Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much disdain towards tradesmen on MN?

241 replies

Enfys1982 · 28/02/2023 21:41

I’m genuinely baffled by it. Most of the men in my family are in trade. including my dad and brother. They are not lazy cowboys or crooks, my dad has worked since he started his apprenticeship when he was fifteen and has never been out of work since (he’s now semi retired) and barely had a day off sick either. He pays all his taxes and his is a registered Limited company with companies house. All are as honest as the day is long. No tax dodging or cash in hand jobs.

Please also be assured that none of them are ‘thick’ as posters are implying on one thread. You won’t see a ‘thick’ plumber or electrician as they need good GCSE grades, particularly in Maths, English and Science, to get a place at college to train. It’s very, very competitive and anything less than a B is pushing it for a place. They’re not going to let ‘thick people’ install gas boilers or rewire peoples homes ffs🙄

Rant over!

OP posts:
Coxspurplepippin · 01/03/2023 08:09

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 01/03/2023 01:36

MN is full of horrific snobs who are allergic to working class people. Even when those working class people are earning 3x as much as they are with no student debt. Classism here is absolutely rife

It has sweet fa to do with class and everything to do with unreliability, crappy work and overcharging. Like pp, I make tradesmen welcome, everyone is offered a cuppa, bacon sandwiches, cold drinks. They are shown where the toilet is and not told not to shit in it.

In return, I would like them to do the work agreed, for the price agreed in the time frame agreed. This rarely happens.

Enfys1982 · 01/03/2023 08:06

@QueenCamilla surely it’s not rocket science to understand why you can’t get a chimney stack taken down in the middle of winter?🤔

Many of the replies on here have just demonstrated the snobbery I believe is at the heart of it, I bet you all sit there with the bill afterwards with a calculator going through like a fine tooth comb don’t you?😂

Facts are:

You will not be their only clients at one time

They will have other quotes to prepare not just yours and it can take time to put it together

Sometimes jobs will overrun

Bad weather will impact work

They are as entitled to lunch breaks as people who work in offices etc

Likewise they are entitled to go to the toilet.

OP posts:
newtowelsplease · 01/03/2023 07:54

Enfys1982 · 28/02/2023 22:25

@lazycats criticism when it’s justified is fine. What’s not acceptable is to tar everyone with the same brush.

Even when experience indicates that the vast majority are the same?

RichardHeed · 01/03/2023 07:47

Enfys1982 · 28/02/2023 22:25

@lazycats criticism when it’s justified is fine. What’s not acceptable is to tar everyone with the same brush.

But you’re saying the criticism people have when they don’t turn up or say they’ll quote and don’t, isn’t justified because you’ve never experienced it. You’ve tarred us all with the same “liar” brush but that’s ok is it? Someone is thick as mince but it’s not the tradies.

sst1234 · 01/03/2023 07:44

Because most people have a had a bad experience with a tradesperson. Meaning that your make likely to be let down by a tradesperson than other people you are encounter for business. And the cost and inconvenience will be greater.

It’s not rocket science that this is why tradespeople get a bad rep.

user1471517095 · 01/03/2023 07:25

user678945 why put "checking the Radiators" in quotation marks? Are you trying to insinuate he was snooping in your drawers? Perhaps he was checking the Radiators were working properly with the newly installed Boiler! You know, like he should.

BooksAndHooks · 01/03/2023 07:25

Enfys1982 · 28/02/2023 21:41

I’m genuinely baffled by it. Most of the men in my family are in trade. including my dad and brother. They are not lazy cowboys or crooks, my dad has worked since he started his apprenticeship when he was fifteen and has never been out of work since (he’s now semi retired) and barely had a day off sick either. He pays all his taxes and his is a registered Limited company with companies house. All are as honest as the day is long. No tax dodging or cash in hand jobs.

Please also be assured that none of them are ‘thick’ as posters are implying on one thread. You won’t see a ‘thick’ plumber or electrician as they need good GCSE grades, particularly in Maths, English and Science, to get a place at college to train. It’s very, very competitive and anything less than a B is pushing it for a place. They’re not going to let ‘thick people’ install gas boilers or rewire peoples homes ffs🙄

Rant over!

There is snobbery about a lot of things on Mumsnet. This is just another one.

However having good grades to get on a plumbing course etc at equivalent to a B isn’t the case. There isn’t a minimum number of GCSEs required you just have to have a grade 4 in English and maths. If you don’t have grade 4 you can still do the course and resit English and maths alongside it. There aren’t high entry grades. The training is 4 years. Usually one or two at college and the rest apprenticeship.

follyfoot37 · 01/03/2023 07:25

Because given most seem to have their life controlled by MIL/SIL/any other family member (according to their aibu's) they try to assert some kind of control/authority by being rude to those they consider inferior

RedHelenB · 01/03/2023 07:23

I must be unusual in that I've never had a tradespeople do a bad job. Some things did get damaged ( not worth more than a few ponds) but that was probably my fault for not moving them in the first place before I went to work. I've also had good experiences with British Gas and the RAC ( although not used them recently )

TheLaughOfRustyLee · 01/03/2023 07:21

When they ask for half the money up front I'm going to refuse from now on. Zero payment until job completed to my satisfaction. Like it or lump it.
I'm not losing any more money to shitty tradesman.

TheySeeMeRowling · 01/03/2023 07:15

Some people on MN are scared of a man with an education who knows more about a subject that they do.

Rainydayparade · 01/03/2023 07:15

My husband is a self employed tradesman and provides an amazing life for our family and a very good wage. However even he will admit that’s because he’s one of the good ones.

He is in such high demand because once people find him they recommend him to everyone they know and he can charge accordingly. He always turns up, is professional, kind and an absolute perfectionist. There are plenty who aren’t!

We’re hopeful our son will want to do a trade as it gives freedom. We regularly spend months travelling as a family then he’s straight back to work once we’re back and inundated.

User678945 · 01/03/2023 07:12

I don't think of tradesmen as lesser in any way, but I find it intrusive to have them in my home and breathe a sigh of relief when they're gone. Recently had a new boiler fitted which took hours and went to do the schoolrun at 2.30pm. Came home to find one of the tradesmen in my bedroom "checking the radiator." Which might have been true but I just find it awkward having strange men in my space all day.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 01/03/2023 07:06

ladykale · 28/02/2023 21:54

Maybe because you know lots of tradesmen and therefore get reliable service. Sucks for the rest of us.

Gardeners.
Plumbers.
Painters.
Electrician.

In the last 18 months alone bad or poor experiences with one of each!

This is a big part of it. If you know people in the trades and have family connections you get much better service.

We’ve had appalling experience and appalling experience - the latest one is a window fitter who’s stolen £3k from us.

I’ve resolved not to use English tradespeople anymore. We’ve never had a good experience. The only good experiences we’ve had have been with Polish tradespeople.

RedHelenB · 01/03/2023 07:04

Maths and English at level 4 is all that's needed for college here and everyone gets in. That's not denigrating tradespeople BTW. I think being practical is a good thing and obviously to do the job you can't ve totally " thick" bur mostly academic people prefer to use their brains rather than their hands.

TootHole · 01/03/2023 07:01

Of course you can't judge all Tradesmen the same, but the majority of comments will be negative, because of peoples experience.

I'm SE in a manual job. I know how hard it is to run a business and do the job, but that doesn't give me an excuse to not turn up, to not be respectful of someone's home, not communicate, not do something I said I would etc. I don't take on more work I can cope with, I don't try and mug people off and apply a driveway tax, because the people have got a nice house/car/look like they've got money. I do the job exactly how I said I would do it.

I've worked with, and employed the services of many trades, and in addition to things already mentioned here, sometimes their behaviour and attitudes have been absolutely shocking. I've had issued with personal hygiene, and cannabis smoking/smell to give a few more examples.

Not every SE person is tax dodging, many will declare all earnings, but given most I encountered were very vocal about all the money they got from the government during covid, but still worked, and boasted about it, they don't help themselves.

User98866 · 01/03/2023 06:56

Because they are a PITA to deal with! I’ve had about a 50/50 success rate with them actually turning up, as have most people I know. Luckily I don’t think we’ve ever had shoddy workmanship but the plumber I know is good and can work our boiler took over a week of him saying he’d come and not showing. Most people would have given up but I’d called other plumbers who didn’t have a clue how to actually service a combi boiler because they only do installs and services of boilers they’ve installed 💰. I’m worried that as the old lot retire it will be nigh on impossible to find people who actually know what they’re doing!

Moonicorn · 01/03/2023 06:45

For example I’ve just had a boiler replaced. They ripped a hole in my kitchen cupboard (seriously) to put the new pipe in without even telling me they were going to do it because the pipe on the new one is lower down than on my last. They did not even cut a neat hole, literally just looked like they’ve punched a hole in it - absolutely shocking and I’m taking it to small claims. When confronted they tried to charge me more money to mend the cupboard!

Barelyable · 01/03/2023 06:45

We've had great and awful experiences recently.
Our builder sent me photos of some work he'd ' completed' and wanted money for. They looked fine so (more fool me) I gladly paid him, only to get there and he'd left a massive hole in a wall that funnily enough, he hadn't sent me a photo of! He now won't return to finish the job and we're having to get someone else.
A gardener laid a patio then decided not to grout it and fell off the face of the earth...no communication at all.
We've just had a great fence painter and electrician and it makes you very much more grateful for them!

Moonicorn · 01/03/2023 06:41

TheLaughOfRustyLee · 28/02/2023 21:45

Because so many of us have been done over or let down by tradesman over and over again? I'd say 1 out of 10 have been good. The rest - absolutely full of shite.

This. Not replying to messages to start with, then not turning up, then leaving halfway through a job and leaving it unfinished for weeks. Before eventually patching it up and charging the Earth for a shoddy job. Not to mention their sexist attitudes (I’ve had requests for not just drinks but food from some of them, would they ask my DH that?!). They make the whole process stressful because they’re incapable of either admitting a job is beyond them, or just doing it quickly and quietly to a good standard when agreed.

vestanesta · 01/03/2023 06:38

My fil and bil are plumbers, many of dhs school friends went into various trades and a couple are now incredibly skilled and highly regarded (one is a plasterer and it's like a piece of art watching him work).

Like another pp, we've pretty much stopped getting work done on the house because it's too stressful and when we have it's via actual building companies for which we pay a premium. We need a tiny indoor building job done and some plastering but literally no one will do it. I've rung every single recommendation I have had and all say yes and none show up. I get the jobs are small but I can't help that (dhs mate lives the other side of the country).

Ohgoahead · 01/03/2023 06:35

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at OP's request

lightlypoached · 01/03/2023 06:09

I've had so many poor experiences,

  • turning up late or not turning up at all
  • lying re experience they had and previous jobs and then not having skills needed
  • trashing parts of my house that weren't in scope
-always dissing the work of any previous trades
  • having work done that then had to be redone as it was so bad /not fit for purpose (so many times)
  • nearly breaking my house by not across-propping it properly.
  • not reading plans and building things wrong
  • not finishing the job

Good trades are so hard to come by, and in my experience the Polish are streets above other nationalities. Trouble is every time I find a good one, they leave.

I've tried using people who come recommended but even had poor experiences there.

I've had some good experiences too but they are only about 30% of the time. I'd not put up with that 'win rate' in any other service industry.

I just heard of a local job for someone I know where they did a huge renovation, looked fab but then they discovered that the electrics were sub par and they all had to be replaced. How did that happen and how was the part 2 issued ? Just dreadful.

We need much better laws and training in the trades.

Oh and the architects I've used on 1 of my 2 major jobs did a spectacular clock up too for a routine job. So,it's not just the hands on trades that can be the issue.

If I had my professional time again I'd run a women only building company that delivered quality, on time with clear communication at all times. I'd make a mint.

Mamaneedsadrink · 01/03/2023 05:55

magicthree · 01/03/2023 05:45

Because many on MN are snobs. People in trades are respected where I live - not the UK.

They're not respected here much for the same reason. Useless and unreliable. NZ

Starseeking · 01/03/2023 05:52

In my experience they never turn up when they say they will.

I've been waiting almost a month for an appointment with one, who was due to come to carry out a job which will cost me £1k today.

I received a text yesterday saying he's come down with a sickness bug. I said I was sorry to hear he is unwell, and if he could let me know when he will be able to come; no reply!

I have to start all over again now.