Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the inclusion/equality is for people with learning disabilities?

235 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 12:36

Or if you prefer, people with academic disabilities.

For full disclosure I have a secondary-aged DC who was initially diagnosed with global developmental delay. This was upgraded to ‘academic/learning disability’ when DC failed to catch up by the age of 5.

Mainstream school isn’t equipped to support inclusion for DC who can’t more or less keep up with the curriculum at the pace of the rest.

Specialist placements mean mixing only with other families of DC with learning disabilities.

Hobbies and clubs are difficult unless specially for DC with learning disabilities so again no mixing outside of that limited circle.

Support groups are usually targeted at Downs Syndrome or ASD etc so no welcome there.

Those with physical disabilities eg wheelchair users, those with CP, those who are Deaf regularly make a point like this: ‘I’m in a wheelchair/Deaf/etc, I don’t have a learning disability, so don’t talk to me as if I were stupid.’ All very well but where is the solidarity for DC like mine? Is it ok to talk to them as if they’re stupid because they do have a learning disability?

Even those with ASD, who make up a sizeable proportion of my DC’s peers at the specialist placement, are keen to point out that it’s any learning disability, not ASD, that is really disabling, again taking care to distance themselves from any solidarity with those like my DC.

AIBU to wonder what is left for us?

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 10:16

Spendonsend · 03/03/2023 08:40

I just wanted to say that I do understand about the schools as we have had similar experiences with head teachers saying the most outlandish things to avoid us applying for a place. It is ASD in our case though.

I also find the special school miles from home difficult as it means you have no local friends. People travelled a 30 miles radius to his last school and relied on taxis. You dont ever get to do that thing where you wander down the local park and some class mates happen to be there.

Thanks for understanding @Spendonsend. I’m sorry you’ve had that dreadful experience with schools too.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 10:12

Notonthestairs · 03/03/2023 08:31

Ive been reading this thread and held off from posting. However I thought I'd jot down what (from a similar position) I have thought and noticed. Its not intended in anyway to tell you what to do, just a reflection of our experiences.

Class parties stop after Yr 3. Then its all about working out the 5-10 children who are closest and hopefully kindest to your child. You focus your attentions on them (lots of playdates even if not reciprocated) and any activity they can do together (cooking, crafting, minecraft, cinema, bowling).

From Yr 5 onwards children become a bit more aware of the wider world - secondary school looming - and simultaneously become a little more conservative around diferent/alternative behaviours. The academic and behavioural gap between child and peers can lengthen - and the peers start noticing and in some instances commenting and being unkind. At this point many LD children opt to spend time with younger children who are less conservative in outlook - but it just doesnt work for long, they change too.

This continues in to the early years of secondary when fitting in and not being different seems key. This is also the point that the rest of the world is very intrusive and frankly worrying (use of SM etc).

At Yr 7 we moved in to a specialist provision (not suggesting you do the same). DD is academically able but needs a slow pace - just visting M/S schools overwhelmed her. I cant tell you how hard that was to accept. We had to face down that her life was going to be different and harder. We know disabled people of all ages are shunted to the sidelines - but going somewhere disabilities are normalised has been wonderful and she has gained confidence. I wish we had done it earlier. (I'll rant about underfunding elsewhere).

What also has been key was accepting that we werent able to match DD with children with the same diagnosis but that worthwhile friendships could be formed with a whole range of individuals of varying disabilities. Plus those parents understood how different life is for our children and we could work together. Facebook was very helpful as our Local offer webpage (County council).

Clubs designed for N/T people havent worked out that well - children move up groups as they progress and DD was left behind and most importantly noticed that she had been left behind.

So now we turn up to D/S groups, ASD groups, Riding for the disabled (excellent), disability swimming sessions, SN guide troops etc. Some have worked, some didn't - but the difference is that they understand about adapting things and want it to work. Worth pursuing on a suck it and see approach.

DD's childhood experiences will never be identical to my older children. But thats ok - we are doing our best to build her the best life we can.

Inclusion IS limited - sometimes by attitudes, sometimes by practicalities. I understand the frustration. But I can't change the world, I can only bend our immediate enviroment so thats what we do.

I hope you complained about those schools although I'd understand if you didnt have the energy. What they said was disgraceful.

Thanks @Notonthestairs for your thoughtful post.

I think In practical terms you may well be right about special needs clubs bring the best option for DC to socialise- I’m still at the point of being really heartbroken and angry that this further retreat from mainstream life is required.

I completely empathise with your description of accepting the move to specialist provision. We did that in Year 4 and we were suddenly hearing things like ‘some of our graduates know how to make their own lunch’ and the shift in expectations and aspirations was brutal. DC is actually now at a different, Y7-Y11 placement which is a much better fit. We are so impressed with them. But still…

I didn’t complain. I wish to God I had. One difficulty, which you will know perhaps, caring for a child with LD, is that the discriminatory arsehole on the other side of the discussion only has to say enough to hint at not wanting your child around, to win the conversation. No parent is going to risk putting a child who can’t express their own needs in a situation where they aren’t wanted. So by being angry with our temerity at turning up for the tour, that headmistress made sure in 30 seconds that we wouldn’t actually trust her school to care for our child.

OP posts:
onetimenamec · 03/03/2023 10:08

My experience with my students is that days out venues such as museums do seem to get it a lot and make provisions if they are asked. However, the support is lacking in their day to day learning experience and it just seems like a divergent path with their peers who would already have started accepting them when the scaffolding was in place to facilitate it during the early years.
Therefore, they either end up marginalized and isolated or are expected to slot into a special provision which does not work for them at all and at much greater expense.

Jellycatspyjamas · 03/03/2023 10:06

Would I be correct in thinking that previously in days gone by, this disability would have been described as "having the mental age of a x year old"?

I think it would have been but in my DDs case it wouldn’t help much because while she is developmentally delayed it’s not consistent across all parts of her development, some things she can manage in an age appropriate way, some things she needs a bit of scaffolding for and other things she can’t manage at all. The real problem is adults giving her instructions and thinking she’s heard and understood so leaving her to it. They then get irritated when she doesn’t manage.

My DD needs to be spoken to in short sentences, if they do that she can process information well and retain it, when they don’t the whole thing becomes scattered in her brain and she doesn’t understand what they mean. Of course she’s adept now at masking which means she’ll try to work out what s been said and figure it out from there, which means she invariably doesn’t quite get things right. Workers then think she’s being willfully difficult, treat it as a behavioural issue and shame her. It’s the difference between saying “go to the changing room, get your gym shoes out of your bag and put them on” and “put your gym shoes on”. She can follow the second instruction but the first, while clear, is too long. What she will remember is something like “go, bag, put on” so will come back with her gym bag. Despite repeatedly explaining how to direct my DD workers continuously forget to keep instructions short and direct.

What I’d like is for there to be a much better understanding of the complexities that encompass learning disabilities and processing difficulties and for people to trust that I as her parent know how to help her understand what’s needed of her. To know that one size doesn’t fit all and that different strategies work for different children. While my DD has complex needs it would actually be relatively easy to make activities inclusive for her.

NoCatsToday · 03/03/2023 10:05

For inclusion to work in the way you desire it has to be systemic and we're just not there as a society.

As they reach their teens children gravitate towards social groups that frequently look like them from an academic and social perspective. These teens grow up to become adults like us who largely have friendship groups, connections and activities with the these things in common. Finding a commonality with a teen or adult who is significantly different is harder and thus the majority don't bother. I'm not saying it is right but it is what happens.

Up thread you dismissed the focus on clubs as a means of inclusion OP. I think this is a mistake. It is when teens and adults do things together in club scenarios that they find commonalities that go beyond class, race or academic ability. You can't change society overnight but small changes will make a difference to you and your DC.

FWIW my DC has ASD. He's 16 and at a mainstream school but has no neurotypical friends. He hangs out with the other ASD kids and they celebrate their differences with nicknames etc. He seems happy. There is something to be said for having the support of your peers.

Owlatnighttime · 03/03/2023 10:03

I think that despite the absolute determination of some ‘not to understand’ this has been one of the most thoughtful and sensitive threads I’ve read for ages.

I don’t want to take away from your thread OP, but I have a relative with autism, no LDs but very vulnerable in all sorts of ways.

I have found it at various times exhausting, upsetting, lonely and isolating because there seems to be so little understanding of the grey space that exists between fully functioning adult and adult needing support. Like you, I’ve had people fire suggestions at me that are well meaning but aren’t remotely appropriate or to be honest, helpful. The last thing I want is to denigrate peoples kindly meant suggestions but the Riding For Disabled is a really good example of this. You’re posting about a position of isolation emotionally as well as socially and someone comes along and with one suggestion thinks they’ve somehow solved all the ills and prejudices of society! It doesn’t mean it’s a ‘bad’ suggestion but it’s not (I don’t think) what you were getting at.

And the posts above re ‘what can you bring to the table’ in a way that others wouldn’t be expected to adhere to is so true.

onetimenamec · 03/03/2023 10:02

Hi OP, I work in a related field. I recently started a thread about a dilemma facing one of my students and while some responses were brilliant, there was always that one poster who was piling on the nasty comments about complaining parents being liars or de3finitely having vulnerabilities themselves. It is an awful situation because primary support is much improved but it falls off a cliff beyond secondary age. The time and resources do not seem to be there and there is less compassion for students going through puberty compared to cute, little infants school kids.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 09:51

MissHoneysHappyEnding · 03/03/2023 08:08

I get you OP, and it's ok to just have a moan without necessarily expecting solutions.
The trouble is that we aren't allowed to talk about autism anymore without thinking of gifted millionaires, we're not allowed to think of ADHD as hyperactive boys anymore. And LD just doesn't fit into the new 'inclusivity' which is actually possibly more exclusive than before. We did a sort of session for adults with autism, most who have LD as well and it was a real struggle to find famous people with LD or even recognisable people with LD. There just isn't that Temple Grandin/ Richard Branson type figure.
I see it with my DD who is emotionally a few years behind her peers as well as academically. She is like a reception kid, but in year three. We're getting the sympathy invites and the sort of mumblings about things which may have happened over the weekend. She doesn't see it but I do.
I also don't want her to just have friends who have additional needs. In the same way that I don't want my NT boy to just invite the NT kids to his party's. Then again, how many adults can honestly say that they have friends with LD or autism?
I worry for my daughters future, she is so trusting and over shares. I think she will feel the need to socialise and won't necessarily be able to assess intentions or boundaries.

Thanks @MissHoneysHappyEnding

I think you make a really good point about ‘new inclusivity’. It seems to be all about Paralympians and war vets and tech geniuses and how ‘inspiring’ they can be, which is sickly and a bit infantilising even to some of the folks it includes- but what it does actually is make inclusion about what you can bring to the table. Prove your worth in some slightly non-standard way.

I understand your fears for your daughter. God it’s so scary.

OP posts:
Dancingcactus · 03/03/2023 09:47

"Would I be correct in thinking that previously in days gone by, this disability would have been described as "having the mental age of a x year old"?"

I sometimes, as a quick way of explaining to people, say my son has the understanding similar to a 2 year old with autism on top.
I don't like it when people say things like "like a 2 year old" because he has 14 more years of lived experience and is an almost adult who deserves the same dignity and respect as other 16 year olds.

JustKeepBuilding · 03/03/2023 09:46

Anything that educates or trains, including therapies, is educational provision, rather than health provision, so should be in F. Therefore, if the NHS can’t or won’t provide the provision the LA must. If they don’t and the provision is detailed, specified and quantified you can force them to, via judicial review if necessary. You may have to appeal to get watertight provision in F in the first place though. It is harder to enforce health provision in G, but not impossible.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 09:41

Starryskiesinthesky · 03/03/2023 07:33

This is awful. And must be exhausting for you to face on repeat. Society needs to be more inclusive of everyone’s needs.

I also think changing terminology hasn’t helped. In the old days everyone understood what ‘mental handicap’ was. I’m not saying it was a good term but I think learning difficulties / learning disability is confusing for people.

This is about people’s values though and having an inclusive society has a long way to go

@Starryskiesinthesky I replied too quickly. Thank you again for your understanding. I agree that terminology is unhelpful.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 09:39

Ha ha! @JustKeepBuilding there are some health provisions in the EHCP. They don’t seem to be worth the paper they’re written on. Our favourite paediatrician was incensed at the idea that ‘education’ could think of telling her lauded self what to do with a patient.

OP posts:
JustKeepBuilding · 03/03/2023 09:37

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 09:32

Thanks @Starryskiesinthesky. That’s interesting about the parameters of your team. Are there other teams who work with adults who don’t have health issues?

Currently my DC is very healthy, and as such discharged by the community paediatric team to ‘toddle along fine with an IQ below 70’. (Direct quote from paediatrician who discharged us- she wasn’t quite stupid enough to write it down but told us in front of DC, for those who need to hear more examples.)

About distressed behaviour, DC ‘self-soothes’ (or self-harms?) by scratching and maintaining bleeding sores especially on the face and neck. We’ve been dismissed by CAMHS once as not meeting thresholds. It seems to be not distressed enough?

So we feel very unsupported in that sense.

Support and therapies can be included in EHCPs even when DC don’t meet the normal threshold. If they are in F they must be provided even if the LA have to commission independent provision. If they are not in DC’s EHCP already you need an early review to try to get them included.

HedgeRin · 03/03/2023 09:34

Just to back up the OP, both for my sister and middle child her experiences some entirely relatable.

For me with my child it was amazing how many private nurseries just didn’t reply. As they were only 18 months younger than their sibling it was starkly obvious. One told her, then went back on their place during the settling in process as they were a risk with other over ones being non-mobile/ non-sitting apparently. They needed 1:1. Another manager was actually decent enough to quietly tell me head office would block the space and go over her anyway, so as not to waste my time

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 09:32

Starryskiesinthesky · 03/03/2023 07:20

I work in a NHS community learning disability team although it is for adults with health or distressed behaviour issues. We do have links to social care who should be able to help. Do you have any contact with health or social care to see if they can advise / provide support?

Thanks @Starryskiesinthesky. That’s interesting about the parameters of your team. Are there other teams who work with adults who don’t have health issues?

Currently my DC is very healthy, and as such discharged by the community paediatric team to ‘toddle along fine with an IQ below 70’. (Direct quote from paediatrician who discharged us- she wasn’t quite stupid enough to write it down but told us in front of DC, for those who need to hear more examples.)

About distressed behaviour, DC ‘self-soothes’ (or self-harms?) by scratching and maintaining bleeding sores especially on the face and neck. We’ve been dismissed by CAMHS once as not meeting thresholds. It seems to be not distressed enough?

So we feel very unsupported in that sense.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 09:23

Owlatnighttime · 03/03/2023 07:14

@Vegrocks i have to say here that your badgering of the OP is really crossing a line. You are firing posts at her and endlessly saying you don’t understand this and you don’t understand that. I don’t (to my knowledge - my son is only little) have first hand experience of this, but she has been perfectly clear and I understand. It is a grey space of no ‘clear’ diagnosis. If you don’t understand it, why not leave the thread to those who do?

Thank you so much @Owlatnighttime. I’m usually pretty lucid, I think, but I’m glad you understand.

I knew specific examples would be disbelieved or reasoned away- they always always are.

As to what I want, yes I want my DC - and others with learning disabilities of whatever severity- to be able to participate fully in society. So yes to being included in activities that involve others with or without disability, with or without ASD. Yes to frequent opportunities for social contact outside of school. Not only ever, maybe, rarely, with the ‘correct’ category of other learning disabled folks. But definitely sometimes with some peers and friends from school. Rather like anyone else.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 09:13

Dancingcactus · 03/03/2023 06:07

My son (teenager) has a severe learning disability. Inclusion doesn't exist for people like him. He doesn't have equal access to health are etc. I would settle for separate equal provision for activities etc but that is not there either. Eg school holiday special needs activities don't take children as severe as him.

I am so sorry about the lack of provision for your son. The health care issue is frightening. I don’t think DC could ever safely be in hospital without me or DP and even then it’s hit and miss whether the HCPs understand us.

OP posts:
Gensola · 03/03/2023 09:04

@Vegrocks what is your problem? Why don’t you go off and pick at and bully someone else?

JustKeepBuilding · 03/03/2023 08:48

Vegrocks · 03/03/2023 06:06

Yes but

The only reason the local authority can refuse the request is if:

The setting is unsuitable for the age, ability, aptitude or special educational needs (“SEN”) of the child or young person; or
The attendance of the child or young person would be incompatible with the provision of efficient education for others; or
The attendance of the child or young person would be incompatible with the efficient use of resources.

and a at capacity class of 30x 4 and 5 year olds in their first ever year of school - the above would apply in the overwhelming majority of cases as a legal reason to refuse a request

No it wouldn’t. DC with EHCPs, which if you read the OP’s posts you would know her DC has, placed after the national offer day are classed as excepted pupils for ICS purposes, and the bar to prove incompatibility is higher than many realise. Case law shows it is more than an “adverse effect”, “impact on” or “prejudicial to”.

ColonelSpondleClagnut · 03/03/2023 08:47

Would I be correct in thinking that previously in days gone by, this disability would have been described as "having the mental age of a x year old"?
I used to go to a parents group with a lady who had a child of school age, and she always used to explain that the child had the mental age of an 18month old. It may not be correct now but it was a simple way of expressing quickly to someone else what they could expect from the child and how to interact with them.

Spendonsend · 03/03/2023 08:40

I just wanted to say that I do understand about the schools as we have had similar experiences with head teachers saying the most outlandish things to avoid us applying for a place. It is ASD in our case though.

I also find the special school miles from home difficult as it means you have no local friends. People travelled a 30 miles radius to his last school and relied on taxis. You dont ever get to do that thing where you wander down the local park and some class mates happen to be there.

Notonthestairs · 03/03/2023 08:31

Ive been reading this thread and held off from posting. However I thought I'd jot down what (from a similar position) I have thought and noticed. Its not intended in anyway to tell you what to do, just a reflection of our experiences.

Class parties stop after Yr 3. Then its all about working out the 5-10 children who are closest and hopefully kindest to your child. You focus your attentions on them (lots of playdates even if not reciprocated) and any activity they can do together (cooking, crafting, minecraft, cinema, bowling).

From Yr 5 onwards children become a bit more aware of the wider world - secondary school looming - and simultaneously become a little more conservative around diferent/alternative behaviours. The academic and behavioural gap between child and peers can lengthen - and the peers start noticing and in some instances commenting and being unkind. At this point many LD children opt to spend time with younger children who are less conservative in outlook - but it just doesnt work for long, they change too.

This continues in to the early years of secondary when fitting in and not being different seems key. This is also the point that the rest of the world is very intrusive and frankly worrying (use of SM etc).

At Yr 7 we moved in to a specialist provision (not suggesting you do the same). DD is academically able but needs a slow pace - just visting M/S schools overwhelmed her. I cant tell you how hard that was to accept. We had to face down that her life was going to be different and harder. We know disabled people of all ages are shunted to the sidelines - but going somewhere disabilities are normalised has been wonderful and she has gained confidence. I wish we had done it earlier. (I'll rant about underfunding elsewhere).

What also has been key was accepting that we werent able to match DD with children with the same diagnosis but that worthwhile friendships could be formed with a whole range of individuals of varying disabilities. Plus those parents understood how different life is for our children and we could work together. Facebook was very helpful as our Local offer webpage (County council).

Clubs designed for N/T people havent worked out that well - children move up groups as they progress and DD was left behind and most importantly noticed that she had been left behind.

So now we turn up to D/S groups, ASD groups, Riding for the disabled (excellent), disability swimming sessions, SN guide troops etc. Some have worked, some didn't - but the difference is that they understand about adapting things and want it to work. Worth pursuing on a suck it and see approach.

DD's childhood experiences will never be identical to my older children. But thats ok - we are doing our best to build her the best life we can.

Inclusion IS limited - sometimes by attitudes, sometimes by practicalities. I understand the frustration. But I can't change the world, I can only bend our immediate enviroment so thats what we do.

I hope you complained about those schools although I'd understand if you didnt have the energy. What they said was disgraceful.

MissHoneysHappyEnding · 03/03/2023 08:08

I get you OP, and it's ok to just have a moan without necessarily expecting solutions.
The trouble is that we aren't allowed to talk about autism anymore without thinking of gifted millionaires, we're not allowed to think of ADHD as hyperactive boys anymore. And LD just doesn't fit into the new 'inclusivity' which is actually possibly more exclusive than before. We did a sort of session for adults with autism, most who have LD as well and it was a real struggle to find famous people with LD or even recognisable people with LD. There just isn't that Temple Grandin/ Richard Branson type figure.
I see it with my DD who is emotionally a few years behind her peers as well as academically. She is like a reception kid, but in year three. We're getting the sympathy invites and the sort of mumblings about things which may have happened over the weekend. She doesn't see it but I do.
I also don't want her to just have friends who have additional needs. In the same way that I don't want my NT boy to just invite the NT kids to his party's. Then again, how many adults can honestly say that they have friends with LD or autism?
I worry for my daughters future, she is so trusting and over shares. I think she will feel the need to socialise and won't necessarily be able to assess intentions or boundaries.

Starryskiesinthesky · 03/03/2023 07:33

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 02/03/2023 22:01

Some PPs are desperate for specific examples of exclusion. I’ve said generally that clubs have not been welcoming, that we have ‘the wrong type’ of disability for other disability specific clubs, and that schools have gone out of their way to put us off.

I suspect if I give specific examples they will be reasoned away as someone’s bad day, or my misunderstanding, or something else less than discrimination. But here are some of the ones that I don’t cry when retelling any more.

One school argued - in writing! - that they couldn’t offer a place to DC as the head was new to the post, expected an ofsted inspection imminently, and my DC would be a distraction. Also my DC might represent a trip hazard to other children in class. As if my DC were literally a great big thick short plank or two.

At another school, the head called us in for a private chat at the start of a group tour to say ‘I don’t really know why you’re here, our reception class is full already.’ We reminded her that DC had an EHCP and so had to be admitted if the LA agreed to name that school. She glowered with rage and said ‘my governors would never allow that’ - a legal nonsense - and spent the tour making unfounded asides to us: ‘Look at our brilliant art room - of course your DC wouldn’t cope with using it…’

A third school said ‘we don’t think we would be the right choice for your family- we are a very sociable school and we often have events like ceilidhs.’ Aside from the sheer perversity of using a selling point to push us away, if they only knew how much I long for a ceilidh. They could have had a free caller and access to discounted musicians. And before anyone jumps on me, DC loves a good ceilidh too. Footwork may not be precise but enthusiasm is all there. Brave enough to ask for a partner too, not just stick by me all night. Stupid school didn’t know what they were missing.

DC has a younger sibling at a dance class. They sometimes run open workshops in the holidays and are happy for DC to go along to those. DC loves it. The teachers steadfastly ignore any message asking about opportunities for DC to be involved more regularly. I can’t push it further because I can’t spoil it for younger sibling but honestly it does spoil it a bit because why can’t they at least have a conversation with me.

And so on ad nauseam.

This is awful. And must be exhausting for you to face on repeat. Society needs to be more inclusive of everyone’s needs.

I also think changing terminology hasn’t helped. In the old days everyone understood what ‘mental handicap’ was. I’m not saying it was a good term but I think learning difficulties / learning disability is confusing for people.

This is about people’s values though and having an inclusive society has a long way to go

Vegrocks · 03/03/2023 07:31

Ok I’ll bow out