Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find DH’s army stories a bit cringy?

141 replies

Thistledew · 01/03/2023 00:50

In practically any social situation, DH likes to tell stories about his time in the army- the training he did, the people he encountered etc. These are somewhat amusing/interesting/entertaining, but not hugely so. They are his memoirs, rather than being particularly meaningful.

What I find a bit cringy is that he was in the army over 20 years ago, and when I say ‘in the army’, he completed the basic training at the military academy at Sandhurst and left at the end without seeing any active service because he decided he hated army life (fair enough). So ‘the army’ was for him little more than a glorified finishing school.

I just feel a bit embarrassed when he shoehorns a story about the army into practically every social situation we are in, but wonder if IABU?

OP posts:
mpsw · 01/03/2023 18:18

Weddingcorker · 01/03/2023 17:56

If people are conning others out of money under false pretences then it's a police matter. Unless people have access to JPAC records, no one really knows what someone's service record is. If they are accessing those records and then leaking information to the public domain, that is a security breach which is a serious offence.

That's not how its done.

Remember, everyone knows everyone else. The six degrees of separation is only ever one or two.

And minor misrepresentations of a genuine military career would't be considered walt-ing.

Turnipworkharder · 01/03/2023 18:16

You must have the patience of a Saint OP.
He done Army training and then left 😐

My brother was in the Army he never ever talks about it...active duty as well.

notimagain · 01/03/2023 18:14

@Weddingcorker

Unless people have access to JPAC records, no one really knows what someone's service record is

True but unfortunately some "Walts" get over enthusiastic and make the mistake of claiming they were part of a small, perhaps vaguely elite cadre/unit where pretty much everybody who really was in that unit/cadre knows everybody who also served in it over a reasonable period of time (as in several years).

As a result of that sort of knowledge I've seen at least one attempt at Walting backfire quite spectacularly, but I guess we are digressing from the thread....

mpsw · 01/03/2023 18:11

Weddingcorker · 01/03/2023 17:33

That's really shitty and just bullying to my mind. There are so many people who exaggerate aspects of their lives in all walks of life, they don't deserve to be publicly shamed by self styled vigilantes. That sort of behaviour can trigger MH breakdowns and potentially suicide. Not something people should support or be proud of.

It's not a specific crime in this country (as it is in US)

But there have been many Walts who have been done for fraud of various kinds.

And if people are impersonating a military officer, how is exposing the impersonation a form of bullying. Saying that someone is a liar, when they are indeed a liar, is fair comment.

RedCarsGoFaster · 01/03/2023 18:11

Weddingcorker · 01/03/2023 17:56

If people are conning others out of money under false pretences then it's a police matter. Unless people have access to JPAC records, no one really knows what someone's service record is. If they are accessing those records and then leaking information to the public domain, that is a security breach which is a serious offence.

Have a look at it on Facebook. The literacy of the authors is terrible, but the points are valid.

They aren't accessing JPA, they usually call for anyone who served in whatever location or time that the Walts make claims about to come forward and either verify or eliminate the claims made. They can also easily verify high profile medals from public records (bravery etc) and it's amazing the knots some of these people tie themselves up in to make claims about why they were apparently issued a WW2 medal in 2007 or similar....

Funny as well how most of the worst public Walts were all decorated snipers in SF, never an AB steward on a frigate.

RedCarsGoFaster · 01/03/2023 18:06

pictoosh · 01/03/2023 17:40

No it really is. The military community aren’t more entitled to bully people than anyone else. You obviously approve but I think they sound a bunch of cunts.

Outing people who claim to have injuries, wearing medals that aren't theirs, people who claim to have served in x y z campaign / unit / regiment / ship isn't bullying. It's catching out liars.

Sadly "stolen valour" is only really a US thing, but I understand it's being considered for a private bill by MP Johnny Mercer in the near future. If that goes through, it'll become a criminal offence.

Weddingcorker · 01/03/2023 17:56

If people are conning others out of money under false pretences then it's a police matter. Unless people have access to JPAC records, no one really knows what someone's service record is. If they are accessing those records and then leaking information to the public domain, that is a security breach which is a serious offence.

notimagain · 01/03/2023 17:50

pictoosh · 01/03/2023 17:40

No it really is. The military community aren’t more entitled to bully people than anyone else. You obviously approve but I think they sound a bunch of cunts.

I wouldn't condone bullying but OTOH there have certainly been instances of "walts" making money/making a living (including lecture tours to unsuspecting usually non mil aware groups) so personally I'm all for the worse offenders being gently called out.

Myusername4321 · 01/03/2023 17:47

LemonTreeSkies · 01/03/2023 01:47

"During the war..!!"

Hehe! Love Uncle Albert.

Weddingcorker · 01/03/2023 17:45

CherryBlossomPants · 01/03/2023 17:37

It’s really not, if you’re in the military community you’d know how disrespectful it is for someone to claim they were in the military or more of what they actually did. Some of the Walter Mitty’a exposed have lied about tours and absolutely deserved to be exposed.

OP tell your husband to stop being such a fucking crowbag

I served for 16 years in the military, my husband did 24.

It really is shitty. Bullying people doesn't honour the friends we lost.

pictoosh · 01/03/2023 17:41

The Facebook group that is, not the military community.

pictoosh · 01/03/2023 17:40

No it really is. The military community aren’t more entitled to bully people than anyone else. You obviously approve but I think they sound a bunch of cunts.

CherryBlossomPants · 01/03/2023 17:37

Weddingcorker · 01/03/2023 17:33

That's really shitty and just bullying to my mind. There are so many people who exaggerate aspects of their lives in all walks of life, they don't deserve to be publicly shamed by self styled vigilantes. That sort of behaviour can trigger MH breakdowns and potentially suicide. Not something people should support or be proud of.

It’s really not, if you’re in the military community you’d know how disrespectful it is for someone to claim they were in the military or more of what they actually did. Some of the Walter Mitty’a exposed have lied about tours and absolutely deserved to be exposed.

OP tell your husband to stop being such a fucking crowbag

Weddingcorker · 01/03/2023 17:33

OopsAnotherOne · 01/03/2023 17:20

Also it's just occurred to me, if he's "bloating" (exaggerating) about his experience in the army or being a "walter mitty" (liar about aspects or all of it), if he is putting some or all of this online, he may be being monitored by the Walter Mitty Hunters Club HQ. They're prominent on Facebook and have a main group and then there are a few other smaller ones. They take tip offs from anonymous people about potential bloaters or walts, they then investigate and pretty much go through the claims with a fine tooth comb and if someone has been found to be doing either, they'll expose them on their website and page. It's made the news several times for exposes on people who over exaggerate their service and this group has a really forensic way of looking into people's details.

I know one person who was exposed by them and rightly so, although it's a pretty undignified, career-ending way of being exposed so it's preferential to avoid being on their radar if at all possible.

That's really shitty and just bullying to my mind. There are so many people who exaggerate aspects of their lives in all walks of life, they don't deserve to be publicly shamed by self styled vigilantes. That sort of behaviour can trigger MH breakdowns and potentially suicide. Not something people should support or be proud of.

HeavenIsAHalfpipe · 01/03/2023 17:22

Yep, I know several people like this. As a pp said, the ones who really did their time and fought hard and got injured and saw their friends die etc, rarely talk about it. I know a man who fought in Desert Storm (early 1990s,) and I knew him for THREE years before I knew this. He didn't even tell me. It just slipped out during a conversation with his mother. The ones who did fuck-all are the ones who carp on about it. When I mentioned it to this man, he said he doesn't want to talk about it.

Not exactly the same but similar, is people who have lived (for several years,) in L.A. or Sydney or Cape Town or somewhere exotic and far away, on a faraway continent. I know a woman who lived in L.A. for 3 years (as a nanny) from 2011 to 2014. She has not stopped rattling on about it since. 'When I was in L.A.............' 100 times per month. She has been back for three times as many years as she was bloody there! No-one cares ARGH!!! Angry The 'stories' from people like this are interesting for the first 4 or 5 times you hear them, but then it's like YAAWWWWN...

OopsAnotherOne · 01/03/2023 17:20

Also it's just occurred to me, if he's "bloating" (exaggerating) about his experience in the army or being a "walter mitty" (liar about aspects or all of it), if he is putting some or all of this online, he may be being monitored by the Walter Mitty Hunters Club HQ. They're prominent on Facebook and have a main group and then there are a few other smaller ones. They take tip offs from anonymous people about potential bloaters or walts, they then investigate and pretty much go through the claims with a fine tooth comb and if someone has been found to be doing either, they'll expose them on their website and page. It's made the news several times for exposes on people who over exaggerate their service and this group has a really forensic way of looking into people's details.

I know one person who was exposed by them and rightly so, although it's a pretty undignified, career-ending way of being exposed so it's preferential to avoid being on their radar if at all possible.

Emmamoo89 · 01/03/2023 17:14

Yanbu

girlfriend44 · 01/03/2023 17:10

DonnaBanana · 01/03/2023 16:28

He's dead now but my grandad was like this back in the day. Always wanging on about the things he got up to during WW2 and the time shortly thereafter. No one cared.

Perhaps he didn't care about what others were talking about either.

Ludo19 · 01/03/2023 17:10

I knew a guy like this. He'd served in the paras. I knew his stories so well, I felt like I had served along side him.

LakeTiticaca · 01/03/2023 17:09

Is he "bloating" his service, ie: elaborating to his audience that he had more service than he actually did? If so anyone who has actually served would catch him.out quite quickly.
I worked with a guy who mentioned on a regular basis that he had served in the navy, and was very particular how things were done on our line of work. He told me it was because of his navy service.
I later discovered he had left the navy 30 years ago after 1 year of service!!!

OopsAnotherOne · 01/03/2023 17:04

Oof OP, that would wind me up! It's the same as when someone shoehorns their "traveling" into every conversation, the memories, the experiences, the culture, the "finding myself", the soul searching, before you realise they actually spent 2 weeks in New Zealand 10 years ago. It's like.....if you'd spent a few years backpacking around Asia then I'd listen to what you're saying but mate you've just been telling me about your holiday!

He's essentially taking all of the perceived glory and admiration given to our troops for himself, despite never seeing service. My Dad also completed the training, basic and further, I can't exactly remember what training it was specifically but he completed it before leaving and getting a civilian job as he decided the military wasn't for him. The reason I can't remember what training he did was because he never mentions it because he wasn't actually in the army! I never saw combat, never did any tours, never acted in his capacity as a "soldier", he dropped out around the same time as your DH did. The only time my dad mentions his time in the army is when someone asks him about his career or how he got into it, as the story starts with "well I signed up for the army but decided that wasn't for me.....". That's all is needed.

I'd personally say to your DH "gosh you go on about the army as if you did several tours of Afghanistan, you do know you only did the training, right?" to shut him up. Preferably in front of people he's telling the stories to.

daretodenim · 01/03/2023 16:56

If he'd actually served and especially if he'd seen action I would have no problem with him talking about it ad nauseum. I had a relative who had experienced some awful things and did occasionally say things, especially when he was drunk (I'm certain he had undiagnosed PTSD). I have a lot of sympathy for people, usually it's men, who leave the armed forces and deeply miss the bond they had with fellow men (and occasionally women), or dead friends, and talk about them a lot. Although that's rare.

But the situation like your DH, well, he's just embarrassing himself. If you want to be nice about it, it may be an idea to point out that he talks about that year (or two?) of his life a bit too much.

Weddingcorker · 01/03/2023 16:53

I've name changed for this as its totally outing.

Between us, DH and I have done 40 years in military service ( Iraq, Afghanistan, N. Ireland, Sierra Leone, you get the idea). I was commissioned, my DH was a WO1.

We went to a wedding once, Dh and I are sat at a table next to a really annoying guy who was married to someone who I think saw herself as a bit of a queen bee type. I knew her from school many years ago and she was always telling everyone how great she was and how perfect her family were.

Anyway, this guy starts mouthing off to me about his time in the service and how great he was and how they just couldn't see his potential. That he was smarter than them and too good for it all. You get the idea.

So I start asking a few questions, just gently finding out what he did ( he has no idea about our backgrounds at this point). As he tells me he gets more and more boastful thinking he's being impressive. Turns out he did basic training and then got kicked out during trade training. He's telling me how all officers are shit and how he was so much better, knew more, had more common sense. Digging deeper and deeper. Anyway, when he stops for breath he asks me what I do (thinking he's impressed me) and I say 'I'm in the military', he looks shocked, then asks what I do, I say I'm a commissioned officer, at which point the blood is visibly draining from his face. He then tries to back track by saying he meant all Warrant Officers are crap, so trying to change the subject he leans over to my DH and asks what he does. My DH, who has been sat there with a wry smile on his face looks him in the eye and says 'I'm a Warrant Officer in the Army'. The guy looked so stunned he literally couldn't speak, went very quiet and was quite pale. I'm guessing in all the years he's been telling the story he's not been in this situation before. I actually felt sorry for him.

When his wife, who hadn't been aware of the conversation at this point, starts trying to big her husband up in front of us, he does frantic cutting motions to his throat saying ' these guys are in the military' and then starts trying to big us up.

Honestly, it was hilarious. Almost like something from a film. We've had a good laugh about that one for years.

We took pity on the guy and ended up being quite nice to him, but he was very sheepish after that.

Shlomping1234 · 01/03/2023 16:39

My ex used to do this. Even using military sayings and slang. I used to tell him he sounded ridiculous as he's never been in the army or even military college. He'd pipe up ' but my brother did' aye you're not your brother you pillock 🤣

InPraiseOfBacchus · 01/03/2023 16:36

DemonSpawn · 01/03/2023 16:24

Forces people think the forces are everything and that they have done something worthwhile. The rest of us couldn’t give a flying feck of course.

1- No they don't, what a weird generalisation. 2 - That's nice for "the rest of us", I guess, whoever they are.