Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I need to get over MIL announcing birth

437 replies

Grumpynewmum23 · 01/03/2023 12:03

I am certain AIBU here but honestly 3 months later am still so annoyed.

For context as am still a bit emotionally drained and have psychological support as I had quite a traumatic birth (PROM, induced, allergic reaction to epidural and failed epidural, 3hr pushing to no avail, baby flipped transverse, episiotomy to pull head round, forceps, ventouse, shoulder dystocia and PPH (lost 1.2l) - mild ptsd/was in shock so refused to hold baby/feed baby etc as a result until next morning).
Anyway, next day after gathering thoughts together etc, DP and I decide we want to announce arrival of our first child to friends and family on Facebook (we didn't announce pregnancy at all as I was scared of losing the baby).
I go and open up Facebook and see MIL has posted a picture of our baby (sent by DP just to family which I hadn't even seen at this point) announcing the arrival of 'her grand[child]' that 'just happened'. Neither DP or I are tagged or even mentioned, and she didn't contact me at all.
At the time I was too in shock and exhausted to even really take it in, but as the initial shock of the birth wore off I've just felt increasingly angry about it and literally cannot shake it off.

Tbh it is not like me to get annoyed or upset by others behaviours that easily, and I hate that I am feeling so negative.

Am I being unreasonably grumpy to feel absolutely incensed by this and is she just excited or is this just not good etiquette?!

Also if anyone has any tips for getting over this, please share!

OP posts:
QueenCamilla · 02/03/2023 09:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 09:55

ZeroFuchsGiven · 02/03/2023 09:49

Honestly what is so hard to believe that some people including myself would not give a shiny shit about a doting grandmother announcing to their friends their grandchild has arrived?

Are you that closed minded in other aspects of your life?

Just because you "wouldn't give a shiny shit" about your MIL telling her friends your child was born before you had had a chance to tell any of yours (which is VERY hard to believe, in fact), that doesn't mean the OP is unreasonable for feeling upset about it.

Calphurnia88 · 02/03/2023 09:51

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 09:43

Yeah, right, pull the other one. You wouldn't like it at all, neither would any normal person. Nothing to do with being uptight, it's just common sense and courtesy.

I have a great relationship with my MIL, by the way. She's not on Facebook but even if she were she wouldn't dream of doing this. She did text me immediately to say congratulations though. I had the pleasure of telling her my daughter has her name as a middle name.

I too have a great relationship with my MIL. She has social media but Facebook likes were the least of her concerns after DS was born (same goes for DM).

She has behaved inconsiderately - and the fact she didn't tag OP leads me to believe she's aware of that - but I do agree that OP should put it behind her, whilst proceeding cautiously in regards to what she shares, now. And a chat with her partner about how much of their child's lives they do want to share online is wise.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 02/03/2023 09:49

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 09:43

Yeah, right, pull the other one. You wouldn't like it at all, neither would any normal person. Nothing to do with being uptight, it's just common sense and courtesy.

I have a great relationship with my MIL, by the way. She's not on Facebook but even if she were she wouldn't dream of doing this. She did text me immediately to say congratulations though. I had the pleasure of telling her my daughter has her name as a middle name.

Honestly what is so hard to believe that some people including myself would not give a shiny shit about a doting grandmother announcing to their friends their grandchild has arrived?

Are you that closed minded in other aspects of your life?

SchoolTripDrama · 02/03/2023 09:49

I agree that it's not a massive deal BUT it's your 'Not a massive deal! Your news to share. Your announcement

I guess one good thing is that she didn't tag you, so there's still presumably some people who you can still inform yourselves?

Congratulations by the way. I only got to have one child and she's 8 now so I'm incredibly broody & envious! Oh how I wish I'd savoured every second.
I missed a lot of those first few months due to emergency house hunting (rental notice given days after birth) and I'd give anything to go back. My advice - don't sweat the small stuff too much and enjoy your little miracle.
I too had almost the exact same birth as yours (even down to the multiple Epidurals, 3 hours no progress, emergency forceps, blood loss and trauma) and I'll be forever grateful to those angels who saved her. And me.

You'll never get the baby days back! Enjoy them :) 🌸

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 09:43

ZeroFuchsGiven · 02/03/2023 09:40

Im seriously not an uptight person, I cant control what other people do and I certainly dont spend my life holding grudges for someone being and acting human. I also like my MIL unlike a lot of people on this thread.

This thread really seems to have hit a nerve with you, I am sorry for whatever is going on in your life to make you so angry, hope it gets better soon Flowers

Yeah, right, pull the other one. You wouldn't like it at all, neither would any normal person. Nothing to do with being uptight, it's just common sense and courtesy.

I have a great relationship with my MIL, by the way. She's not on Facebook but even if she were she wouldn't dream of doing this. She did text me immediately to say congratulations though. I had the pleasure of telling her my daughter has her name as a middle name.

theleafandnotthetree · 02/03/2023 09:42

Grumpynewmum23 · 02/03/2023 09:38

I'm OK with difference of opinions on this topic.. its what you expect imo when you put stuff out there.

For context, she's 50 so imo would kinda get SM but maybe as pp have highlighted maybe it's still used differently but different generations.

Time to work on myself and get over this now I think. X

OP you sound very fair minded and thank you for saying that. As others have chosen to miss, you did in fact ask AIBU! So opinions were sought and duly given. Good luck with your lovely new baby and with the future.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 02/03/2023 09:40

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 09:33

So if your MIL posted YOUR personal information that you hadn't yet shared with YOUR friends and family on HER Facebook and shared it with HER friends who you don't even know, that would be fine by you, would it?

Aye, like hell it would.

Im seriously not an uptight person, I cant control what other people do and I certainly dont spend my life holding grudges for someone being and acting human. I also like my MIL unlike a lot of people on this thread.

This thread really seems to have hit a nerve with you, I am sorry for whatever is going on in your life to make you so angry, hope it gets better soon Flowers

Grumpynewmum23 · 02/03/2023 09:38

I'm OK with difference of opinions on this topic.. its what you expect imo when you put stuff out there.

For context, she's 50 so imo would kinda get SM but maybe as pp have highlighted maybe it's still used differently but different generations.

Time to work on myself and get over this now I think. X

OP posts:
RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 09:37

Silverkirk · 02/03/2023 09:35

The MIL/baby boomer generation discovered social media long after we did and many of them are still in that first stage of thinking that oversharing of personal information is great fun, and not thinking about the potential consequences. They're still enjoying that dopamine hit from every like.

You're being ridiculous. And ageist.

I am accurately describing my own experience, and that of many of my friends, with boomer parents running amok on Facebook.

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 09:36

saraclara · 02/03/2023 09:16

@RosaBonheur that's a spectacular but of ageism in your long post.

If anything, those of us who are boomers had MORE interference from parents, because there was this whole 'respecting your elders' thing that was taken too far. Insistence on using family names, our own parents thinking they could dictate our decisions....
Seriously, you have no idea. I relish the freedoms my own children have, compared to me.

With regard to social media, it's really down to the pregnant/new parents to make it clear what they want to happen when the baby is born. There are lots of things that newer technology has to make us have plans for. For instance, at my husband's funeral, in my grief, I got obsessed with the idea that someone's phone might ring. It sounds daft now, but I asked the funeral director to ask people to turn off their phones as they arrived.

So yes, make your wishes clear ahead of time. "It might take us a while to make the baby announcement, so please don't put anything on social media until we let you know that we're ready"

Just because the generation and before was interfering and controlling, that doesn't make it OK for them to be.

And "respect your elders" is a load of nonsense. Maybe the boomer generation had a good reason to respect their own elders, who had fought two world wars, but they as a generation have done nothing in particular to merit respect anyway. Respect is earned.

And I struggle to respect people too stupid to understand that you don't announce the birth of someone else's baby on Facebook.

Silverkirk · 02/03/2023 09:35

The MIL/baby boomer generation discovered social media long after we did and many of them are still in that first stage of thinking that oversharing of personal information is great fun, and not thinking about the potential consequences. They're still enjoying that dopamine hit from every like.

You're being ridiculous. And ageist.

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 09:33

ZeroFuchsGiven · 02/03/2023 09:18

Im wondering what is wrong with you actually. Not everyone has to have the same opinion as you, not everyone has to have the same opinion as op.

She asked if she was being unreasonable, some said yes, some said no.

I said yes, simply because the MIL posted to HER facebook to HER friends, she didnt even tag op or her dh and this was after a photo had been sent and the birth had been announce to the family. I see absolutely no issue with a proud Grandmother telling HER friends that her grandchild had been born.

That is not gaslighting.

So if your MIL posted YOUR personal information that you hadn't yet shared with YOUR friends and family on HER Facebook and shared it with HER friends who you don't even know, that would be fine by you, would it?

Aye, like hell it would.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 02/03/2023 09:21

saraclara · 02/03/2023 09:16

@RosaBonheur that's a spectacular but of ageism in your long post.

If anything, those of us who are boomers had MORE interference from parents, because there was this whole 'respecting your elders' thing that was taken too far. Insistence on using family names, our own parents thinking they could dictate our decisions....
Seriously, you have no idea. I relish the freedoms my own children have, compared to me.

With regard to social media, it's really down to the pregnant/new parents to make it clear what they want to happen when the baby is born. There are lots of things that newer technology has to make us have plans for. For instance, at my husband's funeral, in my grief, I got obsessed with the idea that someone's phone might ring. It sounds daft now, but I asked the funeral director to ask people to turn off their phones as they arrived.

So yes, make your wishes clear ahead of time. "It might take us a while to make the baby announcement, so please don't put anything on social media until we let you know that we're ready"

And yes the ageism is disgusting in that stupidly long waffly post.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 02/03/2023 09:18

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 09:08

She is quite obviously not being even remotely unreasonable.

Those telling her she is are trying to make her believe that her feelings don't matter and she doesn't get to have any boundaries.

Wtf is wrong with some of you?

Im wondering what is wrong with you actually. Not everyone has to have the same opinion as you, not everyone has to have the same opinion as op.

She asked if she was being unreasonable, some said yes, some said no.

I said yes, simply because the MIL posted to HER facebook to HER friends, she didnt even tag op or her dh and this was after a photo had been sent and the birth had been announce to the family. I see absolutely no issue with a proud Grandmother telling HER friends that her grandchild had been born.

That is not gaslighting.

saraclara · 02/03/2023 09:16

@RosaBonheur that's a spectacular but of ageism in your long post.

If anything, those of us who are boomers had MORE interference from parents, because there was this whole 'respecting your elders' thing that was taken too far. Insistence on using family names, our own parents thinking they could dictate our decisions....
Seriously, you have no idea. I relish the freedoms my own children have, compared to me.

With regard to social media, it's really down to the pregnant/new parents to make it clear what they want to happen when the baby is born. There are lots of things that newer technology has to make us have plans for. For instance, at my husband's funeral, in my grief, I got obsessed with the idea that someone's phone might ring. It sounds daft now, but I asked the funeral director to ask people to turn off their phones as they arrived.

So yes, make your wishes clear ahead of time. "It might take us a while to make the baby announcement, so please don't put anything on social media until we let you know that we're ready"

Arebella · 02/03/2023 09:10

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 09:08

She is quite obviously not being even remotely unreasonable.

Those telling her she is are trying to make her believe that her feelings don't matter and she doesn't get to have any boundaries.

Wtf is wrong with some of you?

OP opens her thread with:

I am certain AIBU here but

Some people reply YANBU
Some people reply YABU

Neither are gaslighting FFS. She's asked for opinions, because that's what Mumsnet is for.

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 09:08

Siennahh · 02/03/2023 09:04

Shes posted in AIBU.....so she can't be told she's being U because that's gaslighting? No, it's an opinion.

She is quite obviously not being even remotely unreasonable.

Those telling her she is are trying to make her believe that her feelings don't matter and she doesn't get to have any boundaries.

Wtf is wrong with some of you?

Siennahh · 02/03/2023 09:04

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 08:20

Telling the OP she is being unreasonable for feeling upset that her mother in law announced her baby's birth on Facebook absolutely is gaslighting, yes.

Shes posted in AIBU.....so she can't be told she's being U because that's gaslighting? No, it's an opinion.

Chestnutlover · 02/03/2023 08:58

My in-laws came into the birth room moments after I had given birth when there was still blood on the floor and we were trying to do golden hour. This was after my dp had specified that my mum was not allowed to be there for the birth. I’m continuously infuriated by them and their lack of boundaries but for my own peace of mind I try to rise above it and let it go. Really hard though and trying to establish more boundaries now.

capermum · 02/03/2023 08:48

It’s one of those once in a lifetime pieces of news that you really want to broadcast yourself. I’m so sorry for you I’d be hopping too…Can you ask her to take the post down? And perhaps send out an announcement card to friends and family through the post it’s a really nice way to share the news more personally

IAmTheWalrus85 · 02/03/2023 08:42

bussteward · 02/03/2023 08:36

Those dismissing the MIL’s behaviour here or claiming that OP is just part of an attention-seeking social media generation (when it’s not her who was posting on social media!): if your DIL was still in hospital after a traumatic birth having not held or fed her own baby yet, would your instinct be “post on Facebook!” or “ask son if DIL is OK and do they need anything?”

A new baby is still a new baby whether it’s an hour or a week old – why not let mothers take a breath after the marathon of pregnancy and birth before running to Facebook? Once again it comes back to thinking only of the baby, not the woman who created it – often at the expense of her mental and physical health.

This is the irony isn’t it?! OP isn’t the one who couldn’t hold back from posting on FB, yet she’s the one who’s apparently a spiteful attention-seeking social media-obsessed narcissist. And the person whose first thought was to post a photo on social media before their DIL has even been discharged from hospital after what sounds like an extremely traumatic birth is just a proud granny.

msannabella · 02/03/2023 08:41

One of my closest friends at the time did this to me. We had messaged maybe 5 or 6 close friends and family and sent them a picture. About an hour or so later, went to announce on Facebook for more distant relatives and she'd put a picture and announced. Didn't even tag me! Things were never quite the same after and even though we still talk, we're nowhere near as close after. I've still never really gotten over it and I've had 2 kids since (that I didn't tell her about till after others!)

IAmTheWalrus85 · 02/03/2023 08:38

theleafandnotthetree · 02/03/2023 07:33

Yes but I would equally I would cringe at parents making some big announcement as if their child is the second coming of Christ. I feel as if I've landed on a different planet here. Do people realise that outside of a small circle of immediate family and close friends, no one actually cares? I'm not on social media, I read a thread like this and I feel ever more grateful for that decision. It's like people lose all sense of perspective and see themselves as the lead character in a movie or something. OP, I think you are overthinking this a bit but come across as pretty fair but some of the posts are frankly unhinged. Would people really cut people off or punish them for a 'crime' like this? You must make like very hard for yourself to be this easily wounded and slighted.

But this isn’t about OP’s MiL stealing her thunder because OP wanted to make a big social media announcement about the second coming of Christ. She’s made that clear. She says she and her DP were unsure about whether to post anything at all. It’s about posting a photo that OP herself hadn’t even seen on Facebook, without asking the OP, without acknowledging the OP, while OP was still lying butchered in a hospital bed from a very traumatic birth.

It’s about respecting other people’s privacy and control.

I can’t imagine feeling entitled to post a picture of someone else’s child on the internet without checking with them first. I don’t do it with my children’s friends or my nieces and nephews.

As another posters have said, some members of the boomer generation are only just getting addicted to social media and craving ‘likes’ and attention without thinking about privacy - like millennials did in 2005.

Notsoivorytower · 02/03/2023 08:37

I would be livid too - but it sounds like you've been through enough trauma and feeling so resentful only makes you feel worse. So, maybe mention it to her with DH present. (from a good place) say that you understand her excitement - but that it wasn't her news to share and that you and your husband would have liked to have been the ones to have broken the news - especially in your weakened state and after such a traumatic birth. The most important thing is CONGRATULATIONS you have a healthy child, you got through what sounds like quite and ordeal and you are here and fit and well and all have something wonderful to celebrate. Well done you. Rebuild that bond with your MIL and let her make it up to you by being a wonderful Grandmother and great support to all of you. Good luck.

Swipe left for the next trending thread