Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find DH’s army stories a bit cringy?

141 replies

Thistledew · 01/03/2023 00:50

In practically any social situation, DH likes to tell stories about his time in the army- the training he did, the people he encountered etc. These are somewhat amusing/interesting/entertaining, but not hugely so. They are his memoirs, rather than being particularly meaningful.

What I find a bit cringy is that he was in the army over 20 years ago, and when I say ‘in the army’, he completed the basic training at the military academy at Sandhurst and left at the end without seeing any active service because he decided he hated army life (fair enough). So ‘the army’ was for him little more than a glorified finishing school.

I just feel a bit embarrassed when he shoehorns a story about the army into practically every social situation we are in, but wonder if IABU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
notimagain · 02/03/2023 11:48

DanseAvecLesLoup · 02/03/2023 11:31

While not military related I was in bar with my sister years ago waiting for a couple of friends to turn up. One chap took a shine to my sister and started trying to chat her up, fairly harmless at first but soon told us he was a professional rugby player. My sister and I come from a rugby family and have followed the game for years so this line of conversation piqued our interest. At first I thought he might have played semi-pro for a lower league club and gave him the benefit of the doubt but no, he had to push it and claimed he played for a certain London Premiership club. My sister played dumb and pretended to be suitably impressed and this chap grew in confidence and started to claim all sorts of great deeds on the rugby field. Our friends eventually turned up and unfortunately for this chap they were both internationals who actually played for the club he claimed to be a key part of. Never seen someone make their excuses and leave so quickly.

😀

That's a classic example of a Walt being caught out claiming to have been in a small elite group....very risky.

The best example I saw was somebody walting about being in the Red Arrows, not realising somebody who really had been in the Reds was sat at the same dinner table.....

That was entertaining.

DanseAvecLesLoup · 02/03/2023 11:31

While not military related I was in bar with my sister years ago waiting for a couple of friends to turn up. One chap took a shine to my sister and started trying to chat her up, fairly harmless at first but soon told us he was a professional rugby player. My sister and I come from a rugby family and have followed the game for years so this line of conversation piqued our interest. At first I thought he might have played semi-pro for a lower league club and gave him the benefit of the doubt but no, he had to push it and claimed he played for a certain London Premiership club. My sister played dumb and pretended to be suitably impressed and this chap grew in confidence and started to claim all sorts of great deeds on the rugby field. Our friends eventually turned up and unfortunately for this chap they were both internationals who actually played for the club he claimed to be a key part of. Never seen someone make their excuses and leave so quickly.

Happysalley · 02/03/2023 11:20

Ex dp does this. Regales unsuspecting bystanders with tales of his army days where he handled REAL guns with REAL bullets. In reality, he did 6 months national service in his home country where he mostly peeled potatoes and guarded empty mountains. Chuck Norris has nothing on him.

Mellymoon · 02/03/2023 11:12

He sounds like he’s very insecure and unconfident in his achievements and maybe has some social anxiety. It is cringe though but I’d look at building his self esteem. Tell him what you genuinely find impressive or interesting about him. Maybe do more hobbies together

mpsw · 02/03/2023 10:45

So these bullies may not realise that the person they are laser focus quizzing about their specific service record is being vague on purpose, not because they’re lying

Anyone who can show they've actually served will be safe from Walt-hunters, even if they've bigged up their story a bit. The sort of people they go after are those who have never served, or are wearing medals to which they have no entitlement whatsoever. Both of which actions are all-too-often accompanied by other fraudulent actions (conning individuals and occasionally even charities for cash or other benefits). There really are some very shitty people out there.

1099 · 02/03/2023 08:41

Why was he in training for 3 years? the RMAS officers course is 44 weeks.

Thistledew · 02/03/2023 08:02

Thanks for all the comments. Sorry I was too busy to reply yesterday.

To be fair to DH he has never claimed to have done any sort of active service or anything beyond the 3 years training. His reasons for leaving and not taking up the commission were also genuine, and not to do with lack of aptitude- he just found he really disliked the way that being in the forces takes over every aspect of your life and you don’t really have a life that is separate from it. He also found himself really uncomfortable with the way that very senior and experienced non-commissioned soldiers were expected to defer to him and his peers just because they had the life choices that enabled them to come in as officers.

I’m going to try to talk to him kindly about this. We are having some issues in our relationship and I’m increasingly thinking that many of these stem from a well-concealed lack of self-esteem on DH’s part. He seems so proud of his army experiences that it feels quite cruel to point out to him that other people don’t view it in the same way, but I think that maybe he needs to let go of it in order to recognise that his worth as a person does not rely on it.

OP posts:
another1bitestheduck · 01/03/2023 20:40

LadyMary50 · 01/03/2023 15:29

Read the post,he was never ‘in’the army he never finished basic training…

The irony of being so eager to jump in to accuse someone else of not reading the post that you reveal you haven't read the post you're criticising....cringe

Hoppinggreen · 01/03/2023 19:16

LightDrizzle · 01/03/2023 01:45

YANBU!
We know someone who was a submariner over 20 years ago, he did do a few years, but Christ! He can’t speak, or post online without shoehorning in some reference to it. He’s even sewn some badge onto a rucksack 😂

My brother worked on submarines, mainly in Gibraltar, mending engines. This was 25 years ago
He started a conversation the other day with “when I was in Iraq helping clean up bodies”

shopmyfeelings · 01/03/2023 19:14

There are many tragic bores.
Golf, wine, cycling for example, but I think forces bored are the worst of them all. Their stories are generally macho bullshit and I see no glory in it.

Whammyyammy · 01/03/2023 19:14

Try and mix with people thst have actually been in the military. They will rib him for not being able to get past basic training, and therefore technically wasn't even in the army, just a wannabe.

He'll get the message.

QuestionableMouse · 01/03/2023 19:09

I went to uni with a man like this. He related everything back to his army days and his "trauma". It got really old quick, especially when someone else found out he'd only (just) completed basic training and all ofnhis war stories were fabricated.

Callipygion · 01/03/2023 19:08

LemonTreeSkies · 01/03/2023 01:47

"During the war..!!"

Haha! Exactly what I was thinking! (Is that you Uncle Albert?)

pictoosh · 01/03/2023 18:51

Agree about the stupid ‘Walt-shaming’ group being utter utter bullies.
Trial by Facebook eh?
Dumb fucks.

Undermyumberellaellaella · 01/03/2023 18:40

I'd be embarrassed OP and probably pull him up on it. It's like going on a boat trip and saying you're a sailor.

tothelefttotheleft · 01/03/2023 18:35

DonnaBanana · 01/03/2023 16:28

He's dead now but my grandad was like this back in the day. Always wanging on about the things he got up to during WW2 and the time shortly thereafter. No one cared.

Perhaps he needed to talk about stuff he'd been through. Being in a war is different to the op's partner.

JoonT · 01/03/2023 18:32

Somebody (can’t remember the quote) once defined a bore as a person who talks about themselves. The only thing more boring than listening to people reminisce about stuff that means nothing to me is listening to them talk about their kids.

Rule one in the art of conversation is don’t repeat your store of ‘hilarious anecdotes’.

Oh my god, I just re-read your post OP. I thought you meant he was in the army for 20 years! Christ, he just did basic training. That’s actually kind of sad (as in pathetic). If he’d fought in the Falklands, or served in the SAS in Iraq, then fair enough.

If you want a killer put down, next time he goes into one at a dinner party, or whatever, say “yes, he’s hoping Hollywood will make a movie about his life - a sort of Rambo update.”

another1bitestheduck · 01/03/2023 18:30

Does he tell the story "when I was in the army" with the implication he was in the armed forces for a while, or does he make clear that it happened in basic training and he then quit?
If the first that is really cringey, isn't he concerned that someone will start asking 'Oh, you were in the army, where did you serve/what rank did you reach etc.' and then have to explain 'oh well I immediately dropped out!'

It's like saying "When I lived abroad..." when you just went to Spain for 3 weeks on holiday!

If it's the second, so the 'in the army' bit is just to provide context, that sort of makes sense - I have quite a lot of stories that start 'when I was in uni' because that's when I was young and carefree and did funny/stupid things!

Deezeboob · 01/03/2023 18:28

Ugh, I had an ex exactly the same. Its too cringey.

It's like its the only identity he could hold onto, even if it was only a short period of his life and its quite sad actually. Gave me the ick.

notimagain · 01/03/2023 18:25

@mpsw

That balcony must have been fucking huge - the number of people who say they were the second man on to it!

Absolutely, Albert Hall sized at least... 😉

Weddingcorker · 01/03/2023 18:23

And if people are impersonating a military officer, how is exposing the impersonation a form of bullying. Saying that someone is a liar, when they are indeed a liar, is fair comment

Because its trial by Facebook.

If it becomes a criminal offence to impersonate a veteran then throw the book at them. If someone is using their lies to con people out of money then report them to the police.

If someone is falsely claiming regimental honours, then alert the regiment in question.

Vigilantes using Facebook to publicly humiliate someone is not something I support.

RattlewhenIwalk · 01/03/2023 18:22

The ones that really irritate me are the ones that describe themselves as being "ex forces" or "veterans" despite having been in the services for 5 minutes and having been nowhere or done nothing.

HeavenIsAHalfpipe · 01/03/2023 18:20

Weddingcorker · 01/03/2023 17:33

That's really shitty and just bullying to my mind. There are so many people who exaggerate aspects of their lives in all walks of life, they don't deserve to be publicly shamed by self styled vigilantes. That sort of behaviour can trigger MH breakdowns and potentially suicide. Not something people should support or be proud of.

Agree. Whilst it's not very nice for people to pretend they were a 'war hero' - or say they did things they never did - it is MUCH worse to shame them, and 'out' them on facebook. This vigilante type behaviour, where someone smugly 'catches someone out' and 'shames' them. is vile and nasty, and yes, totally bullying. By all means, approach them privately and personally, and tell them your 'findings,' but to shame them publicly is just vile, and utter utter bullying.

Bit like the twats on facebook who post a pic of someone's car with their full registration, and a photo of the person driving off (on the town facebook page for 25,000 people to see,) because they scraped their car slightly, and drove off. Why? To what end? To make nasty little vigilantes attack said person, slash their tyres, throw shit at them in the street?! Chances are they may not have realised they clipped anyone's car, and the police are not more likely to help you, and chase after them for the repair costs, because you 'shamed' them in front of 25,000 people.

Utterly classless, nasty, bullying behaviour. Probably the same when they were at school.

Onnabugeisha · 01/03/2023 18:20

Weddingcorker · 01/03/2023 17:45

I served for 16 years in the military, my husband did 24.

It really is shitty. Bullying people doesn't honour the friends we lost.

I also agree its bullying. I did 18yrs (retired disabled) and my DH did 4yrs (single enlistment). There’s a lot we did that even today we cannot talk about due to the Secrets Act. So these bullies may not realise that the person they are laser focus quizzing about their specific service record is being vague on purpose, not because they’re lying.

mpsw · 01/03/2023 18:19

True but unfortunately some "Walts" get over enthusiastic and make the mistake of claiming they were part of a small, perhaps vaguely elite cadre/unit where pretty much everybody who really was in that unit/cadre knows everybody who also served in it over a reasonable period of time (as in several years)

That balcony must have been fucking huge - the number of people who say they were the second man on to it!