50 ratio. Three of those are teenagers who provide direct 1:1 support to the three kids that need it. It's actually been the making of the club, and changes are being made on a regional level for the sport on the back of it which is amazing. We seem to have found a balance that works - but maybe too well as we have more kids than places at the moment and saying no is so difficult.

blubberball · 02/03/2023 11:40

I understand where you're coming from, my ds sounds similar to yours. He has global developmental delay, learning difficulties and weak core muscles. We have tried many activities over the years. He went to swimming lessons, cubs, boxing, football, gymnastics and martial arts. At all of them, I've had to explain the situation, sometimes more than once, because his disabilities aren't obvious or visible. I've had to remind people that even though he is of an age, he is several years younger in his manner. It was always pretty tricky when we had a 5/6 year old tantrumming like a 2 year old. But as a 2 year old, he was very passive like a much younger baby.

JusteanBiscuits · 02/03/2023 11:32

If there is a particular interest he has, could you speak to a club about helping them be more inclusive?

Most clubs are run by volunteers and it can be incredibly hard setting up to be more inclusive. I run a youth sports club, and we have set up a specific session for kids with additional needs. But this has been an awful lot of work, on top of at least 5 hours a week simply running the club itself (on top of normal family life, my own kids, and full time work). We have a waiting list for this session as we're really limited on how many can come due to the extra support needed - and we've had complaints that we can't do more - we would totally bite the hand off anyone who offered to help support this!! But, we love it, and even had a teacher contact us recently to tell us what a difference we'd made to the life of one of the children which was amazing.

Vegrocks · 02/03/2023 10:45

I want to host a birthday party for DC, why do I who am already exhausted from caring, have to host a room full of kids with behavioural issues? I could do parties in mainstream with a handful of kids with ASD and learning disabilities and the other 20 kids from the mainstream class and I was good at it.

can you elaborate on this op? Why would you have to host a room full of kids with behavioural issues? Surely you just invite whomever your son is friends with / wants to invite? I’m struggling with that point to find anyone to “blame” for not being inclusive in this scenario.

countrygirl99 · 02/03/2023 10:00

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/03/2023 09:49

Parents have been pedalled the idea that any school can be inclusive of their child if only the school tries hard enough, but it’s not true.

I don’t think every school is right for every child, but I do think more children could be in mainstream if the school were fully resources to support this, but that costs money. Mainstream high school could never be made suitable for my DD, she literally couldn’t get herself to 6 different classes a day - and couldn’t switch her brain from one subject to another so quickly. She’s best placed in specialist provision. Other kids, with a bit of flexibility and support might manage well but that means resourcing schools so teachers have some wiggle room and we all know that’s not going to happen.

Simply put making schools, activities and clubs accessible in a meaningful way costs money - to provide enough well trained staff, equipment and time to accommodate those who have complex learning needs.

And most clubs are run by volunteers in their spare time. The reasons they are there will vary. Some will have an interest they get pleasure from passing on, some will be there to make sure the activity is available for their child, some will be volunteering to enhance their CV or to complete a DofE award. Make the training needed wide enough for them to be able to cope with a multitude of disabilities in the free time they give up and the activity will likely disappear for everyone because it's too onerous.
It's unfair but unless there are publicly funded helpers who can fit in with a range of activities it's hard to see an alternative solution.

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/03/2023 09:49

Parents have been pedalled the idea that any school can be inclusive of their child if only the school tries hard enough, but it’s not true.

I don’t think every school is right for every child, but I do think more children could be in mainstream if the school were fully resources to support this, but that costs money. Mainstream high school could never be made suitable for my DD, she literally couldn’t get herself to 6 different classes a day - and couldn’t switch her brain from one subject to another so quickly. She’s best placed in specialist provision. Other kids, with a bit of flexibility and support might manage well but that means resourcing schools so teachers have some wiggle room and we all know that’s not going to happen.

Simply put making schools, activities and clubs accessible in a meaningful way costs money - to provide enough well trained staff, equipment and time to accommodate those who have complex learning needs.

McGonagallshatandglasses · 02/03/2023 09:42

I know about schools being on the edge of discrimination. It's amazing how close they sail towards illegal while being careful to not give you anything specific to call them on.

One local to us accepted my severely dyslexic daughter but made it very clear that we shouldn't expect her to get an education. We didn't send her there.

Reading this thread I'm glad that intellectual disability seems to be a better understood description/category here than over there. It sounds like your biggest barrier is a lack of shorthand explanation of your child's needs/profile.

You are right, too, that by putting together all the children with higher needs your child is now spending a lot of time in a space where the majority have social communication barriers and behavioural support needs that make for a chaotic environment. A different kind of chaotic than a mainstream school, and maybe the right place for academic support, but socially it may be just as big a misfit.

Unsolicited advice - is there a pool locally where you can not only have lessons but also spend an hour social swimming? Our local pool has two lanes roped off for water play and I've found that children can be quite inclusive and play together with other children in that space across ages and ability.

I'd also maybe put out feelers for any Paralympic gymnastics, swimming, diving or other sport your child might find interesting. A 'special' gymnastic team might give your girl a lot of what she is craving in terms of being 'normal' and having a life more like the girls in the media she's exposed to.

The other place we found inclusive was drama. Even if they were acting, the teachers were most often genuinely willing to work with a girl who was passionate about being there even though she was clearly some years behind her age peers. The mixed age groups worked to E's advantage. Amateur drama groups that put on their own productions also sometimes can work.

I like the above suggestions for parkrun and RDA.

Socially it's hard. Friendship requires common ground. Otherwise it's tokenism. It's not easy to be friends with someone who processes so slowly and whose likes and hobbies are often 'young' for their age. As an adult my sister has mostly friendships with others who have disabilities, because that's who she's got enough in common with for the friendships to last.

Another skill to consider working on is board games. Having something to do together can ease otherwise awkward social engagements.

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/03/2023 09:41

And this is where as parents we come in. We engineer and create situations which allow our kids to access things in the way they want to (as much as possible).

Absolutely it’s for parents to support their kids in accessing as many opportunities as possible, however despite many varied attempts finding a mainstream gymnastics club, dance group, drama group, after school clubs who all say they cater to children with additional support needs when what they mean is they’re autism friendly. They don’t have the knowledge and understanding of GDD or developmental trauma and how those issues impact children and strategies for autism don’t tend to work with less understood or more complex issues.

I’ve offered to train staff/volunteers in these issues, agreed care plans and processes, I’ve yet to be taken up on the offer of training by any of the groups or clubs (I do this professionally so know what I’m talking about) and care plans invariably fall by the way side. Some of those relationships have ended disastrously when staff have worked against the care plan in place and have caused harm to my child because they think they know better.

Inclusion is a myth if the only way to “include” is to put all the kids with additional needs into a group or club separate from kids without those needs.