Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think behaviour in USA schools is better than UK?

144 replies

NowIknowMyEFGs · 01/03/2023 10:01

Any Americans on here who can tell me what behaviour is like in high schools in the states? In the UK it's pretty dire, bad language is rife, treatment of girls by boys is obscene, vaping in the toilets, rogue students wandering corridors, uncontrollable classes etc

OP posts:
Frankola · 26/04/2023 21:10

Yeh cos school shootings are inconsequential compared to bad language right?

You cannot be serious.

Florenz · 26/04/2023 20:09

I do think the American education system has surpassed that of the UK. I think Americans expect more of their kids, the British system babies them too much, there's too much teaching to the test and not just teaching the subject and letting them sink or swim on their own merits. I think too much of the British system worries too much about kids enjoying school and being happy instead of concentrating on preparing them for leaving school and moving into the adult world where their employers are going to expect them to get on with their work.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 26/04/2023 19:56

nochangeever · 26/04/2023 15:54

I don't think many Brits spend time on American FB groups? Confused

If you're not in Britain anymore why post here and not on Babycentre or such like?

Yes they do and there have been many threads creating where OP asks questions off something they saw on an American Facebook group or watching American movies to shows etc.

The fact remains Brits on MN spend a lot of time talking about and bashing Americans. Every other day there a new thread with a silly question and everyone piles on with random stereotypes to insult Americans.

MissConductUS · 26/04/2023 16:10

giroux · 26/04/2023 15:48

Yeah, I don’t think there are many Americans on Mumsnet. The spelling of the name would preclude it from many Americans’ interests for a start. I’m a Brit living in the US, that’s why I’m here. Obviously occasionally an American unconnected with the uk does pop up on here, but it’s not frequent.

I am confident based on what the other folks who live in the US on this thread have said, that they are mostly British as well. As someone who lives in the US, I make that analysis based on their use of language (linguistic structures such as vocabulary and spellings), as
well as sometimes their usernames.

I don’t understand all the hate against the US. It wasn’t like that when I first moved here.

I found MN based on an article in The Economist six or seven years ago. I have no personal connection to the UK. I took a look, liked it here, and stayed. I agree that this is probably not frequent.

I don't understand the hate either. Americans generally think quite well of the UK, and don't consider it our place to criticize how you do things there.

nochangeever · 26/04/2023 15:54

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 26/04/2023 02:28

Why do Brit’s in Mumsnet seem to spend so much time on American Facebook groups?
Serious question.

You all seem to dislike and look down on Americans yet can’t seem to stay away from their Facebook groups and can’t help but ask dumb questions on Mumsnet and then go on a tirade of how crap America and American are.

Every few days there’s make her stupid question and then a bunch of ignorant Brits come up with stereotypes and dumb responses.

I don't think many Brits spend time on American FB groups? Confused

If you're not in Britain anymore why post here and not on Babycentre or such like?

giroux · 26/04/2023 15:48

Yeah, I don’t think there are many Americans on Mumsnet. The spelling of the name would preclude it from many Americans’ interests for a start. I’m a Brit living in the US, that’s why I’m here. Obviously occasionally an American unconnected with the uk does pop up on here, but it’s not frequent.

I am confident based on what the other folks who live in the US on this thread have said, that they are mostly British as well. As someone who lives in the US, I make that analysis based on their use of language (linguistic structures such as vocabulary and spellings), as
well as sometimes their usernames.

I don’t understand all the hate against the US. It wasn’t like that when I first moved here.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 26/04/2023 12:53

x2boys · 26/04/2023 11:31

Because it was the only autism face book group,
it that I could find that has parents and carer,s that are facing similar challenges to me
but on that note I could ask why do many Americans spend so much time on mumsnet ,which is a UK based forum.?

There are not many Americans spending time on mumsnet.

You do have some Americans living in the UK or married to Brits spending time on mumsnet but the average American does not spend time on mumsnet or even talking about about Brits on the internet the way we seem to do. It’s like a strange obsession and we seem to take pride in proving we are better than Americans.

I’m a Brit and I find this very very strange.

x2boys · 26/04/2023 11:33

x2boys · 26/04/2023 11:31

Because it was the only autism face book group,
it that I could find that has parents and carer,s that are facing similar challenges to me
but on that note I could ask why do many Americans spend so much time on mumsnet ,which is a UK based forum.?

Particularly as you find us Brits so ignorant?

x2boys · 26/04/2023 11:31

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 26/04/2023 02:28

Why do Brit’s in Mumsnet seem to spend so much time on American Facebook groups?
Serious question.

You all seem to dislike and look down on Americans yet can’t seem to stay away from their Facebook groups and can’t help but ask dumb questions on Mumsnet and then go on a tirade of how crap America and American are.

Every few days there’s make her stupid question and then a bunch of ignorant Brits come up with stereotypes and dumb responses.

Because it was the only autism face book group,
it that I could find that has parents and carer,s that are facing similar challenges to me
but on that note I could ask why do many Americans spend so much time on mumsnet ,which is a UK based forum.?

Labraradabrador · 26/04/2023 09:12

Every time the topic of the US comes up on MN, someone says, "But school shootings!" and there goes the discussion. From there on, it's "Lalala school shootings, lalala", fingers in ears... Nobody can see further than that single phenomenon, and it is trotted out on virtually every thread to do with the US, as if it proves something about every single aspect of American life.

the visual of this made me smile - so true.

knitnerd90 · 26/04/2023 08:06

Sunflowers80 · 26/04/2023 07:14

I have quite a lot of family and an old school friend who moved to the States. It's such a mess there they re removing their children from schools.

But again, it's a generalisation about a country of 330M, where schools aren't controlled by the national government--how do you know this is representative?

I think the OP was daft, but this is no better. Depending on who you talk to here they're removing their kids because of CRT and gender ideology or because they want to put up the Ten Commandments and arm the teachers.

Sunflowers80 · 26/04/2023 07:14

I have quite a lot of family and an old school friend who moved to the States. It's such a mess there they re removing their children from schools.

Kanaloa · 26/04/2023 07:12

mathanxiety · 26/04/2023 03:53

It's not an issue at 'many schools'. The US is a huge country. There are hundreds of thousands of schools.

The issue of school shootings is completely irrelevant to the issue of behaviour inside schools. It's as irrelevant as the issue of car crashes involving pedestrians or cyclists and moving vehicles in the streets outside schools.

The fact that there are gun culture problems has absolutely nothing to do with behaviour in schools. I don't know why you're mentioning them in the same post. They're not related.

Every time the topic of the US comes up on MN, someone says, "But school shootings!" and there goes the discussion. From there on, it's "Lalala school shootings, lalala", fingers in ears... Nobody can see further than that single phenomenon, and it is trotted out on virtually every thread to do with the US, as if it proves something about every single aspect of American life.

School shootings say nothing about the ordinary daily life of 350 million people in America, and they say nothing about behaviour in American schools. They are actually an unusual phenomenon (in a huge country with hundreds of thousands of schools) arising from the confluence of varying degrees of misogyny and self-hatred on the part of the gunmen, and certain cultural elements swirling around guns and concepts of power and identity. The perfect storm is a rare thing.

It's usually not students who are responsible for school shootings. And nobody has said what you allege has been said in your last sentence there.

I would think students shooting other students in school does have something to do with the behaviour in schools if I’m honest.

And someone has said that. The OP has said it. She asks if behaviour in American schools (all of them) is better than behaviour in British schools (all of them). This is of course ridiculous.

And in my past experience (living in the Midwest so very possibly different to wherever you are) school shootings very much affect the lives of American people. Even if it’s simply requiring children to participate in school shooting practices etc. Regardless, the point is that if even one student at one school in the US shoots one classmate, that pretty much puts an end to the op’s point that behaviour in every American school must be better than behaviour in every British school.

mathanxiety · 26/04/2023 04:12

blubberball · 25/04/2023 14:26

I wouldn't want to send my dc to school in America. It would freak me out them having to do active shooter drills and go through metal detectors just to go to school.

Schools in Scandinavian countries sound nice.

I remember a thread not too long ago here on MN where a lot of British MNers mentioned that their schools do active shooter and other emergency drills. Cue shock and disbelief.

The point being that actually, British schools do active shooter drills.

Also, metal detectors are not a thing in a huge number of schools. They tend to be found in inner city schools.

Not to put too fine a tooth in it, but the focus on school shootings is very much a focus on sensational, unusual news. Shootings and stabbings and beatings related to gang life in inner cities claim a lot more lives than school shooting incidents do, and gang activity - vice, drug sales, protection rackets, intimidation of law abiding citizens - blights communities and affects lives in certain parts of American cities to an infinitely greater degree than the threat of a very rare school shooting. This isn't an aspect of American life the very caucasian-centric and sensation-obsessed BBC chooses to report on, obviously.

mathanxiety · 26/04/2023 03:53

Kanaloa · 25/04/2023 23:33

Right, but you are surely aware that it is an issue at many schools? Unless you have never seen the news or spoken to anyone who attends any school but the one near you. So the issue of school shootings is still relevant to op’s assumption that all schools in the US have much better behaviour than all schools in the UK. It’s unlikely that her generalisation has any truth in it when I’m at least some schools in the US have students who get shot to death by classmates.

Of course, if she had said ‘aibu to think behaviour at mathanxiety’s American school where nobody has had any gun violence issues since 1873 is much better than the school where my son got stabbed by another student’ then she may have had a point. But saying a country where there are known gun culture problems which affects schools must have better behaviour in every single school than any school in the UK is of course ridiculous.

It's not an issue at 'many schools'. The US is a huge country. There are hundreds of thousands of schools.

The issue of school shootings is completely irrelevant to the issue of behaviour inside schools. It's as irrelevant as the issue of car crashes involving pedestrians or cyclists and moving vehicles in the streets outside schools.

The fact that there are gun culture problems has absolutely nothing to do with behaviour in schools. I don't know why you're mentioning them in the same post. They're not related.

Every time the topic of the US comes up on MN, someone says, "But school shootings!" and there goes the discussion. From there on, it's "Lalala school shootings, lalala", fingers in ears... Nobody can see further than that single phenomenon, and it is trotted out on virtually every thread to do with the US, as if it proves something about every single aspect of American life.

School shootings say nothing about the ordinary daily life of 350 million people in America, and they say nothing about behaviour in American schools. They are actually an unusual phenomenon (in a huge country with hundreds of thousands of schools) arising from the confluence of varying degrees of misogyny and self-hatred on the part of the gunmen, and certain cultural elements swirling around guns and concepts of power and identity. The perfect storm is a rare thing.

It's usually not students who are responsible for school shootings. And nobody has said what you allege has been said in your last sentence there.

Tg2023 · 26/04/2023 03:02

Rather have kids being told to fuck off than being shot!

JMSA · 26/04/2023 02:36

My daughter has recently started working for an American airline at a UK airport (we're Scottish). She said her American passengers are unfailingly polite, and that you really notice how passive-aggressive we Brits are by comparison.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 26/04/2023 02:28

x2boys · 25/04/2023 08:03

My child has severe autism and learning disabilities and goes to!a special school here in the UK , im, on an American Facebook group.for parents of children with similar needs ,s lot struggle with the education system ,are there special school,s in the US ?
because many of the kids seem to.be in mainstream schools but in special education classe,s obviously the quality of SEN,education us variable across the UK too with some areas having more provision than others .

Why do Brit’s in Mumsnet seem to spend so much time on American Facebook groups?
Serious question.

You all seem to dislike and look down on Americans yet can’t seem to stay away from their Facebook groups and can’t help but ask dumb questions on Mumsnet and then go on a tirade of how crap America and American are.

Every few days there’s make her stupid question and then a bunch of ignorant Brits come up with stereotypes and dumb responses.

Kanaloa · 25/04/2023 23:33

mathanxiety · 25/04/2023 19:12

Weirdly, nobody at my local high school has ever shot any of their classmates either. The high school was founded back in 1873. That's 150 years of everyone rubbing along pretty well together.

Right, but you are surely aware that it is an issue at many schools? Unless you have never seen the news or spoken to anyone who attends any school but the one near you. So the issue of school shootings is still relevant to op’s assumption that all schools in the US have much better behaviour than all schools in the UK. It’s unlikely that her generalisation has any truth in it when I’m at least some schools in the US have students who get shot to death by classmates.

Of course, if she had said ‘aibu to think behaviour at mathanxiety’s American school where nobody has had any gun violence issues since 1873 is much better than the school where my son got stabbed by another student’ then she may have had a point. But saying a country where there are known gun culture problems which affects schools must have better behaviour in every single school than any school in the UK is of course ridiculous.

Labraradabrador · 25/04/2023 22:23

@MinervaSaidThat i don’t think anyone on this thread has indicated they find the gun situation in the US acceptable. It is a major cultural divide in the US, and a solid majority of Americans favour more gun control (democracy <> representative).

what we object to is reducing the entire educational system in the US down to guns. There are so many absolutely brilliant aspects to the US educational system, which many of the posters with actual direct experience have attested to.

while I and a majority of Americans would love to see more restrictions on guns, my kids are more likely to be injured in an automobile accident on the way to school than an American kid is likely to experience by gun violence.

salamanderturtle · 25/04/2023 19:30

I’d rather the initial post than school shooters to be honest….

MinervaSaidThat · 25/04/2023 19:25

I do think some Americans are in denial.

This chart is scary, watching from abroad.

To think behaviour in USA schools is better than UK?
mathanxiety · 25/04/2023 19:21

MinervaSaidThat · 25/04/2023 04:40

Not sure of the difference between US and UK schools, I’m sure both have their +s and -s, but I think the Americans on this thread are mistaking our utter bafflement and fear of the frequent school shootings in the US as anti—American sentiment. I think they have become inured whilst it is incomprehensible for us.

If that's all you've bothered to learn about life in the US, then it is actually anti-American sentiment.

It would be akin to me deciding never to live in the UK and deciding the British must spend a lot of their time shrugging their shoulders because I've heard about county lines and the level of knife crime, seen scenes of football hooliganism, and footage of certain city centres on New Years Eve.

mathanxiety · 25/04/2023 19:12

Kanaloa · 25/04/2023 08:07

And I’m struggling to see why you would post something so ridiculous. I mean behaviour in the UK schools can definitely be bad but (touch wood) nobody at my school has ever shot any of their classmates. Do you really think American schools have no problems whatsoever and do school shooting drills for fun?

Weirdly, nobody at my local high school has ever shot any of their classmates either. The high school was founded back in 1873. That's 150 years of everyone rubbing along pretty well together.

Triedit · 25/04/2023 19:09

@hummingbirdsinmygarden if you read my post again you will see I said that there are 27,000 HIGH SCHOOLS as the OP mentioned High Schools specifically in her post.

Of course in total there are 100,000 of public schools because that counts all the elementary and middle schools. I mentioned public and private High Schools.

Swipe left for the next trending thread