Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not use the baby name we picked because she has used it?

234 replies

Elciekay · 28/02/2023 23:02

So I'll try to be as unemotional about this as possible and this is incredibly outing but I'm genuinely at a loss as what to do.

Also this is my first ever thread and I'm not 100% sure on all the MN acronyms!

I have a step-sister who I lived with since I was aged 6 until 15 (she went to university). Our family consists of my mum, brother, me and my sted-dad and two step-sisters.

DSS is 4 years older than me. She became pregnant last spring/summer. I became pregnant last summer. Her due date was 8 weeks before mine. Both expecting girls.

DSS told my mum she liked the name Josephine. My mum told her Elciekay has chosen that name.

DSS said 'oh well we are going to call her Joey and Elciekay can call hers Josie'

Fast forward to today and DSS has finally told my Mum she named her daughter Josphine (4 weeks old)

I am very upset as I had my heart set on Josephine/Josie.
I am due in 4 weeks.

So my question is, do I use the name anyway or not? Yes we have other options but none feel quite right.

For what it's worth the family get together now between 8-10 times a year.

So:

  • AIBU it's a name, who cares if they have the same name?
  • YANBU they can't have the same name, pick something else
OP posts:
CandlelightGlow · 01/03/2023 09:58

I wouldn't care - the name you want is the name you want. I have a friend who has a friend (not a mutual one) and they both had a baby within weeks of each other and used the same name! It's just not an issue.

They already know you like it and wanted it first so it's not like you can be accused of "copying"

rumporolypolyofthebailey · 01/03/2023 09:55

ok so posted before I had rtft How about Henrietta It shortens nicely to Etta

rumporolypolyofthebailey · 01/03/2023 09:49

If you were planning to shorten it anyway why not use something like Joisette? Or just use Josie

pontipinemum · 01/03/2023 09:49

I'm glad you got answers that made you feel calmer.

For what it's worth I think Josephine is a beautiful name. I am also in the group of don't call this baby after the baby you lost. I had named (only in my head) my first baby that I lost pretty early on and now I could never not associate that name with that MC. From then on I choose nicknames until I finally had a successful pregnancy.

purpledalmation · 01/03/2023 09:42

I'd use it.

JenniferBarkley · 01/03/2023 09:33

I don't think OP means she would be naming the baby after it's stillborn sibling. I think she means she had a miscarriage, and had Harriet on her list for if the baby was a girl.

bellabasset · 01/03/2023 09:32

Wait until your baby arrives before choosing her name. You could give her a different first name with your original choice as a second name.

Hadtocomment · 01/03/2023 09:32

Op you sound really nice. Your SS sounds like she maybe has a few jealousy issues or something. I don't want to judge on the internet though as she might have a different perspective.

She doesn't sound like a monster to me though. It just sounds tiring and a bit petty of her. But of course from your side it probably doesn't feel small and petty because the name has a big significance for you and also is attached to a very real and raw grief which will makes it even more significant and upsetting.

I do think it can be hard for people who haven't been through something that raw and upsetting to totally understand how big that grief can be. Your step sister may not be horrible but just insensitive or not very mature. Only you can know that. My instinct from what you've said is not to cut her off but to try not to allow her small actions upset you so much and maybe see them more about her insecurities. I know that the name has huge significance to you. It's also quite a popular and fashionable name right now and perhaps it was that that meant she was really drawn to it. Or it could be subconsciously she did want to grab attention for herself but it doesn't sound conscious somehow from what you've said.

Whether it's a petty action or completely unthinking, I'd wonder if she was a child who felt she didn't get enough attention or was a bit jealous when young etc etc. I don't know the background of your relationship. But I wouldn't cut her off for this. Siblings can go through all sorts of stages and you can be at daggers drawn at some points in life and then become extremely close at other points and they would then really regret cutting each other off at the difficult times. She sounds somewhat self-centred but I wonder if she might grow out of this or this might die down. The remark you made off the cuff about being worried about the two Josephines being compared was telling to me. You also sound conscious of some kind of competitive thing. Families can do this and it's shit. BUt you can just refuse to play that game. It's not good for either you or your step sister. Maybe your family roles have kind of set you both up in that mode slightly but you don't have to do that, kids don't have to be compared and the pair of you aren't in competition with each other, even if there are outside dynamics. I'd also say that this kind of thing can dies down a lot later on for sibs, and relationships can improve when those outside comparisons go away eventually.

On the names, it's absolutely up to you and you should feel free to choose the name you want to choose. You know you have a right to use the name you loved first. Don't even consider comparisons etc. In big families many people will have the same names and various nicknames. In the past there were so many Johns and Marys and families could be huge and sometimes even sibs got the same first names with different nicknames! The thing about your former loss is also for you to decide what works for you. Don't like either a counsellor or the internet tell you what is or isn't appropriate.

UnfinishedBusiness · 01/03/2023 09:32

SwordToFlamethrower · 01/03/2023 09:28

Two of my nephews are called Charlie. No one cared. Use the name you love

The issue here is that the child as she grows up may very much care that they are named after their deceased sibling. I imagine they would much prefer to hold their own name, one picked for them only. I imagine it might well make you feel like you were a replacement for someone lost, rather than a much wanted daughter in your own right.

SwordToFlamethrower · 01/03/2023 09:28

Two of my nephews are called Charlie. No one cared. Use the name you love

raguragu · 01/03/2023 09:25

Hester or Henrietta w nn of Hettie

Whydoitry · 01/03/2023 09:23

How about Haidie (Hay-dee), or Hallie?

But I really like Josephine!

raguragu · 01/03/2023 09:20

OP

Go for something entirely different . Is there a grandmother or ancestors name you can have?

Harriet/ Harry isnt a great name

Josephine/ Josie is better

SD1978 · 01/03/2023 09:19

With your update, like others. I am very surprised by your councillor. I am so sorry for your loss, but surely that name, in your little family is already taken by your first daughter? I find it very strange that they suggested naming your next child the name you gave your first child. I would seriously consider a different name, and your step sister is a c*%t for using the name of your first child who didn't survive, but was still a much loved baby in her own right.

nanodyne · 01/03/2023 09:17

I've only read through your posts OP, but YANBU that seems like a petty thing for DSS to do. I do think using a different name would be best for you though, how about Alexandra - Alex/Lexi?

aSofaNearYou · 01/03/2023 09:17

@Ceryneianhind I'd say it depends how the parents handle it and how much they reference their loss. I wouldn't try and tell OP how to grieve, either way.

Itsagrandoldteam · 01/03/2023 09:14

My son has the same name as my brother's son, nobody cares it's just a name. I hardly ever see my brother so I knew it wasn't going to be an issue.
Call your daughter Josephine, the shortened names you both are going to use are very different. All the best.

Whydoitry · 01/03/2023 09:10

I would use it.

Firstly, your DSS knew it is the name you'd chosen, it's not a surprise for her. I actually think it's cruel of her to use it in the circumstances.

Secondly, I had the same name as my cousin. We saw each other less (about once a year), but it caused zero issues.

coffeestrongblacknosugar · 01/03/2023 09:08

What about Kitty? you could have a formal version 'Kathryn' but call her Kitty.

Branleuse · 01/03/2023 09:08

My uncle ,my mums brother used same name for their sons. My dad has same name as one of his nephews. I think its not that uncommon in families for names to be repeated. I think in your shoes I would use the name you have already chosen and love, as in reality they will use different nicknames anyway and will both make the name their own.
I do think in your circumstances I would probably not be that impressed with your stepsister, but try and not take too much notice and dont let her influence you too much or make you feel you cant use it

ouch321 · 01/03/2023 09:05

I would love to hear all this from the side of the step sister.

Ceryneianhind · 01/03/2023 09:03

aSofaNearYou · 01/03/2023 08:50

I'm surprised at all the people questioning your decision to use the same name as your previous pregnancy. If OP is comfortable with it and feels that would help her that's all that matters, telling her she shouldn't do it is cruel, regardless of what other people would do.

In these circumstances I would just use it. She fully knew you were intending to and it wouldn't cause a fall out. I'd either just use it, or use the shortened version.

Really?
You cant see any issues at all with being named after your dead sibling? Nothing?

www.researchgate.net/publication/343743389_Necronym_the_effects_of_bearing_a_dead_little_sibling's_name

Theres some interesting stuff in here, (I skim read it, and these bits stood out to me)

Whereas ‘subsequent child’entails all children born after the loss of an older sibling,the term ‘replacement child’refers to a child conceived shortly after this loss (Cain & Cain,1964; Olmsted & Poznanski, 1972). Krell and Rabkin (1980)Q7 identified three types of135replacement embodied in surviving children, all of which derive from parents’consciousand unconscious expectations: the ‘haunted child’, who often knows nothing about theirpredecessor, causing the parents to suffer from guilt and shame; the ‘bound child’,characterised by excessive protection; and the ‘resurrected child’, who is treated asa reincarnation.

Theme 2: identity problems related to the necronymThe name itself was mostly associated with a deep feeling of loss. The narratives of Sofia,Simone and Ilaria continually evoked the oxymoron of absent presence:265My name continually reminds me of this loss.

The sorrow has become deeper since I visited his grave and saw my name on the tombstone; tears came down on me like a river. Very sorry,I’m still very sorry for this loss [Sofia 4:7]

I would have liked to have had a sister with her name, different from me and with a namedifferent from my own name, perhaps a younger or older sister, but concrete –not a dead one270with my name. Not something that is nothing. Somehow my name suggests to me that itindicates non-existence [Simone 5:23].

I never wished for her. I never wanted to visit her at the cemetery. Never. I don’t want to seemy name on the tombstone. To me, she doesn’t exist. I have only to carry on the condemna-tion of inheriting the name [Ilaria 19:12].275

In other cases, the name became a placeholder that indicated absent presence as theimpending void of death –a void that the replacement child was made to fill to assuagetheir parents’unconscious needs.

ClairDeLaLune · 01/03/2023 08:59

Counsellors shouldn’t be recommending anything. It’s the first rule of counselling - you don’t advise. SS should not have used that name knowing the story behind it, I would be upset about that. But not to the extent I’d cut her off, I’d try and rise above it and be the better person. But I would pick a different name for your new baby to give her a different identity from her older sister who sadly didn’t make it. Sorry for your loss OP Flowers

JudgeRudy · 01/03/2023 08:58

RichardHeed · 01/03/2023 07:28

You know what’s more icky? Policing how people refer to their dead children.

No policing at all. I was clarifying why I didn't find @TheBigWangTheory s response nasty.

Even if you disagreed, icky would probably not be the correct word.

gabsdot45 · 01/03/2023 08:52

You can use it.
My brother a d a cousin of ours are both called John after their dads. They were born a few months apart.
It's no issue. And I this case you'll be using different shortened versions so it's even better

Swipe left for the next trending thread