Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much disdain towards tradesmen on MN?

241 replies

Enfys1982 · 28/02/2023 21:41

I’m genuinely baffled by it. Most of the men in my family are in trade. including my dad and brother. They are not lazy cowboys or crooks, my dad has worked since he started his apprenticeship when he was fifteen and has never been out of work since (he’s now semi retired) and barely had a day off sick either. He pays all his taxes and his is a registered Limited company with companies house. All are as honest as the day is long. No tax dodging or cash in hand jobs.

Please also be assured that none of them are ‘thick’ as posters are implying on one thread. You won’t see a ‘thick’ plumber or electrician as they need good GCSE grades, particularly in Maths, English and Science, to get a place at college to train. It’s very, very competitive and anything less than a B is pushing it for a place. They’re not going to let ‘thick people’ install gas boilers or rewire peoples homes ffs🙄

Rant over!

OP posts:
magicthree · 01/03/2023 05:45

Because many on MN are snobs. People in trades are respected where I live - not the UK.

FangsForTheMemory · 01/03/2023 05:03

There are tradesmen and tradesmen. I’ve known one brilliant gas engineer and one ok one as against half a dozen who would rip off anyone. I’ve now got a brilliant carpenter and I won’t let anyone else do work on my house. However the guys who fitted the flooring were arseholes. It all depends.

Emptycrackedcup · 01/03/2023 04:33

Unfortunately because (imo) the majority I've encountered have been hopeless at turning up on time if at all, and/or have been cowboys. A good tradie is worth their weight in gold and I would go out of my way to recommend them, unfortunately the good ones are few and far between. Perhaps it's because unlike other services you engage the standards differ so more "bad" ones get through.

mondaytosunday · 01/03/2023 04:27

I disagree with you op. I used to flip properties so have engaged dozens of tradespeople over the years. I have a lot of respect for people who have skills I don't. I don't care about their education level - I've had tradespeople who don't have any GCSEs and learned on the job, and some who are university graduates. I always pay invoices within 24 hours, I provide access to kettle and provide tea, coffee and on occasion biscuits (though I do not make them tea unless I am making myself some), they are welcome to use the toilet. I also provide parking permits if needed.
What I expect in return is: turning up when agreed, treating me, my property and other tradespeople with respect, doing a good job and keeping a tidy site, and finally charging what they say they will.
The first one seems to be a HUGE problem. The vast majority of complaints I hear are about this. I hear them usually after someone has asked me for a recommendation as they have been let down. On one job, I myself went through four plumbers. This was due to: failing to turn up so putting other trades off their schedule; not being able to work with others; incompetence, failing to complete a job. Several times I've had to have work redone. Two other plumbers were so rude during the quoting process I never hired them. Also plumbers in particular seem to be guilty of the 'just nipping to the shop for a part' excuse then not returning for hours.
I've had tradesmen who I have worked on one project satisfactorily quote on another, turn up the week before to confirm the job and schedule, then disappear. No answering phone calls from me or other trades. This, as stated above, is the most frequent and most frustrating problem. Why can't they call if they got another job/broke their leg/didn't finish a previous job/ just are no longer interested? Why?
All of the people that have had problems with have been English.
My current team have been amazing. All have done exactly as requested, all have turned up the day agreed and on time, all have not only done the job but done it with pride and care. All have left the site tidy each day. Most of them are not English.
It's not snobbery. It's not anything other than expecting competent work in return for a fee.

Mouthfulofquiz · 01/03/2023 04:05

I can understand a tradesman being busy, booked up for months etc. I can wait. All I want is for them to learn to book work into some kind of appointment system and then turn up. If they can’t turn up, message or call, and be HONEST. I waited three weeks for a roofer to ‘pop’ round. He cancelled for the following:

  • forgot it’s his son’s birthday
  • the next day - hurt leg and in minor injuries
  • the day after that - van broken down
  • two days after that - was unwell and couldn’t come. (Saw his van!)

eventually he called to arrange to come with about 30 mins notice. I didn’t reply. I’d already found someone else less calamitous. Just don’t bullshit people. I hate that.

oneyouknow · 01/03/2023 03:56

I have had more bad tradesmen than good. If I can't do it myself I'm loathed to get tradesmen in.

I've had some right shits, plenty more negative experiences than good. At least with other workers I can complain to their company ect bad tradesmen just vanish.

NastyNiff · 01/03/2023 02:45

Am amazing builder quoted for our roof recently. Punctual, communicative, reads scientific papers connected to the industry. I developed quite the crush on him. But he was a bit unusual.

Nightlystroll · 01/03/2023 02:00

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 01/03/2023 01:36

MN is full of horrific snobs who are allergic to working class people. Even when those working class people are earning 3x as much as they are with no student debt. Classism here is absolutely rife

Sorry, it's not classism to criticise a tradesman who when replacing a window, removed the lintel and put a piece of plastic over the hole where the lintel had been and thought that was ok. My back wall could have come down.

My mum's care home was rewired and the electrician did it wrong and caused an electrical fire. They had to evacuate 30 residents in that freezing January weather outside in their nightclothes. It new all the door security systems to keep the residents in the home. They lost all their electronics like their telephone systems, emergency alerts and computers. 10 days later they were still using electric fires because they had no central heating.

Why am I being a snob to criticise them and to have lost faith in tradesmen? If they're earning that much money, you'd think they'd take the time to do at least a safe job even if not a good one.

DPotter · 01/03/2023 01:55

Theobstinateheadstronggirl

Where's the snobbery in expecting someone to turn up when they say they will ?

I am fully respectful of the skills and knowledge of others, but if you put yourself out there offering those skills and knowledge for a fee, then it is perfectly reasonable for your customers to expect you to turn up when you said you would. I would apply this to a solicitor, doctor, teacher as well as a plumber, electrician or plasterer. Class and educational background doesn't come into it.

Nightlystroll · 01/03/2023 01:49

DPotter · 01/03/2023 01:03

Funny that I’ve never met anyone who has been done over by a trades person. Nor have I heard of any not turning up Enfys1982

Allow me to introduce myself as someone who has been 'done over' and not had tradesmen turn up.

I've been employing tradesmen & women for approx 40 years. In that time I have needed the services of all sorts of trades - plasterers, electricians, plumbers, carpenters, painters & decorators - you get the picture. Only today has another tradesman not turned up, after insisting he would come today, me re-arranging work and other commitments, and no reply to texts and calls. He should have arrived at 9am and I eventually heard from him just before 4pm, saying he'll let me know when he can come. I'm not holding my breath, certainly won't be chasing him and I will be looking around for another. This is not the first time he and others have failed to arrive - to give quotes, to send the actual quote, fix a starting date, arrive on said starting date, to continue until the job is complete. Funnily enough the bill always arrives the next day.

Yes - there have been those who do turn up when they say they will and some of those do a good job, but sadly they are not the majority.

I used to argue with my DP about the time it took to get things repaired, he wanted to know why it took me so long to arrange things. So I 'let' him organise a bathroom re-fit, and now he knows.

Sadly the reputation of the UK tradesman is poor

Let me introduce myself too.

My sister had a bathroom refit and it took two months for them to finish it. I have a German friend and he said that his dad had a new bathroom and it was like a military operation. Dates and times given for one workmen to arrive and leave so the next one could come and do their part. It was done in days.
At my sisters none of the tradesmen seemed to talk to each other and then, for good measure, the tiler threw his grout down the toilet and it solidified in the pipes. 🤦‍♀️

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 01/03/2023 01:36

MN is full of horrific snobs who are allergic to working class people. Even when those working class people are earning 3x as much as they are with no student debt. Classism here is absolutely rife

DPotter · 01/03/2023 01:03

Funny that I’ve never met anyone who has been done over by a trades person. Nor have I heard of any not turning up Enfys1982

Allow me to introduce myself as someone who has been 'done over' and not had tradesmen turn up.

I've been employing tradesmen & women for approx 40 years. In that time I have needed the services of all sorts of trades - plasterers, electricians, plumbers, carpenters, painters & decorators - you get the picture. Only today has another tradesman not turned up, after insisting he would come today, me re-arranging work and other commitments, and no reply to texts and calls. He should have arrived at 9am and I eventually heard from him just before 4pm, saying he'll let me know when he can come. I'm not holding my breath, certainly won't be chasing him and I will be looking around for another. This is not the first time he and others have failed to arrive - to give quotes, to send the actual quote, fix a starting date, arrive on said starting date, to continue until the job is complete. Funnily enough the bill always arrives the next day.

Yes - there have been those who do turn up when they say they will and some of those do a good job, but sadly they are not the majority.

I used to argue with my DP about the time it took to get things repaired, he wanted to know why it took me so long to arrange things. So I 'let' him organise a bathroom re-fit, and now he knows.

Sadly the reputation of the UK tradesman is poor

Justdontbejudgy · 01/03/2023 00:23

Because people are more likely to post when they have something to complain about ?

NewspaperTaxis · 01/03/2023 00:11

ladykale · 28/02/2023 21:52

No one thinks they're lesser.

  1. They often don't show up when they stay they will.
  2. Or quote for a job never to be heard of again. 3) Or lie and take on multiple jobs, do one day of work to lock you in then call in "sick" while they do other jobs
  3. Or by a miracle actually show up and do an absolutely shoddy job...

This is about it. We are doing up the family house a bit and it's taken over a year to get a decent set of people, ie plumber, electrician, plasterer and so on. And they are fine, but along the way we got ghosted a lot, people showing up for half an hour to look at the job, take photos, never hear back from them with a quote. Wastes time.
Doesn't help that the regulators are a bit rubbish, as is the way in this country. Checkatrade is not a State-based regulator - not that it would be much better if it was, the State is corrupt now - and that has its horror stories.
Personally I feel a bit of reverse snobbery in me - I've had some lads talking like bovver boys or the underclass then I think, well, what kind of tosser am I then, who am I to judge - then indeed they do a crap job. If they sound like lairy con men, they probably are. Same with one who offered a wet lettuce handshake - said to be a sign of untrustworthiness, but who says this? Who decides? Went ahead with him and it was a rubbish job so there you go.
Looking back... that was the guy who strolled onto my back garden through the side gate when I was at work, he was working on the neighbour's house, could he do any jobs? I'm a bloke so it wasn't physically threatening but I did feel a bit irked, then got irked at feeling irked.

Nightlystroll · 28/02/2023 23:59

I have no disdain for tradesmen who turn up, charge an honest price (ie profit for them without gouging me), do the job without leaving half way through whilst leaving me with no hot water, a non functioning toilet, no electricity, etc, and finish the job in a timely manner as promised with no extortionate "unforeseen" extra fees.

If that's your family members, send them round to mine.

I have a decorator who is as honest and reliable as above. He's in high demand because of that. I always give him extra when I pay the bill.

On the other hand, the electrician I had to do our extension nearly caused my house to be burnt down, did an awful job, went missing days at a time and still expected full payment. CF. If he'd gone up with the house, he'd have been the last thing I'd have put out.

TomPinch · 28/02/2023 23:50

I'm in NZ and the attitude towards tradies is - like Australia - very positive. People do mention bad experiences but it's not the dominant theme of the conversation. There are bad tradies out there, but there are bad lawyers and accountants too.

Tradies seem to get paid more here and have a pretty good standard of living. I suspect that has a lot to do with it.

The only really bad experience we've had was with an Englishman, incidentally (but we've had other English tradies who have been fine.)

ladykale · 28/02/2023 23:46

Enfys1982 · 28/02/2023 21:41

I’m genuinely baffled by it. Most of the men in my family are in trade. including my dad and brother. They are not lazy cowboys or crooks, my dad has worked since he started his apprenticeship when he was fifteen and has never been out of work since (he’s now semi retired) and barely had a day off sick either. He pays all his taxes and his is a registered Limited company with companies house. All are as honest as the day is long. No tax dodging or cash in hand jobs.

Please also be assured that none of them are ‘thick’ as posters are implying on one thread. You won’t see a ‘thick’ plumber or electrician as they need good GCSE grades, particularly in Maths, English and Science, to get a place at college to train. It’s very, very competitive and anything less than a B is pushing it for a place. They’re not going to let ‘thick people’ install gas boilers or rewire peoples homes ffs🙄

Rant over!

Sorry OP, but the examples on this thread have sort of proved why people speak about tradesmen with disdain.

The 1 in 100 who is actyally good, honest ans reliable will be booked up for the next 3 years so the rest of have to deal with the cowboys or learn how to do everything ourselves via YouTube which isn't possible for things requiring electricians / plumbers!

FrostyFifi · 28/02/2023 23:44

Mostly people on MN seem terrified a tradesman might defecate in their toilet.

Zwicky · 28/02/2023 23:40

Maybe because I treat them with respect, let them use the toilet, don’t chase them for a quote the moment they leave my front door, and even leave tea and snacks out for them, I get the same respect in return

I love the idea that leaving out snacks will mean your new gas fire won’t have to be condemned.
I provided 2 cooked meals a day and enough tea to satisfy the whole of Yorkshire when I had my extension built but it still was an absolute shitshow despite my actual main builder man being reasonably good and a very nice man.

Wednesdaysotherchild · 28/02/2023 23:40

ladykale · 28/02/2023 21:52

No one thinks they're lesser.

  1. They often don't show up when they stay they will.
  2. Or quote for a job never to be heard of again. 3) Or lie and take on multiple jobs, do one day of work to lock you in then call in "sick" while they do other jobs
  3. Or by a miracle actually show up and do an absolutely shoddy job...

This has been our experience! Especially in London, in various parts of town!

SW slightly better but assume they behaved better as it’s a smaller place so word got around more.

QueenCamilla · 28/02/2023 23:33

I'm in the North East and the trades here utterly suck.

It was a tad better down South. I had an excellent plumber/gas man there. Everyone working with him were top guys.
Had a half-reliable carpenter. Half-reliable is amazing!

I wish someone could pay me a daily rate to fix my own house. Even a minimum wage. I'd take time away from work and with a little help do a better job than trades can.
I'm actually scheming now... 🤔

cakewench · 28/02/2023 23:21

I never had an opinion on tradesmen until I bought a house and needed some work done. It is actually infuriating to invite someone into your home to get a quote for a fairly standard job just to be spoken to as if I’m a complete dimwit who couldn’t possibly understand anything. So many times. I’m at the point where I’d love to have more work done but I just can’t deal with what seems to be generally accepted behaviour that I’m expected to put up with.

Is it every single tradesman? Of course not. I have met a few brilliant ones and have clung to them. But I can absolutely see where the stereotype comes from now.

QueenCamilla · 28/02/2023 23:18

UsernameNotAvailableApparently · 28/02/2023 23:02

@QueenCamilla I don’t have every single tradie type in the family and have therefore been a client many times for multiple construction projects - like I said, I’ve never had an issue.

Maybe because I treat them with respect, let them use the toilet, don’t chase them for a quote the moment they leave my front door, and even leave tea and snacks out for them, I get the same respect in return Wink

Haha, that's quite funny.

I need a builder to remove a chimney stack from two floors and support the rest in the attic. An electrician would need to be on the job, since the previous "geniuses" have passed all the socket cables downstairs-upstairs via the chimneys.

I'd love to pass you the phone book(Google) and watch you work your magic. That would be very amusing indeed.

Babdoc · 28/02/2023 23:10

Crikey, I must have led a charmed life. All the many tradesmen I’ve employed in the 40 years I’ve lived in this house have been excellent - that includes my builder, plumber, electrician, joiner, double glazed window installers, painter, boiler engineer, handyman, bathroom fitter and chimney sweep.
I think it helps that I live in a village in rural Perthshire. Any local tradesman with a bad reputation would rapidly go out of business, as it’s all word of mouth and personal recommendations round here.

Ketchupwee · 28/02/2023 23:08

I would imagine all those who have friends and family in the trades, don't get an experience that is any way representative of the average person.

We really need several areas sorted in the house, but the idea of having to deal with all the stress of terrible communication and being treated like shit is really putting us off

And before someone comes along and declares 'it must be because you are a shit customer', that is bollocks. We are pleasant, keep out of their way but make ourselves available for questions, don't have any weird toilet or radio hang ups, provide plenty of tea and biscuits and pay the bill before they've even started the van.