Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not use the baby name we picked because she has used it?

234 replies

Elciekay · 28/02/2023 23:02

So I'll try to be as unemotional about this as possible and this is incredibly outing but I'm genuinely at a loss as what to do.

Also this is my first ever thread and I'm not 100% sure on all the MN acronyms!

I have a step-sister who I lived with since I was aged 6 until 15 (she went to university). Our family consists of my mum, brother, me and my sted-dad and two step-sisters.

DSS is 4 years older than me. She became pregnant last spring/summer. I became pregnant last summer. Her due date was 8 weeks before mine. Both expecting girls.

DSS told my mum she liked the name Josephine. My mum told her Elciekay has chosen that name.

DSS said 'oh well we are going to call her Joey and Elciekay can call hers Josie'

Fast forward to today and DSS has finally told my Mum she named her daughter Josphine (4 weeks old)

I am very upset as I had my heart set on Josephine/Josie.
I am due in 4 weeks.

So my question is, do I use the name anyway or not? Yes we have other options but none feel quite right.

For what it's worth the family get together now between 8-10 times a year.

So:

  • AIBU it's a name, who cares if they have the same name?
  • YANBU they can't have the same name, pick something else
OP posts:
Gillyyy · 01/03/2023 05:04

I wouldn’t use it, mainly because for your daughter I think it’d be nice to have her own name rather than the same as her cousin.

I think using Harriet as a middle name would be a lovely way to honour your loss.

The first name that really jumped out for me was Rosanna Harriet, nicknames could be Rosie or Annie which has a similar feel to Hattie.

Florence Harriet is also very pretty!

Others I really like:

Tabitha Harriet
Beatrice/Beatrix Harriet
Daisy Harriet

I think there are so many beautiful names to choose from, you can find something just as special for your daughter.

ShandaLear · 01/03/2023 05:01

Josephine is much nicer that Harriet!

Zonder · 01/03/2023 04:59

Flojoohno · 01/03/2023 00:42

Pick a different name, more so because of your loss. Maybe DSS didn’t think you’d use the name again.
Matilda is lovely, Mattie for short is very similar to Hattie.

This. Remember your first baby with that name and start again with a new name for this baby

It does sound like you could all do with some help to get along though. This whole idea of stealing things from one another needs dealing with. You can't steal a university - I've known several siblings go to the same uni as each other and nobody would think anyone stole it!

bussteward · 01/03/2023 04:32

Historically it was normal.
Historically lots of bad ideas were normal.

MaireadMcSweeney · 01/03/2023 04:10

Use Harriet as a middle name for your first daughter but give this child her own name.

Youdoyoubabe · 01/03/2023 04:00

Having read further, so sorry your previous baby didn’t make it. I also think it is nice to use the same name you had planned for your earlier pregnancy.

I have a cousin with the same name as me and we both like itMakes us feel like in a special club as if we were twins or something. It is sweet. Use the name of it has not been too tarnished for you.

JudgeRudy · 01/03/2023 03:53

Thekirit · 01/03/2023 01:31

Louds of Families use the same names
At a family wedding we had 14 Michaels, ages 80 to 2yrs and everything in between
So many Mary’s I lost count
Every family in my family has one daughter with the same name as mine
At gatherings we all line up for photos.

It really is quite normal

If you love the name don’t compromise.

Ps We also have six Josephine’s.

Don't want to presume but are you Irish? It's not usual in England. I don't think anyone would think it was abnormal, but it would certainly get noticed and probably commented on.

Youdoyoubabe · 01/03/2023 03:52

You can still use it. JoJo is a nice diminutive too. Or look at Baby Names Wizard for similar options. Genevieve?

JudgeRudy · 01/03/2023 03:50

GPFavo · 28/02/2023 23:58

Do you realise how nasty this post is?

I don't find it nasty. Blunt maybe but there's no malice there. I find the term Angel Baby rather icky too (but not quite as bad as Rainbow Baby).

IdisagreeMrHochhauser · 01/03/2023 03:45

Shame you didn't want the Harri nickname as I know an Angharad that goes by Hari.

JudgeRudy · 01/03/2023 03:40

Elciekay · 28/02/2023 23:21

@Yahyahs22 not so much drama between us two but she is who I am least close to.

Historically, her sister 'stole' the university she wanted to go to so maybe this is normal for them?

I know this isnt what your tales about but how do you steal a university? Do you mean one sister was admitted to the uni where the other was rejected? Or one sister elected to study at fhe same uni? Neither of these choices seem unreasonable.

Oh and regards the name. It's OK to have 2 x Josephines in the family particularly if you'll use different nic names. If you had a baby that died I think it's a bit insensitive of you step sister and her OH, but if you had an early miscarriage and had just mentioned a name you might like if you had a girl.....I think it's fair game to use it.
What does your OH think? Any other names he particularly liked?

PyongyangKipperbang · 01/03/2023 03:27

As the mother of a Harriet (Hattie) who is a twinless twin to her sister Mary.....go with what your heart says and to hell with everyone else.

Just that.

Kitkatcatflap · 01/03/2023 02:49

I have the same.name.as two second cousins (a very age related name). We rarely see either now we are all grown, one moved up north as a teenager. The other emigrated to Australia and I now live in Scandinavia. We all hear about each other via different family members and we refer to them by their full name ie Josephine Smith has a new dog Josephine Carter is going on holiday to .Greece etc.

Rinkydinkydoodle · 01/03/2023 02:40

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 01/03/2023 01:38

This is going to sound nuts, @Elciekay

The actress Hattie Jacques full name was Josephine Edwina Jacques.
A colleague gave her the nickname "Hattie" after one of her early performances, and it stuck.

I don't know if you knew this? Grin

Serendipity!🤣

Putthefireon · 01/03/2023 02:38

TheBigWangTheory · 28/02/2023 23:25

I would find that utterly bizarre from a grief counsellor. If you've already attached to a foetus enough to name it, why would you then give the name to another child?
I know people used to call new babies after previous ones that lived and died, but that wouldn;t be seen as normal now.

I have actually done this as I had a stillborn. I changed the spelling but it's still the same name. Nothing wrong with doing so. DC knows they share their name with a sibling who died & Is okay with that.

Thekirit · 01/03/2023 02:33

soleilblue · 01/03/2023 02:27

You have no idea, your dad might have been ok with it but others may have struggled with the weight

We’ll have to agree to disagree on this
Like I said we consider it an honour
You don't and that’s great as OP gets to explore both opinions.
Which is why she’s asked.

soleilblue · 01/03/2023 02:27

Thekirit · 01/03/2023 01:52

My family have done it for generations.

My dad was the third Michael, the first died at 1yr, the second at 6yrs.

There were also 2 Johns, etc etc
Historically it was normal.
These days less children die in childhood, but people still have miscarriages and …yes …family members have kept the names they loved and used them.

No ones ever suffered from it.
My dad always said it was an honour.

Clearly OPs therapist thinks it’s a good thing too.

You have no idea, your dad might have been ok with it but others may have struggled with the weight

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/03/2023 02:23

No ones ever suffered from it.

That's quite the generalisation.

Thekirit · 01/03/2023 01:52

soleilblue · 01/03/2023 01:44

Make the 1st child part of the 2nd one? What a weight to carry.

My family have done it for generations.

My dad was the third Michael, the first died at 1yr, the second at 6yrs.

There were also 2 Johns, etc etc
Historically it was normal.
These days less children die in childhood, but people still have miscarriages and …yes …family members have kept the names they loved and used them.

No ones ever suffered from it.
My dad always said it was an honour.

Clearly OPs therapist thinks it’s a good thing too.

Thekirit · 01/03/2023 01:48

Thekirit · 01/03/2023 01:31

Louds of Families use the same names
At a family wedding we had 14 Michaels, ages 80 to 2yrs and everything in between
So many Mary’s I lost count
Every family in my family has one daughter with the same name as mine
At gatherings we all line up for photos.

It really is quite normal

If you love the name don’t compromise.

Ps We also have six Josephine’s.

Oop just read your later posts
not Josephine then😫

we don’t have any Harriet’s but it is a beautiful name.

soleilblue · 01/03/2023 01:44

Thekirit · 01/03/2023 01:41

It’s a lovely thing to do. What a thing to say

Make the 1st child part of the 2nd one? What a weight to carry.

Thekirit · 01/03/2023 01:41

soleilblue · 01/03/2023 01:32

That is an awful thing to do to your 2nd child

It’s a lovely thing to do. What a thing to say

MrsJessePinkmann · 01/03/2023 01:40

This is why you never tell people your baby names.

I personally wouldn't use it.

Thekirit · 01/03/2023 01:39

Elciekay · 28/02/2023 23:22

@TheBigWangTheory interesting perspective... aside from it being the name I've wanted since childhood, using it was recommended by my grief counsellor!

Lots of posters are saying not to use a name that you thought of for a previous pregnancy. Suggesting this is wrong
I disagree
Many families do this and again like my previous post mine have , both in my generation and in previous.
It was quite common to re use a name if a child died even if they were quite old…Not just family names you pass on down the generations but also ones you just like.

Theres nothing wrong with this
You should do what you want.

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 01/03/2023 01:38

This is going to sound nuts, @Elciekay

The actress Hattie Jacques full name was Josephine Edwina Jacques.
A colleague gave her the nickname "Hattie" after one of her early performances, and it stuck.

I don't know if you knew this? Grin