Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I need to get over MIL announcing birth

437 replies

Grumpynewmum23 · 01/03/2023 12:03

I am certain AIBU here but honestly 3 months later am still so annoyed.

For context as am still a bit emotionally drained and have psychological support as I had quite a traumatic birth (PROM, induced, allergic reaction to epidural and failed epidural, 3hr pushing to no avail, baby flipped transverse, episiotomy to pull head round, forceps, ventouse, shoulder dystocia and PPH (lost 1.2l) - mild ptsd/was in shock so refused to hold baby/feed baby etc as a result until next morning).
Anyway, next day after gathering thoughts together etc, DP and I decide we want to announce arrival of our first child to friends and family on Facebook (we didn't announce pregnancy at all as I was scared of losing the baby).
I go and open up Facebook and see MIL has posted a picture of our baby (sent by DP just to family which I hadn't even seen at this point) announcing the arrival of 'her grand[child]' that 'just happened'. Neither DP or I are tagged or even mentioned, and she didn't contact me at all.
At the time I was too in shock and exhausted to even really take it in, but as the initial shock of the birth wore off I've just felt increasingly angry about it and literally cannot shake it off.

Tbh it is not like me to get annoyed or upset by others behaviours that easily, and I hate that I am feeling so negative.

Am I being unreasonably grumpy to feel absolutely incensed by this and is she just excited or is this just not good etiquette?!

Also if anyone has any tips for getting over this, please share!

OP posts:
bussteward · 02/03/2023 08:36

Those dismissing the MIL’s behaviour here or claiming that OP is just part of an attention-seeking social media generation (when it’s not her who was posting on social media!): if your DIL was still in hospital after a traumatic birth having not held or fed her own baby yet, would your instinct be “post on Facebook!” or “ask son if DIL is OK and do they need anything?”

A new baby is still a new baby whether it’s an hour or a week old – why not let mothers take a breath after the marathon of pregnancy and birth before running to Facebook? Once again it comes back to thinking only of the baby, not the woman who created it – often at the expense of her mental and physical health.

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 08:20

Siennahh · 02/03/2023 08:16

@RosaBonheur gaslighting though? You sure you don't just mean a difference of opinion, which is what MN is for. People asking for opinions, and people giving their opinions!

Telling the OP she is being unreasonable for feeling upset that her mother in law announced her baby's birth on Facebook absolutely is gaslighting, yes.

Siennahh · 02/03/2023 08:16

@RosaBonheur gaslighting though? You sure you don't just mean a difference of opinion, which is what MN is for. People asking for opinions, and people giving their opinions!

Calphurnia88 · 02/03/2023 08:11

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 08:02

The gaslighting on this thread is unreal.

OP, don't let others minimise your feelings. Don't let it fester either, because holding a grudge about something that is done and can't be undone isn't healthy either.

But you can bet your life that half the women on here telling you you're being unreasonable would have been beyond furious if social media had existed when their kids were born and someone else had done this to them.

I'm 37 and although I use social media (and announced my own baby's birth on Facebook), I feel like we are the generation who embraced social media when it was brand new and are a bit more wary of it now. I joined Facebook back when it was only for university students and you could only sign up if your university was participating. Almost everyone's profile was completely open, you added people as friends after meeting them once on a night out, stalking strangers' profiles was considered completely normal, as was uploading albums with loads of pictures of your friends off their faces after a night out. We used to live out our lives on Facebook, and now I post once a month if that, and many of my friends never post at all anymore.

The MIL/baby boomer generation discovered social media long after we did and many of them are still in that first stage of thinking that oversharing of personal information is great fun, and not thinking about the potential consequences. They're still enjoying that dopamine hit from every like.

They had their babies a generation ago. They got to pick their own children's names, announce their births and all that. Now they've forgotten what it's like for the mother, how exciting and scary and traumatic and emotional it can all be. And they're maybe a bit jealous that social media didn't exist when their kids were born and they didn't get to post pictures of their baby on the internet for likes, so they're all playing the cutest grandchild competition instead.

My mum and her friends and relatives are all falling over themselves to post pictures of their grandchildren on the internet. Mine frequently posts pictures I'd rather would remain private, or just posts too many. It's an ongoing issue but I know she is just excited and proud, and the best I can do is have a word with her occasionally and keep an eye on her privacy settings. But even she understood that you don't announce your grandchild's birth before the parents have given you permission to do so.

My dad and in laws aren't on social media at all, thank God, so at least I only have one proud grandparent to try and rein in.

I agree with all of this.

I post very little nowadays, and thankfully our families have little to no interest in social media, but I despair at some of the information others share online, especially regarding their children or grandchildren. I think a huge backlash is on its way.

Heyhoitsme · 02/03/2023 08:08

Please let it go. Older people don't always know the etiquette of social media. I am a mother in law and would be mortified if I inadvertently offended my family.

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 08:02

The gaslighting on this thread is unreal.

OP, don't let others minimise your feelings. Don't let it fester either, because holding a grudge about something that is done and can't be undone isn't healthy either.

But you can bet your life that half the women on here telling you you're being unreasonable would have been beyond furious if social media had existed when their kids were born and someone else had done this to them.

I'm 37 and although I use social media (and announced my own baby's birth on Facebook), I feel like we are the generation who embraced social media when it was brand new and are a bit more wary of it now. I joined Facebook back when it was only for university students and you could only sign up if your university was participating. Almost everyone's profile was completely open, you added people as friends after meeting them once on a night out, stalking strangers' profiles was considered completely normal, as was uploading albums with loads of pictures of your friends off their faces after a night out. We used to live out our lives on Facebook, and now I post once a month if that, and many of my friends never post at all anymore.

The MIL/baby boomer generation discovered social media long after we did and many of them are still in that first stage of thinking that oversharing of personal information is great fun, and not thinking about the potential consequences. They're still enjoying that dopamine hit from every like.

They had their babies a generation ago. They got to pick their own children's names, announce their births and all that. Now they've forgotten what it's like for the mother, how exciting and scary and traumatic and emotional it can all be. And they're maybe a bit jealous that social media didn't exist when their kids were born and they didn't get to post pictures of their baby on the internet for likes, so they're all playing the cutest grandchild competition instead.

My mum and her friends and relatives are all falling over themselves to post pictures of their grandchildren on the internet. Mine frequently posts pictures I'd rather would remain private, or just posts too many. It's an ongoing issue but I know she is just excited and proud, and the best I can do is have a word with her occasionally and keep an eye on her privacy settings. But even she understood that you don't announce your grandchild's birth before the parents have given you permission to do so.

My dad and in laws aren't on social media at all, thank God, so at least I only have one proud grandparent to try and rein in.

Grumpynewmum23 · 02/03/2023 07:48

Hey @Arebella yeah I acknowledge (qnd acknowledged!) that I think she can't win either and I reckon I am being unreasonable and really this issue is scapegoat for larger things at play.😓thanks for the feedback though x

OP posts:
Arebella · 02/03/2023 07:47

Katypp · 01/03/2023 18:54

Some of the responses on here!
I really do not get this ultra possessiveness that seems to feature so prominently on MN.
A baby is a family event but thread after thread of new parents who seem to think that having a baby gives them the leverage to micromanage every element of the wider family's lives.
The pp who indicated that she 'punished' her in laws for telling people about her baby by not using their name says it all.
It is a new baby, a real person, not a bargaining chip to show everyone who is in charge.
This isn't aimed at you OP as I think you realise you are being ridiculous. It's aimed at the many posters who are angry at missing their big chance to be the centre of attention.

I agree with this 💯

MN is so odd compared to real life when it comes to babies, MILs and so on. Baffles the fuck out of me.

And to think that 83% of people think that OP is not being unreasonable??!

ZeroFuchsGiven · 02/03/2023 07:45

Kjpt140v · 01/03/2023 23:34

Mother-in-law are ahit aren't they.

Speak for yourself, I have a wonderful MIL.

theleafandnotthetree · 02/03/2023 07:42

Katypp · 02/03/2023 07:09

I honestly find all this angst utterly bizarre. When did this ridiculous possessiveness become a thing? Seriously, if new mums behaved like this in the 1980s/90s there's would think they were mad. Back then, a baby was (with everyone I know anyway - I am sure someone will disagree with me) was very much welcomed into a family, not regarded as 'mine' to be shared only when I deigned to consider it. I always think of a child with a much-coveted new toy who doesn't want to share when I read replies like some of these, which border on spiteful in some cases.

Hey I'm with you and I've had children much more recently. I read threads like this and I conclude that social media has had a corrosive effect on people's judgement and perspective. On the one hand it's 'hey look at me' on the other it's 'but I want to control my story' (as if one is a character in a book or film). I think if you live by the Facebook sword you die by the Facebook sword. Just don't engage with or worry about that shit and life gets a lot easier. Focus on the actual people in your actual life, build good relationships- which will occasionally involve messiness and disappointment because everyone is not there to serve our perspective - and chill out. It's another baby, one of millions, special to you and yours but otherwise not.

Arebella · 02/03/2023 07:41

I see your update says you'd have like to have been tagged in the post. Kindly, honestly, MIL can't win in this situation. If she would have tagged you your MN post would have been how you were raging because MIL posted on FB and tagged you in it so all your friends got to see her post before yours. I honestly couldn't get wound up about a social media post, but we all have different levels of what we've been through in life therefore what we class as an issue versus a complete and utter non issue.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 02/03/2023 07:38

Katypp · 01/03/2023 18:54

Some of the responses on here!
I really do not get this ultra possessiveness that seems to feature so prominently on MN.
A baby is a family event but thread after thread of new parents who seem to think that having a baby gives them the leverage to micromanage every element of the wider family's lives.
The pp who indicated that she 'punished' her in laws for telling people about her baby by not using their name says it all.
It is a new baby, a real person, not a bargaining chip to show everyone who is in charge.
This isn't aimed at you OP as I think you realise you are being ridiculous. It's aimed at the many posters who are angry at missing their big chance to be the centre of attention.

☝👏👏

theleafandnotthetree · 02/03/2023 07:33

IAmTheWalrus85 · 02/03/2023 07:03

Nope, I don't get the "problem" and yes, I despair at the women-think. Definitely women-think. I'm sure my DH would burst with pride at FIL eagerly announcing: The Grandson is born!

And I wouldn't mind.

Well, we’re all different but if anyone I’m related to announced ‘The Grandson is born!’ as if they were announcing the second coming of Christ I would cringe like there’s no tomorrow.

Yes but I would equally I would cringe at parents making some big announcement as if their child is the second coming of Christ. I feel as if I've landed on a different planet here. Do people realise that outside of a small circle of immediate family and close friends, no one actually cares? I'm not on social media, I read a thread like this and I feel ever more grateful for that decision. It's like people lose all sense of perspective and see themselves as the lead character in a movie or something. OP, I think you are overthinking this a bit but come across as pretty fair but some of the posts are frankly unhinged. Would people really cut people off or punish them for a 'crime' like this? You must make like very hard for yourself to be this easily wounded and slighted.

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 07:33

Katypp · 02/03/2023 07:09

I honestly find all this angst utterly bizarre. When did this ridiculous possessiveness become a thing? Seriously, if new mums behaved like this in the 1980s/90s there's would think they were mad. Back then, a baby was (with everyone I know anyway - I am sure someone will disagree with me) was very much welcomed into a family, not regarded as 'mine' to be shared only when I deigned to consider it. I always think of a child with a much-coveted new toy who doesn't want to share when I read replies like some of these, which border on spiteful in some cases.

And I always wonder whether the empathy gene is missing in some people when I read replies like yours.

Justalittlebitduckling · 02/03/2023 07:09

Our FIL did the same and I have never seen my DH so angry or upset. He felt really robbed of the moment of announcing his first child.

Katypp · 02/03/2023 07:09

I honestly find all this angst utterly bizarre. When did this ridiculous possessiveness become a thing? Seriously, if new mums behaved like this in the 1980s/90s there's would think they were mad. Back then, a baby was (with everyone I know anyway - I am sure someone will disagree with me) was very much welcomed into a family, not regarded as 'mine' to be shared only when I deigned to consider it. I always think of a child with a much-coveted new toy who doesn't want to share when I read replies like some of these, which border on spiteful in some cases.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 02/03/2023 07:03

QueenCamilla · 02/03/2023 00:22

I've never sent or received A new baby card.
Neither I announced the birth of my son to a bunch of people on social media.

It is very apparent that I have been missing out on a whole bunch of amateur dramatics. Though I think my life will have to get quite a bit more boring before I join the pass-time.

Nope, I don't get the "problem" and yes, I despair at the women-think. Definitely women-think. I'm sure my DH would burst with pride at FIL eagerly announcing: The Grandson is born!
And I wouldn't mind.

Maybe I need therapy to find a way to get wound up by this.

Nope, I don't get the "problem" and yes, I despair at the women-think. Definitely women-think. I'm sure my DH would burst with pride at FIL eagerly announcing: The Grandson is born!

And I wouldn't mind.

Well, we’re all different but if anyone I’m related to announced ‘The Grandson is born!’ as if they were announcing the second coming of Christ I would cringe like there’s no tomorrow.

CandleRigg89 · 02/03/2023 06:44

Honestwife · 02/03/2023 04:24

Mil was excited about the arrival - I would just accept and get on with life. Far more important things to worry about. It is partially her news also as it’s her grandchild, if it wasn’t for her you wouldn’t have a partner and the child with him. Focus on the important things.

It is NOT partially her news to share first. Another woman had a child that she’s related to. That’s it. When my nephew was born I wouldn’t have dreamed about sharing the need publicly before SIL. She grew him. She gave birth. It was her news, regardless of how the child was related to me.

As the baby becomes a toddler and starts developing separate relationships and the parents allow picture on social media, then fine. But the birth is all about the mother, then the baby. All baby needs is a healthy mum initially. Everyone else is irrelevant until baby grows.

artimesiasfootsteps · 02/03/2023 06:16

*too late

Also there maybe a small but vocal minority defending your rude mil here, but your poll tells a different story, a definitive YANBU!

artimesiasfootsteps · 02/03/2023 06:05

We knew my mil would do this, so put a complete ban on any social media for my baby.

I would have liked to do one announcement post then not post again, but that would have led to pressure for her to post too.

Mil was actively awful, during ivf, losses, pregnancy and post partum period and birth, but expects after that she can use my child like a dolly to show off to her friends and get likes.

I now keep her at arms length.

I think some of the posters here, either have in laws that are normal or are mils themselves, because those falling over themselves to excuse mils behaviour are absolutely wild.

It should be obvious to anyone with a brain that using private family photos and announcing a birth before the mother who actually carried the baby and birthed it gets a chance to do so, is the height of rudeness and bad etiquette.

OP is allowed to be angry and it’s not to late to say something. DH just needs a quiet word with her to say it wasn’t on and please don’t do it in the future.

OddSockSeeker · 02/03/2023 05:40

So sorry you had such a traumatic birth. Hope you’re feeling a bit better in yourself now. The feelings are so intense after giving birth and emotions run high. I can see why you’d be upset. 100%. If she knew it would’ve upset you she wouldn’t have done it, I’m sure. I bet she just got so excited. Just be careful you’re not actually angry at yourself for not feeling all gushy like she was at that time (due to trauma). The anger you’re feeling towards her could be a projection of some unresolved trauma/anger around the birth. Sounds like she really loves your baby. Being kind to her will help you heal. It’d be much worse if she didn’t give a shit. Get your partner to quietly mention it one day so at least you’ve got it off your chest. He’ll do that for you hopefully. Then try & let it go. Speaking to a specialist psychotherapist around birth trauma would also help you. Congratulations by the way. ❤️‍🩹

HandScreen · 02/03/2023 05:23

I suggest counselling, both to deal with your traumatic birth, snd to think through what happened with MIL.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 02/03/2023 04:48

YANBU. My parents did this, complete with sharing some quite private pictures of me holding DS in a hospital bed having got out of theatre a short time before.

I was annoyed but didn’t say anything. It turned out that I should have said something because that inappropriate behaviour continued - with sharing lots of pictures of DS that I’d shared on the family WhatsApp on Facebook without asking, included ones from the bath. Which obviously is not ok.

It all came to a head a while later and I eventually felt I had to ask them not to share any pictures of or information about my family on Facebook because they clearly were unable to tell the difference between material that was private and what was ok to be shared on the internet.

It would have been much better if I’d spoken up and communicated expectations when they first did it - ie please ask before sharing any pictures of DS on social media.

Has she continued doing it?

Honestwife · 02/03/2023 04:24

Mil was excited about the arrival - I would just accept and get on with life. Far more important things to worry about. It is partially her news also as it’s her grandchild, if it wasn’t for her you wouldn’t have a partner and the child with him. Focus on the important things.

Grumpynewmum23 · 02/03/2023 02:09

Yeah thanks for your input guys! As I've previously said, everyone's advice/opinions have helped me really clarify what thr real issues are here.

For those siding with MIL and suggesting lack of respect on my behalf..
In our situation it has been opposite 9n quite a few occasions and I still try and orchestrate positive opportunities for us all to interact/be together. I know no one is perfect (including myself, hence why I suspected I probably was being a bit unreadonable!) and I've grown up with really negative 'in law' relationships on both sides and really do not want my child to feel the impact of them like I have at times.

Though even though I've said that Facebook isn't the actual issue here, I suppose my one hang up here contrary to other posters opinions is that I actually would have liked to be tagged or even if she mentioned my DH saying how excited she was.. she usually tags us in all sorts of posts that are totally random, is not old and would expect to be tagged herself. I think it probably also just left me feeling a little bit dismissed as the vessel of delivery for her grandchild. (To be honest, some subsequent behaviour has confirmed these feelings further, unfortunately. I am however chalking a lot of this up to being an excited grandchild parent.. when does the excitement wear off?!)
Think it hit me at a bad time as neither me or grandchild could have potentially made it and so whilst she was excited I think it would have probably been nice to be acknowledged in that excitement. Though completely agree with previous users that I think that this is a situation she probably can't win in, and a situation that I'm not going to win in either by letting myself get hung up on it.

Again, thanks again for everyone's input and points if view..been so much more helpful in giving me tools to move forward than I expected when posting. Xx

OP posts: