Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not use the baby name we picked because she has used it?

234 replies

Elciekay · 28/02/2023 23:02

So I'll try to be as unemotional about this as possible and this is incredibly outing but I'm genuinely at a loss as what to do.

Also this is my first ever thread and I'm not 100% sure on all the MN acronyms!

I have a step-sister who I lived with since I was aged 6 until 15 (she went to university). Our family consists of my mum, brother, me and my sted-dad and two step-sisters.

DSS is 4 years older than me. She became pregnant last spring/summer. I became pregnant last summer. Her due date was 8 weeks before mine. Both expecting girls.

DSS told my mum she liked the name Josephine. My mum told her Elciekay has chosen that name.

DSS said 'oh well we are going to call her Joey and Elciekay can call hers Josie'

Fast forward to today and DSS has finally told my Mum she named her daughter Josphine (4 weeks old)

I am very upset as I had my heart set on Josephine/Josie.
I am due in 4 weeks.

So my question is, do I use the name anyway or not? Yes we have other options but none feel quite right.

For what it's worth the family get together now between 8-10 times a year.

So:

  • AIBU it's a name, who cares if they have the same name?
  • YANBU they can't have the same name, pick something else
OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 01/03/2023 08:50

I'm surprised at all the people questioning your decision to use the same name as your previous pregnancy. If OP is comfortable with it and feels that would help her that's all that matters, telling her she shouldn't do it is cruel, regardless of what other people would do.

In these circumstances I would just use it. She fully knew you were intending to and it wouldn't cause a fall out. I'd either just use it, or use the shortened version.

SugarRushCrush · 01/03/2023 08:50

Then if you change your mind you could always call her by her middle and instead which quite a lot of people do

SugarRushCrush · 01/03/2023 08:49

Haven't read the whole thread just your responses but could you use it as a middle name? And then think of first name that is really meaningful to you so you don't regret it?

Justmeandthedog1 · 01/03/2023 08:48

My cousins ( brother and sister) gave their daughters the same name. They were born 4 years apart so the first “Anne” was well established when second was born. It wasn’t a name that could be shortened or changed but no one seemed to mind.
If you really like Josephine go for it.

Lambchop1 · 01/03/2023 08:35

Use the name, pick a lovely middle name too and you can call her either if you like. You don’t see her much as she has behaved unfairly imo, so it’s all fair game.

you had your heart set on the name and you want to use it. Done deal.

Untitledsquatboulder · 01/03/2023 08:31

DedicatedFollowerOfFashion84 · 01/03/2023 08:23

I think the bigger concern here is that you’d consider naming your child after a baby you’d lost who you’d already named…

This. Speaking as one, being the first child born after a loss comes with a lot of emotional baggage as it is. Naming your new baby after the one you lost - that's not a good thing (and Im putting that mildly).

WalkingOnTheCracks · 01/03/2023 08:28

Eyerollcentral · 01/03/2023 00:05

Josephine is a far nicer name

I don't think the idea here is to express an opinion on the alternatives, but...er..no, Josephine is not. Of the list given, I'd go for Matilda.

See, isn't that a help?

DedicatedFollowerOfFashion84 · 01/03/2023 08:23

I think the bigger concern here is that you’d consider naming your child after a baby you’d lost who you’d already named…

TheGoogleMum · 01/03/2023 08:23

It's strange she stole your name tbh, but can't control that unfortunately
My DH has the same name as his cousin, but it was their grandfather's name
It feels a bit strange to do same name nowadays but if you've got your heart set on it then do it
I think I prefer some of the alternatives mentioned on here to Harriet though!

Heather sounds kind of similar to me as an option?

TeenLifeMum · 01/03/2023 08:14

I find it more odd that she’d choose the name of the baby her dss lost. Give your lovely Dd her own name with Harriet as the middle name. That’s a special link to her sister without being in the shadow.

SoonBeTeaTime · 01/03/2023 08:10

DelphiniumBlue · 01/03/2023 07:31

I agree with all of this.
Find another name for the sake of your baby.

This was exactly my thinking too, but I didn't want to get jumped on for saying it. I'm not convinced naming a baby the same as the one you lost is a good idea, I'm surprised a counsellor would suggest this.

I'd find a completely new name.

WoofWoofBeachLife · 01/03/2023 08:03

Use Harriet as a middle name and choose an individual first one for her. Then you still have the rememberence of your loss, and your baby is an individual in her own right. X

kimchifix · 01/03/2023 08:03

You could use it as a middle name or give it as the first name on the birth certificate but call the baby by the middle name. My father is known by his middle name and always had been as his first name was the "family" name & there were loads of them. This is obviously discounting any future discussions with your child about the planned use of the name for the lost older sibling.

Alternatively, I like Mattie which is similar. If your DSS knew about all of this I think she's been insensitive, but there's nothing you can do about that now. Maybe this baby deserves a name no one can associate with any of this stuff - her own unique name? Use Harriet as her middle in honour of her sister. That's what I would do I think.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 01/03/2023 08:03

Hattie and Harry are quite different so I wouldn't let that bother me, only you know whether having the same name as the baby you lost would be an issue for you.

LookItsMeAgain · 01/03/2023 08:00

@Elciekay - congratulations on your pregnancy. Sincere condolences on your earlier loss.

Can I suggest that you stop telling your family all of your decisions, all of your details, and so on? The less information of this type that they know, the less information of this type that they can share with others, reducing the likelihood of someone 'taking' a name that you had earmarked for your own use.

No need to be rude if asked, just deflect the question.

Bournetilly · 01/03/2023 07:56

I’m sorry for your loss.

I personally wouldn’t name baby the same as your baby who passed away. I would use Harriet as a middle name though.

I do like Hattie on it’s own, could that be an option?
Also really like the name Josephine/ Josie.

FishandChipsarelife · 01/03/2023 07:56

I actually prefer all your alternatives. My niece has just had a baby and her middle name is the name of my SILs baby that died a few hours after birth. Its a lovely touch.

Fansandblankets · 01/03/2023 07:56

TheBigWangTheory · 28/02/2023 23:25

I would find that utterly bizarre from a grief counsellor. If you've already attached to a foetus enough to name it, why would you then give the name to another child?
I know people used to call new babies after previous ones that lived and died, but that wouldn;t be seen as normal now.

Agree with this.

ive had several miscarriages but not so late that I knew the sex or named them. If I’d lost a baby late enough to know the sex and give them a name I wouldn’t use that name for any subsequent children.

in this situation for that reason alone I’d find a new name.

AliceS1994 · 01/03/2023 07:50

I would use it, it means so much to you I think you might always regret not doing it. Cousins having the same name is fine in my book, and as others have said it's very common in certain cultures, religions etc. and just where families have multi generational names. You will be able to differentiate, it will be a minor inconvenience at worst, but that's better than you always wishing yous done it. That aside, it was horrible of her to use the name in my opinion....

harriethoyle · 01/03/2023 07:42

Elciekay · 28/02/2023 23:22

@TheBigWangTheory interesting perspective... aside from it being the name I've wanted since childhood, using it was recommended by my grief counsellor!

Honestly @Elciekay if I had been her I would have assumed you wouldn't use it because it was the name you picked for the daughter you lost. I find it a bizarre suggestion from your grief counsellor and wonder if your second daughter will always feel under the shadow of your first...

Confusion101 · 01/03/2023 07:36

Elciekay · 01/03/2023 00:29

@Bensmum1988 unfortunately, Henrietta just doesn't sit right. A friend suggested I just use Hattie and forgo Harriet but I know I'm leaning towards a formal name and then a nickname.

But you might use the nickname but that doesn't mean everyone will. When she starts school she will be registered as Harriet and so teachers and friends might use her formal name then. I'd go with Hattie if that's what you plan on calling her all the time anyway and DSS can't say anything about that

DelphiniumBlue · 01/03/2023 07:31

Whataretheodds · 28/02/2023 23:30

Weird of her to name her baby after your baby that died.

Weird of the grief counsellor to suggest naming your next baby after the first one. 'allow first loss to live on through another' I'm astonished. The baby you're expecting now should be allowed to be its own person not a phantom of its dead sibling.

I agree with all of this.
Find another name for the sake of your baby.

RichardHeed · 01/03/2023 07:31

Wishawisha · 01/03/2023 07:01

I can see this.

Just imagine being a teenager full of hormones and self loathing and thinking to yourself “I wonder what the real Josie would be like” or “if they’d had the first Josie, I wouldn’t be here”.

I think it’s great that as a society we are less secretive about miscarriage and stillbirth now but I think we do need to think carefully, amongst being so open, about the information we share with our children who are perhaps too young to understand.

I had a few miscarriages between DC 1 and 2 and I think I won’t share that information with my children until they’re older - perhaps adults thinking about their own fertility - it’s too much to put on children. Just my own decision.

Also OP I wouldn’t want to use a name a step sibling used. It sounds like you see them a lot (8-10x a year?) so it’s not like a cousin that you only see at weddings and funerals.

A teenager full of raging hormones could also be thinking “I wonder if the first baby had lived would I even exist” so by that logic we shouldn’t even go on to have babies post miscarriage just in case they might get upset as an irrational teenager.

Meandfour · 01/03/2023 07:29

Normally I say no but I think you can use it for the following reason;

  1. she said it was fine
  2. various nickname options
  3. you clearly aren’t close and don’t speak much
  4. you don’t see each other often

Its not like these children will be growing up together so I think it’s fine.

RichardHeed · 01/03/2023 07:28

JudgeRudy · 01/03/2023 03:50

I don't find it nasty. Blunt maybe but there's no malice there. I find the term Angel Baby rather icky too (but not quite as bad as Rainbow Baby).

You know what’s more icky? Policing how people refer to their dead children.