Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I need to get over MIL announcing birth

437 replies

Grumpynewmum23 · 01/03/2023 12:03

I am certain AIBU here but honestly 3 months later am still so annoyed.

For context as am still a bit emotionally drained and have psychological support as I had quite a traumatic birth (PROM, induced, allergic reaction to epidural and failed epidural, 3hr pushing to no avail, baby flipped transverse, episiotomy to pull head round, forceps, ventouse, shoulder dystocia and PPH (lost 1.2l) - mild ptsd/was in shock so refused to hold baby/feed baby etc as a result until next morning).
Anyway, next day after gathering thoughts together etc, DP and I decide we want to announce arrival of our first child to friends and family on Facebook (we didn't announce pregnancy at all as I was scared of losing the baby).
I go and open up Facebook and see MIL has posted a picture of our baby (sent by DP just to family which I hadn't even seen at this point) announcing the arrival of 'her grand[child]' that 'just happened'. Neither DP or I are tagged or even mentioned, and she didn't contact me at all.
At the time I was too in shock and exhausted to even really take it in, but as the initial shock of the birth wore off I've just felt increasingly angry about it and literally cannot shake it off.

Tbh it is not like me to get annoyed or upset by others behaviours that easily, and I hate that I am feeling so negative.

Am I being unreasonably grumpy to feel absolutely incensed by this and is she just excited or is this just not good etiquette?!

Also if anyone has any tips for getting over this, please share!

OP posts:
Jamandbreadsupper · 03/03/2023 07:44

no it wasn’t dramatic at all at the side of a hospital birth, yes unplanned but I never said dramatic. Annoying some silly woman is desperate to get the first look when what was important was getting me and the baby checked out. No one minded me waking them up either at 1am. People did mention the woman’s post and congratulated me in private message after she’d txt them also. Hardly loosing sleep over it katypp.

Jooliusreezer · 03/03/2023 07:39

Katypp · 03/03/2023 07:19

It sounds like your baby had a dramatic entrance into the world and it must have been traumatic for you. But I don't get why you had to wake your family to 'announce' your news? Surely at the end of the day, the point is your family know your baby is here not that they know from you specifically? Why make such a big deal over it?

Because she wanted them to hear from her, after a bit of a shocking birth, rather than second hand from some nosy loitering neighbour who wanted in on the action and so posted about it on Facebook.

Katypp · 03/03/2023 07:19

Jamandbreadsupper · 02/03/2023 22:52

This happened to me but by one of the neighbors, I had an unplanned home birth. I was stood in my hallway refusing to get in the ambulance because she was parked behind the ambulance waiting to see the baby.
I was stood with the umbilical cord hanging between my legs and obviously wasn’t in the mood for meet and greets. My mum was stood outside holding the baby trying to avoid contact while trying to get in the ambulance.
I got home at 1am to find she’d congratulated me on the birth of my baby. I had to start ringing waking family and my dad at 1am to tell them their granddaughter had arrived before they looked and found out on fb. I’m still annoyed 7 years later.

It sounds like your baby had a dramatic entrance into the world and it must have been traumatic for you. But I don't get why you had to wake your family to 'announce' your news? Surely at the end of the day, the point is your family know your baby is here not that they know from you specifically? Why make such a big deal over it?

Jamandbreadsupper · 02/03/2023 22:52

This happened to me but by one of the neighbors, I had an unplanned home birth. I was stood in my hallway refusing to get in the ambulance because she was parked behind the ambulance waiting to see the baby.
I was stood with the umbilical cord hanging between my legs and obviously wasn’t in the mood for meet and greets. My mum was stood outside holding the baby trying to avoid contact while trying to get in the ambulance.
I got home at 1am to find she’d congratulated me on the birth of my baby. I had to start ringing waking family and my dad at 1am to tell them their granddaughter had arrived before they looked and found out on fb. I’m still annoyed 7 years later.

FictionalCharacter · 02/03/2023 19:04

bussteward · 02/03/2023 08:36

Those dismissing the MIL’s behaviour here or claiming that OP is just part of an attention-seeking social media generation (when it’s not her who was posting on social media!): if your DIL was still in hospital after a traumatic birth having not held or fed her own baby yet, would your instinct be “post on Facebook!” or “ask son if DIL is OK and do they need anything?”

A new baby is still a new baby whether it’s an hour or a week old – why not let mothers take a breath after the marathon of pregnancy and birth before running to Facebook? Once again it comes back to thinking only of the baby, not the woman who created it – often at the expense of her mental and physical health.

Spot on.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 02/03/2023 17:59

saraclara · 02/03/2023 16:54

Social media requires new manners and guidelines, and one of those is not announcing someone else’s good news for them, without their permission.

I absolutely agree with that. But clearly the etiquette hasn't quite reached everyone, with the rate of change being so rapid. Yes, they are NEW manners. So I do recommend that people ask/remind those close to them of what they want when it comes to SM and the baby, and early enough to prevent any mis-steps.

I agree completely, @saraclara.

bussteward · 02/03/2023 16:57

the expectation that society must bow at the feet of new mothers and entertain their every whim.
Or, you know, treat them as a medical patient who’s just gone through a major physical process and might need a wee bit of recovery, respect and a cup of tea before pictures of their blood-covered children are plastered on social media?

saraclara · 02/03/2023 16:54

Social media requires new manners and guidelines, and one of those is not announcing someone else’s good news for them, without their permission.

I absolutely agree with that. But clearly the etiquette hasn't quite reached everyone, with the rate of change being so rapid. Yes, they are NEW manners. So I do recommend that people ask/remind those close to them of what they want when it comes to SM and the baby, and early enough to prevent any mis-steps.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 02/03/2023 16:48

Katypp · 02/03/2023 13:47

You see this is something else that I think is a relatively recent phenomena - the expectation that society must bow at the feet of new mothers and entertain their every whim.
I am one of the much-maligned old people on here (although I do manage to hold down a job in tech - go me!) but I honestly don't remember this requirement to acknowledge the new mum to be special and be regarded as on a higher plain because they have given birth. As a pp said, millions of babies are born every year. It's very special for the parents and immediate family, probably not that interesting to wider family and friends and definitely not at all interesting to everyone else.
I stand by my opinion that a lot of pps on here are annoyed because they missed their big moment, hence the apparent micromanaging of when the big announcement could be made to a lot of people who - to be frank - are not waiting on tenterhooks for the news.

Is it really ‘bowing at the feet’ and ‘entertaining every whim’ of a new mother not to put a picture of her bloodied baby on Facebook without asking her if she’s ok with that? Or without showing concern as whether she’s ok generally? (When she clearly wasn’t, as it happens). Isn’t it just a question of treating a new mother like a human being rather than a vessel? I just don’t really get it. I’m not a MIL but if/when I am I hope I’ll care about my DIL as a human being.

My parents were like OP’s MIL too when I had my oldest son so I get how OP feels. Their priority was posting pictures for likes without asking - some of them very personal pictures. My darling MIL was the complete opposite. Her priority was looking after me and the baby. She filled up the freezer with lovely batch-cooked dinners for us. When she first came over after we brought the baby home her first words were to me - ‘how are you feeling darling?’ She cuddled the baby while I had a shower and ate. She helped with washing and cleaning. She helped me find my feet when my DH went back to work. That pattern continued (I eventually had to speak to my parents about internet safety because it got really awful - think pictures of the kids in the bath). By contrast I think my MIL asked a week or so later if she could share some pictures with her friends and family (note - not on Facebook).

Guess who has a really close bond with both me and my children now? And guess who I’ll be moving heaven and earth to help if she ever needs anything?

If you have a daughter or a DIL and they ever have children do be sure to tell them they can’t expect any special treatment from you just because they’ve given birth.

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 02/03/2023 16:40

Bamboux · 02/03/2023 10:39

You don't give a shiny shit about your child's safety on the internet then?

Posting a picture of a child along with its full name and date of birth (and probably place of birth in many cases) is a huge breach of privacy.

Parents shouldn't be doing it either, but for a third party to do it when parents (as in our case) were very clear that we weren't going to risk breaching privacy and security guidelines like that is appalling.

Here's some further info for those who are actually interested in understanding why this is a bad idea, rather than those who are getting their kicks from insulting other posters

www.eset.com/blog/consumer/why-you-shouldnt-post-childrens-photos-online/

This is a very good point and a useful link. I am always horrified by seeing pictures of young children posted on fb

artimesiasfootsteps · 02/03/2023 16:35

@SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius this 👆🏼in spades!!!

My inlaws just see my daughter as a chance to show off to her friends. She has no interest in my or my baby’s well-being or in my baby as her own autonomous person at all.

From my own perspective, my mother had a father she estranged when she was 13. When we were a bit older she took us to see if him, to see if we wanted to have a relationship with him, as she felt guilty we were missing out. We weren’t, he was selfish with her growing up and no better with us and we could see straight through him. Children aren’t idiots and they don’t miss out by removing toxic people from their lives. This might not be the case for OP, but I’m sick of the narrative on Mumsnet that grandparents relationships should be fostered at the expense of the parent (usually the dil on here). I have wonderful grandparent substitutes I chose and cherish. Family isn’t always blood, sometimes the family you choose is the healthiest, most supportive and loving.

Calphurnia88 · 02/03/2023 16:33

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 15:37

Jesus Christ, what did I just read?

There is an ocean of clear water between "respecting a new mother's right to decide when, how and with whom her and her child's personal information is shared online" and "bowing at their feet and entertaining their every whim".

Wanting to announce the birth of your own child in the manner in which you see fit, or indeed, preferring not to share this information online at all for many very good reasons posters have outlined in this thread even if it does deprive family members of the chance to use your new baby for social media likes is not a "whim", for goodness sake.

Ignore her, she makes a habit of making disparaging remarks about new mums.

Last time it was a new mum who was worried about people kissing her newborn on the face. According to Katypp new mums are controlling, hysterical and basically ridiculous and if they* would just relax and stop trying to dictate to everyone how they should behave, life would be a lot less stressful. *This comment was made shortly after another poster said they knew a couple who had lost a baby due to neonatal herpes.

But god forbid anyone say anything remotely ageist.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 02/03/2023 16:04

Yes, this is a fairly recent phenomenon, but as society and technology change, then so must our manners and mores.

Now it is pretty normal to announce your baby’s arrival on social media - it is something many new parents look forward to, and I can see why - for the new mum, who has been all through pregnancy and labour, it’s something to look forward to - and I don’t think someone else, no matter how excited, should co-opt that experience.

Social media requires new manners and guidelines, and one of those is not announcing someone else’s good news for them, without their permission.

RosaBonheur · 02/03/2023 15:37

Katypp · 02/03/2023 13:47

You see this is something else that I think is a relatively recent phenomena - the expectation that society must bow at the feet of new mothers and entertain their every whim.
I am one of the much-maligned old people on here (although I do manage to hold down a job in tech - go me!) but I honestly don't remember this requirement to acknowledge the new mum to be special and be regarded as on a higher plain because they have given birth. As a pp said, millions of babies are born every year. It's very special for the parents and immediate family, probably not that interesting to wider family and friends and definitely not at all interesting to everyone else.
I stand by my opinion that a lot of pps on here are annoyed because they missed their big moment, hence the apparent micromanaging of when the big announcement could be made to a lot of people who - to be frank - are not waiting on tenterhooks for the news.

Jesus Christ, what did I just read?

There is an ocean of clear water between "respecting a new mother's right to decide when, how and with whom her and her child's personal information is shared online" and "bowing at their feet and entertaining their every whim".

Wanting to announce the birth of your own child in the manner in which you see fit, or indeed, preferring not to share this information online at all for many very good reasons posters have outlined in this thread even if it does deprive family members of the chance to use your new baby for social media likes is not a "whim", for goodness sake.

theleafandnotthetree · 02/03/2023 15:20

Katypp · 02/03/2023 13:47

You see this is something else that I think is a relatively recent phenomena - the expectation that society must bow at the feet of new mothers and entertain their every whim.
I am one of the much-maligned old people on here (although I do manage to hold down a job in tech - go me!) but I honestly don't remember this requirement to acknowledge the new mum to be special and be regarded as on a higher plain because they have given birth. As a pp said, millions of babies are born every year. It's very special for the parents and immediate family, probably not that interesting to wider family and friends and definitely not at all interesting to everyone else.
I stand by my opinion that a lot of pps on here are annoyed because they missed their big moment, hence the apparent micromanaging of when the big announcement could be made to a lot of people who - to be frank - are not waiting on tenterhooks for the news.

I agree completely with you and I am possibly younger (late 40s). I do remember the moderate degree of attention around my having had my children , not generated by me necessarily, but just the normal range of good wishes, goodwill, visits etc and I do remember thinking 'gosh, someone could let this go their head'. It is probably one of the few times in your life when you are naturally kind of centred and I think some people really enjoy that, want more of it and the ability to micromanage, almost curate the big announcement ( regardless of the level of real interest in said announcement) is all part of that. Throw in social media, designed to make narcissists of us all, and you have some of the perspectives on here. I actually don't include the OP in this necessarily, she seems pretty grounded and self aware but some people's perspectives are very odd to me and seem more designed to create a lonely real life even if a perfectly curated on-line life

BigFeelingsMoment · 02/03/2023 15:15

Katypp · 02/03/2023 13:47

You see this is something else that I think is a relatively recent phenomena - the expectation that society must bow at the feet of new mothers and entertain their every whim.
I am one of the much-maligned old people on here (although I do manage to hold down a job in tech - go me!) but I honestly don't remember this requirement to acknowledge the new mum to be special and be regarded as on a higher plain because they have given birth. As a pp said, millions of babies are born every year. It's very special for the parents and immediate family, probably not that interesting to wider family and friends and definitely not at all interesting to everyone else.
I stand by my opinion that a lot of pps on here are annoyed because they missed their big moment, hence the apparent micromanaging of when the big announcement could be made to a lot of people who - to be frank - are not waiting on tenterhooks for the news.

“Definitely not at all interesting to anyone else.”

This is a mumsnet cliche. Actually I was amazed and overwhelmed by the outpouring of love, cards, gifts, kindness and general joy that greeted the birth of my DC. People you wouldn’t think of were so lovely.

Katypp · 02/03/2023 14:40

@Anklespraying Explain? I am a mum.

Anklespraying · 02/03/2023 14:10

You must be in the wrong place @Katypp

You are on a website called mumsnet

Katypp · 02/03/2023 13:47

bussteward · 02/03/2023 08:36

Those dismissing the MIL’s behaviour here or claiming that OP is just part of an attention-seeking social media generation (when it’s not her who was posting on social media!): if your DIL was still in hospital after a traumatic birth having not held or fed her own baby yet, would your instinct be “post on Facebook!” or “ask son if DIL is OK and do they need anything?”

A new baby is still a new baby whether it’s an hour or a week old – why not let mothers take a breath after the marathon of pregnancy and birth before running to Facebook? Once again it comes back to thinking only of the baby, not the woman who created it – often at the expense of her mental and physical health.

You see this is something else that I think is a relatively recent phenomena - the expectation that society must bow at the feet of new mothers and entertain their every whim.
I am one of the much-maligned old people on here (although I do manage to hold down a job in tech - go me!) but I honestly don't remember this requirement to acknowledge the new mum to be special and be regarded as on a higher plain because they have given birth. As a pp said, millions of babies are born every year. It's very special for the parents and immediate family, probably not that interesting to wider family and friends and definitely not at all interesting to everyone else.
I stand by my opinion that a lot of pps on here are annoyed because they missed their big moment, hence the apparent micromanaging of when the big announcement could be made to a lot of people who - to be frank - are not waiting on tenterhooks for the news.

saraclara · 02/03/2023 13:39

LemonPeonies · 02/03/2023 12:28

@saraclara But you didn't grow or birth that grandchild did you? Your DD/ DIL did. So you don't take the credit. Just be happy mum and baby are alive and healthy.

Take the credit? What about my post indicated that I thought I should have the credit for the new arrival?

Grandparents share the news with their friends (at the right point) just as they share any other good news! Second to having one's own children, it's the best kind of news, and those of us of grandparent age are always pleased to hear of new arrivals and safe deliveries for the mum. Because we know how special it is, and we know the worry that we go through when our DDs (and hopefully DDiLs) are pregnant/in labour (but which we try to hide from them).

In fairness, I didn't get it when I was a new mum either. Grandparenthood didn't seem like anything special to me then, either (though the look on my dad's face when he held his first grandchild is something I'll always remember.

But yes, just as you don't know what it's like to be a mum until you are one, same applies with GPhood.

T1Dmama · 02/03/2023 13:29

QueenCamilla · 02/03/2023 00:22

I've never sent or received A new baby card.
Neither I announced the birth of my son to a bunch of people on social media.

It is very apparent that I have been missing out on a whole bunch of amateur dramatics. Though I think my life will have to get quite a bit more boring before I join the pass-time.

Nope, I don't get the "problem" and yes, I despair at the women-think. Definitely women-think. I'm sure my DH would burst with pride at FIL eagerly announcing: The Grandson is born!
And I wouldn't mind.

Maybe I need therapy to find a way to get wound up by this.

It’s not always about the fact someone else has announced…. It’s about the fact that as a new parent you want to tell certain people first!…. After my baby was born, I wanted to make sure my 90 year old nan knew before it was announced to people I didn’t know or hasn’t seen for 20 years… it’s really not hard to understand that close family members won’t want to see it on Facebook and realise 100 people had already commented before they’d even seen the news.
My friend lost her dad, before the body was even taken out of the house and her and her sister were trying to deal with it all, a neighbour put a condolence message on their dads Facebook page..it’s just awful!… his 2 daughters started getting messages and they were then forced to make calls when they weren’t yet ready to, to their fathers siblings, grandchildren etc who shouldn’t learn about the death through Facebook!
i’ve had this done to me too when my daughter was very ill in hospital and someone shared a very personal and distressing picture of my DD on Facebook despite me stating I didn’t want anything about it put on Facebook… I find other people making announcements about someone else before they have, very disrespectful…
I waited till my brother and his wife announced the birth of their children, then I put a post up saying how proud I was of my beautiful SIL & congratulating them.. wouldn’t dream of ever posting other peoples news before they had.

WhatALlama2 · 02/03/2023 12:37

My FIL did this! At first I was a bit annoyed but I understood he was just so excited about it and as he didn't tag us in the post it meant only close family saw it. I was still able to share it with all my friends on my own time so hopefully you'll be able to do the same. I do understand the feeling OP but probably not worth worrying about too much. Congratulations on you little one :)

LemonPeonies · 02/03/2023 12:28

@saraclara But you didn't grow or birth that grandchild did you? Your DD/ DIL did. So you don't take the credit. Just be happy mum and baby are alive and healthy.

BigFeelingsMoment · 02/03/2023 12:23

Grumpynewmum23 · 02/03/2023 11:43

@OnceTwiceThreeTimesATheybe bless you ❤

Incidentally, ours was covered in blood too alongside all baby's facial injuries from the rough instrumental birth...☹

The choice of a photo that was perhaps more indicative of the trauma than you might have chosen was probably also quite triggering for you. Well done for unpacking this whole thing, I hope you have some peace now.

Anklespraying · 02/03/2023 12:11

What is "dark basement behaviour"?

Someone has completely lost the plot.