Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the inclusion/equality is for people with learning disabilities?

235 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 12:36

Or if you prefer, people with academic disabilities.

For full disclosure I have a secondary-aged DC who was initially diagnosed with global developmental delay. This was upgraded to ‘academic/learning disability’ when DC failed to catch up by the age of 5.

Mainstream school isn’t equipped to support inclusion for DC who can’t more or less keep up with the curriculum at the pace of the rest.

Specialist placements mean mixing only with other families of DC with learning disabilities.

Hobbies and clubs are difficult unless specially for DC with learning disabilities so again no mixing outside of that limited circle.

Support groups are usually targeted at Downs Syndrome or ASD etc so no welcome there.

Those with physical disabilities eg wheelchair users, those with CP, those who are Deaf regularly make a point like this: ‘I’m in a wheelchair/Deaf/etc, I don’t have a learning disability, so don’t talk to me as if I were stupid.’ All very well but where is the solidarity for DC like mine? Is it ok to talk to them as if they’re stupid because they do have a learning disability?

Even those with ASD, who make up a sizeable proportion of my DC’s peers at the specialist placement, are keen to point out that it’s any learning disability, not ASD, that is really disabling, again taking care to distance themselves from any solidarity with those like my DC.

AIBU to wonder what is left for us?

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 07/03/2023 11:27

And good for your DD @Fifi0000, and well done to you raising her to be accepting.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 07/03/2023 11:25

You're so right about exposure as well. I understand how it can be difficult to know what/how to say things at first, but just a few little habits and a bit of familiarity can make communication possible and then you've got a starting point.

@Jellycatspyjamas talked about how just simple modifications to language make a really big difference to her DD, and can be the difference between enabling her to participate or not. She's right that it's not a huge ask, you just have to know what to do and be willing to try it.

OP posts:
Fifi0000 · 07/03/2023 11:19

It's also exposure my NT DD regularly makes friends with people with LD and autism because from a very young age she knows I work in that field and how to communicate. It's not scary for her I think less othering more integration would really help.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 07/03/2023 11:19

You sound lovely @Fifi0000 😊

OP posts:
Fifi0000 · 07/03/2023 11:15

This has broke my heart, the best job I ever had was supporting people with learning disabilities. I used to have the group round for dinner , baking it's not allowed in my current role because of professional boundaries. Hopefully when I have time , I will volunteer for activity sessions and befriending.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 07/03/2023 10:43

No problem @cheapskatemum Thanks for the reply. Sounds interesting

OP posts:
cheapskatemum · 07/03/2023 10:36

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 01/03/2023 15:41

@cheapskatemum no I haven’t heard of Ros Blackburn. Curious. In what way similar?

When she was a child, her mother insisted that she go to mainstream activities & clubs. She has ASD and dyspraxia. She has carried on in the same mindset. She earns a living giving talks about autism.

Sorry for late reply, the latest phone update decided to switch off my email notifications 😐

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 05/03/2023 18:45

I think the answers have to do with changing the way we ascribe worth based on physical and intellectual prowess. I think we also have to change the way we idolise independence as the sine qua non of life.

I have a suspicion that some sort of communal life would work well for my DC- I don’t mean a manufactured community of half a dozen folk with learning disabilities and half a dozen under paid carers, but a real community that included our whole family and other families and individuals with and without disabilities of whatever kind.

It does upset me when I hear the families and extended families of kids with learning disabilities distancing themselves from the possibility of future care. If we can’t even have compassion towards the needs of our own family members it all seems a bit hopeless. But again I think this is down to the idolisation of independence- and a caring role would limit the independence of that sibling or cousin or grandparent of the person with learning disabilities. Also it comes back to the way we tell the mothers of these kids that it was their choice, and thus their fault, to end up with a disabled child.

OP posts:
onetimenamec · 05/03/2023 16:13

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 05/03/2023 14:22

That loser comment is pretty shocking @onetimenamec

I worry that the situation is ultimately hopeless for people like my DC because society at large doesn’t really ascribe full humanity to those with a cognitive impairment. If you can’t conceptualize and articulate your own worth, you are condemned.

This is actually the reason, I think, why care for those with dementia is so shockingly awful, and so punitive compared to the equally expensive care for say, those with cancer. We would be outraged if toddlers in daycare were treated the way people in dementia-related day care settings are treated and I think the main reason is that we still expect the toddlers to grow and learn, but the folk with dementia won’t and so they are written off.

I think my DC and others with learning disabilities are written off early but in a very similar way.

I couldn't agree more. I truly feel that the cost of living crisis and the knife-edge living through covid has made many people more self-centered and unfeeling towards the vulnerable whom they perceive as effectively stealing resources from themselves in times of scarcity.
Many of my SN students are being raised by mums who say that their relationships broke down because of the challenges directly/indirectly created by the SN. Many are NC with their own families by the time their children are teenagers often because lack of empathy. They ask me what will happen to their DC once they are no longer able to support them or if they suddenly died because their DC often have literally nobody - not one single other person who would go the extra mile for them or even tolerate them in their homes long-term. There is no easy answer.
Something needs to be put in place to extend the scaffolding as they grow older rather than offering a wide range of the resources at pre-school age and throwing them off the cliff in Year 12.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 05/03/2023 14:22

That loser comment is pretty shocking @onetimenamec

I worry that the situation is ultimately hopeless for people like my DC because society at large doesn’t really ascribe full humanity to those with a cognitive impairment. If you can’t conceptualize and articulate your own worth, you are condemned.

This is actually the reason, I think, why care for those with dementia is so shockingly awful, and so punitive compared to the equally expensive care for say, those with cancer. We would be outraged if toddlers in daycare were treated the way people in dementia-related day care settings are treated and I think the main reason is that we still expect the toddlers to grow and learn, but the folk with dementia won’t and so they are written off.

I think my DC and others with learning disabilities are written off early but in a very similar way.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 05/03/2023 13:52

That does seem like a real shame @LivingDeadGirlUK. The snootiness - Im so sorry the other kids were like that and also not very surprised. I think there is a lot to do with class at play for anything to do with horses because ultimately it’s a really expensive hobby.

OP posts:
LivingDeadGirlUK · 05/03/2023 13:09

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 04/03/2023 16:02

Hi @LivingDeadGirlUK, thanks for sharing your experience. Do I take it you were a ‘disabled rider’ for want of a better term? I’m sorry to hear that it didn’t translate into adulthood for you. Was it an unwillingness to keep making adaptations once you were an adult?

This is one of the concerns I have about RDA type activities, and one of the reservations about clubs aimed at learning disabilities being the solution - do they allow for building relationships that can continue into adulthood?

Yes I was a disabled rider, I'm sight impaired. I really enjoyed it and tried to talk to other kids at school who rode but they were really snooty because I didn't have my own pony. I tried to get part time work at stables so I could ride but it never came to anything and ultimately without being able to drive I couldn't persue it further afield. Possibly just a few bad experiences and bad luck but it seemed a shame!

onetimenamec · 05/03/2023 12:24

One of the students I supported was described as a "class mascot" by his form tutor during parents' evening. The parent was dreadfully upset and asked me what I thought. The (newly qualified ) teacher was trying to convey that the other NT students liked having him in their class. However, the mother only wanted her son to have friends, not be fetishized in this way.

Later on in the year, another teacher described her son as being " a loser". When probed, he meant that in a situation of bullying, her son would always lose out. However, we all know the main usage of that word in a school setting with teenagers. This was a senior teacher in charge of behaviour and once again, meant in good faith (believe it or not).

I suspect that they don't really have the vocabulary, the empathy or the concern needed for SN students to be fully supported and thrive and they wont make it priority.

boboshmobo · 04/03/2023 19:59

I got a job for this reason , no school run and his friends grew out if him!

I don't get what you means about mixing with the sn school though ? They are the same parents as you

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 04/03/2023 19:45

I agree about connection but I’m a bit hesitant about being ‘at the same level’. I’m not sure if that necessary or even possible

OP posts:
Boomboom22 · 04/03/2023 17:32

Yes it's really hard, true friends need to connect so it needs to be something he can be at the same level at so they are not humouring him but wanting to spend time together.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 04/03/2023 16:34

NoCatsToday · 03/03/2023 10:05

For inclusion to work in the way you desire it has to be systemic and we're just not there as a society.

As they reach their teens children gravitate towards social groups that frequently look like them from an academic and social perspective. These teens grow up to become adults like us who largely have friendship groups, connections and activities with the these things in common. Finding a commonality with a teen or adult who is significantly different is harder and thus the majority don't bother. I'm not saying it is right but it is what happens.

Up thread you dismissed the focus on clubs as a means of inclusion OP. I think this is a mistake. It is when teens and adults do things together in club scenarios that they find commonalities that go beyond class, race or academic ability. You can't change society overnight but small changes will make a difference to you and your DC.

FWIW my DC has ASD. He's 16 and at a mainstream school but has no neurotypical friends. He hangs out with the other ASD kids and they celebrate their differences with nicknames etc. He seems happy. There is something to be said for having the support of your peers.

@NoCatsToday you said finding a commonality with a teen or adult who is significantly different is harder and thus the majority don’t bother

I think you’re sadly right. I hear a lot, even on this thread, the comment ‘Well I don’t have disabled friends so why should I expect my kids to befriend disabled kids.’ And even ‘Lafayette I bet you don’t have any disabled friends so how can you expect people to spend time with your DC.’

A couple of things to say there- there are actually more opportunities now for kids in mainstream school to meet kids like my DC. That didn’t happen so much when I was in school. So let’s embrace the opportunity. Kids at my DC’s mainstream primary actually did that quite well while it lasted.

Secondly, since when should we treat any kid according to what we think their parent has deserved?? As it happens my friendship group over the last 4 decades has included two or three wheelchair users, a couple of folk with CP, a few with chronic illnesses, some folk with visual impairment, many with ASD, and one lady with a significant learning disability. Some are still friends now, one I married. Have I been ‘good’ enough to earn friends for my DC??! What a nonsensical question. To be honest I feel grubby even writing that, it’s not how I think, these people are just friends because they are nice people and I’ve enjoyed their company. I’m pretty sure they’ve enjoyed mine. My DC is also a nice person, as it happens, and can be great company.

There is something to be said for having the support of your peers - yes I think that’s true too. It sounds nice. Part of the difficulty for my DC is that the potential peer group at school are inclined to define themselves against my DC.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 04/03/2023 16:02

LivingDeadGirlUK · 03/03/2023 11:23

I did this as a child and it was an incredibly lovely experience, there was a really wide range of disabilities there too. Unfortunately it didn't translate to adulthood as I found the wider 'horsey' community incredibly unwelcoming!

Another 'sport' I really enjoyed was trampolining, there is no competitive team element but lots of time to natter while waiting for your turn.

Hi @LivingDeadGirlUK, thanks for sharing your experience. Do I take it you were a ‘disabled rider’ for want of a better term? I’m sorry to hear that it didn’t translate into adulthood for you. Was it an unwillingness to keep making adaptations once you were an adult?

This is one of the concerns I have about RDA type activities, and one of the reservations about clubs aimed at learning disabilities being the solution - do they allow for building relationships that can continue into adulthood?

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 04/03/2023 15:44

JusteanBiscuits · 02/03/2023 11:44

Just to clarify a little about our session.

We hold 3 sessions of the club. Unfortunately, due to it's nature, having mixed ability groups doesn't work as it would put the less able at risk, and also hold the more able back. So to over come the social aspect - which is very important - 5 of the kids from the earlier sessions also take part in the session for kids with additional needs to provide the social aspect and also to provide support and encouragement. So it's a 50/50 ratio. Three of those are teenagers who provide direct 1:1 support to the three kids that need it. It's actually been the making of the club, and changes are being made on a regional level for the sport on the back of it which is amazing. We seem to have found a balance that works - but maybe too well as we have more kids than places at the moment and saying no is so difficult.

I’ve been meaning to come back and say, thanks for explaining about your club @JusteanBiscuits It sounds really well thought through and I’m not surprised you have a waiting list 😊 Hopefully others can learn from the model you’ve developed.

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 04/03/2023 14:52

Parents of DC like ours are in a vulnerable position too. And if someone is in a position of knowledge and authority it is natural to expect them to be acting in good faith.

Absolutely, vulnerable and usually at their wits end trying to resolve the issues with their child. It’s awful trying to get the help your child needs, too many conflicting opinions and little actual help.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 04/03/2023 14:25

I think there is also a sense of being made to jump through hoops so a sort of, yes I’ll try your strategy for a while so that it can fail and we can move on to the real help.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 04/03/2023 14:23

Well but this is the thing. Parents of DC like ours are in a vulnerable position too. And if someone is in a position of knowledge and authority it is natural to expect them to be acting in good faith. That’s kind of the basis of the relationship working, until proven otherwise.

It makes me feel- and I expect often look-crazy to be always suspicious of the motives and advice of the people who are supposedly there to support our family.

So yes I regret taking her advice but it was presented as a cry-it-out type strategy, which lots of people do after all. It’s only with the benefit of hindsight and the knowledge of the paediatrician’s other terrible opinions that I would be able to outright dismiss it.

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 04/03/2023 13:51

Paediatrician said that it was our fault as we had failed with sleep training as a baby, and we must put a stair gate on the door, take all toys from the room and unscrew the lightbulbs so that DC learned nighttime was a boring time for sleep. She said DC would scream and cry for attention a lot but we must ignore DC as we had caused the problem.

Thats shockingly bad advice bordering on abusive - children need to feel safe and secure to sleep. Which is what I mean, yes professionals can give advice but as a parent you need to be able to discern the good from the bad. Someone telling me to lock my child in their bedroom with not so much as a lightbulb would be getting short shrift from me.

My DD has a tutor privately to supplement her school attendance because the school can’t give her the learning strategies that work for her.

JustKeepBuilding · 04/03/2023 12:36

For sleep, ask for a referral to a specialist sleep clinic such as the one at Evelina or GOSH.

Sadly parents who know the system and can advocate for their DC get better support. It really shouldn’t be that way.

You don’t need to know what provision is necessary. If you seek independent assessment (assuming the LA ones you have are rubbish) they will inform what provision is required.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 04/03/2023 12:35

Jellycatspyjamas · 04/03/2023 10:09

Unfortunately here learning disability doesn’t seem to qualify as a health need. We get told a lot that DC’s ability is ‘in line with overall development’ - which feels a lot like they are saying DC is a bit crap at everything and so they won’t bother to help.

While a learning disability might not qualify as a health issue, I’d argue not attending to the learning disability will give rise to health issues. Being able to be understood and understand others is a huge need, and SALT cover so much more. It was SALT who identified the fracturing of my DDs processing - understanding how to explain things to her has massively helped her cope with day to day life. We found she had a hearing impairment that impacted her communication, language skills and literacy, just knowing she couldn’t hear properly has made a difference because she knows she’s missing something and can ask folk to repeat etc, and it turns out her hearing can be fully restored with surgery. My concerns about her hearing were written off as me not accepting her disability - I had to argue her into paediatric audiology who quickly found out what was going on.

I agree that knowing what you want and why is important- I’ve long stopped saying “she needs some kind of help with X”, I do a tonne of research and explain exactly what I think she needs and why. And then I stand my ground.

I also found having a specialist tutor has been incredibly helpful, she helps my DD learn how to learn in a way that she can follow, which builds her confidence. Her reading age has gone from 6 to 10 in 2 years, and her ability to explain her own thoughts and experiences has increased hugely as a result.

Its very hard but spending time on one issue, arguing that and then moving on to the next thing can work well. I also found that once I had one service on board others were more prepared to listen to me.

@Jellycatspyjamas you make a really sensible argument. How do you find the time for all the research? God I worry all the time about the ways I’m letting DC down by not knowing and doing more. And no body else gives a stuff. Do you have the tutor because your DD is not in school full time?

OP posts: