Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the inclusion/equality is for people with learning disabilities?

235 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 12:36

Or if you prefer, people with academic disabilities.

For full disclosure I have a secondary-aged DC who was initially diagnosed with global developmental delay. This was upgraded to ‘academic/learning disability’ when DC failed to catch up by the age of 5.

Mainstream school isn’t equipped to support inclusion for DC who can’t more or less keep up with the curriculum at the pace of the rest.

Specialist placements mean mixing only with other families of DC with learning disabilities.

Hobbies and clubs are difficult unless specially for DC with learning disabilities so again no mixing outside of that limited circle.

Support groups are usually targeted at Downs Syndrome or ASD etc so no welcome there.

Those with physical disabilities eg wheelchair users, those with CP, those who are Deaf regularly make a point like this: ‘I’m in a wheelchair/Deaf/etc, I don’t have a learning disability, so don’t talk to me as if I were stupid.’ All very well but where is the solidarity for DC like mine? Is it ok to talk to them as if they’re stupid because they do have a learning disability?

Even those with ASD, who make up a sizeable proportion of my DC’s peers at the specialist placement, are keen to point out that it’s any learning disability, not ASD, that is really disabling, again taking care to distance themselves from any solidarity with those like my DC.

AIBU to wonder what is left for us?

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 04/03/2023 12:31

I think what I mean is, if we had access to a professional who cared they could presumably make educated suggestions about available support. But we struggle on.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 04/03/2023 12:29

I agree that if I knew what I wanted and why I could make a better argument. You are right though that it is hard to know what would be useful. I’m sure there are things that might help that I can’t even imagine.

@Spendonsend is right that one good professional helping would make a big difference.

I remember early on we asked the paediatrician- that same one- for help with sleeping. DC has always spent more time in the night awake than asleep. Paediatrician said that it was our fault as we had failed with sleep training as a baby, and we must put a stair gate on the door, take all toys from the room and unscrew the lightbulbs so that DC learned nighttime was a boring time for sleep. She said DC would scream and cry for attention a lot but we must ignore DC as we had caused the problem.

We were still at the point of assuming the paediatrician had good advice and we did it. DC never cried. DC is mostly well behaved and keen to be good. But we had smearing every night for months. Poor DC was utterly bored and playing with what was available. It only stopped when we put the toys and the light back.

DC still doesn’t sleep at night and I have no clue what to ask for that might help.

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 04/03/2023 10:09

Unfortunately here learning disability doesn’t seem to qualify as a health need. We get told a lot that DC’s ability is ‘in line with overall development’ - which feels a lot like they are saying DC is a bit crap at everything and so they won’t bother to help.

While a learning disability might not qualify as a health issue, I’d argue not attending to the learning disability will give rise to health issues. Being able to be understood and understand others is a huge need, and SALT cover so much more. It was SALT who identified the fracturing of my DDs processing - understanding how to explain things to her has massively helped her cope with day to day life. We found she had a hearing impairment that impacted her communication, language skills and literacy, just knowing she couldn’t hear properly has made a difference because she knows she’s missing something and can ask folk to repeat etc, and it turns out her hearing can be fully restored with surgery. My concerns about her hearing were written off as me not accepting her disability - I had to argue her into paediatric audiology who quickly found out what was going on.

I agree that knowing what you want and why is important- I’ve long stopped saying “she needs some kind of help with X”, I do a tonne of research and explain exactly what I think she needs and why. And then I stand my ground.

I also found having a specialist tutor has been incredibly helpful, she helps my DD learn how to learn in a way that she can follow, which builds her confidence. Her reading age has gone from 6 to 10 in 2 years, and her ability to explain her own thoughts and experiences has increased hugely as a result.

Its very hard but spending time on one issue, arguing that and then moving on to the next thing can work well. I also found that once I had one service on board others were more prepared to listen to me.

Notonthestairs · 04/03/2023 08:47

Spendonsend · 04/03/2023 08:15

I think the trick of arguing your case comes from knowing what you need and why. Otherwise you are just arguing for something please. Its incredibly hard to know what you need and why unless you get one good professional to help guide you. Noone helps and there are things you dont even know exist.

Absolutely.
We've found just understanding terms and processes a massive headache. It leaves us one step behind.
DD's SLT hours were cut year after year and I'd have to go back and question them. Now she's been discharged (rightly) and instead given some MH intervention at school - but I didn't know that therapy existed until it was flagged by her teachers.
We've been reliant on them for help. Her county case worker changes a couple of times a year so there is no continuity.

Spendonsend · 04/03/2023 08:15

I think the trick of arguing your case comes from knowing what you need and why. Otherwise you are just arguing for something please. Its incredibly hard to know what you need and why unless you get one good professional to help guide you. Noone helps and there are things you dont even know exist.

JustKeepBuilding · 03/03/2023 22:52

All DC are individual, but if you have been told that by anyone connected to the LA &/or NHS I would request an early review of the EHCP in order to try to get the right of appeal and seek independent assessments. Sadly, many LA & NHS assessments for the EHCP process are lacking. Independent assessments are more comprehensive, detailed, specified and quantified than the vast majority of LA reports.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 22:43

JustKeepBuilding · 03/03/2023 11:56

Both have weekly SALT, ‘normal’ OT, SIOT and clinical psychologist sessions. 1 has physio twice a week. The other has physio 3 times a week, rebound therapy once a week, and swimming (a session with mix of swimming, aqua-therapy and hydrotherapy but in a normal temp pool for medical reasons) once. Both also have smaller bits of provision/therapeutic input. They only have this level of provision because it is in their EHCPs.

SALT is about far mare than saying the beginnings of words when prompted and the scope of OT is vast. My DS’s who have SALT provision in their EHCPs have SALT needs, but can both speak, albeit they have selective mutism.

It sounds like you did really well for your DC @JustKeepBuilding. I find it hard to believe, as I am told, that such a level of provision would simply have no benefit for my DC. Thanks for sharing.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 22:40

Jellycatspyjamas · 03/03/2023 11:34

Equally if a child with CP struggled as much to fasten buttons, flush the toilet etc there would be a lot of physio and OT and eventually tools and workarounds. But I am just told to give lots of opportunities to practise.

I think the reality is there’s minimal support for any kind of disability unless you really argue your case, I’ve had meetings with agencies that have felt like I’m defending my Masters such was the need to evidence the supports I knew would help my DD.

Do you have access to community paediatrics? My DD was referred about 3 years ago and they have been fantastic in pulling together SALT, OT and CAMHS along with other health provision. Basically they met with my DD and I, and we had a full consultation covering her physical health needs, social, cognitive and emotional needs and came up with a plan. Community Paeds made all the referrals and coordinated various specialties through health - she has an annual review where we check progress with the various specialists and identify further supports needed.

It means one health professional has oversight of my DDs care and can identify her needs overall. She’s just been referred back to OT for support with personal care, for example.

Im in Scotland so I don’t know if this is available in the rest of the UK but worth exploring just in case. We don’t have the ECHP system here so having everything pulled together in one place in the health system is a godsend.

I do hear you about the need to argue your case. Sometimes I wonder what the trick is- I’m pretty well educated and I make a pretty strong argument and I get pushed back over and over.

The Scottish system of joined up health oversight sounds pretty sensible. Unfortunately here learning disability doesn’t seem to qualify as a health need. We get told a lot that DC’s ability is ‘in line with overall development’ - which feels a lot like they are saying DC is a bit crap at everything and so they won’t bother to help.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 22:31

Congratulations to Prof Arday. Cambridge is a fascinating place from a point of view of education, SEND and deprivation, never mind the prestige of his new post, so hopefully he will enjoy his time there.

I didn’t hear the interview, but if he did make a point about writing off children with GDD, assuming learning disability, then it sounds like he is also in the camp of defining autism over against learning disability. Where does it leave the children who do, actually, have a learning disability? If my DC doesn’t actually ever catch up; isn’t in fact very very clever in a way that’s hard to see - does my DC deserve to be written off?

OP posts:
Boomboom22 · 03/03/2023 17:43

On radio 5l this morning the first ever black professor at Cambridge was on. He didn't speak at all until 11 and had gdd. I felt very annoyed at his assumptions but also he had a point that society writes off these children with global development delay assuming they will have ld but he obviously is very very clever.

He talked about high self esteem being instilled from parents. It was quite interesting as I've never heard of an academic catch up like that before. Also Dr dance couldn't read and write until after age 18 and is now a professor.

So it does seem that learning can come much later even with children who were identified as very low in.

Not to dismiss the fact many do not, just upthread said there are no examples of gdd done well or ld.

ColonelSpondleClagnut · 03/03/2023 16:07

And I wouldn't discount Youth Club type places either. Teenagers can be right nobs, but they can also be some of the most caring and inclusive groups of people. Whilst giving off a general air of "whatever" obviously. 😬

ColonelSpondleClagnut · 03/03/2023 16:05

Speaking as a (board) gamer myself, a lot of us do it for the fun and the social interaction - although admittedly many of us are a bit awkward with the social side. And because there's so many games and new players, learning and picking up rules is something that everyone has to go through. Players have to develop patience and enthusiasm for explaining games otherwise no one would have anyone to play with if you see what I mean.
If you have a local gaming cafe I would highly recommend having a look. 🙂

Notonthestairs · 03/03/2023 12:14

Agree this is such a thought provoking thread. I'm mulling over views and experiences and think I will be for days to come. To be honest I'd don't think it's ever that far from my mind - I'll never know whether I made the right choices or pushed hard enough.

I think the difference in experience for DD came preteen - by age 10 she was far behind. Social nuances (currency in preteens and beyond) flew over her head. Interests diverged. Many children continued to be lovely and supportive but it only takes a few. And she noticed her differences and tried to make herself fit in. But it goes beyond eccentric interests.

The 7 form intake of our local schools probably would have meant she'd have found a friend somewhere in the deluge but the cost to her to find that would have been high.

Friendships form through shared interests and (in teen years) mirrored behaviour. She would have willingly altered herself to fit in and suppressed needs but the pressure would have been tremendous.

I see the same in my older NT kids - they are just beginning to assert their differences (whilst maintaining standard issue for our area teen boy haircuts, heaven forbid they stick out).

But it's a loss all round.

Gah. I'd like to use some good old fashioned Anglo Saxon terms here.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 12:00

Owlatnighttime · 03/03/2023 10:03

I think that despite the absolute determination of some ‘not to understand’ this has been one of the most thoughtful and sensitive threads I’ve read for ages.

I don’t want to take away from your thread OP, but I have a relative with autism, no LDs but very vulnerable in all sorts of ways.

I have found it at various times exhausting, upsetting, lonely and isolating because there seems to be so little understanding of the grey space that exists between fully functioning adult and adult needing support. Like you, I’ve had people fire suggestions at me that are well meaning but aren’t remotely appropriate or to be honest, helpful. The last thing I want is to denigrate peoples kindly meant suggestions but the Riding For Disabled is a really good example of this. You’re posting about a position of isolation emotionally as well as socially and someone comes along and with one suggestion thinks they’ve somehow solved all the ills and prejudices of society! It doesn’t mean it’s a ‘bad’ suggestion but it’s not (I don’t think) what you were getting at.

And the posts above re ‘what can you bring to the table’ in a way that others wouldn’t be expected to adhere to is so true.

Thanks so much @Owlatnighttime I see that you really do get it. I’m so sorry about the struggle to support your relative. In many ways vulnerable is just vulnerable and the exhaustion and isolation are no different for the family.

Interestingly enough, some of DC’s teachers have started to say we could explore assessment for ASD. It was written off by the lovely paediatrician as irrelevant either way, given that DC’s experience would be defined, she expected, by the learning disability.

I’m not sure what I think of that. An additional diagnosis of ASD would let us into that “club” but it might not be wise to try to join in, given that if anyone talks about ‘autism as a superpower’ I mostly want to slap them with a wet fish. Good for them, I suppose, with their superpowers, but it puts us back at what we can bring to the table. And most of my friends’ kids with ASD are too severely affected to have a ‘superpower’ anyway- rather like my DC.

OP posts:
JustKeepBuilding · 03/03/2023 11:56

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 11:15

You make a very good point. I can’t believe how easily I still fall back into expecting the LA to make sense. Of course when I go in expecting rubbish from them, they act like I must be deranged to be so suspicious. I think a person just gets tired, and wants the other party to speak plainly, after a while. It’s hard to describe how utterly weary I am sometimes.

No pressure to give details that are too personal, but I’d be interested to know more about the type and frequency of therapy you managed to secure. For instance, because DC can say the beginnings of words when prompted, it has been decided that SALT is not required to correct the fact that DC usually verbalises words starting at the second syllable - ‘puter’ for ‘computer’ etc. I don’t know how this is ever supposed to improve.

Equally if a child with CP struggled as much to fasten buttons, flush the toilet etc there would be a lot of physio and OT and eventually tools and workarounds. But I am just told to give lots of opportunities to practise.

Both have weekly SALT, ‘normal’ OT, SIOT and clinical psychologist sessions. 1 has physio twice a week. The other has physio 3 times a week, rebound therapy once a week, and swimming (a session with mix of swimming, aqua-therapy and hydrotherapy but in a normal temp pool for medical reasons) once. Both also have smaller bits of provision/therapeutic input. They only have this level of provision because it is in their EHCPs.

SALT is about far mare than saying the beginnings of words when prompted and the scope of OT is vast. My DS’s who have SALT provision in their EHCPs have SALT needs, but can both speak, albeit they have selective mutism.

Jellycatspyjamas · 03/03/2023 11:34

Equally if a child with CP struggled as much to fasten buttons, flush the toilet etc there would be a lot of physio and OT and eventually tools and workarounds. But I am just told to give lots of opportunities to practise.

I think the reality is there’s minimal support for any kind of disability unless you really argue your case, I’ve had meetings with agencies that have felt like I’m defending my Masters such was the need to evidence the supports I knew would help my DD.

Do you have access to community paediatrics? My DD was referred about 3 years ago and they have been fantastic in pulling together SALT, OT and CAMHS along with other health provision. Basically they met with my DD and I, and we had a full consultation covering her physical health needs, social, cognitive and emotional needs and came up with a plan. Community Paeds made all the referrals and coordinated various specialties through health - she has an annual review where we check progress with the various specialists and identify further supports needed.

It means one health professional has oversight of my DDs care and can identify her needs overall. She’s just been referred back to OT for support with personal care, for example.

Im in Scotland so I don’t know if this is available in the rest of the UK but worth exploring just in case. We don’t have the ECHP system here so having everything pulled together in one place in the health system is a godsend.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 11:33

@onetimenamec you are quite right that we are more accepting of ‘cute little kids’ with differences. I’m not sure why this is. I suppose the gap between expected ability and actual ability is smaller and that helps. You can also still hope or imagine that actually this kid will grow up to be just fine after a tricky start. And unwanted behaviours can be contained more easily.

You also make an interesting point that all the work done integrating the child with their peers at a young, impressionable stage is lost. DC was ultimately very welcome at their mainstream primary and I think the staff and other parents were genuinely very sorry to see us go. I think they were proud of themselves to have got so much right, and they deserved to be. But all those potential relationships are broken now, and that’s another 30 kids who will grow up ‘not being friends with anyone with a learning disability’ and probably feeling reluctant to try as adults.

OP posts:
LivingDeadGirlUK · 03/03/2023 11:23

Swimmingagainstthewide · 01/03/2023 13:39

Recommend horse riding for the disabled

I did this as a child and it was an incredibly lovely experience, there was a really wide range of disabilities there too. Unfortunately it didn't translate to adulthood as I found the wider 'horsey' community incredibly unwelcoming!

Another 'sport' I really enjoyed was trampolining, there is no competitive team element but lots of time to natter while waiting for your turn.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 11:21

ColonelSpondleClagnut · 03/03/2023 10:47

I see yes, and you wouldn't want them limited to only activities that would be suitable for a five year old either.

I know you're not necessarily looking for clubs or groups, but something like Games Workshop, (Warhammer, D&D) or another tabletop gaming group might be or become suitable. If you have a local gaming cafe they are often a lovely group of people, and can have a wide range of games going on ranging from full on multi session games, to Snap and Snakes and Ladders. Oh and of course Pokémon and other card based games!

Thanks that’s a nice suggestion 😊

A pp was scornful about the possibility of my DC ‘tagging along’ to youth group and not understanding Cluedo. But actually DC can play games like Uno and Carcasonne- not very strategically but with a lot of enjoyment of the social aspect of the game and a great deal of pleasure at a good final score.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 11:15

JustKeepBuilding · 03/03/2023 10:37

When you look into it, don’t trust what the LA or NHS tell you, they will tell you what they want you to know and their unlawful policies. Have a look at IPSEA and SOSSEN instead.

I have 2 DC who have therapies and other provision via their EHCPs that they wouldn’t get, or wouldn’t get to the same level/duration/frequency, via the normal routes.

You make a very good point. I can’t believe how easily I still fall back into expecting the LA to make sense. Of course when I go in expecting rubbish from them, they act like I must be deranged to be so suspicious. I think a person just gets tired, and wants the other party to speak plainly, after a while. It’s hard to describe how utterly weary I am sometimes.

No pressure to give details that are too personal, but I’d be interested to know more about the type and frequency of therapy you managed to secure. For instance, because DC can say the beginnings of words when prompted, it has been decided that SALT is not required to correct the fact that DC usually verbalises words starting at the second syllable - ‘puter’ for ‘computer’ etc. I don’t know how this is ever supposed to improve.

Equally if a child with CP struggled as much to fasten buttons, flush the toilet etc there would be a lot of physio and OT and eventually tools and workarounds. But I am just told to give lots of opportunities to practise.

OP posts:
ColonelSpondleClagnut · 03/03/2023 10:47

I see yes, and you wouldn't want them limited to only activities that would be suitable for a five year old either.

I know you're not necessarily looking for clubs or groups, but something like Games Workshop, (Warhammer, D&D) or another tabletop gaming group might be or become suitable. If you have a local gaming cafe they are often a lovely group of people, and can have a wide range of games going on ranging from full on multi session games, to Snap and Snakes and Ladders. Oh and of course Pokémon and other card based games!

JustKeepBuilding · 03/03/2023 10:37

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 10:33

Thanks for your patience @JustKeepBuilding. I will have another look at this.

When you look into it, don’t trust what the LA or NHS tell you, they will tell you what they want you to know and their unlawful policies. Have a look at IPSEA and SOSSEN instead.

I have 2 DC who have therapies and other provision via their EHCPs that they wouldn’t get, or wouldn’t get to the same level/duration/frequency, via the normal routes.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 10:33

JustKeepBuilding · 03/03/2023 09:46

Anything that educates or trains, including therapies, is educational provision, rather than health provision, so should be in F. Therefore, if the NHS can’t or won’t provide the provision the LA must. If they don’t and the provision is detailed, specified and quantified you can force them to, via judicial review if necessary. You may have to appeal to get watertight provision in F in the first place though. It is harder to enforce health provision in G, but not impossible.

Thanks for your patience @JustKeepBuilding. I will have another look at this.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 10:30

HedgeRin · 03/03/2023 09:34

Just to back up the OP, both for my sister and middle child her experiences some entirely relatable.

For me with my child it was amazing how many private nurseries just didn’t reply. As they were only 18 months younger than their sibling it was starkly obvious. One told her, then went back on their place during the settling in process as they were a risk with other over ones being non-mobile/ non-sitting apparently. They needed 1:1. Another manager was actually decent enough to quietly tell me head office would block the space and go over her anyway, so as not to waste my time

Thanks @HedgeRin , and I’m so sorry about those experiences with the nurseries- it’s just awful what they can get away with.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 03/03/2023 10:25

ColonelSpondleClagnut · 03/03/2023 08:47

Would I be correct in thinking that previously in days gone by, this disability would have been described as "having the mental age of a x year old"?
I used to go to a parents group with a lady who had a child of school age, and she always used to explain that the child had the mental age of an 18month old. It may not be correct now but it was a simple way of expressing quickly to someone else what they could expect from the child and how to interact with them.

You’re right @ColonelSpondleClagnut and I think that can still be a helpful shorthand. It was more helpful, I think, when DC was younger. Now it needs to be more nuanced, and I’m not honestly sure in all circumstances. DC likes to play in ways that are age-appropriate to a five year old, but as for understanding and world-view, I think they’re a bit more mature if only due to having experienced more…

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread