Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much disdain towards tradesmen on MN?

241 replies

Enfys1982 · 28/02/2023 21:41

I’m genuinely baffled by it. Most of the men in my family are in trade. including my dad and brother. They are not lazy cowboys or crooks, my dad has worked since he started his apprenticeship when he was fifteen and has never been out of work since (he’s now semi retired) and barely had a day off sick either. He pays all his taxes and his is a registered Limited company with companies house. All are as honest as the day is long. No tax dodging or cash in hand jobs.

Please also be assured that none of them are ‘thick’ as posters are implying on one thread. You won’t see a ‘thick’ plumber or electrician as they need good GCSE grades, particularly in Maths, English and Science, to get a place at college to train. It’s very, very competitive and anything less than a B is pushing it for a place. They’re not going to let ‘thick people’ install gas boilers or rewire peoples homes ffs🙄

Rant over!

OP posts:
Lincslady53 · 05/03/2023 07:01

LikeAStar1994 · 01/03/2023 18:00

Some people on Mumsnet are honestly the most despicable creatures I've ever come across. Honestly. I have read that some MN'ers won't even let tradespeople use their toilet.

Anybody who strips anybody else of a basic human right are automatically put in the category marked "Total Scum"

Our roofer had a portaloo in the back of his van, which I thought was a good idea as he may well have been working on locked houses with no access to a toilet. And it saved him having to disturb us whenever he needed a pee.

Lincslady53 · 05/03/2023 06:51

We have had quite a few different tradesmen in over the last few years. Bathrooms and kitchen refurbished, house decoraters inside and out, roofers, we had our conservatory rebuilt and reroofed, and we had our fireplace ripped out and replaced at short nitice. Without exception all the workers turned up early and worked constantly. The conservatory guy worked from 8.00am and was often still working after 9.00pm. All did a good job, and came back for any snagging. The problems we had were getting the roofers to come round to give a quote in the first place, and the 2 different decorators had gold medals in talking, once they started it was hard to get away! The electrician was brilliant, turned up at short notice three times for different smallish jobs, and did the work to suit the other trades. So we have loads of respect for tradesmen, usually skilled and hard working.

RotundBeagle · 05/03/2023 01:54

As for tradesmen working commercial jobs, have you seen the amount of complaints about newbuilds. Shoddy workmanship, cutting corners, dangerous work.

Well, I work for a aggregates company that delivers to a lot of the biggest housebuilders so I spend a lot of time on newbuild estates. The main issue is the rush rush rush mentality as they're building hundreds.

However, it doesn't invalidate my point that most tradesmen will go for the bigger lengthier contracts, leaving the less experienced to pick up the domestic bits and bobs.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 05/03/2023 00:51

I wouldnf touch my own electrics etc. We have found a great lad and although we've only ever used qualified electricians , the new lad has definitely found shoddy work. Before he found it he actually was saying he wouldn't trust others .
I have no snobbery about trades. I'd be more than happy if our ds went into a trade rather than uni and I know that all of our family and most (if not all) of our friends would feel the same.

JMSA · 05/03/2023 00:38

I've never seen the disdain you speak of, but then I'm a bit oblivious generally! I haven't had any real problem with tradesmen, but do tend to research the best ones (asking for recommendations on local FB groups, etc).
Your dad sounds great and I wish they were all like him! Maybe it's the difference between old-school and modern.

UserError1 · 05/03/2023 00:19

People only whinge when they get ripped of

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 05/03/2023 00:10

I know a few gas fitters, most are in their 50's now and are sick of working for the general public. They can now make do with a couple of boiler installs a week.

They can't be bothered with the small stuff and when they finally give up nobody is coming on behind them so there will be less tradespeople.

Someone was complaining on here the other day about their builders eating some crisps that were the homeowners that were laying around. Now I am sure a couple of pounds in crisps is better than the builders going to the local shop for an hour.

Coxspurplepippin · 04/03/2023 23:49

'people' don't get annoyed at a bricklayer earning £45k. They get annoyed at a crap bricklayer letting them down and doing a rubbish job. As for tradesmen working commercial jobs, have you seen the amount of complaints about newbuilds. Shoddy workmanship, cutting corners, dangerous work.

RotundBeagle · 04/03/2023 23:41

I think another key point is that a lot of decent tradespeople will be working commercial instead - newbuilds etc. It's ongoing, steady work where you, don't have to deal with the general public.

RotundBeagle · 04/03/2023 23:28

I think it's usually outdated stereotypes about 'white van men' and working class which go unchallenged as its generally middle class people and students calling people out.

It's odd because the average trade salary is now £10k higher than the average office salary. In fact, maybe that's why. People getting annoyed that a bricklayer earns £45k.

NewspaperTaxis · 04/03/2023 20:18

I would like to raise you all one.

Booked in a local plumber, a firm that does 24-hr callout at short notice, recommended by a neighbour, can't be bad. They weren't. Showed up on time, worked hard to fix the central heating which was old and knackered, it was winter with an elderly dad in the house, plumber was normal and courteous!

It was draining the water tank for a pre-arranged job that did it. It needed cleaning. Lads who turned up a bit more lairy, a bit over familiar. (But for context, I'm a bloke). Took from 11am to 6pm, longer than I'd been lead to believe. After they left, the hot water didn't work. So I called them up, another one came out, more taciturn. Seemed to fix it, all good.

It was some months down the line when I tried to get a quote off them for radiator valves and wasn't mad about what they quoted or had to offer, so we tried an alternative. He offered much the same quote but we were given a choice of valves. He did also notice - get this - that the immersion heater was on and did we know?

So basically, the guy they'd sent out to fix the problem of the hot water had 'solved' it by simply putting the immersion heater on!

When I queried this with the firm I got the thing about how they pride themselves on top service and would send someone out. But it seems they must have had a think on the quiet and realised that this would be tantamount to an admission so instead they asked for a call-out fee of £80 to look at it! Given it was how they left it, and another plumber had noticed the problem, I took umbrage! This played into their hands as they could then claim another plumber had interacted with the situation so it wasn't their fault.

We got someone in to have a look at it - they were the old school local plumber who puts in a shift but doesn't charge by the hour - and after taking up the floorboards to no avail realised it was because the last but one plumber hadn't opened the gate valve (small metal circular dial) under the boiler after the job.

We take our energy bills out of Dad's direct debit savings account so it got swallowed up, so thankfully I don't know how much it cost to heat our water via the immersion for months on end.

The firm had polish but as it employed a stable of recruits they had a tendency to victim-blame or pass the buck because if they couldn't fix it, it reflected poorly on them with the firm. Otherwise, it would most likely be okay because they had a lot of employees who tbf were available to be called out at short notice, and did so because they weren't their own boss, ie they were accountable (unless their mistake would make the firm liable for a lot of money, as in this case).

taxguru · 04/03/2023 08:48

WineCap · 04/03/2023 08:36

The main issue I've had with tradesmen is that they are, as a rule, poor communicators.

They generally cannot be bothered to let you know if they are running behind on another job until they're a few hours late. I think the reason they work this way is because they know that the clients aren't going to be able to find someone else quickly.

Delaying or changing a job due to an emergency is understandable but often it is down to poor communication and forward planning. I don't think they consider or care about the fact that their client may have had to book time off or schedule WFH day/s to accomodate them for instance.

That said, we have worked with some brilliant tradesmen too. It's just hit and miss.

That's sadly nothing new. We now phone several times ahead of jobs that need us to do lots of room emptying etc, as we've been caught out far too many times by spending hours (or in one case, an entire weekend), moving furniture out of a room, moving furnishings, putting down cover cloths, etc., only for them not to bother turning up!

The worst was when we replaced our old boiler with a combi boiling which meant floors up in a bedroom and landing for the new pipework - it took an entire weekend as they wanted the bedroom completely empty to get the floor up (wardrobes, bed, drawer units, etc) which took ages to move around into other rooms and we had to dismantle the wardrobes to move them. We'd checked mid-week the week before that they will still on target for coming first thing Monday morning - they said yes. Come Monday morning and no sign of them. We phoned mid-morning, phone went to answerphone, we kept phoning all day, but they never picked up nor answered messages. They must have had my number on caller display as my OH eventually tried ringing them from his phone and they picked up straight away! Cue excuses and lies - they claimed they'd left a message on our answerphone to say they'd be delayed (lie, as there was no message), they lied that they hadn't received my messages nor phone calls. Then they promised to be there first thing Tuesday morning, guess what - they didn't show up! Trouble was that we had to bear with them as the room was empty and we knew we couldn't get anyone else in quickly to do the job, so they knew they had us over a barrel. When they didn't turn up on Wednesday morning either, we'd had enough and put everything back in the room as we were fed up sleeping on the sofa bed in the lounge surrounded by boxes and clothes! Funny thing was that they were seriously miffed when they finally showed up on Thursday morning and we told them where they could stuff their boiler! They just complained bitterly that "we" had wasted their time and caused them a couple of days of lost work as they had no other work planned that day or the day after. Well Tough! You should have thought about that when we took time off work to wait in for you Monday and Tuesday!

taxguru · 04/03/2023 08:36

Coxspurplepippin · 04/03/2023 08:13

Honeyrider, agree wholeheartedly with your last 2 paragraphs. When I left school, 8% of our cohort went to university. Of the others, many of the boys especially went into a trade via the apprenticeship route - apprenticed to local firms, day or block release to college. These were people who would probably now be pushed down the university route. Fine, if you end up with a good career, but so many graduates seem to end up in jobs that 50 years ago you would have been able to walk into straight out of school. Plus, we no longer have enough good tradespeople.

Yep started with the abolition of grammar schools, and conversion of all schools into "comps" which were more geared up for the needs of the more academically able students, and tossed aside the ones who were more practical. The old style "sec moderns" were actually really good at preparing their pupils for manual work! Rather than scrapping the old two tier system, they should have found ways of enabling more movement of pupils between them, rather than a pass/fail at the far too young age of 10 to decide your future route!

Similar happened with the conversion of Polys into Unis and then Blair's crazy plan to get 50% of pupils into universities! (Even though 50% of jobs don't need degrees). That's also caused some of the housing shortage as we now have huge numbers of Uni students living in student accommodation (often residential homes or conversions), as they've moved away for Uni when a couple of decades earlier, they'd have been going to a more local college/Uni or getting a local apprentice job and living at home for the duration.

WineCap · 04/03/2023 08:36

The main issue I've had with tradesmen is that they are, as a rule, poor communicators.

They generally cannot be bothered to let you know if they are running behind on another job until they're a few hours late. I think the reason they work this way is because they know that the clients aren't going to be able to find someone else quickly.

Delaying or changing a job due to an emergency is understandable but often it is down to poor communication and forward planning. I don't think they consider or care about the fact that their client may have had to book time off or schedule WFH day/s to accomodate them for instance.

That said, we have worked with some brilliant tradesmen too. It's just hit and miss.

Coxspurplepippin · 04/03/2023 08:13

Honeyrider, agree wholeheartedly with your last 2 paragraphs. When I left school, 8% of our cohort went to university. Of the others, many of the boys especially went into a trade via the apprenticeship route - apprenticed to local firms, day or block release to college. These were people who would probably now be pushed down the university route. Fine, if you end up with a good career, but so many graduates seem to end up in jobs that 50 years ago you would have been able to walk into straight out of school. Plus, we no longer have enough good tradespeople.

honeyrider · 04/03/2023 02:49

WiddlinDiddlin · 01/03/2023 19:13

On occasion it may be necessary to pay for materials up front - where that is necessary (for example, an unusual job requiring materials from a new supplier, or such a large expenditure the tradesperson does not have sufficient to cover it), it would be normal to have the customer purchase that themselves and supply it for the tradesperson to fit.

Asking for cash for materials that are run of the mill and supplied by a wide range of normal trade suppliers... SCREAMS 'I can no longer hold a credit account with these businesses as I have fucked them over in the past 1 too many times!'.

It's not always about holding a credit account with a business but to cover the tradesperson the cost of the materials if the client doesn't pay at the end of the job which happens a lot.

I'm in Ireland and it's routine to pay for materials before starting the smaller jobs or staged payments for the bigger jobs. Having watched the likes of Cowboy Builders on tv I haven't heard of anything like that here probably due to being a small country where most recommendations are word of mouth and if someone did such shoddy work it would be common knowledge very quickly.

It's not just construction that look for some money upfront here, I've a routine hygienist appointment next week and the norm is to phone patients a week in advance to confirm the appointment and pay in advance so the dental practice is not out of pocket if I fail to turn up.

As someone mentioned ordering a cake and not paying for the ingredients before getting the cake I've yet to come across a baker or supermarket where you order a made to order cake not charge when accepting the order. These cakes are different to the regular off the shelf cakes.

Fortunately I've only had positive experiences with tradespeople when having work done, nearly all turned up when they said they would or phoned to let me know if they were running late or if any materials hadn't arrived from the building merchants.

The problem now is finding a tradeperson as there's a massive shortage of them since a generation of them emigrated after the 2008 crash. The remaining ones are mostly in their 50's. There's also the points race for college where schools want the prestige of a high percentage of pupils going on to college so discourage trades.

One of my sons is a chartered accountant with one of the big 4 and top 5% in college has commented he wouldn't have minded training to be an electrician so may go back and retrain at some stage.

ProbablyDogNappersHunX · 04/03/2023 00:08

Fimofriend · 03/03/2023 13:46

I am worried about the health of tradesmen and their families. When we had lived in Britain for three years we had had five different tradesmen cancel due to a death in their closest family.

(I am pretty sure it was true in one if the cases as they looked like people who were grieving when they came by a week later)

Likewise the state of their vehicles, which have a remarkable tendency to break down, even when they're only about 5 years old

Fimofriend · 03/03/2023 13:46

I am worried about the health of tradesmen and their families. When we had lived in Britain for three years we had had five different tradesmen cancel due to a death in their closest family.

(I am pretty sure it was true in one if the cases as they looked like people who were grieving when they came by a week later)

BetterFuture1985 · 03/03/2023 11:43

daisypond · 02/03/2023 17:44

No, I don’t misunderstand. I’m making a point. There are many so-called “tradesmen” who live off someone else instead of “working” - they live off, exploit and cheat the vulnerable in society.

But they're not tradesmen, are they?

daisypond · 02/03/2023 17:44

BetterFuture1985 · 02/03/2023 17:37

You misunderstood. I meant it's the kind of people who live off someone else who spend all day on Mumsnet instead of going to work.

Check out the Divorce section for vomit enducing levels of entitlement from the feckless and the workshy here.

No, I don’t misunderstand. I’m making a point. There are many so-called “tradesmen” who live off someone else instead of “working” - they live off, exploit and cheat the vulnerable in society.

BetterFuture1985 · 02/03/2023 17:37

daisypond · 01/03/2023 13:43

No, the poor, the elderly, the disabled, the unemployed, the carers, the low-earning shift workers also need work done on their properties too. The vulnerable and poor are being scammed by tradesmen.

You misunderstood. I meant it's the kind of people who live off someone else who spend all day on Mumsnet instead of going to work.

Check out the Divorce section for vomit enducing levels of entitlement from the feckless and the workshy here.

Xiaoxiong · 02/03/2023 10:42

@QueenCamilla thanks so much for that - in fact there is a gutter outside that window! it isn't overflowing that I can see but maybe I need to get a guttering guy in instead/as well. Or if you are anywhere in the SW I'll pay you to come over and fix it for me haha.

I've just chased the roof guy again off the back of this thread, "I hope to have a dry spell next week so I will plan the rest of my diary for March" ok...having told me since December that we're his very next job, one more week, one more week, the weather, the school holidays, etc etc etc. Ugh it's so frustrating and of course I can't express the slightest frustration or he might just ghost me like the other 3 so I have to plaster on a smile and send back a chirpy "Thanks so much! Look forward to hearing from you soon!" arrghghgh

Firefly2023 · 01/03/2023 21:04

I do think that there is a lack of accountability in the building industry for the general public. Obviously there are guarantees for major builds, but for smaller repairs etc there are no real safeguards. Anyone can say they are a builder, do shoddy work and walk away once they have been paid.

I have employed numerous tradesmen on various jobs over the last few years. I can't name one that has done a good job. When their failures come to light, they don't want to know. Every job seems to be left unfinished, the place in a mess and faults arising shortly after they leave. They don't care.

TomPinch · 01/03/2023 20:51

taxguru · 01/03/2023 18:43

@TomPinch

Which isn't to say there aren't cowboys here too but you can avoid them just by going to an established firm.

Rubbish.

"Established firms" still use random sub-contractors, put substandard workers on the job. It was an established firm who replaced our boiler - they just sent a subbie who told us he'd never even worked for established firm before - it was his first job with them, and he made a right pig's ear of it, with a proper employee of the established firm having to come out several times afterwards to fix the installation faults.

Likewise with an established local independent carpet firm. We'd had several carpets fitted by them years ago when we first bought our house. Always the same fitter (owner's son) along with another much younger employee (presumably their apprentice) - they always did a brilliant job. Years later when a couple of those carpets needed replacement, we went back - the "owner's son" was now running the shop as his father had retired. A random bloke came to do the fitting - one was a staircase which he made a right foul up of (cut too short in places, and it wasn't "tucked in" enough to the gripper rods, so it came undone within a few days of fitting. Then another random bloke came to "re-fit" it and, yes, it lasted longer, but a few weeks later it came loose again. We insisted the shop owner came to look which he did, and basically said "we can't get the subbies anymore" - that's his problem, not his customers! Needless to say, he's not had any more business from us and we've now found another local carpet shop who have their own staff and do a brilliant job!

That's a fair point about subbies, actually.

NeelyOHara1 · 01/03/2023 20:11

YANBU. People can have to put their trust in professionals of various disciplines which they don't understand and are often similarly let down, but might not even be aware that they have been.

Swipe left for the next trending thread