Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to demand my DD16 pays rent if her sixth form attendance doesn’t improve

61 replies

hello12456 · 01/03/2023 02:12

My DD struggles with mental
health problems pretty severely and as a result her attendance has suffered hugely and she’s currently sitting on about 55%.
I suggested to her doing 2 days minimum in school per week and the days she doesn’t make it in online and she was very enthusiastic about this idea, and she said it would be better for her to not have the time limitations of being up and ready every morning and still being able to catch up on those days that she can’t make it
in.
Unfortunately this has been discussed with her sixth form and isn’t an option they’re willing to do, so the only choice is to get her into school.
So DH and I have told her we will take a percentage of her salary every month, and if her attendance that month is good enough we will give it back, or if it’s mediocre we will give some back.
She is not happy with this whatsoever and says it’s unfair to have been understanding when suggesting school online, and now be so harsh, and how we’re treating her like a child in so many ways but expecting her to be an adult in paying rent.

so aibu i’m really doubting this decision just don’t know what to do

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Onnabugeisha · 01/03/2023 09:45

hello12456 · 01/03/2023 02:36

i wholly jumped the gun i know, i didn’t see it as not being possible since it was originally brought up by her social worker

she for sure isn’t solely set on that, she just wants more flexibility so that on the days she doesn’t make it in she isn’t throwing away her education bevause that’s what’s happening now

Your social worker can write a letter to the school stating your DD needs this as accommodation for her MH.

Onnabugeisha · 01/03/2023 09:42

hello12456 · 01/03/2023 02:12

My DD struggles with mental
health problems pretty severely and as a result her attendance has suffered hugely and she’s currently sitting on about 55%.
I suggested to her doing 2 days minimum in school per week and the days she doesn’t make it in online and she was very enthusiastic about this idea, and she said it would be better for her to not have the time limitations of being up and ready every morning and still being able to catch up on those days that she can’t make it
in.
Unfortunately this has been discussed with her sixth form and isn’t an option they’re willing to do, so the only choice is to get her into school.
So DH and I have told her we will take a percentage of her salary every month, and if her attendance that month is good enough we will give it back, or if it’s mediocre we will give some back.
She is not happy with this whatsoever and says it’s unfair to have been understanding when suggesting school online, and now be so harsh, and how we’re treating her like a child in so many ways but expecting her to be an adult in paying rent.

so aibu i’m really doubting this decision just don’t know what to do

Do not do this! You should be fighting the school as they are required by law to accommodate her MH disability. They should be allowing her to work remotely when she is not up to physically going into school.

To demand “rent” as in confiscate her wage and then dole it out based on attendance (which is unreasonable demand due to her disability) is financial abuse of a disabled child.

Thoughtful2355 · 01/03/2023 09:40

OR speak to the local colleges and universities etc and see if there are any night classes/qualifications. I did a night course in my local college, was the best thing ever

Thoughtful2355 · 01/03/2023 09:39

why dont you look at doing an online college course for her then? there are lots of choices out there, she can stop schooling and do it all online. have a look and see if there is anything she would be interested in doing from home.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 01/03/2023 09:36

So, does the world end if she stops going to sixth form? Could she stop now, do some work in the evening as she is now and look for further education in September for something that suits her better?

WhenisitmyturntobePM · 01/03/2023 09:29

Just to offer a different perspective because I really identify with your daughter. I had undiagnosed ADHD in sixth form twenty years ago and my attendance went so low I nearly got kicked out after the first year (saved by getting all As in exams after cramming like mad for a fortnight beforehand).

I am still in academia now, so task avoidance and not wanting to get started on things is still a massive issue for me. I hate mornings but I do need structure. Whenever I have really firm boundaries I thrive, when I’m left to self-govern in a wishywashy way I’ll do sweet FA. I personally would have responded really well to the wages thing - I like an element of risk and reward and my brain needs the dopamine hit it would bring.

There is actually a website you can use for this. You put however much money you want to on account with them (I normally do £50 or £100, it’s got to be a little bit painful). Then you set a goal, choose a deadline and nominate an organisation you hate for the money to go to if you fail (think the gun lobby, political nemeses etc) and if you don’t succeed they give your cash away. It’s brutal but kind of perfect.

Mabelface · 01/03/2023 09:03

Is she bipolar or, as happens fairly frequently, has she been misdiagnosed and is actually neurodivergent?

Punishing her for anxiety is actually an awful thing to do. It'll exacerbate it as she now has the added pressure of that punishment and it'll have the opposite effect to what you were hoping for.

Working is different, as it's something she loves without the pressure of sixth form. Please don't take that from her as it'll isolate her.

First and foremost, she needs more help when her anxiety, and I would suggest doing some reading around asd/adhd in girls. Please don't punish her for how her brain is wired.

Mariposista · 01/03/2023 09:01

She doesn’t have to complete sixth form. If she has her GCSEs and hates school why doesn’t she just work full time. Further education isn’t for everyone.

Serrassi · 01/03/2023 08:47

You shouldn’t have suggested 2 days in and 3 days wfh without getting permission from school first, she must be feeling extremely upset and disappointed that this ideal solution is no longer on the table when she thought it was agreed.

If her salary was earned by her, it belongs to her and is nothing to do with you, to take it would be theft. If you’re referring to money that you give her (what most families call pocket money) then that’s different, but I still think it’s crappy parenting to pay her to go to school and withhold it on the days she isn’t well enough.

I suspect a different school would suit her better, perhaps a sixth form colllege or somewhere hippy that allows flexischooling, but depending on your area that may be hard to find.

MamOfFive · 01/03/2023 08:18

YANBU, if she can work she can go to school. Getting up early isn't mental health it's laziness.

I would suggest stopping the job so she can go to bed earlier to get up earlier.

peachgreen · 01/03/2023 08:09

This was me at your DD’s age. My attendance was something like 30% and I just absolutely could not make myself get up and go. I still got AAB because I was fortunate enough to be quite bright (all changed when I got to uni though where I had to turn things around because standards were so much higher – but I digress!).

Anyway, looking back, these were the issues for me:

  • I had to get the bus to college which took over an hour and left at 6.50. It was cold and miserable and dark and I loathed it. A lift would have made a huge difference.
  • I was working too much. I did both days at the weekend and an evening during the week and on top of college it was way too much for me. I didn’t get any down time and I was just exhausted.
  • I DID NOT GO TO BED EARLY ENOUGH. I wish my parents had removed all devices and insisted I was in bed by 10. I would have railed against it at the time but I simply wasn’t mature enough to control my own sleep schedule at that point.

If it helps I’m now a successful mum with a good career and am known for being organised, sorted, and capable. People who meet me now would never believe what a mess I was at 16-18. She’ll turn things around. Best of luck to you all.

HedgeWitchy · 01/03/2023 07:59

I think regardless of her grades she needs a year out and to restart something else, maybe an alternative college course, online learning or whatever you have locally that is accessible.
Grades can be sorted or redone, mental health is had to overcome.
20 years ago I took a year out after the first year of university. I worked full time and I went back with so much more confidence.
If she struggled through this sixth form she may or may not get grades. She will though end up anxious and with mounting unresolved needs.
I’d be suggesting something else full time to occupy her and learn skills.

I also see her point on rent. She can make her own mistakes (or not) at this point.

Im saying this as someone whose child got very very high grades, school to master level- but has such a barrier to learning due to anxiety and mental health.

IkBenDeMol · 01/03/2023 07:51

Leave school altogether and work more shifts?

Look, I'm a huge advocate of education which is why I've just applied for a PhD at the age of 51. But if she's not in the right place NOW to go to school and do her A-levels, then there's nothing wrong with taking a few years away, working, doing an apprenticeship or whatever and then going back later. Evening school, online, whatever suits.

There are many routes to getting educated and the traditional path of school -> a-levels -> university doesn't suit everyone.

FatCatt · 01/03/2023 07:50

Take some money from her but secretly keep it so she can have a lump sum back when she’s older. Could she have the lesson timetables and do them at home? Even if they aren’t streaming online

KalvinPhillipsBoots · 01/03/2023 07:46

How is charging her rent going to help her anxiety?

Summerfun54321 · 01/03/2023 07:45

I was totally miserable for the final year of A levels and barely went into school. I missed quite a lot of classes but studied very hard at home through self directed study and managed to get good a level results and into the uni I wanted to.

School just doesn't suit everyone but that doesn't mean she has to drop focus on her studies. She may find college more suitable for less contact time if she wants to study more at home.

Whycanineverever · 01/03/2023 07:39

This is interesting my DD11 struggles a bit with mental health. She has right from a few months old hated being rushed anywhere / woken in the morning.

She now chooses to wake at 5.30 for school despite not needing to leave until 7.30.

I think it's her time to set herself up for the day.

DancingDaughter50 · 01/03/2023 07:39

I can't understand why her school Cant be more flexible. 8 thought they legally had to do everything they can to be inclusive and help.

Who said no? Did you raise any complaints?
Often what happens depends on which member of staff you speak too. Many staff are not legally aware of all this and their obligations.

redskydelight · 01/03/2023 07:37

I'd also agree with looking at other options. For example, my DC's sixth form doesn't start until 9.30am, and half the time she doesn't have a timetabled first lesson so doesn't start until 11am.
Her friend goes to a sixth form college where they only have to attend 2 days a week (which I know still means early mornings, but 2 of them might be more palatable?)

What does her current school suggest?

DDivaStar · 01/03/2023 07:31

I would be looking at other education options that would be more flexible.

sashh · 01/03/2023 07:21

Legally the school need to make 'reasonable adjustments'.

Could she manage afternoons?

It might be worth pulling her out and restarting in September.

Or look at other options.

The OU do allow under 18s in certain circumstances. They cannot do all course because sometimes course material isn't suitable eg requiring someone to watch a film that is an 18 or a module with a compulsory residential.

I'm not sure how fees work under 18.

Can you tell I'm a current OU student?

Gh12345 · 01/03/2023 07:21

I think it sends mixed messages to your child to ask them to do minimum days. How will they ever cope when they have a proper job? To answer your post question I would start putting a consequence on her if she doesn’t improve. It sounds like she’s avoiding something at the 6th form and leaning on her mental health to avoid it (no judgment here I did the exact same thing and felt a little lost).

autienotnaughty · 01/03/2023 06:59

School needs to be more supportive- later classes, options to join in online. With a view to building up more. What's being done to improve mh - counselling or meds? I found hypnotherapy really helpful and mindfulness,if school refuses to support would college be better option. I wouldn't punish her for school's ignorance. It's not her fault they won't accommodate Id maybe try reward /incentive but tbh it's unlikely to work. It's the environment that needs to be adjusted for her needs. It's unfair to expect her to get better just because it suits everyone else

daretodenim · 01/03/2023 06:36

Would it be possible to make a nice morning routine, which starts v early? And then go to bed early too? She definitively needs to be getting a good night's sleep.

Early morning wakeups are not enjoyable,m (for me), but if there's a reason it can help. So what if she had something nice to get up for, ie there's nice tea (or whatever she wants to drink/eat) for her downstairs, she has some quiet time out of bed, alone? And she could do homework before heading into school, rather than in the evenings, meaning she has downtime in the evenings before an early night?

It may be a bit like being jet lagged at first but ultimately would enable her to be slow about getting up, get homework done, have enough sleep and have some downtime.

I think you need to sit down with her and admit your idea of charging her wasn't a good one, she's right. Tell her your concerns and that your goal is to help her. She's not a kid so you want to brainstorm ALL ideas of how things could be improved (remember nobody can criticise others' ideas in that process) and bring the above idea up as part of it. There may be ideas she has that are better.

TeenDivided · 01/03/2023 06:35

A thought. Is she either going in or not going in?

What about aiming for being in by say 11? (or are there travel issues with this)