Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much disdain towards tradesmen on MN?

241 replies

Enfys1982 · 28/02/2023 21:41

I’m genuinely baffled by it. Most of the men in my family are in trade. including my dad and brother. They are not lazy cowboys or crooks, my dad has worked since he started his apprenticeship when he was fifteen and has never been out of work since (he’s now semi retired) and barely had a day off sick either. He pays all his taxes and his is a registered Limited company with companies house. All are as honest as the day is long. No tax dodging or cash in hand jobs.

Please also be assured that none of them are ‘thick’ as posters are implying on one thread. You won’t see a ‘thick’ plumber or electrician as they need good GCSE grades, particularly in Maths, English and Science, to get a place at college to train. It’s very, very competitive and anything less than a B is pushing it for a place. They’re not going to let ‘thick people’ install gas boilers or rewire peoples homes ffs🙄

Rant over!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
taxguru · 03/04/2023 18:56

Harrypewter · 03/04/2023 17:41

I employ subcontractors, my biggest bugbear is poor communication or over-communicating with ridiculous commentary. Re-giving opinions with limited information or knowledge.
Some of them are thick as two short planks.
The training must be upgraded to a diploma or degree level, with a customer service-professionalism module.
That would weed out the numpties.

Trouble is a lot of them have no formal "training" at all and just pick it up on the job themselves. So having "better" training wouldn't help. What is needed is proper regulation on a par with gas engineers and electricians, where it's actually illegal to do work without a proper training/qualification behind them. Once we get to that point, then yes, improve the training, but as it stands, pointless to make training/qualification harder when there's no actual need to do it at all!

Harrypewter · 03/04/2023 17:41

I employ subcontractors, my biggest bugbear is poor communication or over-communicating with ridiculous commentary. Re-giving opinions with limited information or knowledge.
Some of them are thick as two short planks.
The training must be upgraded to a diploma or degree level, with a customer service-professionalism module.
That would weed out the numpties.

RotundBeagle · 08/03/2023 00:09

Goosebarnacle · 07/03/2023 23:22

I wasn't bothered about our plumber having a coke habit, as I said he was easily the best plumber we've had. He did keep odd hours, but we weren't living in the property at the time, so as long as the job was done 🤷‍♀️

But having renovated quite a few properties, one of the biggest challenges is actually finding someone and getting them to commit. I get that trades are super busy. But if you come out to look at a job, just why wouldn't you say if you don't want the work, or even drop an email. Or why say you'll come round to look and then not turn up. It's not just the tradesman's time and money, it's also the homeowner's time (which is also money) and the resentment of being dicked about.
And then if you get them to do the job, then getting a written invoice is another battle. If you are selling a house then these bits of paper are needed. It's all so infuriating.

I think many over commit. Much like the salesmen whose bids I used to help write.

Goosebarnacle · 07/03/2023 23:22

RotundBeagle · 07/03/2023 22:26

I couldn't really get annoyed about a plumber rolling a joint. Loads of the brickies are at it.

I wasn't bothered about our plumber having a coke habit, as I said he was easily the best plumber we've had. He did keep odd hours, but we weren't living in the property at the time, so as long as the job was done 🤷‍♀️

But having renovated quite a few properties, one of the biggest challenges is actually finding someone and getting them to commit. I get that trades are super busy. But if you come out to look at a job, just why wouldn't you say if you don't want the work, or even drop an email. Or why say you'll come round to look and then not turn up. It's not just the tradesman's time and money, it's also the homeowner's time (which is also money) and the resentment of being dicked about.
And then if you get them to do the job, then getting a written invoice is another battle. If you are selling a house then these bits of paper are needed. It's all so infuriating.

RotundBeagle · 07/03/2023 22:26

Goosebarnacle · 06/03/2023 03:45

I trained in a construction based trade. No degree, just C&G, so no snobbery here. I'd say my experience has been 50/50, totally understand where a lot of these posters are coming from, we've had some shockers working on various house renovations. The pp who mentioned catching a plumber rolling a joint, the best plumber we ever had was a cokehead🤣.
I actually made a sideways move into another profession, because of the rampant sexism.

I couldn't really get annoyed about a plumber rolling a joint. Loads of the brickies are at it.

GasPanic · 06/03/2023 13:25

What annoys me the most is their almost total unwillingness to complete any regulatory paperwork on the jobs. Getting it done after you have paid is next to impossible.

So much so the last job I had one did I made him do a separate line on the quote and invoice for the regulatory completion, with the cost associated with getting the certificate, so there was no way he could claim it was out of the agreed work.

So I paid the invoice and did I get the cert ? Of course I bloody didn't - even though I paid for it.

It's not enough to just do the good job, you need to supply the paperwork and register the job in many cases.

Goosebarnacle · 06/03/2023 03:45

I trained in a construction based trade. No degree, just C&G, so no snobbery here. I'd say my experience has been 50/50, totally understand where a lot of these posters are coming from, we've had some shockers working on various house renovations. The pp who mentioned catching a plumber rolling a joint, the best plumber we ever had was a cokehead🤣.
I actually made a sideways move into another profession, because of the rampant sexism.

QueenCamilla · 06/03/2023 02:41

@HelloDaisy

You might be of the few decent ones!

I don't choose the cheapest quotes but the most expensive ones mostly are unjustified. In fact, it's taking the absolute piss often!

Just now I'm about to buy two windows from the manufacturer directly. The most presentable glazing company wanted just over 3.1k for them supplied and installed.
Well.. Both windows will cost me (so no discounts, no VAT back) to buy 1k from the manufacturer. The installation will be a days work.
So the glazing company wanted to make at least £ 2100 (!) on 1 day of labour.
No wonder the job's a minted one!

I feel really sorry for less resourceful clients who either over-pay, or are stuck with a substandard product.

I feel the industry needs a serious watchdog and consumer protection (from cowboys and bodges). Most building works carried out by licenced, insured companies and the self-employed permitted only for landscaping, decorating, non-structural joinery, etc.
At least there would be somewhere to turn for the big bodges! And they would happen less too.

RotundBeagle · 06/03/2023 02:27

QueenCamilla · 06/03/2023 02:04

@ZoZoisresting might be right about the dating though.

I had a roofer showing, you know, interest. Turning up knocking at the door at 1am. However, I'm too full of myself to open the door to a builder rapist/murderer in the dead of the night, so I got CCTV installed instead.

I'll go check my privilege and be more open-minded in the future. Ta 🙄

Yeah, because this definitely happened. 🙄

SomersetONeil · 06/03/2023 02:24

There is disdain for everyone on here, it’s complete equal opportunities disdain.

You’ve just noticed it more towards tradies because you come from a family of tradies.

Why let it wind you up?

QueenCamilla · 06/03/2023 02:20

RotundBeagle · 06/03/2023 02:04

I don't really need to. I already know how a lot of MC people view tradesmen.

You're telling me that if I go and read all ten pages of the thread it won't be filled with people justifying their snottiness with "oh well, our plumber didn't turn up once so my views are justified".

Yep, you should read. It's much worse than you would believe.

My experience of builders in the North East has made me disgusted with the whole local lot. I'm pretty sure I flinch when someone "comes out" as tradie down the pub.

Judging by the average reviews of most builders hovering around two stars, I ain't the only one not lovin' it.

About to hire a large contractor as a last resort - so far so good but will know for sure only once the works commence (or not, as often is the case).

HelloDaisy · 06/03/2023 02:13

I run a trade business with dh and our communication is excellent 😊

Some of the problems people have with trades is that they are reluctant to pay the quoted price, always thinking they are being ripped off and it should be cheaper, so will opt for the cheapest quote and then get upset when it’s not done properly. We’ve had that many times- new customers say we’re too expensive and go elsewhere only to come back further down the line asking us to rectify the mistakes.

We don’t advertise at all as word of mouth is plenty and have lots of loyal customers…

RotundBeagle · 06/03/2023 02:06

Yup, page one, fourth reply. I knew it would be the case. 😂😂😂

QueenCamilla · 06/03/2023 02:04

@ZoZoisresting might be right about the dating though.

I had a roofer showing, you know, interest. Turning up knocking at the door at 1am. However, I'm too full of myself to open the door to a builder rapist/murderer in the dead of the night, so I got CCTV installed instead.

I'll go check my privilege and be more open-minded in the future. Ta 🙄

RotundBeagle · 06/03/2023 02:04

QueenCamilla · 06/03/2023 01:58

The "Snob" hunters clearly haven't read the thread.
RTFT! As we posh ones say 👍

I don't really need to. I already know how a lot of MC people view tradesmen.

You're telling me that if I go and read all ten pages of the thread it won't be filled with people justifying their snottiness with "oh well, our plumber didn't turn up once so my views are justified".

QueenCamilla · 06/03/2023 01:58

The "Snob" hunters clearly haven't read the thread.
RTFT! As we posh ones say 👍

RotundBeagle · 06/03/2023 01:48

ZoZoisresting · 05/03/2023 07:37

Because they’re snobs. These are the same women who would only consider dating someone with a similar degree to theirs (regardless of whether they make fuck all money). They have something they think makes them better than other people and they can’t be told otherwise.
of course they’ll deny that’s the cause but it a hunge is.

It's odd because the average office salary in the UK is only £35k. Average trade salary is £45k.

Having gone from a corporate environment to trades/construction I'd say that a lot of young tradespeople have their heads screwed on better than many of the young graduates I've encountered. I often think this is because they're working at 18yo when most similarly aged graduates are out drinking and partying with several years left before they enter the work world.

A lot of graduates are moving back to their parents' at the age young tradespeople are already in their own place.

echt · 05/03/2023 21:11

When in the UK, the tradesmen we employed were without exception excellent. In Australia, where we've had significantly more work done, only one was utterly shite and one meh. The rest have been very good, and punctual.

On thing I still do though is to make first contact using both my and my late husband's names. I never let on I'm widowed.

NewspaperTaxis · 05/03/2023 21:04

Article on being ghosted by tradesmen in today's Sunday Times - though I guess that might provoke the whole 'Ooh, la-di-dah, they get the Sunday Times, bet they shop in Waitrose and have a log burner' type response.

Viewfrommyhouse · 05/03/2023 16:00

IME (after a year+ long house refurbishment) - no, they're not thick. But they're lazy, sloppy, and don't seem to give a shit about the standard of work they produce. We've had a whole house refurb, top to toe. The only trades I'd have back is the joiner who made my kitchen. He was conscientious, keen, and so proud of his work - rightly so. As for the rest, apart from one labourer that worked like a dog doing all the shit jobs, I'd not have one of them anywhere near my house again.

Oblomov23 · 05/03/2023 15:54

I disagree. I saw that thread, posted on that thread, and others. Many of the men in my family are trade, my bil is a builder. He's fabulous, replies, booked up for ages.

But if you don't know that many many people have been either ripped off massively, which 3 of my friends have. Or more irritating is that they just don't respond, don't turn up. You must know that many many people face that. So the criticism of them is fair. So I don't know what you are complaining about.

LolaSmiles · 05/03/2023 15:43

Because they’re snobs. These are the same women who would only consider dating someone with a similar degree to theirs (regardless of whether they make fuck all money). They have something they think makes them better than other people and they can’t be told otherwise.
of course they’ll deny that’s the cause but it a hunge is.

You're right, it really is snobbery to expect a skilled professional to behave professionally and do the job they're paid for to a safe and acceptable standard.

Expecting your house not to be ruined, expecting work to be done to a safe standard, and expecting a contractor to show up when they say they will has everything to do with a silly conspiracy about dating people with a certain degree.

😂

LivingDeadGirlUK · 05/03/2023 08:26

Trades are just like any other job, some people are just not as good as others. This applies on all levels not just domestic, I worked on a 6 floor apartment block where the quality of one of the trades was so bad they had to be sacked off and another company brought in to fix and finish.

A PP said not all sole traders know how to run their business and this is very true, I had an excellent electrician about 3 weeks ago who still hasn't sent me their invoice.

ZoZoisresting · 05/03/2023 07:37

Because they’re snobs. These are the same women who would only consider dating someone with a similar degree to theirs (regardless of whether they make fuck all money). They have something they think makes them better than other people and they can’t be told otherwise.
of course they’ll deny that’s the cause but it a hunge is.

Auldfangsyne · 05/03/2023 07:29

Given your family are tradesmen who appear to be the professional ones, I imagine you have a pool of people to draw from you need a tradesman. They would at least recommend someone good.

You are unlikely to meet the bad ones and there your view will be biased. Just like someone who has experienced bad workmanship will be biased the other way.

The difficulty is knowing who is good. Word of mouth to me has always been the best recimmendation.

I've had an extension done after seeing the builders work on another house in our street - really happy with it and recommended him on several times.

Same with a painter we know and everyone I've recommended him to has been happy.

We have a guy who fixes white goods, also brilliant.

I've also seen some shocking work where jobs gave been left half done.

I don't think people think tradesmen are thick or lazy, but having a job poorly completed or having yiur house left in a mess is annoying.